Snowmobile Use Reduction: Pollution Solution?

Snowmobiles have been a source of controversy for conservationists and environmentalists due to their impact on wildlife, air and water quality, noise levels, and the aesthetic of natural parks. While snowmobile enthusiasts argue that newer technologies have made snowmobiles cleaner and quieter, reducing their environmental impact, there is evidence to suggest that snowmobile emissions cause air pollution and can lead to health problems for those exposed to them for significant amounts of time. Furthermore, snowmobiles can disturb the wildlife that inhabits natural parks, and they can also cause damage to vegetation when there is inadequate snowpack.

Snowmobile emissions and air pollution

Snowmobiles have been a controversial topic in Yellowstone National Park and other national parks for over a decade. The controversy revolves around the impact of snowmobiles on wildlife, air and water quality, noise levels, and the aesthetic of the natural environment.

Snowmobiles, particularly older models, emit significant amounts of pollution. In one hour, a typical snowmobile emits as much hydrocarbon as a 2008 model automobile emits in 54,000 miles of driving. This is due to the two-stroke engines used in most snowmobiles, which pass 20-33% of the fuel straight through the engine and out the tailpipe unburned. In addition, two-stroke engines require lubricating oil to be mixed with fuel, resulting in the release of particulate matter composed of volatile organic compounds and hydrocarbons. These emissions can lead to health issues for both snowmobile riders and park staff, including cardiovascular and neurological problems.

To address these concerns, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) introduced regulations in 2002 to limit air emissions from snowmobiles. However, these regulations still allow snowmobiles to emit as much hydrocarbon pollution in a day as a new car does in its entire lifetime. The EPA has also not set any noise standards for snowmobiles, despite their significant contribution to noise pollution.

The National Park Service (NPS) has attempted to manage snowmobile use in national parks by developing Winter Use Plans with specific regulations and limits for individual parks. For example, the NPS required that snowmobiles in Yellowstone meet Best Available Technology (BAT) standards for noise and exhaust emissions, including carbon monoxide, unburned hydrocarbons, volatile organic compounds, oxides of nitrogen, and particulate matter. However, these efforts have been met with legal challenges from both environmental groups and the snowmobile industry, resulting in conflicting court rulings.

While supporters of snowmobile use argue for the economic benefits to local communities and the importance of public access to national parks, opponents prioritize the potential environmental and health impacts. The debate continues, with both sides actively pursuing their interests.

Snowmobile noise pollution

Snowmobiles have been a source of noise pollution in national parks like Yellowstone, Grand Teton, Rocky Mountain, Acadia, Zion, Mount Rainier, and Sequoia. The noise from snowmobiles can be heard up to 95% of the time by visitors in certain areas of Yellowstone, disrupting the natural soundscape and the overall visitor experience.

Snowmobiles are built to federally-mandated noise control standards to protect humans and animals from the effects of noise pollution. However, some snowmobile users modify their sled's exhaust system to make it louder. This can startle wildlife, causing them to injure themselves or flee their habitat.

Noise pollution from snowmobiles has been a contentious issue, with environmental groups and the public largely opposing their use in national parks. The National Park Service has attempted to address the issue by developing Winter Use Plans that establish regulations and limits for individual parks. These plans have been subject to legal challenges, and the issue of snowmobile noise pollution remains unresolved.

To reduce noise pollution, snowmobile users are advised to stay on designated trails, avoid areas where animals may be easily startled, and refrain from riding after dark or at sunrise when animals are more active. Additionally, installing aftermarket exhaust silencers can further reduce noise levels.

Snowmobile impact on snowpack and water quality

Snowmobiles can have a significant impact on snowpack and water quality, especially when used off-trail. Here are some key points to consider:

Impact on Snowpack:

• Snowmobile use can cause snowpack density, hardness, and ram resistance to increase, especially in shallow snow conditions. This can lead to a denser and harder snowpack that may impact the underlying natural resources.
• Snowmobile tracks can damage vegetation by ripping into ground-level plant life and compacting surface soil. This is more likely to occur when there is inadequate snowpack, and manufacturers recommend sledding when there is at least 4-6 inches of snow to prevent environmental damage.
• Snowmobile use is prohibited in certain environmentally sensitive areas (ESAs) to protect fragile vegetation, as snowmobiles can cause damage to root zones, create ruts, and increase erosion.

Impact on Water Quality:

• One of the least-studied aspects of snowmobile emissions is their potential effect on water quality through snowmelt runoff. However, there is some research suggesting that snowmobile emissions may impact water quality.
• A study in Yellowstone National Park found that samples from the on-road snowpack near snowmobile routes contained several varieties of pollutants known to be major ingredients in two-stroke engine lubricants. These pollutants were not present in areas without snowmobile traffic.
• Snowmobile emissions may impact surface water contamination during snowmelt, especially in areas with a high density of snowmobiles and proximity to water bodies.

Snowmobile impact on wildlife

Snowmobiles have been a controversial topic in national parks, with environmentalists and snowmobile enthusiasts debating their impact on wildlife. While snowmobile lovers argue that the machines do not harm wildlife, conservationists and researchers have raised concerns about the potential stress and disruption they may cause to animals. Here are some key considerations regarding the impact of snowmobiles on wildlife:

Noise Pollution

Snowmobiles produce significant noise, which can startle and panic animals, leading them to injure themselves or flee their habitats. This noise pollution can have a detrimental effect on both the behaviour and well-being of wildlife. To address this issue, snowmobiles are built to federally mandated noise control standards, and riders are encouraged to stay on designated trails, avoid revving their engines, and refrain from modifying their sleds to increase loudness.

Physiological Stress

Research has shown that snowmobile activity can lead to increased levels of glucocorticoids, or "stress hormones", in elk and wolves. Scott Creel of Montana State University and his colleagues collected faecal samples from elk and wolves in several national parks and found a positive correlation between higher glucocorticoid levels and increased snowmobile use. While the populations of these animals remain stable, the researchers caution that chronic elevation of stress hormones can have adverse effects on reproduction and survival rates.

Habitat Disruption

Snowmobile tracks can damage vegetation and compact topsoil, particularly when there is insufficient snow cover. Environmental advocates recommend staying on designated trails and avoiding sensitive areas such as wetlands, shorelines, and riverbeds. By adhering to these guidelines, snowmobilers can minimise their impact on wildlife habitats.

Air and Water Pollution

Snowmobiles emit hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide, and other pollutants, which can affect both wildlife and human visitors to national parks. While newer models are generally cleaner and more efficient, aftermarket modifications to exhaust systems can increase emissions and noise levels. Maintaining snowmobiles properly and complying with regulations can help reduce air and water pollution, creating a more favourable environment for wildlife.

Economic impact of reduced snowmobile use

Snowmobiles have a significant economic impact, particularly in North America, where the industry generates over $30 billion in economic activity and supports more than 100,000 full-time jobs. The average snowmobiler spends $2,500 each year on snowmobile-related recreation, contributing to this substantial economic impact.

In the United States alone, the economic impact of snowmobiling is estimated to be $26 billion annually, with over 1.27 million registered snowmobiles in the country. This includes the cost of manufacturing, dealerships, and tourism-related businesses. Snowmobiling also has a notable economic impact in Canada, contributing $9.3 billion annually to the country's economy, and in Europe, where it generates $4 billion in economic activity.

The snowmobile industry's economic significance extends beyond direct sales and manufacturing. Snowmobilers contribute to the economy through their spending on related recreation, such as trail grooming, charity fundraising, and family activities. Additionally, snowmobile tourism has increased in North America and beyond, further enhancing the economic impact of this industry.

Snowmobile manufacturers have recognised the importance of promoting safe riding behaviour, and they actively distribute safety materials through the "Safe Riders! You make snowmobiling safe™" safety campaign. This initiative ensures that snowmobilers have access to safety brochures, decals, posters, and DVDs, which are provided free of charge.

The economic impact of snowmobiling is closely tied to the number of registered snowmobiles and the miles ridden by snowmobilers. As the number of registered snowmobiles in North America increases, the economic impact is expected to grow accordingly. Additionally, the expansion of riding areas and trail systems has led to an increase in miles ridden by snowmobilers, further boosting the economic significance of this industry.

In summary, the economic impact of reduced snowmobile use could have a notable effect on the snowmobile industry and the overall economy, particularly in regions with high snowmobile usage and manufacturing presence.

Frequently asked questions