Pollution's Global Reach: Poor Nations Pay The Price

While every country deals with pollution to some extent, the problem is exacerbated in developing nations, where rapid and unregulated economic expansion, industrialization, and urbanization contribute to severe environmental degradation. Developing countries face challenges such as population growth, poverty, and weak environmental regulations, making them vulnerable to pollution from both local and global sources. This pollution takes the form of air, water, and land pollution, with far-reaching consequences for the health and well-being of their citizens. Wealthier nations often contribute to this issue by outsourcing their polluting practices to developing countries, taking advantage of cheaper labor and less stringent environmental laws. The health impacts of pollution in these countries are significant, with higher rates of cardiovascular disease, respiratory infections, and other health issues. Addressing pollution in developing nations requires a multifaceted approach, including the implementation of cleaner technologies, improved waste management, and a transition to more sustainable economic models.

Industrialized nations dump waste in third-world countries

Industrialized nations have been known to dump waste in third-world countries, taking advantage of the lack of environmental regulation in these countries. This practice is known as waste colonialism.

In 1991, World Watch magazine reported that Western companies dumped more than 22 million metric tons of hazardous waste in Africa in 1988. This problem persists today, with Germany being the world's largest exporter of plastic waste, with shipments totaling over 734,000 metric tons in 2022. The United Kingdom and Japan are also among the major exporters of plastic waste, often sending it to countries that lack waste management infrastructure.

Electronic waste, or e-waste, is also a significant issue, with the United States exporting a large amount of e-waste to China. North America also exports a large amount of e-waste to China and Nigeria. The processing of this waste often involves burning plastic casings or dumping acid from heavy metal components directly into rivers, leading to dangerous living conditions and life-threatening environmental damage.

In addition to the direct dumping of waste, industrialized nations also contribute to pollution in third-world countries through the outsourcing of environmentally hazardous production processes. For example, IBM, General Motors, and Sony have established manufacturing plants in Mexico, resulting in severe environmental problems, including the discharge of raw sewage into the Tijuana River.

The consequences of these practices are disastrous for the affected regions and the world. Pollution is the largest environmental cause of disease and premature death, with more than 90% of deaths caused by air pollution occurring in low- and middle-income countries. It is essential for industrialized nations to address the root causes of pollution and take responsibility for their waste disposal practices to prevent further harm to the environment and vulnerable communities.

Water pollution in third-world countries causes high death rates

Water pollution is a significant issue in third-world countries, leading to high death rates and causing severe health problems, especially among children and women. The lack of access to clean water and proper sanitation facilities results in the contamination of water sources by human and animal waste, industrial waste, and agricultural runoff, leading to the spread of waterborne diseases.

In developing nations, access to adequate wastewater treatment facilities is limited. For instance, in India, only 209 out of 3,119 towns and cities have even partial sewage systems, with the rest dumping their waste into rivers like the Ganges, which receives over 1.3 billion liters of domestic waste and 260 million liters of industrial waste. Similar issues are seen in Mexico, where factories discharge raw sewage into the Tijuana River, and in Zimbabwe, where industrialization has caused pollution in both urban and rural areas.

The impact of water pollution on health is significant. In developing countries, around 3.2 million children die each year from unsafe drinking water and poor sanitation. Waterborne diseases, such as cholera, typhoid, dysentery, and diarrhea, have high mortality rates in these regions. Additionally, dirty water provides a breeding ground for mosquitoes that spread diseases like malaria and encephalitis. The UN estimates that 60% of global malaria cases and 80% of malaria deaths in Sub-Saharan Africa are linked to inadequate water storage.

The lack of access to clean water and sanitation also disproportionately affects women and girls in these communities. Teenage girls may be unable to attend schools that lack adequate sanitation facilities, and they are often responsible for collecting water for their families, taking time away from education and other opportunities.

Furthermore, water pollution has economic implications. The health issues arising from polluted water lead to substantial healthcare costs for families and governments, impacting a country's GDP. Additionally, the time spent collecting water and the loss of productivity due to illness further burden the economy.

While donor nations and organizations can assist, the key to addressing water pollution lies within the developing countries themselves. Governments must prioritize implementing pollution reduction technologies, such as investing in waste management and creating communal transit options, to improve the health and well-being of their citizens and mitigate the high death rates caused by water pollution.

Air pollution and its health impacts

Air pollution is a mix of hazardous substances from both human-made and natural sources. Human-made air pollution comes from vehicle emissions, fuel oils, natural gas, manufacturing by-products, coal-fueled power plants, and chemical production fumes. Natural sources include smoke from wildfires, ash and gases from volcanic eruptions, and gases like methane emitted from decomposing organic matter in soils.

Air pollution is the leading environmental risk to health, causing about 7 million premature deaths each year, with more than 90% of these deaths occurring in low- and middle-income countries. It is a major threat to global health and prosperity, causing about 6.5 million deaths annually worldwide, a number that has increased over the past two decades. The health impacts of air pollution depend on the types, sources, and concentrations of pollutants in the air, but it primarily enters the body through the respiratory tract.

The main health effects of air pollution include inflammation, oxidative stress, immunosuppression, and mutagenicity in cells throughout the body, impacting the lungs, heart, and brain, among other organs. Fine particulate matter, or particle pollution, is a critical pollutant leading to negative health impacts. These particles are tiny bits of solids and liquids in the air, emitted directly by factories, power plants, and diesel- and gasoline-powered vehicles, or generated as other pollutants that later form into fine particles in the atmosphere. These fine particles can penetrate deep into the lungs and even enter the bloodstream, carrying serious health risks.

In 2019, exposure to lead was associated with more than 5.5 million adult deaths from cardiovascular disease, with 90% of these deaths occurring in lower- and middle-income countries. Air pollution also contributes to high rates of asthma, especially in economically disadvantaged communities of color, where sources of pollution such as power plants and industrial facilities are more commonly placed.

Developing countries face particular challenges with air pollution due to rapid and unregulated economic expansion. As a result, they struggle to balance reducing air pollution with maintaining economic growth. Coal, for example, is a cheap energy source that powers developing infrastructure, but it is also the dirtiest fossil fuel. The pressure to remain competitive with developed nations further encourages governments in developing countries to invest in dirty but cheap fuel.

Wealthier countries outsource dirtier manufacturing practices

Wealthier countries are often accused of outsourcing their dirtier manufacturing practices to developing countries. This is done to take advantage of cheaper labour and less stringent environmental regulations. The goods produced in these developing countries are then consumed in the wealthier nations, leaving the local population to suffer the environmental and health consequences of the dirty manufacturing processes. This practice is known as "pollution haven hypothesis" or "race to the bottom".

There is some evidence to support this claim. For example, in 1991, Western companies were reported to have dumped more than 24 million tons of hazardous waste in Africa alone. In addition, industries with shrinking markets in developed countries due to environmental concerns have begun to vigorously advertise in the developing world. For instance, DDT production, led by US and Canadian companies, is at an all-time high even though it is illegal to produce or use the pesticide in the United States or Europe since the 1970s.

Another example is the New River, which flows from northern Mexico into southern California. The river is regarded as the most polluted river in North America due to lax environmental standards in Mexico. Similarly, IBM, General Motors, and Sony have established manufacturing plants in Mexico, which discharge about 10 million gallons of raw sewage into the Tijuana River daily. As a result, the US and California governments pay for most of the cleanup.

However, it is important to note that the outsourcing of pollution is not a simple matter of wealthy countries exporting their dirty industries to developing nations. The truth is more nuanced. While it is true that emissions intensities for similar industries are higher in poorer countries, the evidence suggests that the mix of goods imported by richer countries has shifted towards those from cleaner industries, not dirtier ones. In other words, as developing countries industrialize, their pollution levels may increase, but this is not solely due to the outsourcing of pollution from richer nations.

Furthermore, the relationship between wealth and pollution is complex. For example, while it is true that air pollution is far worse in developing countries, it is also true that these countries have different challenges than developed ones, such as rapid and unregulated economic expansion. This means that their pollution problems are worse, but it is not necessarily due to the outsourcing of pollution. In addition, developing countries may be more likely to invest in dirty but cheap fuel sources to power their expanding infrastructure, which can contribute to higher pollution levels.

In conclusion, while it is true that wealthier countries may outsource some dirtier manufacturing practices to developing nations, the issue of pollution in these countries is multifaceted and cannot be attributed solely to this factor. The complex interplay of economic expansion, industrialization, and energy sources contributes to the pollution levels in developing countries. Addressing these issues will require a comprehensive approach that considers the unique challenges faced by developing nations.

The economic burden of pollution

Pollution is a significant burden on the economies of many countries, particularly those in the developing world. The economic cost of pollution is substantial, with countries incurring huge expenses to tackle the issue and mitigate its impacts. Furthermore, pollution hinders development outcomes, and the health impacts of pollution on populations result in further economic costs.

Developing countries face particular challenges in addressing pollution due to rapid and unregulated economic expansion, and the pressure to grow their economies and remain competitive. As a result, pollution problems in developing countries are often more severe and widespread than in developed nations. The health hazards of air pollution in these countries are a significant concern, with approximately 98% of cities in middle-to-low-income countries falling below recognised air quality standards. The health impacts of pollution include the development of cardiovascular diseases, asthma, and other respiratory issues, resulting in millions of deaths and hospitalizations worldwide. In 2019, it was estimated that more than 5.5 million adults died from cardiovascular disease associated with lead exposure, with 90% of these deaths occurring in lower- and middle-income countries.

Pollution also has indirect economic impacts, such as reducing the ability to work and lowering participation rates in the labour force. For instance, in 2018, air pollution was linked to 4.5 million deaths, 4 million new cases of child asthma, 2 million preterm births, and 1.8 billion days of work absence worldwide. Additionally, the costs of addressing pollution can be significant, with countries investing in clean-up efforts and pollution reduction technologies. However, implementing cleaner forms of energy and more efficient resource management can save economies money in the long run by reducing health costs associated with pollution.

Addressing pollution at its source and promoting a circular economy can have economic benefits, including enhancing economic growth, improving resource efficiency, and creating employment opportunities. For example, the World Bank Group supports developing countries in reducing pollution and promoting clean development, with projects focused on waste management, hazardous waste remediation, and promoting sustainable practices in various sectors. These efforts aim to alleviate poverty, improve health outcomes, and foster healthier lives and better livelihood opportunities.

Frequently asked questions