Pollution's Stunting Effect: Does It Limit Human Growth?

There is a clear link between air pollution and children's height, with those in highly polluted areas being shorter than those in less polluted areas. A study by researchers in India found that pollution levels vary at different heights above the ground, with concentrations of black carbon and particulate matter being maximum at the surface and decreasing with height. Similarly, a British study found that children in highly polluted areas were shorter by 1.2 cm at age 7 compared to those in the least polluted areas, with the effect diminishing after age 7 and disappearing by age 15. Another study from Lancaster University in England found that urban children are exposed to billions of toxic air pollution particles, damaging their cells and cardiovascular muscles. These findings underscore the impact of air pollution on human growth and development, highlighting the need for further investigation into the biological mechanisms underlying this relationship.

Air pollution and children's height

Air pollution has been linked to a range of adverse health effects in childhood, and evidence suggests that it may also impact children's physical growth and development. Recent studies have found an association between air pollution and children's height, indicating that exposure to air pollution can lead to reduced stature or stunted growth in some cases.

A 2004 study published in the *International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health* journal examined the relationship between outdoor air pollution from coal-burning sources and children's height. The researchers analysed data from the 1946 British birth cohort study, which included 5,362 children born in March 1946. They measured the children's height at various ages ranging from 2 to 15 years and categorised their areas of residence into four groups based on published coal-consumption data. After controlling for socio-economic factors, the study found a significant association between air pollution and children's height, particularly at the age of 7 years. On average, children in the most polluted areas were 1.2 cm shorter than those in the least polluted areas, with the effect diminishing after 7 years of age and disappearing by 15 years.

Another study conducted by researchers at Lancaster University in England and the Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi, further emphasises the impact of air pollution on children's growth. This research focused on young children residing in urban areas and found that they were exposed to billions of toxic air pollution particles, which can damage cells and cardiovascular muscles. Additionally, the study reported that air pollution is associated with a shortening of children's lives by approximately 20 months. The findings suggest that air pollution not only affects the current generation but also the health and development of the next generation.

The mechanisms underlying the link between air pollution and children's height are not yet fully understood. However, it is speculated that pollution particles can reach the human body and penetrate deep into the lungs, causing respiratory issues and potentially influencing overall growth. Furthermore, air pollution has been linked to other serious chronic health complications, including mental cognition and diabetes.

It is important to note that the effects of air pollution on height may vary depending on individual factors such as genetic predispositions and socio-economic conditions. Additionally, the concentration of pollutants and the height above ground also play a role, as evidenced by a study in New Delhi, India, which showed that pollution levels vary at different heights above the ground. Nevertheless, the existing research highlights the detrimental impact of air pollution on children's health and underscores the urgency of implementing measures to improve air quality, particularly in highly populated urban areas.

Pollution levels vary at different heights

It is a well-known fact that air pollution is detrimental to human health. Studies have shown that air pollution is associated with children's height, with those in the most polluted areas being shorter than those in less polluted areas. However, the question arises: does living at a higher elevation provide relief from pollution?

Researchers in India have found that pollution levels vary at different heights above the ground. A study published in the Science of the Total Environment was the first to profile how pollution changes as one moves up from the ground. Using a hydrogen-filled tethered balloon, scientists from India, Sweden, and the United States measured pollution at different heights up to one kilometer from the ground. They found that pollution levels were highest at the surface and decreased with increasing height.

However, regions up to 200 meters above the ground remained substantially polluted, though less so than at ground level. Beyond this height, pollution levels decreased until 800 meters and then remained stable until the one-kilometer mark. This indicates that while pollution levels generally decrease with height, they can still be significant even at relatively high elevations.

The effect of height on pollution levels is also influenced by other factors such as the openness and ventilation of the area, terrain, building placement, and street width. For example, in open environments or areas with wider streets and lower buildings, pollution levels tend to be lower. On the other hand, in street canyons lined with tall buildings, ventilation is weak, causing emissions to spread and pollution levels to increase.

Additionally, the type of pollutant can also play a role in how it is distributed at different heights. For instance, black carbon, being lighter than other aerosols, is easily transported upward and can contribute to enhanced heating of the atmosphere.

In summary, while pollution levels generally decline with height, they can still be significant even at elevations above ground level. The interaction of various factors, such as ventilation, terrain, and building placement, influences the distribution of pollution at different heights. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for developing effective strategies to mitigate the impact of pollution on human health and the environment.

Malnutrition and stunted growth

A study of British children born in 1946 found a correlation between air pollution and reduced height in children. The association was strongest at age seven, when children in the most polluted areas were 1.2 cm shorter than those in the least polluted. After age seven, the effect of air pollution diminished and disappeared by age fifteen.

Malnutrition is a major cause of stunted growth. Stunted growth, or linear growth failure, is defined as impaired growth and development, manifested by low height-for-age. It is a manifestation of undernutrition and can be caused by endogenous factors, such as chronic food insecurity, or exogenous factors, such as parasitic infection.

Stunted growth in early life, particularly in the first 1000 days from conception until the age of two, can have adverse consequences on a child's health and development. These consequences include poor cognition and educational performance, low adult wages, and an increased risk of nutrition-related chronic diseases in adulthood. Stunted growth can also be passed on to the next generation, in what is known as the "inter-generational cycle of malnutrition".

The three main causes of stunted growth in South Asia, and probably in most developing countries, are poor feeding practices, poor maternal nutrition, and poor sanitation. Prolonged exclusive breastfeeding, for example, is associated with undernutrition because breast milk alone is insufficient for children over six months old. Poor maternal nutrition during pregnancy and breastfeeding can also lead to stunted growth in their children.

To prevent stunted growth, it is important to provide not only better nutrition but also access to clean water, improved sanitation, and handwashing at critical times. Nutritional interventions such as dietary supplementation and nutritional education have the potential to decrease stunted growth.

Air pollution and shorter stature

Air pollution has been linked to shorter stature in children, with studies suggesting a correlation between exposure to air pollution and reduced height. This effect was observed to be most significant at the age of 7, with children in highly polluted areas being, on average, 1.2 cm shorter than those in less polluted regions. The impact of air pollution on height diminished after age 7 and disappeared by age 15.

A study conducted in New Delhi, India, found that pollution levels vary at different heights above the ground. The concentration of black carbon aerosol and particulate matter was highest at ground level and decreased with increasing height. This finding highlights the importance of considering vertical distribution in pollution studies.

The adverse effects of air pollution on stature are particularly prominent in urban areas, where billions of toxic air pollution particles can be found in the hearts of young residents, causing damage to cells and cardiovascular muscles. The consequences of stunted growth extend beyond shorter stature, including potential mental cognition issues and an increased risk of developing diabetes.

Furthermore, air pollution has been associated with a shortened lifespan, reducing children's lives by approximately 20 months on average. This discovery underscores the urgent need to address the issue of toxic air contamination, which affects over 90% of the global population, according to the World Health Organization.

While genetics play a significant role in determining height, accounting for 60% to 80% of the variation, environmental factors, such as malnutrition and air pollution, also contribute to the remaining 20% to 40%. The study published in Environmental Health specifically highlights the risk of stunted growth for newborns exposed to high levels of air pollution during their mother's third trimester.

Stunted growth and health complications

Air pollution has been linked to stunted growth in children, with a direct correlation between the level of pollution and the child's height. A study by researchers at Lancaster University in England found that children exposed to toxic air pollution particles experienced damage to their cardiovascular system, which can hinder growth. This is supported by a study of 200,000 children born between February 2010 and December 2015, which found that children born during peak pollution times were shorter than those born at other times.

The impact of air pollution on height was most pronounced at age seven, according to the British 1946 birth cohort study. Children in the most polluted areas were, on average, 1.2 cm shorter than those in the least polluted areas. This disparity decreased with age and was no longer significant by age 15. The biological mechanisms behind this link are not yet fully understood, and more research is needed to confirm a causal relationship.

Stunted growth, as defined by the World Health Organization, is a reduced growth rate relative to a person's age. It is determined using the Child Growth Standard Median, with any child who is at least two deviations below their age median classified as suffering from stunting. Stunted growth can have serious health implications beyond just reduced height, including mental cognition issues and an increased risk of developing chronic health conditions such as diabetes.

The particles that cause air pollution are often very small and can easily be inhaled, making their way deep into the lungs. This can lead to respiratory illnesses and further compound the health complications associated with stunted growth. Poor ambient air quality caused by pollution has been linked to a significant number of deaths. For example, in 2012, more than 620,000 deaths in India were attributed to poor air quality.

The effects of air pollution on height and overall health are complex and influenced by various factors, including socioeconomic status, birth weight, and respiratory health. However, the existing research highlights the importance of reducing toxic air pollution to protect the health and well-being of children and young people.

Frequently asked questions