The Dark Side Of Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion

Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion (OTEC) is a process that has the potential to produce a significant amount of electrical power. However, concerns have been raised about the environmental impact of OTEC technologies, particularly regarding water quality and the potential for pollution. An environmental impact assessment of an open-cycle OTEC plant on Cozumel Island, Mexico, identified several factors that could be impacted by the operation of the plant, including air, soil, water, and marine life. The operation of multiple OTEC facilities worldwide could have serious consequences for the global oceans and atmosphere. This article will explore the potential environmental impacts of OTEC and discuss measures to mitigate these effects.

OTEC and water quality

Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion (OTEC) technology uses sea temperature differences at the surface and the bottom to operate heat engines and generate electricity. OTEC is often touted as a world of clean energy and water, but there are several environmental concerns associated with OTEC technologies, including changes in water quality.

One of the primary environmental concerns arises from the withdrawal of cool, nutrient-rich water from the deep ocean and its discharge at a different temperature higher in the water column. This can affect nearby habitats through temperature changes and increased biological growth. The discharge of water at a different temperature can cause a shock term, resulting in a dilution effect until the water column reaches a balance. This small temperature change can also influence the relocation of fish, as they seek optimal ecosystems for their reproduction, feeding, and growth.

The use of screens on intake tubes can help mitigate the impact on marine organisms, but there is still a risk of fatal entrapment. Additionally, the operation of seawater pumps can be a significant source of noise, potentially impacting marine life.

Another concern is the potential for nutrient upwelling, where nutrients are dragged to the surface. This can lead to an artificial reef effect and contamination by heavy metal salts, impacting marine life and altering coastal ecosystems.

Despite these concerns, OTEC has the potential to produce enough drinking water to ease water scarcity and drought crises. The freshwater produced can be used for agriculture, industry, and potable drinking water, providing valuable resources to local communities.

OTEC and noise pollution

Noise pollution, or sound pollution, is the propagation of noise or sound with potentially harmful effects on humans and animals. The main sources of outdoor noise worldwide are machines, transport, and propagation systems. Research suggests that noise pollution in the United States is the highest in low-income and racial minority neighborhoods.

An environmental impact assessment (EIA) was carried out for the operation of a 1MWe open-cycle OTEC plant on Cozumel Island, Mexico. Water noise measurements from a 1 MWe anchored (off-shore) OTEC-CC facility near Keahole, Hawaii, determined that seawater pumps are the maximum noise source of the OC-OTEC plant project. The noise generated by these pumps presents a broadband spectrum that does not exceed the expected levels by more than 10 dB.

The impact of noise on human health is well documented. Noise pollution has been associated with faster cognitive decline, and it can affect both mental and physiological health. It has also been linked to several health conditions, including cardiovascular disorders, hypertension, high stress levels, tinnitus, hearing loss, and sleep disturbances. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), noise is the second-largest environmental cause of health problems after air pollution.

To address noise pollution, individuals can take steps such as using hearing protection like earplugs or earmuffs when exposed to loud sounds. Additionally, various strategies can be implemented in homes, schools, workplaces, and communities to mitigate noise. On a larger scale, measures such as installing low-noise asphalt on roads, using quiet tires on public transport vehicles, and promoting active travel like walking or cycling can help reduce noise pollution.

OTEC and water temperature changes

Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion (OTEC) is a technology that uses the temperature difference between warm surface waters and cold deep waters to generate electricity. OTEC systems can use seawater as a working fluid to produce desalinated water, which has a variety of applications, including drinking water, irrigation, and aquaculture. OTEC has the potential to be a consistent and sustainable source of clean energy, particularly in tropical regions with access to deep ocean water.

The temperature difference between the surface and deep waters is essential for the operation of OTEC systems. The warm surface water is pumped into a low-pressure container, causing it to boil and vaporize. This vapor is then used to drive a turbine or lift water to significant heights, generating electricity. The cold seawater, on the other hand, is brought to the surface through active pumping or desalination. Desalination near the sea floor lowers the density of the seawater, causing it to rise to the surface. This process reduces technical and environmental problems and lowers costs compared to using pipes to bring cold water up.

The water rejection discharges in the operation of an OC-OTEC plant project can have a negative impact on marine waters. The temperature difference between the condenser and the evaporator in the plant and the ocean at the time of discharge can be significant, causing a shock that needs to be diluted within the water column. Additionally, the small temperature change of 3°C can influence the relocation of fish as they seek an optimal ecosystem for reproduction, feeding, and growth.

While OTEC has the potential to be a sustainable and clean energy source, environmental impact assessments are crucial to understanding and mitigating any potential negative consequences. These assessments consider various factors, including air, soil, water, landscape, geology, and flora. By carefully studying and addressing these factors, it is possible to minimize the environmental footprint of OTEC plants and harness the benefits of this renewable energy technology while protecting the surrounding ecosystem.

OTEC and marine life

Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion (OTEC) is a technology that uses the ocean's thermal gradient to produce electricity. It relies on the temperature difference between the warm surface waters and the cold depths of the ocean to run a heat engine. While OTEC has the potential to provide a consistent and sustainable source of clean energy, particularly in tropical regions, there are concerns about its potential impact on the environment and marine life.

One of the main concerns regarding OTEC's impact on marine life is the mixing of deep ocean water with shallower water. This process brings up nutrients that can be beneficial for the aquaculture of commercially important species. However, it may also disrupt the ecological balance around the power plant. The deep seawater is oxygen-deficient and has a higher concentration of nutrients, particularly nitrate and nitrite. When these plumes mix, they can have a negative impact on the surrounding marine life, potentially causing a redistribution of oceanic water bodies and affecting the behaviour of marine organisms.

Another issue is the potential noise pollution caused by OTEC plants. Water noise measurements from an OTEC plant in Hawaii found that seawater pumps were the maximum noise source, presenting a broadband spectrum that exceeded expected levels. This noise pollution can disturb marine life, particularly marine mammals who rely on sound to communicate and navigate.

The discharge of water from OTEC plants can also impact marine life. The temperature difference between the discharged water and the surrounding ocean can favour the relocation of fish, as they seek optimal ecosystems for reproduction, feeding, and growth. Additionally, the discharge pipes should be placed in protective trenches to prevent them from being damaged during storms and heavy seas. The mixed discharge of cold and warm seawater may need to be released several hundred meters offshore to reach the proper depth, requiring additional construction and maintenance costs.

Overall, while OTEC has the potential to provide a sustainable and renewable source of energy, it is important to carefully consider and mitigate its potential impacts on marine life. Environmental impact assessments are crucial to understanding and minimising any negative consequences of OTEC deployment.

OTEC and water discharge

Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion (OTEC) is a clean energy technology that uses the temperature difference between warm surface waters and cold deep ocean waters to generate electricity. OTEC systems can be land-based or near-shore, but the latter may be preferable to avoid the dangers of turbulent surf. However, near-shore sites can support mariculture or chilled water agriculture, and the products can be easily delivered to market via standard transport.

The water discharge from OTEC operations can have a range of environmental impacts. Firstly, the discharge of warm and cold seawater can affect the temperature of the surrounding ocean waters. In the case of the OC-OTEC PLANT project on Cozumel Island, the water discharge temperature differed from the ocean temperature, causing a negative impact. Additionally, the small temperature change of 3°C can influence the behaviour of marine fauna, such as fish relocation in search of optimal conditions for reproduction, feeding, and growth.

To minimise the impact of water discharge, OTEC plants should be configured to discharge flows downwards at a depth of 70 meters or more. At this depth, dilution is adequate, and nutrient enrichment is minimal, ensuring that the temperature and nutrient variations remain within naturally occurring levels. Studies have shown that in all cases modelled with discharge at 70 meters depth or more, no unnatural variations occurred in the upper 40 meters of the ocean's surface.

The discharge of nutrients from OTEC operations can also influence biological activity. While the impact is expected to be small, there could be an increase in the productivity of microplankton and a response from picoplankton and phytoplankton. However, it is important to carefully assess each site and design to ensure that OTEC technology remains environmentally benign and does not negatively affect the sustainability of the marine environment.

Frequently asked questions