The Big Apple's Pollution Problem: A Closer Look

New York City, the most populous city in the United States, has relatively clean air on average. The city's air quality index (AQI) has been rated as good by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for the last few years. However, air pollution remains a significant concern, with pollutants such as ozone, PM2.5, NOx, and SOx posing risks to public health and contributing to respiratory issues such as asthma. The transportation sector, buildings, and industrial activities are major sources of pollution. While efforts to improve air quality have been made, such as the introduction of the OneNYC plan and the electrification of buildings, the city continues to face challenges in reducing emissions and improving air quality.

New York's air quality has improved

New York City is the most populous city in the United States. Despite this, New York City has relatively clean air on average. New York City's air quality has improved in recent years, as the City and State have worked to lower emissions from regional and local sources.

In 2011, a study found that about 10% of hospital visits for asthma in New York City were attributable to ozone pollution. Staten Island, Southern Brooklyn, Central Queens, and the Northwest Bronx had the highest ozone-related death rates. However, city-wide ozone levels have decreased significantly in the last three decades.

Local regulations have also played a role in improving air quality. Regulations requiring building owners to transition to cleaner heating oils by 2015 have significantly improved air quality, as heating oils were a major source of SO2 in New York City. In 2023, only one of 84 sites detected any SO2, with levels similar to those measured on Whiteface Mountain in the Adirondack Mountains.

New York City has also pushed a three-pronged approach to improve air quality, including community outreach, increasing access to public charging stations, and improving accessibility and vehicle economics. The city aims to achieve 10,000 electric vehicle charging stations by the end of 2021 and 850,000 zero-emission vehicles by 2025.

New York City's air quality index (AQI) has been consistently rated as "good" by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for the last three years (2017, 2018, and 2019). During this period, New York's AQI remained below 50, indicating little to no risk to health.

While air quality in New York City has improved, air pollution remains a concern, posing a severe hazard to the health of residents. Ozone and PM2.5, fine particulate matter, are still present in the air and cause about 2,400 deaths per year in NYC, as well as thousands of hospitalizations for asthma, heart, and lung problems.

Air pollution still poses a health risk

Despite improvements in air quality over the years, air pollution in New York City still poses a health risk to its residents.

New York City is the most populous city in the United States, and while it has relatively clean air on average, air pollution remains a concern. The transportation sector is the dominant contributor to emissions in the city, with motor vehicles being a primary source of ambient benzene and formaldehyde. High congestion and traffic areas have been found to have 83% higher benzene levels and 45% higher formaldehyde levels than areas with lower traffic congestion.

Ozone pollution is another significant issue in New York City. While city-wide ozone levels have decreased in recent decades, ozone is still considered one of the greatest environmental health threats to residents. Ozone pollution is challenging to tackle as it is a gas pollutant created in the atmosphere from precursor pollutants reacting to sunlight. Rising temperatures due to climate change are expected to worsen this problem. New York City's buildings also contribute significantly to ozone pollution, generating twice as much NOx pollution as the city's light-duty passenger vehicles.

The health impacts of air pollution are extensive and well-studied. Air pollution has been linked to various diseases, including respiratory, circulatory, neurological, gastrointestinal, and urinary illnesses, which can be fatal. It is also a trigger for asthma attacks and hospitalizations, particularly in children. A study found that in 2017, pollution from fuel combustion in residential and commercial buildings in New York City led to an estimated 1,940 premature deaths and $21.7 billion in health impacts. Communities of color are disproportionately affected by air pollution, with exposure to higher levels of PM2.5 emissions, which are associated with residential gas combustion.

To address these health risks, New York City has implemented various initiatives to improve air quality. Local Law 97, enacted in 2019, aims to reduce emissions in large existing buildings, and the city has also strengthened its Air Pollution Control Codes. The transportation sector is slowly being modernized and improved, contributing to a decrease in emissions. However, despite these efforts, air pollution continues to pose a severe hazard to the health of New Yorkers, and more work needs to be done to mitigate its impact.

Ozone pollution is a concern

New York City is the most populous city in the United States, and despite having a large population, the city has relatively clean air on average. However, air pollution is still a concern for the environment and public health. Ozone pollution, in particular, is a critical issue. Ozone is among the most dangerous gaseous pollutants and a significant component of smog.

The State of the Air Report published by the American Lung Association gave New York City an "F" for ozone pollution. This poor rating was due to the city exceeding the national 8-hour ozone standard of 70 ppb on 5.5 days in 2019. While city-wide ozone levels have decreased in the last three decades, ozone pollution still presents a significant environmental health threat to residents. A 2011 analysis found that roughly 10% of hospital visits for asthma in New York City are attributable to ozone pollution. Staten Island, Southern Brooklyn, Central Queens, and the Northwest Bronx have the highest ozone-related death rates.

Ozone occurs in the atmosphere when high temperatures (over 80°F) cause pollutants, nitrogen oxides, and reactive organic substances from vehicles and smokestack combustion to react. New York's high population density and heavy vehicle traffic pose significant challenges to tackling ozone pollution. The city has implemented relatively strict emission controls and legislated for "cleaner" mass transport to reduce traffic congestion. However, precursor pollutants can also be emitted in other cities and states, and rising temperatures due to climate change are expected to exacerbate the problem.

The New York Health Department estimates that overall air pollution contributes to more than 3,000 deaths and 2,000 hospital admissions for coronary and respiratory conditions annually. Ozone pollution is a significant contributor to these health issues, and tackling it is challenging due to its gaseous nature and the complex interplay of various factors.

Fossil fuel consumption in buildings

New York City, despite being the most populous city in the United States, has relatively clean air. The city's air quality index (AQI) has been "good" for the past few years, indicating little to no health risk. However, air pollution remains a concern, with ozone pollution contributing to hospital visits for asthma and high death rates in certain areas.

The burning of fossil fuels for heating, ventilation, and lighting in U.S. manufacturing facilities contributes about 2% to the country's total end-use energy consumption. While New York City has made efforts to reduce emissions, indoor pollution resulting from fuel burning inside buildings is still a concern.

To address the environmental and health impacts of fossil fuel consumption in buildings, several measures can be implemented. Firstly, the adoption of renewable and alternative energy sources can reduce reliance on fossil fuels. This can include utilizing solar, wind, or geothermal energy for powering buildings. Additionally, improving energy efficiency in buildings through better insulation, energy-saving appliances, and smart technology can help reduce overall fossil fuel consumption.

Furthermore, the implementation of stricter emission regulations and the promotion of sustainable building design and construction practices can also contribute to reducing fossil fuel consumption in the built environment. By combining these strategies, New York City and other urban areas can work towards minimizing the environmental and health impacts associated with fossil fuel consumption in buildings.

Vehicle congestion and pollution

New York City is the most populous city in the United States, yet it has relatively clean air on average. The city's air quality index (AQI) has been rated as "good" by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for the last few years. However, air pollution still poses a severe hazard to the health of New Yorkers, and vehicle congestion is a significant contributor to this issue.

Vehicle congestion in New York City has been a persistent problem for decades, with over 700,000 vehicles entering the Manhattan Central Business District (CBD) daily. This has resulted in slower travel speeds, with average speeds in the CBD decreasing by 23% since 2010. The congestion has also contributed to air pollution, as vehicles are a major source of emissions. A study by NYCCAS researchers found that areas of high congestion and traffic had 83% higher benzene levels and 45% higher formaldehyde levels than areas with lower traffic congestion. These pollutants are harmful to human health and are associated with various diseases, including respiratory, circulatory, and neurological illnesses.

To address the issues of vehicle congestion and pollution, New York City has implemented congestion pricing, also known as the Central Business District Tolling Program or CBDTP. This initiative began on January 5, 2025, and applies to most motor vehicle traffic in the Congestion Relief Zone, which includes Manhattan south of 61st Street. The program aims to reduce traffic congestion and pollution by encouraging commuters to use public transportation instead of driving. Tolls are collected electronically and vary based on factors such as the time of day and type of vehicle. The revenue generated from these tolls is expected to fund improvements to the city's subway, bus, and commuter rail systems.

The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) has confirmed that the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's (MTA) Congestion Pricing Initiative will significantly benefit the environment and reduce traffic congestion by 17%. This will lead to improved air quality not just in New York City but across the entire region, benefiting multiple counties in New York and New Jersey. The congestion pricing program is projected to reduce traffic-related pollution by up to 10%, which will have significant public health benefits.

In conclusion, while New York City has relatively clean air compared to other large cities, vehicle congestion remains a significant challenge. The implementation of congestion pricing is a crucial step towards reducing traffic congestion and improving air quality in the city. The expected reduction in vehicle emissions and traffic volume will have positive environmental and health impacts, making New York a safer and more livable city for its residents.

Frequently asked questions