Air Pollution In France: Is The Country Breathing Clean Air?

France has been recognised as a country with moderate air pollution, ranking 71st in the world in 2019. Despite its leading role in monitoring climate change and pollution levels, France is more polluted than many of its Western European counterparts, including the UK, Spain, Switzerland and Germany. The country has pledged to hit net-zero emissions by 2050 to combat climate change, but it is currently the second-biggest emitter in the EU, with the transportation sector being the largest source of GHG emissions.

France's air pollution levels are higher than those of many of its Western European counterparts

France's pollution levels are influenced by various factors, including road traffic, the combustion of fossil fuels for residential heating, industrial activities, and agricultural practices. The country has taken initiatives to address this issue, such as investing in greener solutions and providing free public transport in Paris during periods of high pollution. Despite these efforts, France's air pollution levels remain a concern, particularly in specific regions and during certain times of the year.

In comparison to other Western European countries, France's air quality ranks lower than neighbouring countries such as the United Kingdom, Spain, Switzerland, and Germany. This disparity is significant, as air pollution poses health risks, increases healthcare costs, and contributes to premature deaths. While France has demonstrated a commitment to monitoring climate change and pollution levels, the country continues to face challenges in reducing its air pollution levels to match those of its Western European counterparts.

It is worth noting that France also experiences extremely good air quality in many of its cities, which helps to mitigate the health risks associated with pollution. However, the presence of high pollution levels in certain areas during specific times, such as stable and calm weather periods, underscores the need for continued efforts to improve air quality across the country. Overall, while France has made progress in addressing air pollution, it still lags behind many of its Western European neighbours in terms of maintaining consistently good air quality throughout the year.

The country's air quality varies greatly from city to city, with northern cities suffering from poorer air quality

France's air quality is generally good, with many cities falling within the World Health Organization's (WHO) target PM2.5 reading of 0 to 10 µg/m³. However, there are variations in air quality across different cities, with some northern cities experiencing poorer air quality.

In 2019, France was ranked 71st out of 98 countries in terms of air pollution, with a PM2.5 reading of 12.34 µg/m³, placing it in the ''moderately' polluted category. While this ranking is relatively respectable, there are still cities in France with comparatively poorer air quality, particularly during certain months and seasons.

For instance, in February 2019, Douai in northern France recorded a PM2.5 reading of 38.4 µg/m³, which is considered 'unhealthy for sensitive groups' such as the young, elderly, and those with compromised immune systems. Other cities in northern France, including Malo-Les-Bains, Boulogne-Sur-Mer, Valenciennes, Calais, and Creil, also recorded similar PM2.5 readings during the same month, indicating a pattern of higher pollution levels in the northern region.

The capital city, Paris, ranked second among the most polluted cities in France in 2019, with a PM2.5 reading of 14.7 µg/m³, which is also classified as ''moderately' polluted. However, Paris's pollution levels are still significantly lower than other cities with the same rating, such as Chiang Mai in Thailand, which had a PM2.5 reading of 32.3 µg/m³ in 2019.

The main sources of air pollution in France include vehicle emissions, residential and commercial heating, industrial activities, and agricultural practices. To address these issues, France has implemented initiatives such as promoting walking and biking, expanding bike lanes, and reducing car usage.

The transportation sector is the largest source of GHG emissions in France

France has a problem with air pollution, ranking 71st out of 98 countries in 2019. While many French cities have very good air quality, some cities, particularly in the north, suffer from poorer air quality. The transportation sector is a significant contributor to France's air pollution and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.

While data on the specific contribution of the transportation sector to France's GHG emissions is not readily available, the sector's emissions have been consistently reported and monitored. Annual greenhouse gas emissions from fuel combustion in the transportation sector in France have been recorded from 1990 to 2021 in million metric tons of CO2 equivalent. Despite this detailed reporting, the latest available data on France's transportation emissions is from 2021, when emissions were well below pre-pandemic levels.

The European Union (EU), of which France is a member, reports its greenhouse gas inventory annually to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). This inventory includes data on various greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N2O). France's commitment to monitoring and reporting its emissions is evident through its participation in the EU's initiatives.

To address pollution issues, France has invested in greener solutions, including the renovation of buildings and houses to improve energy efficiency. Additionally, France is taking initiatives to reduce pollution levels, including international efforts and encouraging individuals to take preventative measures during periods of high pollution, such as wearing particle-filtering masks and avoiding outdoor activities.

France has pledged to reach net-zero emissions by 2050

France has been taking steps to address its air pollution levels and has pledged to reach net-zero emissions by 2050. While the country has shown commitment to tackling climate change, it currently falls short of its targets and faces challenges in reducing its emissions.

France has a history of playing a leading role in monitoring climate change and pollution levels. However, in 2019, it was ranked 71st out of 98 countries in terms of air pollution, with some cities, particularly in the northern region, suffering from poorer air quality. To address this issue, France has implemented various measures, including international initiatives and investments in greener solutions. For example, the country is renovating buildings and houses to improve energy efficiency and reduce pollution from residential heating, a major source of air pollution.

In line with the Paris Agreement, France has set ambitious targets for reducing emissions and transitioning to renewable energy sources. The country's "roadmap" for cutting emissions is the SNBC, which sets five-year carbon budgets and guides the transition towards long-term targets. Complementing the SNBC is the PPE, which outlines five-year plans for energy consumption, networks, and security.

France's commitment to reaching net-zero emissions by 2050 was further solidified in 2019 with the passage of a climate and energy law. This legislation includes measures to reduce energy consumption, speed up the development of low-carbon energies, and increase the use of renewable hydrogen. Additionally, the law aims to cut emissions from the housing sector, which accounts for a significant portion of the country's energy consumption and carbon emissions.

However, despite these efforts, France is currently not on track to meet its domestic or EU targets for reducing emissions. The country's emissions continue to rise, particularly in the transport sector. Additionally, France lags behind its European neighbours in constructing wind and solar power sources and did not meet its 2020 renewables target. To achieve net-zero emissions by 2050, France will need to accelerate its transition to renewable energy sources and implement more aggressive emission reduction strategies.

The EU has taken France to court for exceeding air pollution limits for over a decade

France has been taken to the EU Court of Justice by the European Commission for exceeding air pollution limits for over a decade. The EU's top court ruled in 2019 that France had breached limits on nitrogen dioxide pollution in 12 regions. Despite its leading role in monitoring climate change and pollution levels, France ranked 71st out of 98 countries in terms of pollution levels in 2019, with a PM2.5 reading of 12.34 µg/m³, placing it in the 'moderately polluted' category.

The EU's case against France focuses on Paris, where the country has breached EU limits on particulate matter pollution for 12 years, and Martinique, a French island in the Caribbean, where limits have been exceeded for 14 years. This prolonged exposure to pollutants has severe health consequences for residents, including an increased risk of diabetes, lung disease, and cancer. In addition, early evidence suggests a potential link between air pollution and higher death rates among COVID-19 patients.

While France has taken initiatives to reduce pollution, such as investing in greener solutions and renovating buildings, the Commission's data confirmed a "systematic failure" to comply with the rules. The French government was warned that it would face significant fines if it did not take swift and effective measures to reduce air pollution. The EU Court of Justice has the power to impose multimillion-euro fines, and countries that fail to address the issue promptly may be subject to these penalties.

It is worth noting that France is not the only country facing legal action from the EU Commission. Germany, Italy, Hungary, Romania, and the UK have also been taken to court for failing to respect air quality rules and reduce toxic air pollution. This collective effort underscores the severity of the pollution problem across Europe and the need for urgent action to protect the health and well-being of citizens.

Frequently asked questions