Does Slower Driving Mean Cleaner Air?

There are over 450 20mph speed limit zones across the UK, many of which are located near schools. Since their introduction in 1991, they have become an increasingly popular traffic-calming measure. However, some people are concerned that driving at 20mph increases pollution. Research shows that in urban areas, the key factor in fuel consumption is the number of times a driver has to accelerate back up to the speed limit after slowing down or stopping. Driving at 20mph in an urban environment means consistently slowing down for obstacles, lights, junctions, and congestion and then speeding up again. However, it is argued that driving steadily at 20mph is no different from maintaining 30, 40, or 70mph.

Fuel efficiency in urban areas

Fuel efficiency is a growing concern, especially in urban areas where fuel consumption is at its highest. With rapid urbanization, more people are congregating in cities, and the energy demands of man-made systems are increasing. This has led to a rise in global temperatures and environmental concerns.

One of the major sources of fuel consumption in cities is road transport, which still relies heavily on liquid fuels derived from natural oil. The combustion of these carbon-based fuels releases carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide, contributing to global warming. To address this issue, cities like Bristol, Portsmouth, and Oxford in the UK have implemented 20 mph speed limits across their city centers.

Research has shown that reducing peak road speeds in built-up areas can save energy and money. A study by Future Transport found that fuel efficiency peaks when speeds are capped at 20 mph in urban settings, resulting in fuel savings of up to 30%. This is because the key factor influencing fuel consumption in cities is the number of times a vehicle accelerates back up to the speed limit after slowing down or stopping. The higher the speed limit, the greater the acceleration and the higher the fuel consumption.

Additionally, slower speeds can reduce the incidence of acceleration, deceleration, and braking, which are all factors that increase air pollution. This not only improves air quality but also makes cities safer and more pleasant for walking and cycling.

To further improve fuel efficiency in urban areas, driver behavior can be modified. Eco-driving tools and support systems can help drivers become more aware of their surroundings, adapt to road situations, and anticipate traffic conditions, resulting in more efficient driving styles.

Road safety

In recent years, there has been a growing trend to introduce 20 mph speed limits in towns and cities across the globe. These reduced speed limits are intended to improve road safety, particularly in built-up areas and near schools, by reducing the number of road-related deaths and accidents. While the primary focus of these measures is on improving safety, there has been speculation about whether driving at lower speeds increases pollution levels.

Research suggests that driving at 20 mph does not necessarily increase pollution. In fact, it can lead to improved air quality and reduced pollution. A report by the US National Research Council's committee for the study of impacts of highway capacity improvement on air quality and energy consumption supports this notion. The report references research from Germany which showed that as vehicle speeds increase in built-up areas, so does the incidence of acceleration, deceleration, and braking—all of which contribute to higher levels of air pollution.

Additionally, driving at lower speeds can result in fuel efficiency gains. According to Future Transport, fuel efficiency peaks when vehicles maintain a speed of 15-20 mph in urban areas with frequent acceleration and deceleration. This not only saves drivers money but also reduces overall fuel consumption, benefiting the environment.

However, it is important to acknowledge that some drivers express frustration with 20 mph speed limits. They argue that prioritising slower driving speeds hinders their ability to drive efficiently and conveniently. Nevertheless, road safety campaigns and organisations, such as the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), emphasise that speed limits are essential for protecting all road users. NHTSA data from 2023 highlights the importance of safety measures, revealing that nearly half of passenger vehicle occupants killed in traffic crashes were not wearing seatbelts, and that motorcyclists had a fatality rate 28 times higher than passenger car occupants.

In conclusion, while the implementation of 20 mph speed limits may cause frustration for some drivers, the benefits for road safety and pollution reduction are significant. By reducing speeds, we can create safer roads, improve air quality, and promote more efficient fuel consumption, ultimately contributing to a healthier environment for all.

Environmental impact

There is a common misconception that driving at lower speeds increases pollution. This is based on the assumption that slower driving leads to lower fuel economy and, consequently, higher emissions. However, this assumption doesn't consider the unique conditions of urban driving, where factors like acceleration, deceleration, and braking play a significant role in fuel consumption and pollution levels.

Research has shown that in built-up areas, the key factor influencing fuel consumption is the frequency of acceleration and deceleration. When a vehicle accelerates from a standstill to higher speeds, it consumes more fuel. In typical stop/start urban traffic, fuel efficiency peaks when the speed is capped at around 15-20 mph. At these lower speeds, drivers can achieve significant fuel savings without significantly extending their trip duration. This reduction in fuel consumption directly contributes to lowering carbon dioxide emissions, which is a critical factor in reducing air pollution and mitigating the environmental impact of vehicular travel.

Additionally, slower speeds can reduce the incidence of acceleration, deceleration, and braking, further decreasing fuel consumption and emissions. This is particularly relevant in areas with speed limits of around 20 mph, where drivers can adopt a steadier driving pattern, minimizing the need for frequent acceleration and braking. This steadier driving style not only reduces fuel consumption but also contributes to a calmer and safer driving environment.

However, some commentators argue that driving at 20 mph can increase emissions under certain conditions. They suggest that when a car maintains a steady speed of 20 mph, it may emit similar levels of CO2 and particulates as a car travelling at 30 mph in a higher gear. In this scenario, the car travelling at 20 mph may take longer to cover the same distance, resulting in comparable or slightly higher emissions for the journey. Nevertheless, this perspective acknowledges that modern cars can comfortably maintain 20 mph in third or fourth gear, minimizing the potential for increased emissions.

The environmental impact of 20 mph speed limits extends beyond just emissions. These reduced speed zones can also contribute to making towns and cities cleaner, safer places for walking and cycling, and generally more pleasant places to spend time. The slower speeds encourage a calmer atmosphere, reducing stress for drivers, pedestrians, and cyclists alike. Additionally, lower speed limits can help reduce road-related deaths, particularly involving children, which is a crucial consideration in built-up areas.

In summary, while there are differing viewpoints on the environmental impact of driving at 20 mph, the weight of research suggests that slower speeds in urban areas can lead to significant fuel savings and reduced emissions. Additionally, the broader benefits of reduced speed limits, including improved safety, cleaner air, and enhanced liveability, contribute positively to the environmental impact discussion.

Driver experience

Driving at 20mph in urban areas can reduce fuel consumption and emissions, but the driver experience may vary depending on several factors. Firstly, some drivers express frustration with 20mph speed limits, especially in areas where they perceive a higher speed to be safer or more appropriate. They argue that driving at 20mph requires lower gears, which increase engine speeds and emissions. In addition, some drivers find that they need to accelerate and decelerate more frequently at lower speeds, which can be frustrating and may also impact fuel efficiency.

However, other drivers find that maintaining a constant speed of 20mph is achievable and even comfortable in third or fourth gear in modern cars. This consistent speed reduces the need for sharp acceleration and deceleration, which are major contributors to fuel consumption and emissions. By eliminating these abrupt manoeuvres, drivers can achieve significant energy and emission savings, improving air quality and reducing stress while driving.

The experience of driving at 20mph is also influenced by the traffic management measures in place. For example, traffic circles or roundabouts are preferred over speed bumps or stop signs because they allow for smoother driving patterns with milder acceleration. Well-designed traffic calming measures can help drivers maintain a steady speed, reducing the negative impacts of stop-and-start driving on fuel efficiency and emissions.

Additionally, the presence of 20mph zones in specific areas, such as near schools, hospitals, or residential neighbourhoods, can improve the driver experience by creating a safer and calmer environment for all road users. Drivers may feel less rushed and more attentive to their surroundings, which can enhance their overall driving comfort and reduce the risk of accidents.

Overall, the driver experience of adhering to 20mph speed limits can vary. While some drivers may express frustration due to the perception of increased engine noise, emissions, and stop-and-start driving, others find that maintaining a constant speed reduces stress, improves fuel efficiency, and contributes to a safer and more pleasant driving environment.

Vehicle performance

Driving at 20 mph in urban areas can be beneficial for vehicle performance in terms of fuel efficiency and cost savings, but it may also have some trade-offs in terms of journey time and driver experience.

Fuel Efficiency and Cost Savings:

Research suggests that driving at a steady speed of 20 mph can improve fuel efficiency, especially in urban areas with frequent stop-starts. This is because accelerating back up to higher speed limits after slowing down or stopping increases fuel consumption. By maintaining a lower speed limit, drivers can reduce the number of times they need to accelerate, resulting in fuel savings of up to 30%. Modern internal combustion engines can achieve fuel efficiency of about 90 mpg at a constant 20 mph, although this may vary depending on the vehicle and driving conditions.

Traffic Calming Measures:

Implementing 20 mph speed limits can also improve vehicle performance by encouraging the use of traffic circles or roundabouts instead of speed humps or stop signs. Traffic circles allow for smoother driving patterns and milder acceleration behaviour, reducing fuel consumption and emissions. This can lead to significant improvements in air quality and energy consumption.

Journey Time and Driver Experience:

However, driving at 20 mph may result in longer journey times, as vehicles will be in the lower gear for a longer duration. This can be a trade-off between fuel efficiency and journey time, as some argue that driving at higher speeds in a higher gear can result in similar fuel consumption to driving at 20 mph in a lower gear. Additionally, some drivers may find maintaining a constant speed of 20 mph challenging and may require more frequent glances at the speedometer.

Overall, while driving at 20 mph can improve fuel efficiency and reduce costs, it may also impact journey times and driver experience. The optimal speed for vehicle performance depends on various factors, including the vehicle type, driving conditions, and traffic calming measures in place.

Frequently asked questions