Vaping And Air Pollution: What's The Real Damage?

Vapes, or electronic cigarettes, have become increasingly popular in recent years. With this rise in popularity, concerns have been raised about their impact on air quality and public health. Studies have shown that vaping can cause indoor air pollution and potentially harm not just active users but also bystanders through secondhand exposure. The high levels of indoor air pollutants produced by vapes, such as nicotine, heavy metals, and volatile organic compounds, have led to calls for precautionary measures to protect public health. However, the extent of the environmental and health impacts of vaping is still not fully understood, and further research is needed to inform policy decisions.

Vaping conventions and indoor air pollution

Electronic cigarettes (e-cigs) are a source of indoor air pollution. They generate fewer carcinogenic and toxic compounds than traditional cigarettes (t-cigs) but still produce substantial amounts of PG, VG, and nicotine, as well as some toxic compounds such as aldehydes and heavy metals. The amount and toxicity of substances released depend on the type of device, how it is used, and the e-liquid used.

E-cigs are commonly used in many indoor places, such as homes, cars, restaurants, bars, workplaces, and vape shops. This has led to concerns about the health risks of secondhand exposure to e-cig aerosols, especially for vulnerable populations such as children, adolescents, and pregnant women.

Vaping conventions, which are public events promoting e-cigarettes and allowing indoor use, can result in high levels of indoor air pollution due to the large concentration of people vaping and poor ventilation. Studies have found that vaping conventions can have extremely high concentrations of particulate matter (PM10), total volatile organic compounds (TVOCs), carbon dioxide (CO2), and airborne nicotine, significantly impairing indoor air quality. These high levels of pollutants expose attendees, vendors, and other staff to potential health risks.

The detection of airborne nicotine, a specific marker for e-cigarette use, confirms that e-cigarettes are a major source of indoor air pollution during these conventions. The indoor PM10 concentration at a vaping convention in Maryland, USA, was estimated to be 1800 μg/m3, 12 times higher than the EPA 24-hour regulation of 150 μg/m3. The PM2.5 concentrations reported in vape shops and vaping conventions are about twice as high as those in hookah bars and significantly higher than in common indoor environments without e-cigs.

While ventilation, filtration, and air cleaning techniques may reduce harmful substances, they are not likely to eliminate them. Therefore, precautionary measures are necessary to protect public health, and further studies are needed to inform policy and mitigate the impact of indoor vaping on air quality.

Vape shops and air pollution

Vaping has gained popularity as a less harmful alternative to smoking. However, the use of e-cigarettes in vape shops has raised concerns about indoor air pollution and its potential health risks.

E-cigarettes emit aerosols containing harmful substances such as nicotine, formaldehyde, heavy metals, and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). These aerosols can be inhaled by both users and bystanders, leading to potential secondhand exposure. While studies on the health effects of secondhand e-cigarette aerosols are limited, the chemical composition profiles show similarities to those of mainstream e-cigarette aerosols but with lower concentrations. Nevertheless, precautionary measures are necessary to protect public health due to the high levels of indoor air pollutants produced by e-cigarettes.

Several studies have reported high concentrations of PM2.5 resulting from e-cigarette use in vape shops, reaching up to 1,121 μg/m3, which is significantly higher than the World Health Organization's recommended limit. The impact of e-cigarettes on indoor air quality in vape shops is comparable to, or even greater than, other nicotine delivery systems. The lack of adequate ventilation in many vape shops exacerbates the problem, leading to increased particle levels and nicotine pollution.

The indoor air pollution caused by e-cigarettes in vape shops can also affect neighbouring businesses and outdoor areas, especially during door-open periods. Nicotine and ultrafine particles from e-cigarette aerosols have been detected in nearby spaces, posing potential health risks to employees, patrons, and bystanders in adjacent areas.

To mitigate the air pollution and health risks associated with vape shops, enhancing ventilation and air filtration is crucial. While ventilation, filtration, and air cleaning techniques can reduce harmful substances, they may not eliminate them entirely. Therefore, further research and policy interventions are needed to effectively address the issue of indoor air pollution in vape shops and protect the health of both employees and customers.

Harmful substances in e-cigarette aerosols

E-cigarettes contain a range of harmful substances in their aerosols, which can have adverse effects on the health of both the user and bystanders. The aerosolized mixture from a solution (i.e. e-liquid) typically contains nicotine, flavouring chemicals, vegetable glycerin (VG), and propylene glycol (PG). The nicotine levels and the flavouring of the chemicals make e-cigarettes particularly addictive, especially for younger people.

The flavouring components are often not included in e-cigarette products' ingredient lists. These chemicals could be harmful when they are aerosolized and inhaled, as they are not safety-tested for exposure routes other than ingestion. For instance, saccharides, which are used to make sweet e-liquid flavours, degrade and produce furans and aldehydes when heated. Sweet, chocolate, and cinnamon flavouring chemicals in e-liquids have shown cytotoxic effects, oxidative stress, and inflammation responses in several in vitro studies.

The heating process of the e-liquid can also produce chemical reactions that form toxic compounds such as carbonyl compounds, including reactive aldehydes, formaldehyde, and acetaldehyde, which are considered to have toxic effects on human health. The heating process can also facilitate the transfer of heavy metals (e.g. nickel, cadmium, chromium, and lead) from the coil into the e-liquid. E-liquid impurities and the breakdown of wick material may also lead to the presence of toxic elements such as arsenic and silica in e-liquids.

The aerosol emissions from e-cigarettes have been found to contain harmful substances such as nicotine, formaldehyde, acetaldehyde, metals, carbonyls, and reactive oxygen species (ROS). These toxic compounds can have adverse effects on oral health, and there is evidence to suggest that they can also negatively affect the lungs and the rest of the body.

The high levels of indoor air pollutants produced by e-cigarettes have been well-documented, with studies reporting high concentrations of PM2.5 resulting from e-cigs. The impacts of e-cigs on indoor air quality are similar to, if not greater than, other combustion-free nicotine delivery systems. The high levels of indoor air pollutants produced by e-cigs call for precautionary measures to protect public health, such as enhancing ventilation and air filtration.

E-cigarette waste and environmental impact

E-cigarettes are a growing waste management concern. The rapid expansion of e-cigarette usage has led to a significant increase in toxic and plastic waste. Many popular e-cigarettes are pod-based with single-use plastic cartridges containing nicotine. Disposable e-cigarettes are also designed entirely for one-time use and have seen a 1,000% increase in use among high school students between 2019 and 2020. With a 399.73% increase in retail e-cigarette sales from 2015 to 2020, the environmental consequences of e-cigarette waste are enormous. E-cigarette waste is a potentially more serious environmental threat than cigarette butts as they introduce plastic, nicotine salts, heavy metals, lead, mercury, and flammable lithium-ion batteries into waterways, soil, and wildlife.

E-cigarette waste is classified as 'hazardous' due to the presence of toxic materials such as mercury, lead, or brominated flame retardants. E-cigarettes also contain precious metals like gold, copper, and nickel, as well as rare materials like indium and palladium. The disposal of e-cigarettes poses a long-term environmental threat due to their material composition. E-cigarettes are consumed and discarded much more quickly than typical electronics, contributing to the growing problem of e-waste, which is already an overwhelming issue, with 99 billion pounds discarded annually according to 2017 global estimates.

The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has the authority to require e-cigarette manufacturers to comply with product robustness standards to ensure proper disposal and minimize environmental health harms. However, e-cigarettes are currently sold with minimal oversight by regulatory institutions, and it is unclear what environmental compliance standards the FDA will enforce. To prevent unnecessary environmental harm, the FDA must act quickly to designate product robustness standards and standardize closed-loop manufacturing and disposal of e-cigarettes.

The environmental impact of e-cigarettes is a novel public health concern that requires urgent investigation. The manufacturing, using, and disposing of e-cigarettes present unique environmental harms compared to traditional cigarettes. The impact of e-cigarettes on the environmental determinants of health, such as air quality, water, land use, and animals, needs to be rigorously assessed to understand the full scope of their environmental and health consequences.

E-cigarette aerosol and secondhand exposure

Electronic cigarettes (e-cigs) are a source of indoor air pollution. The use of e-cigs in indoor spaces such as vape shops, homes, cars, restaurants, bars, and workplaces can expose bystanders to e-cigarette aerosols. It is estimated that more than 70% of inhaled e-cigarette aerosols are eventually exhaled, which may cause secondhand exposure. The aerosol particles are smaller than 1000 nanometers, which is a similar size to tobacco smoke and diesel engine smoke.

E-cigarette aerosols can contain potentially harmful substances, including nicotine, formaldehyde, heavy metals, volatile organic compounds, and other toxicants. The amount and toxicity of the substances released depend on several factors, such as the type of device, how it is operated and used, and the e-liquid used. The US Surgeon General has concluded that e-cigarette aerosol is not harmless, and exposure to it may have harmful health effects. Some of the harmful substances emitted in secondhand e-cigarette aerosols are the same as those in secondhand tobacco smoke.

Studies have found high concentrations of PM2.5 resulting from e-cigarette use, which can reach up to 1,121 μg/m3, or about 45 times the World Health Organization's recommended 25 μg/m3 limit for 24-hour outdoor concentrations. The reported indoor PM2.5 levels during e-cigarette use are often above 150 μg/m3, similar to those produced by traditional cigarettes. The impacts of e-cigarettes on indoor air quality are also similar to, if not greater than, other combustion-free nicotine delivery systems such as water pipes and "heat-not-burn" products.

While ventilation, filtration, and air cleaning techniques may reduce harmful substances released from e-cigarette use indoors, they are not likely to eliminate them. Prohibiting e-cigarette use inside or near buildings, vehicles, and other enclosed spaces is the only way to completely prevent exposure to secondhand e-cigarette aerosol and the associated health risks.

Frequently asked questions