Who Cares More About Pollution?

There is a gender gap in environmental views and climate change opinions, with women expressing more concern about the environment and the impact of climate change. Women are more likely to be harmed by environmental problems like climate change and air pollution, and they are also more susceptible to the negative health effects of air pollution. Studies have found that gender socialization and resulting value systems, such as altruism and compassion, may contribute to these differences. Additionally, women's roles as primary caregivers and food providers, as well as their socioeconomic status, can increase their vulnerability to climate-related issues. Furthermore, women tend to be more committed to greener actions and sustainable dietary patterns, such as veganism and vegetarianism. However, it is important to note that individual, social, and cultural factors also play a role in shaping people's understanding and actions towards the environment and climate change.

Women are more susceptible to the negative health effects of pollution

Research has shown that women are more susceptible to the negative health effects of pollution. This is due to a combination of biological and socially derived gendered exposure factors. Firstly, certain chronic health conditions, such as COPD and asthma, are more prevalent in women than in men. As a result, exposure to air pollution can exacerbate these conditions or increase the risk of developing them. Additionally, women experience higher rates of reproductive issues, including miscarriages, stillbirths, and pregnancy complications when exposed to high levels of air pollution. This is particularly concerning given that air pollution is linked to adverse pregnancy outcomes such as low birth weight and small gestational age.

Another factor contributing to women's increased susceptibility is their socio-economic status. Women, especially single mothers, are more vulnerable to poverty and often have less socio-economic power than men. This makes it difficult for them to recover from the impacts of climate change, such as natural disasters. Furthermore, gender norms and societal expectations influence women's exposure to pollution. For example, women are more likely to be caregivers and food providers, increasing their exposure to household air pollution, which has similar health risks and disease pathways as ambient air pollution.

Gender also shapes activity patterns and the use of personal care and cleaning products, which can increase exposure to pollutants. For instance, nickel dermatitis and hand eczema are more prevalent among women in Western countries due to chronic exposures from jewelry. Additionally, cosmetic use and personal care products can contain pollutants that women are more likely to be exposed to. These exposures can interact with biological sex differences, such as dermal thickness and permeability, influencing the dose and health outcomes of pollution exposure.

The effects of pollution on women's health are further exacerbated by their access to healthcare. Women may have lesser healthcare access, poorer nutrition, and greater stress or violence exposure, which can increase their susceptibility to the negative health effects of pollution. Furthermore, women's health issues may be underrepresented in health research, leading to a knowledge gap in understanding the full extent of pollution's impact on women's health. Overall, it is evident that women bear a disproportionate burden when it comes to the negative health consequences of pollution, and this disparity needs to be addressed through targeted interventions and policies.

Women are more likely to be harmed by environmental problems

Secondly, women are often the primary caregivers and food providers, and they tend to have less socioeconomic power than men. As a result, they are more vulnerable to climate problems such as flooding, droughts, and hurricanes. For example, in the US, 83% of low-income single mothers did not return to their homes in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina in 2005. Single mothers are vulnerable to poverty, as they often have to care for themselves and their children with little or no income.

Thirdly, women's health is more threatened by climate change. Pregnant women are at a higher risk of infectious diseases, food and water insecurity, and worsening heat waves. Air pollution is considered a leading threat to pregnant women and their babies. In addition, women are more likely to suffer from health issues caused by indoor fossil fuel burning, such as kitchen PM2.5 concentrations.

Finally, women face higher rates of violence, displacement, and human trafficking as a result of climate change. In Northeastern Nigeria, for example, the terrorist group Boko Haram has targeted women displaced from their land by drought. Climate change can also fuel the rise of human trafficking and extreme labor exploitation, with women and marginalized groups being the most vulnerable to these human rights violations.

Women are more concerned about the environment and have stronger pro-climate beliefs

Several studies have found that women are more concerned about the environment and have stronger pro-climate beliefs than men. For instance, a 2017 survey by the Yale Program on Climate Change Communication found that women are more likely to agree with climate scientists, believe that climate change will be harmful, and be concerned about climate change than men. Similarly, a 2018 study by researchers from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln and the International Labour Organization in Geneva, Switzerland, found that female economists are more likely to support environmental policies than their male counterparts. This suggests that having more female leaders and politicians could lead to a greater likelihood of reducing emissions to safe levels.

There are several proposed explanations for the gender gap in environmental views and climate change opinions. One factor may be gender socialization and the resulting value systems. Research has found that females are often socialized to be more caring, altruistic, cooperative, and helpful, while males are socialized to be more independent and competitive. As a result of these different expectations, women may be more inclined to foster bonds with nature and have a higher level of concern for the environment. For example, women tend to be more concerned about specific environmental problems, particularly local issues, and are more likely to view climate change as harmful to themselves, their communities, and future generations.

Biological differences between men and women may also play a role in their varying susceptibility to the health effects of air pollution. Women's bodies metabolize pollutants more quickly than men's, resulting in higher toxicity. Additionally, sex steroid hormones may influence the effectiveness of lung immunity in response to air pollution. Furthermore, gendered work and caregiving roles can influence chemical body burden, with women often taking on the role of primary caregivers and food providers, making them more vulnerable to the impacts of climate change.

The impacts of climate change disproportionately affect women, particularly single mothers, who are vulnerable to poverty and the challenges of caring for their children with limited resources. United Nations data shows that globally, women make up 80% of people displaced by climate change. Additionally, in the context of public health, air pollution poses a significant threat to pregnant women and their unborn children. Therefore, it is not surprising that women are more concerned about the environment and have stronger pro-climate beliefs, as they are often more directly affected by the consequences of climate change and environmental degradation.

Women are more likely to be vegan or vegetarian

While political views play a strong role in shaping Americans' opinions on climate change, research shows a small but consistent gender gap in environmental views and climate change opinions. On average, women are slightly more likely than men to be concerned about the environment and have stronger pro-climate beliefs. For instance, a 2017 survey by the Yale Program on Climate Change Communication found that women are more likely to agree with climate scientists, believe that climate change will be harmful, and be concerned about climate change than men. This may be due to the fact that women are more likely to be the primary caregivers and food providers in many countries, making them more vulnerable to climate problems.

Women are also more likely to be vegan or vegetarian than men. This could be attributed to the perception that eating meat is associated with masculinity. Some men may feel that consuming a vegetarian diet is incongruent with maintaining a masculine identity and is therefore socially discouraged. This idea of "precarious masculinity" may explain why men feel sensitive about eating foods that are considered feminine, such as salads or tofu. Additionally, women tend to be more compassionate, especially towards animals, and are more likely to have a problem with animal use and experimentation. They are also more likely to keep pets and less likely to abuse them. Feminists and animal activists have been working together for over a century, with prominent campaigners for women’s suffrage, Alice Wright and Edith Good, lobbying the United Nations to give animals formal rights in the 1940s.

Furthermore, women may be more motivated to follow a vegetarian or vegan diet due to health concerns or a desire to eat lightly. Social expectations of gender and eating manifest themselves in individuals' behaviors in romantic contexts, with women being more concerned about eating lightly and viewing vegetables as more acceptable dating foods than men. However, it is important to note that these gender differences in dietary choices may also be influenced by other social and cultural factors, and individual differences in values and beliefs.

Women are more likely to recycle and care about water waste

A study by Aaron Brough and James E.B. Wilkie found that men are more likely to donate to environmental organizations with masculine logos and are less likely to buy products marked as "green." Both men and women perceive consumers who recycle or buy green products as more feminine. Additionally, men are equally likely to avoid green practices in public and private, indicating a concern for maintaining their self-perception of masculinity.

Empathy may also play a role in these differences. A study by Steven Arnocky and Mirella L. Stroink found that gender differences in environmental attitudes could be explained by the presence or absence of emotional empathy. Women, who are generally more empathetic, expressed greater levels of altruistic concern and cooperation for the sake of the ecosystem, while men expressed more competitiveness for resources.

Women are also disproportionately affected by water waste and lack of access to clean water. They are often responsible for collecting water, which can take up valuable time that could be spent on education, income-generating activities, or leisure. The lack of access to clean water at home can also lead to health issues, especially for pregnant women and children.

Furthermore, women tend to have less socioeconomic power and are more vulnerable to climate problems, including natural hazards like flooding, droughts, and hurricanes. They are also more likely to be displaced by climate change and face higher health risks from air pollution, particularly during pregnancy. Overall, women's greater concern for the environment and their unique experiences with water waste highlight the importance of addressing these issues to promote gender equality and improve public health.

Frequently asked questions