Dams And Air Pollution: A Complex Relationship

Dams are massive structures that retain water for various purposes, including domestic use, irrigation, and power generation. While they can provide benefits to people, dams also have significant negative impacts on the environment, wildlife, and human communities. In this paragraph, we will explore the question: do dams contribute to air pollution?

Dams can increase methane emissions

Dams are often considered clean, renewable sources of power, but they can have a significant impact on the environment. Dams can increase methane emissions, a greenhouse gas with even worse effects than carbon dioxide. The construction and operation of hydroelectric dams require the creation of reservoirs by flooding the area upstream, which causes the formation of greenhouse gases. The flooding of organic matter leads to its decomposition, resulting in a large release of carbon dioxide during the first 20 years after a dam's construction. However, the rise of methane poses a bigger problem.

Over time, the water collected behind dams will release greater amounts of methane. A recent study published in Nature Geoscience analyzed data and projections from 9,000 reservoirs on five continents to assess their climate impact from 1900 to 2060. The study found that while carbon dioxide emissions are declining, methane emissions have increased and will likely continue to rise without mitigation measures.

The increase in methane emissions from reservoirs is due to several factors. Firstly, methane is often concentrated in deep water, and one of the major ways it is emitted is through degassing, when water is pulled from the reservoir depths and passed through turbines or a spillway. The turbulence and flow into the river below allow the supersaturated methane to come into contact with the atmosphere, where it is rapidly emitted. Additionally, warmer waters produce more algae, and increased storms and runoff send more nutrients into rivers and the impoundments created by dams, leading to more methane emissions.

The impact of methane emissions from dams can be mitigated to some extent. For example, managers can change the depth of water withdrawal from reservoirs to potentially reduce emissions. A study at a Malaysian dam found that varying the withdrawal depth could reduce methane emissions by up to 90%. Additionally, dams on river systems with fewer nutrients to feed algae growth could produce less methane than dams on higher nutrient streams.

Dams can cause flooding

Dams are supposed to prevent flooding by storing water and releasing it in the dry season, and by holding back floods. However, several factors can cause dams to increase the risk of flooding.

Firstly, dams can cause flooding by altering the natural flow and composition of the water within rivers and channels. Water released downstream from dams has unnaturally high energy and very little sediment, which causes "hungry water" to run forcefully downstream, eroding riverbeds without sufficient sediment to offset their losses. This deepens the riverbed compared to the surrounding water table, causing the groundwater to rush into the channel and become surface water—a process known as incision.

Secondly, dams can increase evaporation rates in the surrounding region, leading to increased heavy rainfall. This can disrupt traditional rainfall patterns, placing stress on ecosystems and human settlements that depend on them. It also contributes to more frequent and intense flooding, as the increased rainfall can lead to river levels rising beyond the dam's capacity.

Additionally, the accumulation of sediment in reservoirs over time reduces their capacity to hold water. This decreased capacity can lead to an increased risk of flooding, as the dam may not be able to contain extreme rainfall events or high river flows.

Moreover, the presence of a dam can impede the natural flow of water, causing it to back up, overflow riverbanks, and spill onto the floodplain. This backup effect can be exacerbated by the formation of dunes in the riverbed, which can slow down floodwaters and cause water levels to rise.

It is important to note that the impact of dams on flooding varies depending on the specific characteristics of the river, such as the type of sediment it carries, and the design and maintenance of the dam itself. While dams can provide benefits, it is crucial to carefully consider their potential downsides and implement measures to mitigate any negative impacts on flooding and the environment.

Dams can negatively impact the water quality

Dams can negatively impact water quality in several ways. Firstly, they can alter the natural flow of rivers, disrupting the seasonal flow variations that trigger growth and reproduction cycles in many species. This can negatively affect both upstream and downstream ecosystems, including fish spawning habitats. For example, salmon are adapted to living in rivers, and changing their habitat to a lake can have detrimental effects on their life cycle and make them more vulnerable to predators.

Secondly, dams can cause temperature fluctuations in the water. Water held in reservoirs tends to heat up, increasing the temperature of the river. This can be particularly harmful to coldwater streams, as elevated temperatures can increase stress and even lead to the death of fish, mussels, stream insects, and other aquatic organisms. Warmer temperatures can also favour non-native generalist species, leading to a replacement of native coldwater species.

Thirdly, dams can decrease oxygen levels in the water. The water released from the bottom of a reservoir often has low oxygen levels, which can cause problems for aquatic life downstream. Additionally, organic material in the water can use up oxygen as it decomposes, further reducing oxygen levels. Low oxygen levels can have detrimental effects on stream wildlife.

Moreover, dams can trap sediment, burying rock riverbeds and disrupting the creation and maintenance of complex habitats downstream. They can also prevent the natural movement of gravel, logs, and other important food and habitat features, negatively impacting the ecosystem. In addition, the water released downstream from dams has very little sediment, causing "hungry water" that erodes riverbeds.

Finally, dams can increase evaporation, changing the moisture concentration of the air and leading to increased heavy rainfall. This can disrupt traditional rainfall patterns, placing stress on ecosystems and communities that depend on them. Overall, while dams can have benefits, it is important to carefully consider and mitigate their potential negative impacts on water quality and the surrounding environment.

Dams can disrupt fish migration

Dams are engineered barriers that can block fish migration, limiting their ability to access spawning habitats, seek food, and escape predators. This disruption can lead to a decline in fish populations and affect the entire ecosystem, as fish are often crucial prey for other animals and important for commercial and recreational fisheries.

Fish, such as salmon, steelhead trout, shad, alewives, and sturgeon, migrate to their native habitats for reproduction. However, dams can act as physical barriers, preventing their upstream migration and disrupting their biological processes. This disruption can lead to a reduction in fish populations, as they are unable to reproduce and build their numbers.

To mitigate this issue, some dams have been retrofitted with upstream passage structures like fish ladders or fish locks. These structures enable adult fish to swim upstream to spawn and then return downstream with their young. However, the effectiveness of these fish passes can vary depending on the species of fish and the number of dams they have to traverse.

Downstream passage at dams remains a complex problem. Fish may face migration delays, increased predation rates, and water temperatures that are too warm for their survival. The lack of downstream passage can lead to ecological traps, where fish can move above dams to spawn, but their offspring struggle to make it back downstream to complete their life cycles.

Additionally, dams can alter the natural flow and composition of the water within rivers. The water released downstream from dams has high energy and low sediment levels, causing "hungry water" that erodes riverbeds. These changes in river composition can further interfere with the chemical signals that guide fish migration.

Dams can alter river composition

Dams are large structures that retain water for various purposes, including domestic use, irrigation, and hydroelectricity generation. While they have been built to benefit people, they can also have unfavourable effects on people, wildlife, and the environment. Dams can alter river composition in several ways.

Firstly, dams can disrupt the natural flow and composition of water within rivers and channels. Water released downstream from dams has abnormally high energy and very little sediment, a phenomenon known as "hungry water." This water erodes riverbeds as it forcefully runs downstream, deepening the riverbed and causing groundwater to rush into the channel, becoming surface water in a process called incision. This alteration in river composition can stress both upstream and downstream habitats, leading to habitat loss, which is the leading cause of extinction.

Secondly, dams can prevent fish migration by acting as physical barriers. This disruption interferes with the chemical signals that guide species through their biological processes, such as spawning and rearing. For example, salmon and river herring depend on steady flows to navigate their migration and spawning habitats. The presence of a dam can delay or trap fish, making them more vulnerable to predators. Additionally, changes in water flow patterns, such as irregular releases during peak demand periods for hydropower, can disrupt the natural seasonal flow variations that trigger growth and reproduction cycles in many species.

Moreover, dams can alter the quality of water in reservoirs and downstream. Water quality can deteriorate when stored in a reservoir due to factors such as organic material decomposition, which reduces oxygen levels. Slow-moving or stagnant reservoir water can also heat up, causing abnormal temperature fluctuations that affect sensitive species and potentially leading to algal blooms and further decreased oxygen levels. These changes in water quality and temperature can have cascading effects on the entire aquatic ecosystem.

Dams can also impact the river substrate composition, trapping gravel, sand, rocks, and large pieces of wood in the reservoir. This can result in a loss of spawning gravel downstream, affecting the habitat and reproductive success of fish species like salmon that rely on these substrates. Additionally, the absence of large wood in the downstream river channels can lead to a more straight and ditch-like stream morphology, further altering the river's composition and habitat availability.

Frequently asked questions