Air Quality In Philadelphia: Historical Pollution Problems

Philadelphia has a long history of air pollution, with the contamination of the region's air, land, and water reflecting the civic and economic ambitions of its residents, businesses, and communities. The city's air pollution problem is primarily driven by ozone, a gas pollutant formed from precursor pollutants suspended in the atmosphere and reacting to sunlight. In 2019, the Philadelphia-Reading-Camden metro area was ranked among the top 25 most polluted regions in the United States for ozone and particle pollution. While there have been improvements in air quality over the years, residents of Philadelphia continue to breathe unhealthy air, facing serious health risks.

Philadelphia's air quality is poor due to ozone and particle pollution

Philadelphia has long struggled with air pollution. In the early 1700s, founder William Penn's intentions for a spacious, orderly grid were thwarted as fetid alleyways developed between major streets. The lack of paved roads meant that foot and carriage traffic soiled the air with dust or mud, depending on the weather. Benjamin Franklin's call for trash collection and street paving in 1757 led to the commencement of street paving in 1762, but pollution continued to worsen. In the 1950s, Philadelphia's open trash dumps were closed, and incinerators began handling solid waste, emitting hazardous fly ash particles.

Today, Philadelphia's air quality is primarily afflicted by ozone and particle pollution. Ozone is a gas pollutant formed from precursor pollutants suspended in the atmosphere and reacting in sunlight. It has been likened to experiencing sunburn inside the airways, particularly for children, older adults, and those with asthma and other lung diseases. Warmer temperatures brought by climate change make ozone more likely to form and harder to clean up.

Particle pollution, or fine particle pollution, is a complex mixture of particles commonly derived from car exhaust, coal power plants, wildfires, construction, and agriculture that react with the atmosphere. These particles are so small that they can lodge deep in the lungs and trigger asthma attacks, heart attacks, and strokes, and can even be lethal. Short-term spikes in fine particle pollution can be deadly.

The Philadelphia-Reading-Camden metro area has consistently ranked among the top 25 most polluted in the United States for ozone and particle pollution. In 2019, the area worsened for a second year for ozone smog, although it improved for year-round particle pollution. The metro area's air quality has improved since 1980, but residents should still be aware that they are breathing unhealthy air, driven by local emissions, upwind sources, and extreme heat due to climate change.

The city's weather conditions and geographical location worsen air pollution

Philadelphia has consistently ranked as one of the worst metropolitan areas in the US for ozone and particle pollution. The city's air quality is primarily afflicted by ozone, a gas pollutant formed from precursor pollutants reacting in sunlight. The weather conditions and geographical location of Philadelphia worsen air pollution by facilitating the formation and accumulation of these harmful pollutants.

Ozone is formed more efficiently in hot and sunny weather. Philadelphia has experienced a rise in temperature over the past three years, which has contributed to the worsening of ozone levels. Heat waves, characterized by extreme heat and stagnant air, increase ozone and particulate pollution. The accumulated heat in Philadelphia is lost at night due to the lack of cloud cover, trapping cooled air and pollutants such as carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides at ground level. This phenomenon exacerbates the city's air pollution problem.

The geographical location of Philadelphia also plays a role in its air pollution issues. The city is susceptible to upwind sources of pollution that cross state lines from other states. Philadelphia's position downwind of these sources means that it receives a significant amount of pollution from outside its immediate vicinity. This is a common issue, as air pollution can be easily transported over long distances by wind and air movement.

Seasonal variations also impact Philadelphia's air quality. For example, ammonia concentrations increase drastically in the spring due to agricultural activities, contributing to secondary particulate matter. In the winter, nitrogen dioxide levels are higher due to the increased use of fuel-burning heating systems.

The combination of weather conditions and geographical factors contributes to Philadelphia's air pollution problem. The city's climate, with its hot summers and cold winters, facilitates the formation and accumulation of harmful pollutants. Additionally, Philadelphia's location downwind of other pollution sources exacerbates the issue, highlighting the complex interplay between weather and geography in influencing air quality.

Air pollution is worse in industrial areas and near highways

Air pollution is a significant environmental health hazard, causing over 6.5 million deaths annually worldwide. It is a mix of hazardous substances from both human-made and natural sources. While air pollution affects everyone, certain groups are more vulnerable to its harmful effects. People of colour in the United States, for instance, are more likely to live in areas with poor air quality due to historically racist zoning policies and discriminatory lending practices. Similarly, outdoor labourers, including migrant and seasonal farmworkers, are exposed to air pollution and lack the political power to advocate for cleaner air.

Philadelphia, a city in the United States, has faced air pollution issues for centuries. Early industry and commerce in the region polluted the Brandywine River and Dock Creek, a tributary of the Delaware River. In the 20th century, Mayor Richardson Dilworth targeted open trash dumps, but the subsequent use of incinerators emitted hazardous fly ash particles. Philadelphia's air quality has improved since 1980, with fewer days classified as "unhealthy" in the US Air Quality Index (AQI). However, in recent years, Philadelphia has experienced elevated levels of ozone, a harmful gas pollutant formed from precursor pollutants reacting in sunlight.

Industrial areas and locations near highways are particularly susceptible to air pollution. Vehicle emissions, industrial discharges, and fuel oils contribute to poor air quality in these areas. Research has linked exposure to pollutants from motor vehicles to lung and heart problems and premature death. Additionally, particulate matter (PM), composed of chemicals like sulfates and nitrates, can penetrate the lungs and bloodstream, causing or exacerbating respiratory and cardiovascular issues.

The impact of air pollution is not limited to physical health; it also affects cognitive ability. A study in China found that higher levels of air pollution correlated with lower verbal and math scores. Furthermore, air pollution can have economic consequences, such as missed workdays and increased medical costs for residents in affected areas.

Addressing air pollution in industrial areas and near highways requires a multifaceted approach. Regulations and emissions standards can help reduce pollutant emissions from vehicles and industries. Additionally, urban planning and design can incorporate noise barriers, roadside vegetation, and building configurations that minimise the impact of air pollution on nearby communities.

The Philadelphia Energy Solutions refinery explosion in 2019 highlighted the city's air pollution problem

Philadelphia has a long history of air, land, and water pollution. In the early 1700s, founder William Penn's intentions for a spacious, orderly grid were thwarted as fetid alleyways developed between the major streets. In the absence of paved roads, foot and carriage traffic soiled the air with dust or mud. Benjamin Franklin's call for trash collection and street paving in 1757 led to the dumping of trash directly into the Delaware River.

Fast forward to the 20th century, and Philadelphia's open trash dumps were closed in 1957 during Richardson Dilworth's mayoral tenure. However, the use of incinerators for solid waste disposal led to the emission of hazardous fly ash particles. The city's air quality issues continued into the 21st century, with Philadelphia ranking as one of the nation's 25 worst metro areas for ozone and year-round particle pollution, according to the American Lung Association.

The explosion was caused by a corroded elbow pipe, installed in 1973, which ruptured and led to an initial leak. This was followed by a series of explosions and a massive fire. The incident triggered concerns about air pollution, with residents and environmentalists welcoming the closure of the refinery, which had been a significant source of air emissions blamed for high rates of asthma and cancer in the surrounding communities.

While the shutdown of the Philadelphia Energy Solutions refinery reduced US refining capacity by about 2%, air pollution concerns in the city persist. Environmentalists continue to press for the cleanup of benzene and other contaminants from the soil and water beneath the former refinery site. Additionally, there are plans for new industrial facilities in the area, raising questions about the potential impact on air quality.

The Clean Water Act of 1972 and the EPA's new air pollution rules aim to improve air quality

Philadelphia has long struggled with air pollution, ranking as one of the worst metropolitan areas for ozone and year-round particle pollution. The city's air quality is primarily affected by ozone, a gas pollutant formed from precursor pollutants suspended in the atmosphere reacting to sunlight. This is exacerbated by local vehicle emissions, upwind sources crossing state lines, and extreme heat due to climate change, posing significant risks to public health.

To address this issue, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has introduced new air pollution rules, aiming to significantly improve air quality. The EPA's rules restrict the amount of fine particulate matter released into the air, reducing the annual allowance from 12 to 9 micrograms per cubic meter of air. This move is expected to have far-reaching benefits, including preventing premature deaths, reducing lost workdays, and generating substantial net health savings.

The EPA's new rules build upon existing legislation, such as the Clean Water Act of 1972, which regulates discharges of pollutants into US waters. The Clean Water Act established a framework for controlling pollution by setting wastewater standards for industries and maintaining water quality criteria for surface waters. It also made it unlawful to discharge pollutants into navigable waters without a permit.

While the Clean Water Act primarily focuses on water pollution, it indirectly contributes to improving air quality by addressing the environmental impact of industries, which are significant contributors to air pollution. The Act's provisions empower the EPA to implement pollution control programs and set standards to mitigate pollution from various sources, including industrial facilities.

The EPA's new air pollution rules and the ongoing enforcement of the Clean Water Act work in tandem to address the complex issue of air quality. By targeting both water and air pollution, these regulatory measures aim to create a healthier environment for Philadelphia's residents, protect natural habitats, and support economic and recreational activities.

Frequently asked questions