Animals And Air Pollution: Who's The Real Culprit?

While humans are often viewed as the primary contributors to air pollution, animals also play a role in this environmental issue. Animals such as cows and sheep produce methane, a potent greenhouse gas, through their digestive processes. Large populations of birds can also contaminate air quality with their droppings. Additionally, the increasing number of cats and dogs in urban areas contributes to greater pollution through their diets of processed food and the carbon emissions from producing and transporting that food. Animals, like humans, suffer harmful health effects from air pollution, and it is important to recognize their impact on the environment as well.

Livestock emissions

Methane and nitrous oxide are the most important greenhouse gases emitted by animal agriculture. Methane emissions from dairy operations, for example, have been evaluated using airborne flux measurements in California's San Joaquin Valley. In addition, nitrous oxide emissions are associated with feed production and soil carbon dioxide dynamics, such as decomposing plant residues, mineralization of soil organic matter, and land use change.

Ammonia emissions from livestock waste are also a dominant issue, contributing to particulate matter (PM) that negatively affects air quality and leads to respiratory problems and premature deaths. According to the EPA, animal waste accounts for 50-85% of ammonia emissions in the United States. The transition to cage-free housing systems for egg-laying hens, which allows them to move around freely, has resulted in a trade-off with reduced air quality in states with high egg production, such as Iowa.

To address these issues, effective emission reduction plans are necessary. This requires a comprehensive understanding of the problem, accurate monitoring technologies, and process-based models to track livestock emissions. Additionally, meteorological impacts of agricultural emissions and the complex interactions within livestock production systems must be considered to enhance the effectiveness of mitigation strategies.

While some states are taking initiatives to monitor and regulate livestock emissions, such as the proposed Community Healthy Air Act in Maryland, the passage of the Fair Agricultural Reporting Method (FARM) Act has exempted farmers and ranchers from reporting air emissions to federal agencies. This highlights the need for continued efforts and collaboration between various stakeholders to address the environmental impact of livestock emissions effectively.

Wildlife emissions

Animals are vulnerable to harm from air pollution. They are exposed to contaminated air and have no refuge from it. Air pollution can harm wildlife in two main ways: by affecting their living environment and by reducing the availability and quality of their food supply.

Acid rain, for instance, can change the chemistry and quality of soils and water, making water bodies too acidic for some animals to survive. It can also increase the release of heavy metals, such as aluminium, from soils into water habitats, which is toxic to many animals, including fish. Similarly, some pollutants can enter the food chain and damage the supply and quality of food. For example, large predator fish such as walleye and trout can have mercury levels over a million times that of the surrounding water. In turn, wildlife that consume these fish are at risk of serious health problems. Mercury is a naturally occurring toxic heavy metal, but human activity has significantly increased mercury levels in the environment over the centuries. Coal-fired power plants are the largest source of mercury contamination, accounting for approximately 50% of human-caused mercury emissions.

Air pollution can also directly impact wildlife through bioaccumulation, causing mortality, injury, disease, physiological stress, anaemia, and more. For instance, a 2017 paper assessed over 1,000 wild birds that flew over the Rust Belt states over 135 years. The researchers found that during periods of high air pollution, such as during the manufacturing boom of World War II, the birds' feathers and bellies, normally white or yellow, were stained jet black from soot.

Pets and their diets

The diets of pets, especially cats and dogs, have a significant environmental impact. The production of pet food is responsible for almost a quarter of the environmental impact of food production. This impact is expected to increase as the global pet population continues to grow. The ecological footprint of the Chinese dog and cat population, for example, is equivalent to that of 70 to 245 million Chinese citizens. In the US, the canine population alone is responsible for 25-30% of the animal production impact on land use, water, and fossil fuels.

The environmental impact of pet diets varies depending on the type of diet. Wet diets have been found to have the highest impact, while dry diets have the least impact on the environment. This is due to the positive correlation between the metabolizable energy provided by animal ingredients and the environmental impact.

The ingredients in pet food, particularly those of animal origin, contribute to higher gas emissions and land use. This is because pollutants are released into the environment through the food chain, damaging the supply and quality of food. These pollutants can accumulate in the tissues of animals, and as they are eaten by other animals, the concentration of pollutants increases. This process is known as bioaccumulation, and it can affect the health of animals, including pets, through organ injury, increased vulnerability to diseases, and reproductive issues.

Additionally, pets can be exposed to indoor and outdoor air pollution, which can impact their health. Smoke from wildfires and burning activities is a significant threat to pets, and they should be kept indoors with proper ventilation during periods of poor air quality. Particulate matter, such as PM2.5, and organic pollutants can also induce stress in dogs and increase the risk of lung cancer in both cats and dogs.

Air pollution's impact on animals

Animals are vulnerable to harm from air pollution, which is considered a form of animal cruelty. Non-human animals live their entire lives outdoors, exposed to the toxic air that we pollute. They have no refuge from contaminated air and no access to air purifiers.

Air pollution can harm wildlife in two main ways: by affecting their living environment and by impacting the availability and quality of their food supply. Acid rain, for instance, can change the chemistry and quality of soils and water, making water bodies too acidic for some animals to survive or carry out their normal physiological functions. It can also increase the release of heavy metals, such as aluminium and mercury, from soils into water habitats, which is toxic to many animals, including fish. These heavy metals can be transported through the air over long distances from their emission sources, accumulating in the tissues of animals and increasing in concentration as they move up the food chain. This process, known as bioaccumulation, particularly affects top-level predators such as bears and eagles.

Other forms of air pollution, such as smog, particulate matter, and ground-level ozone, likely harm wildlife health in similar ways to human health, including damaging the lungs and cardiovascular system. The vulnerability of animals to air pollution depends on their method of breathing and gas exchange. For instance, the feathers and bellies of white or yellow birds can become stained jet black from flying through air polluted with soot.

Air pollution can also poison wildlife through the disruption of endocrine function, organ injury, increased vulnerability to stresses and diseases, lower reproductive success, and possible death. These health impacts can, in some cases, be visible to the naked eye. As air pollution changes the abundance of certain species, it can also dramatically influence the abundance and health of dependent species.

Animals' exposure to air pollution

Animals are exposed to air pollution in various ways, and this exposure has significant impacts on their health and well-being.

Firstly, animals, both wild and domesticated, breathe the polluted air that humans generate. This air contains toxic pollutants, such as black carbon or soot, which can accumulate in their tissues, causing damage to their organs and weakening their immune systems. For example, a study of wild birds in the Rust Belt states found that increased usage of coal and fossil fuels led to birds' feathers and bellies, normally white or yellow, becoming stained jet black from flying through polluted air.

Secondly, animals are also exposed to air pollution through indirect pathways, such as water and soil contamination. Acid rain, caused by emissions of SO2 and NOx, can increase the release of heavy metals like aluminum and mercury into soils and water habitats, which are toxic to animals, especially fish. These heavy metals can be transported through the air and deposited in soils or water, where they are ingested by animals, accumulating in their bodies and magnifying up the food chain. This process, called bioaccumulation, particularly affects top predators like bears and eagles.

Additionally, air pollution can harm wildlife through the food chain. Pollutants can enter the food chain, reducing the supply and quality of food available. For instance, excessive nitrogen and phosphorus in water from nitrogen oxide deposition can cause algae to grow faster than ecosystems can handle, reducing water quality and harming aquatic life.

The vulnerability of animals to air pollution also depends on their respiratory systems. Whether they breathe through lungs, gills, or other forms of gas exchange, such as passive diffusion across the skin, will influence how air pollution affects them.

Overall, animals are exposed to air pollution through direct inhalation and indirect pathways, leading to tissue damage, organ injury, weakened immune systems, and reduced reproductive success. These impacts can have cascading effects on ecosystems, highlighting the urgent need to address air pollution and its impact on wildlife.

Frequently asked questions