Reagan's Misguided War On Pollution And Trees

Ronald Reagan claimed in 1981 that trees cause more pollution than automobiles do. His comments were widely mocked at the time, but some scientists have since confirmed that there is some truth to his statement.

Ronald Reagan's 1981 assertion that trees cause more pollution than automobiles do

In 1981, Ronald Reagan asserted that "trees cause more pollution than automobiles do". This claim was met with ridicule at the time, but it has since been partially proven correct by environmental scientists.

Reagan's claim was based on the fact that trees emit volatile organic hydrocarbons, including terpenes and isoprenes, which are linked to photochemical smog. In hot weather, the production of these hydrocarbons begins to accelerate. America's Great Smoky Mountains are thought to take their name from the photochemical smog released by the millions of hectares of hardwoods in the area.

University of Florida researchers have also found that pine trees emit eight different types of terpenes, which contribute to the global ozone problem. Reagan was referring to this when he said that "approximately 80% of our air pollution stems from hydrocarbons released by vegetation".

While Reagan's claim that trees cause more pollution than cars is not entirely accurate, it does highlight the fact that trees can contribute to air pollution in certain contexts. Diseased trees, for example, can emit high concentrations of methane, a greenhouse gas that contributes to climate change. However, as Kristofer Covey, a lead author on a study about this topic, points out, this does not negate the overall benefit of trees to the environment.

University of Florida researchers confirmed Reagan was right, in part

In 1981, Ronald Reagan stated in a speech that "trees cause more pollution than automobiles do". This claim was initially met with ridicule, but environmental scientists later confirmed that Reagan was partially correct.

University of Florida researchers found that in hot weather, trees release volatile organic hydrocarbons, including terpenes and isoprenes, two molecules linked to photochemical smog. In very hot weather, the production of these molecules begins to accelerate.

The Great Smoky Mountains in America are thought to take their name from the photochemical smog released by millions of hectares of hardwoods. Similarly, researchers at the Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies have discovered that trees in Connecticut that are diseased by fungi can emit high concentrations of methane, a greenhouse gas that contributes to climate change.

However, it is important to note that the benefits of trees still greatly outweigh their negative impacts. While Reagan was partially correct, trees play a crucial role in absorbing carbon dioxide and providing oxygen, among other environmental benefits.

Environmental scientists also confirmed Reagan's claim was partially true

In 1981, Ronald Reagan stated in a speech that "trees cause more pollution than automobiles do". Environmental scientists later confirmed that he was partially correct. In hot weather, trees release volatile organic hydrocarbons, including terpenes and isoprenes, two molecules linked to photochemical smog. In very hot weather, the production of these molecules begins to accelerate.

America's Great Smoky Mountains are supposed to take their name from the photochemical smog released by millions of hectares of hardwoods. This week, Natural Environment Research Council scientists warned that as summer temperatures rise in the UK, the isoprene output from trees could make a small but noticeable contribution to human discomfort.

Furthermore, researchers at the Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies have discovered that trees in Connecticut that are diseased by fungi can emit high concentrations of methane, a greenhouse gas that plays a role in climate change. However, lead author Kristofer Covey, a Ph.D. candidate, admitted that the methane isn't completely negating the benefit of trees, even diseased ones.

Reagan's claim was based on the fact that around 80% of air pollution comes from hydrocarbons released by vegetation

In 1981, Ronald Reagan stated in a speech that "trees cause more pollution than automobiles do". This statement was met with ridicule, but environmental scientists later confirmed that he was partially correct. Reagan's claim was based on the fact that around 80% of air pollution comes from hydrocarbons released by vegetation.

Trees release volatile organic hydrocarbons, including terpenes and isoprenes, which are two molecules linked to photochemical smog. In hot weather, the production of these molecules begins to accelerate. The Great Smoky Mountains in America are thought to take their name from the photochemical smog released by millions of hectares of hardwoods.

However, Reagan's statement should not be taken to mean that trees are more polluting than cars overall. While trees do release hydrocarbons, they also absorb carbon dioxide and produce oxygen, which helps to mitigate the effects of air pollution. In addition, trees can help to reduce pollution by acting as a physical barrier between sources of pollution and the atmosphere.

Furthermore, Reagan's statement ignores the fact that the vast majority of air pollution is caused by human activity. Industrial plants, for example, release a variety of pollutants into the atmosphere, including SO2, H2S, NO2, and HF (hydrogen fluoride). These pollutants can be carried high into the atmosphere by tall chimney stacks, but they eventually return to Earth and contribute to air pollution.

Overall, while Reagan's statement that trees cause more pollution than cars may have some truth to it, it is important to recognise that trees also play a crucial role in reducing air pollution and that the primary responsibility for air pollution lies with humans.

Reagan's claim was mostly wrong, but not completely

In 1981, Ronald Reagan stated in a speech that "trees cause more pollution than automobiles do". While Reagan's claim was mostly wrong, it was not entirely incorrect. Environmental scientists later confirmed that he was partially right. In hot weather, trees release volatile organic hydrocarbons, including terpenes and isoprenes, two molecules linked to photochemical smog.

America's Great Smoky Mountains are supposed to take their name from the photochemical smog released by millions of hectares of hardwoods. Additionally, researchers at the Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies have discovered that trees in Connecticut that are diseased by fungi can emit high concentrations of methane, a greenhouse gas contributing to climate change.

However, it is important to note that the methane emitted by diseased trees does not completely negate the benefits they provide. Trees play a crucial role in absorbing carbon dioxide and releasing oxygen, contributing to cleaner air and mitigating climate change. While Reagan's statement may have had some basis, the overall impact of trees on the environment is overwhelmingly positive, making his claim mostly wrong.

Frequently asked questions