Fish From Polluted Water: Safe To Eat?

Fish are a great source of protein, micronutrients, and healthy fats, but they can also be a source of harmful pollutants. The presence of pollutants in our oceans and waterways is a growing concern, and it's not just marine life that's at risk. Fish absorb pollutants from the water, and these toxins can accumulate over time, especially in larger, predatory fish. As a result, eating fish from polluted waters can expose humans to dangerous chemicals and heavy metals such as mercury, PCBs, dioxins, and pesticide residues. These contaminants have been linked to an increased risk of cancer, as well as neurological and behavioral problems, and can be particularly harmful to pregnant women and young children. While the health benefits of eating fish may outweigh the risks in some cases, it's important to be aware of the potential dangers and make informed choices about the types and sources of fish we consume.

Farmed fish are raised in tanks with pesticides, antibiotics, and chemicals

Farmed fish are indeed raised in tanks with pesticides, antibiotics, and chemicals. This is due to the crowded conditions in which they are kept, which can cause disease outbreaks and infections. Fish farms frequently use antibiotics to control disease in their crowded pens. While antibiotics are used as therapeutants rather than growth promoters, their overuse in farming speeds up the development of antibiotic resistance. This undermines the effectiveness of these antibiotics in treating human illnesses.

Farmed fish are also treated with vaccines, antibiotics, and chemical treatments to control diseases and pathogens. Medicinal treatments are often administered by farm veterinarians and are tightly regulated. For example, in the UK, the supply and use of medicines are regulated by the Veterinary Medicines Directorate, which maintains a list of authorised products. Similar controls exist in Norway, Canada, and Chile.

In addition to antibiotics, pesticides, and chemicals, farmed fish are also treated with fungicides. The chemical malachite green is used as a fungicide to prevent the growth of fungus on fish eggs. Malachite green is believed to be toxic, mutagenic, and carcinogenic in animals. Although its use is banned in the US, it is still used in many countries that contribute to the seafood supply.

Another concern with farmed fish is the presence of polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs). PBDEs are toxic industrial chemicals that were used as flame retardants and can alter brain function, damage DNA, and affect thyroid function. PCBs are also industrial chemicals that can accumulate in the body and lead to liver cancer, thyroid problems, and weakened immune responses. Farmed fish can contain up to 16 times more PCBs than wild-caught fish.

Fish contain pollutants such as microplastics, mercury, and PCBs

Fish are a vital source of protein for humans, and their contamination by pollutants is a significant concern. Fish can ingest microplastics, which are tiny plastic particles resulting from the degradation of plastic products. These microplastics can accumulate in the gastrointestinal tract of fish, leading to physical harm and blockage. They can also release toxic chemicals and act as carriers of microorganisms, posing risks to both fish and human health.

Microplastics can cause oxidative stress, cytotoxicity, and immune system disruption in humans. They may also translocate to other tissues and organs, leading to chronic inflammation and increased risk of cancer. In fish, microplastics can result in growth retardation, behavioural abnormalities, and neurotoxicity. The presence of microplastics in seafood poses a significant hazard to human health, and their consumption can lead to the spread of microplastics to other parts of the body.

The effects of microplastics on both fish and human health are still not fully understood, and further research is needed to assess their potential long-term impacts.

Shellfish carry hepatitis A if caught in polluted water or near sewage

Shellfish, especially bivalves such as oysters, clams, mussels, and scallops, can carry the hepatitis A virus (HAV) if caught in polluted water or near sewage. Bivalves are filter feeders, meaning they absorb food particles and nutrients by filtering out seawater. As a result, they tend to concentrate the virus present in polluted water.

Consuming contaminated shellfish that has not been thoroughly cooked can lead to a hepatitis A infection. Hepatitis A is a highly contagious liver infection that can cause mild to severe illness, with symptoms including fatigue, poor appetite, nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea, abdominal discomfort, jaundice, and tea-coloured urine. The incubation period for the disease ranges from two to six weeks.

The risk of contracting hepatitis A through shellfish consumption is higher for bivalve shellfish, such as cockles, oysters, and clams. In fact, consumption of these bivalves is strongly associated with hepatitis A outbreaks. However, it's important to note that proper handling and cooking of shellfish can make it as safe to eat as any other food source.

To minimise the risk of contracting hepatitis A from shellfish, it is recommended to:

• Buy fresh shellfish with intact shells and no abnormal odour.
• Avoid buying from illegal hawkers and unlicensed food premises.
• Scrub and rinse the shellfish in clean water.
• Cook shellfish at boiling temperature for at least five minutes.
• Remove shells before cooking, as they can impede heat penetration.
• Remove the viscera of the shellfish before cooking.
• Use separate utensils for handling raw and cooked shellfish to avoid cross-contamination.
• Obtain shellfish from reliable sources and ensure importers have the necessary health certificates.

In addition to these precautions, vaccination and good hygiene practices, including proper handwashing and safe food handling, can effectively prevent hepatitis A infection.

Larger, predatory fish have higher mercury concentrations

Fish is a great source of protein, micronutrients, and healthy fats, but it can also contain high levels of mercury, which is toxic. Mercury is a heavy metal found naturally in air, water, and soil. It is released into the environment through industrial processes, natural events, and human activities.

Some of the fish species with the highest mercury levels include:

• Shark
• Swordfish
• King mackerel
• Tuna (especially bluefin)
• Marlin
• Tilefish
• Northern pike

These larger, predatory fish may contain mercury concentrations up to 10 times higher than the fish they consume. This process is called biomagnification. For example, shark contains mercury levels greater than 1 part per million, while herring contains mercury levels at about 0.1 parts per million.

The accumulation of mercury in fish can have serious health consequences for humans who consume them. Mercury has been linked to brain problems, high blood pressure, an increased risk of heart attacks, and higher "bad" LDL cholesterol. Therefore, it is important to moderate the consumption of high-mercury fish, especially for pregnant women, breastfeeding mothers, young children, and those who regularly consume large amounts of fish.

High-risk groups for mercury toxicity include pregnant women, breastfeeding mothers, and young children

Fish absorb methylmercury, the most hazardous form of mercury, from polluted water. This is a powerful neurotoxin that can cause severe health issues, especially in high-risk groups such as pregnant women, breastfeeding mothers, and young children.

Pregnant women should be extremely cautious about consuming fish from polluted water. Methylmercury can pass through the placenta, harming the baby's brain and nervous system. Research has shown that children born to mothers who consumed high levels of mercury during pregnancy had lower cognitive function and reduced coordination. The effects on the unborn baby can be severe and long-lasting, including microcephaly and lack of eye coordination. Unborn infants are the most vulnerable to the toxic effects of mercury, with their nervous systems being particularly sensitive during the third and fourth months of gestation.

Breastfeeding mothers should also be cautious, as mercury can be transferred to the baby through breast milk. While the levels of mercury in breast milk are lower than in the womb, it can still pose a risk to the infant's developing brain and nervous system.

Young children, especially up to the age of six, are also considered high-risk. Their developing brains and nervous systems are vulnerable to the effects of methylmercury. Studies have shown that children exposed to high levels of mercury in the womb can experience issues with cognitive thinking, memory, attention, language, fine motor skills, and visual-spatial skills.

It is important to note that fish is a valuable part of a healthy diet, providing essential nutrients such as omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids. However, pregnant women, breastfeeding mothers, and young children should be selective about the types and amounts of fish they consume, choosing fish with lower mercury levels and limiting their consumption of fish with high mercury levels.

Frequently asked questions