Salt Lake City's Pollution: A Health Crisis?

Salt Lake City has some of the worst air quality in the US. The city's air quality has never met federal attainment levels for ozone or 24-hour PM2.5 pollution, resulting in consistent F ratings for both measures. In 2019, Salt Lake City was ranked 7th out of 217 metropolitan areas for the worst 24-hour particle pollution. The city's geography, at the basin of several mountains, exacerbates the pollution by trapping cold air in the Salt Lake Valley. Seasonal fluctuations also play a significant role, with winter months experiencing more pollution than summer months. The pollution has been associated with adverse health effects, including irritation to the nose, throat, and eyes, coughing, wheezing, chest pain, heart arrhythmia, and shortness of breath, and asthma.

Salt Lake City's air quality is among the worst in the US

Seasonal fluctuations play a significant role in Salt Lake City's air pollution. Temperature inversions in the winter trap polluted air, preventing its dispersal. The geography of the city, situated in a basin surrounded by mountains, exacerbates this effect by trapping cold air in the Salt Lake Valley and shielding the city from winds that could otherwise clear out inversions. Winter months in Salt Lake City tend to be the most polluted, with PM2.5 concentrations more than five times higher than in summer.

The sources of Salt Lake City's air pollution include vehicle emissions, domestic heating, transportation, and industrial emissions. Motor vehicles represent the largest source of pollution emissions, a trend common across most locations in the US. A 2023 study by NOAA also identified emissions from a magnesium refinery as a significant contributor to the city's winter pollution, accounting for 10-25% of regional PM2.5 during winter pollution episodes.

The health effects of Salt Lake City's poor air quality are significant. According to a study, 75% of Utah residents lose one year or more of their lives due to air pollution, and 23% lose five years or more. The pollution is particularly harmful to sensitive groups, including children, the elderly, and those with heart and lung diseases. Adverse health effects range from irritation to the nose, throat, and eyes, coughing, wheezing, chest pain, heart arrhythmia, and shortness of breath. The high levels of PM2.5 pollution have also been associated with increased rates of respiratory and cardiovascular diseases, stroke, cancer, and autoimmune disorders.

Seasonal fluctuations impact pollution levels

Seasonal fluctuations play a significant role in Salt Lake City's air pollution. The winter months tend to be the most polluted, with December, January, and November representing the highest AQI months. This is due to temperature inversions, where cold ground-level air becomes trapped under warmer air above, preventing the dispersal of pollutants. The unique geography of the city, situated among several mountain ranges, further exacerbates this effect by shielding the city from winds that could otherwise clear out inversions.

During winter, the city experiences temperature inversions, where the air closest to the ground is colder than the layers above it. This inversion prevents the normal upward movement of warm air, trapping polluted air and causing it to accumulate. As a result, winter months can experience more than five times the PM2.5 concentration compared to summer. This phenomenon has severe health implications, with sensitive groups such as children, the elderly, and those with respiratory or cardiovascular conditions being particularly vulnerable.

The impact of seasonal fluctuations on Salt Lake City's air quality is evident in the data. Between 2016 and 2018, the city experienced a weighted average of 25.7 days of unhealthy ozone levels and 11.5 days of unhealthy PM2.5 levels, far exceeding the US government's target of no more than 3.2 days of unhealthy pollution annually. The winter of 2019 further highlighted this issue, with AQI ratings of 60 in December, 57 in January, and 39 in November, significantly higher than the ratings in spring and summer months.

The sources of pollution contributing to these seasonal fluctuations include domestic heating and transportation. Fossil fuel combustion, particularly from home and building heating, accounts for a significant portion of harmful emissions. Additionally, emissions from a local magnesium refinery have been identified as a significant contributor to the dense winter brown clouds that form over the city.

While there have been long-term reductions in particle pollution and ozone levels over the past few decades, the air quality in Salt Lake City remains among the worst in the United States. The unique climatic and geographic conditions of the city, coupled with human activities, result in seasonal fluctuations that significantly impact the city's air pollution levels.

Harmful emissions predominantly come from fossil fuels

Salt Lake City's air quality has been described as "terrible", with the air causing irritation to the nose, throat, and eyes, coughing, wheezing, chest pain, heart arrhythmia, and shortness of breath. The air quality has also been attributed to causing asthma and lung collapse in some individuals. The city has consistently failed to meet federal attainment levels for ozone or 24-hour PM2.5 pollution, resulting in "F" ratings for both measures. In 2019, the Salt Lake City area ranked 7th out of 217 metropolitan areas for the worst 24-hour particle pollution and 11th out of 228 metropolitan areas for worst ozone pollution.

Motor vehicles are the largest source of pollution emissions in Salt Lake City, a common trend across the United States. The burning of fossil fuels in vehicles and power plants releases harmful emissions, contributing to the city's poor air quality. Fossil fuels, including coal, oil, and gas, are non-renewable energy sources that supply around 80% of the world's energy. They are formed from the decomposition of carbon-based organisms that died millions of years ago, creating carbon-rich deposits that are extracted and burned for energy.

Coal is the dirtiest fossil fuel, responsible for over 0.3 degrees Celsius of the 1-degree increase in global average temperatures. When burned, coal releases large quantities of carbon dioxide, the dominant cause of global warming. Coal-fired power plants in the United States generate 35% of dangerous mercury emissions, two-thirds of sulfur dioxide emissions, and most soot in the air. Sulfur dioxide contributes to acid rain, which further exacerbates environmental issues. Additionally, the burning of coal releases nitrogen oxides, which form smog and acid rain, leading to respiratory illnesses with sustained exposure.

Oil is another significant contributor to harmful emissions. When burned, oil releases a substantial amount of carbon, accounting for approximately one-third of the world's total carbon emissions. Fossil fuel companies are major polluters, continuing to produce and sell fossil fuel products despite the urgent need for a transition to renewable energy. While advertising campaigns may promote low-carbon energy and cleaner natural gas, the reality is that these companies' expenditures remain heavily focused on oil and gas.

Gas, the third type of fossil fuel, also contributes to harmful emissions. The extraction and burning of natural gas can lead to methane leaks, which have a global warming potential over 80 times that of carbon dioxide in a 20-year period. While natural gas may be touted as a cleaner alternative to coal, the full lifecycle of gas, including production, transmission, and distribution, can result in significant emissions.

To address the issue of harmful emissions from fossil fuels, a transition to renewable energy sources is imperative. This includes embracing clean energy technologies, such as wind, solar, and hydroelectric power, to reduce our reliance on fossil fuels and mitigate their detrimental impact on the environment and public health.

Health effects of air pollution

Salt Lake City's air quality has been described as "terrible", with some residents reporting that it has caused them to develop asthma and aggravated existing respiratory issues. The city has consistently failed to meet federal attainment levels for ozone and 24-hour PM2.5 pollution, receiving "F" ratings for both measures. The air quality is particularly harmful to sensitive groups, including children, the elderly, pregnant women, and those with pre-existing heart and lung conditions.

Air pollution has been linked to a range of adverse health effects, and the specific impacts depend on the types, sources, and concentrations of pollutants in the air. Short-term exposure to high levels of particulate matter can lead to reduced lung function, respiratory infections, and aggravated asthma. Long-term exposure to fine particulate matter, such as PM2.5, increases the risk of more serious diseases with longer onsets, including stroke, heart disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and cancer. Maternal exposure to air pollution has been associated with adverse birth outcomes, such as low birth weight, pre-term birth, and small gestational age births. Air pollution may also affect neurological development in children and increase the risk of diabetes.

Ozone, a powerful lung irritant, is a significant component of air pollution in Salt Lake City. Ground-level ozone is created when pollutants from vehicles, power plants, industrial boilers, refineries, and other sources react chemically in the presence of sunlight. When inhaled, ozone reacts with the delicate lining of the small airways, causing inflammation and damage that can impact multiple body systems. High ozone levels can lead to breathing problems, chest tightness, coughing, and shortness of breath, even within hours of exposure.

Particulate matter, or particle pollution, refers to a mixture of tiny solids and liquids in the air, emitted directly or indirectly by factories, power plants, vehicles, and equipment. These particles can be inhaled and contribute to serious health problems, particularly when they are fine particles such as PM2.5, which can be inhaled deeply into lung tissue.

In addition to the physical health impacts, psychosocial stress, poverty, racial/ethnic discrimination, and residency status can amplify the harmful effects of air pollution. Lower-income communities are often more vulnerable to pollution due to their proximity to sources of pollution and limited resources for relocation.

Pollution control regulations and cleaner technologies

Salt Lake City has a severe air pollution problem, with the air quality causing and exacerbating health issues for its residents, including asthma, lung collapse, coughing, wheezing, chest pain, heart arrhythmia, and shortness of breath. The city has never met federal attainment levels for ozone or 24-hour PM2.5 pollution, and seasonal fluctuations, particularly during the winter, can cause AQI levels to increase. The geography of the city, situated among several mountain ranges, can trap cold air in the Salt Lake Valley, preventing the dispersal of polluted air.

To combat this issue, Salt Lake County has implemented a Vehicle Emissions Program that requires vehicles registered in the county to undergo emissions testing. This program aims to reduce the amount of pollutant emissions in the county and offers assistance to those whose vehicles fail the inspection. Additionally, Salt Lake City has adopted transportation measures to decrease travel miles, reduce vehicle idling, and promote alternative modes of transportation. These strategies are outlined in the Sustainable Salt Lake Plan 2015, which sets ambitious goals to improve air quality, protect community health, and reduce particulate matter and ozone pollution.

The city is also formulating a vulnerability assessment and adaptation plan, which will include a climate vulnerability assessment, a greenhouse gas mitigation strategy, and an adaptation plan. Furthermore, commercial cleaning services in Salt Lake City utilize advanced technologies, such as electrostatic sprayers and high-filtration vacuums, to minimize the spread of pathogens and improve the cleanliness of various facilities.

While Salt Lake City is actively working to improve its air quality, it is essential to recognize that the city still experiences periods of unhealthy air pollution. The implementation of pollution control regulations and the utilization of cleaner technologies are ongoing processes that require continuous evaluation and adaptation to ensure their effectiveness in improving the city's air quality.

Frequently asked questions