Electric Energy's Pollution Paradox: Clean Power, Dirty Secrets?

Electric energy is a clean and safe form of energy, but the process of generating and transmitting it can have environmental and health impacts. Nearly all types of electric power plants affect the environment, but some have larger effects than others. The burning of fossil fuels, such as coal, natural gas, and petroleum-based fuels, releases harmful pollutants into the air, water, and land, affecting the health of nearby communities and contributing to climate change. Power plants that burn fossil fuels are a significant source of air pollution, including nitrogen oxides (NOx), sulfur dioxide (SO2), and fine particle emissions, which can cause respiratory and cardiovascular issues. Additionally, the generation and transmission of electricity require land use, water resources, and can result in the discharge of pollution into water bodies and the generation of solid waste.

Electric power plants are a leading source of air pollution

Despite advancements in reducing pollution from the electric power sector, electric power plants are a leading source of air pollution. In the United States, about 62% of electricity generation in 2022 was produced from fossil fuels, biomass, and industrial and municipal wastes. Fossil fuel-fired power plants are a significant source of nitrogen oxides (NOx) and sulfur dioxide (SO2) emissions, as well as mercury and fine particle emissions.

NOx emissions, which are released from power plants, motor vehicles, and other sources, contribute to the formation of ground-level ozone and fine particle pollution, causing adverse health effects. These pollutants are linked to heart and lung disease, asthma, stroke, and increased susceptibility to respiratory infections. They also contribute to acid rain, which negatively impacts aquatic life and harms sensitive plants and animals.

SO2 is primarily generated from coal-fired power plants and is a highly reactive gas. In addition to contributing to acid rain, SO2 emissions are associated with a range of adverse health effects, particularly in children and the elderly. They worsen respiratory illnesses and heart diseases, leading to premature deaths, new asthma cases, and other serious health issues.

Electric power plants are also a significant source of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, which contribute to the greenhouse effect and drive climate change. CO2 emissions from power plants affect ecosystems, influencing how plants grow, how animals behave, and how different organisms interact with their environment.

Furthermore, the burning of fossil fuels and other fuels for electricity results in the emission of harmful pollutants such as sulfur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide, and mercury. These emissions directly impact lung health and can cause cancer and other health problems. Particle pollution, formed from ash and soot, and ozone pollution, caused by nitrogen dioxide emissions, further contribute to the degradation of air quality.

Nuclear power plants, while not producing greenhouse gases or particulate matter, generate radioactive waste that requires specialized storage and disposal methods.

Fossil fuels are a significant contributor to climate change

The burning of fossil fuels like oil, coal, and natural gas has a significant impact on climate change. Fossil fuels emit greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, which trap heat in the Earth's atmosphere, causing global warming. In 2019, fossil fuels accounted for 74% of US greenhouse gas emissions, with nearly 25% coming from fossil fuels extracted from public lands. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has found that emissions from fossil fuels are the dominant cause of global warming. In 2018, 89% of global CO2 emissions came from fossil fuels and industry.

The combustion of fossil fuels releases harmful pollutants, including sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide, and mercury. These pollutants have negative effects on both the environment and human health. Sulfur dioxide contributes to acid rain, which is harmful to plants and aquatic life, and worsens respiratory illnesses and heart disease. Nitrogen oxides contribute to ground-level ozone, which irritates and damages the lungs. Carbon monoxide is a toxic gas that can cause serious health issues, including headaches, dizziness, and even death in high concentrations. Mercury is a potent neurotoxin that affects the nervous system and brain function, particularly in infants and children.

The extraction, transportation, and refining of fossil fuels also contribute to environmental issues. Oil spills, for example, can have devastating effects on marine ecosystems, destroying habitats, eroding shorelines, and resulting in beach, park, and fishery closures. Fracking, a common method for extracting natural gas, uses large amounts of water and generates toxic wastewater that can contaminate groundwater and drinking water sources. Additionally, the production and use of plastic, which is mostly made from fossil fuels, adds to the pollution problem, with 300 million tons of plastic waste produced globally each year, 14 million tons of which end up in the ocean.

The health impacts of fossil fuel-generated electricity are significant, with air pollution leading to asthma, cancer, heart disease, and premature death. In the United States alone, 350,000 premature deaths in 2018 were attributed to fossil fuel-related pollution. The annual cost of the health impacts of fossil fuel-generated electricity in the US is estimated to be up to $886.5 billion. Communities of color and low-income communities are disproportionately affected by these negative health outcomes.

To address the issue of fossil fuel emissions and their impact on climate change, several policy mechanisms have been proposed, including eliminating fossil fuel subsidies, increasing the social cost of carbon, implementing a federal clean electricity standard, and putting a price on carbon dioxide emissions.

Power plants affect the health of people, especially children and the elderly

Despite years of progress in reducing pollution from the electric power sector, fossil fuel-fired power plants remain a leading source of air, water, and land pollution, which affects communities across the United States. There are over 3,400 such power plants in the US, and they are the largest source of nitrogen oxides (NOx) and sulfur dioxide (SO2) emissions. They also emit significant amounts of mercury (Hg), fine particles, and carbon dioxide (CO2).

These emissions have a range of adverse health effects, particularly on the heart and lungs. Research has shown that elevated concentrations of ground-level ozone and fine particles can lead to heart attacks, asthma attacks, strokes, and increased susceptibility to respiratory infections. They are also linked to premature deaths, new asthma cases, and lung cancer. Mercury, a potent neurotoxin, is of particular concern, as it affects the nervous system and brain functions, especially in infants and children.

The elderly are also at high risk from the health impacts of power plant pollution. Fine particle pollution from power plants has been linked to tens of thousands of premature deaths each year, with the average number of life-years lost being 14 years. In addition, hundreds of thousands of people suffer from asthma attacks, cardiac problems, and respiratory issues associated with fine particles from power plants. These illnesses result in tens of thousands of emergency room visits, hospitalisations, and lost workdays annually.

People living near power plants are especially vulnerable to the health impacts of emissions. Those in metropolitan areas near coal-fired plants have much higher attributable death rates than those living in areas with few or no such plants. Additionally, children are particularly susceptible to the effects of mercury, a hazardous air pollutant emitted by power plants. Mercury affects the nervous system and brain functions and can cause other significant health issues.

To mitigate the health impacts of power plant emissions, transitioning to clean, renewable, and non-combustion sources of electricity is essential. Sources such as solar, wind, geothermal, and tidal power can dramatically reduce health harms and premature deaths caused by air pollution.

Nuclear power plants produce radioactive waste

Nuclear power plants produce two types of radioactive waste: low-level waste and high-level waste. Low-level waste includes contaminated protective clothing, wiping rags, mops, filters, reactor water treatment residues, equipment, and tools. High-level waste includes highly radioactive spent nuclear fuel assemblies.

Low-level waste is stored at nuclear power plants until it decays to a level safe for disposal as ordinary trash or is sent to a low-level radioactive waste disposal site. High-level waste must be stored in specially designed storage containers and facilities until its radioactivity has decayed to relatively low levels, which can take 40-50 years.

The amount of waste generated by nuclear power is relatively small compared to other thermal electricity generation technologies. Nuclear waste is also not particularly hazardous or hard to manage compared to other types of toxic industrial waste. Safe methods for the final disposal of high-level radioactive waste exist, and the international consensus is that geological disposal is the best option.

Radioactive waste management is carefully regulated, and the cost of managing and disposing of nuclear waste is included in the price of electricity. Nuclear power is the only large-scale energy-producing technology that takes full responsibility for all its waste.

While nuclear power plants do produce radioactive waste, it is important to note that they do not produce greenhouse gases, particulate matter, sulfur dioxide, or nitrogen oxides, which are common pollutants from fossil fuel-fired power plants.

Electricity generation impacts water usage and quality

Secondly, water is used for cleaning equipment in solar power generation, and hydroelectricity also results in water usage through evaporation from reservoirs and seepage into the water table. The amount of water consumed and withdrawn during these processes can vary depending on the specific technology and geographic location.

The use of water in electricity generation can have several impacts on water usage and quality. Water withdrawal can reduce the amount of water available for other uses, and water consumption through evaporation or incorporation into products can further deplete water resources. Additionally, thermal pollution, or the increase in water temperature, can occur when waste heat is discharged into natural bodies of water, adversely affecting aquatic life.

To mitigate these impacts, some power plants have implemented closed-loop recirculating and hybrid cooling systems, which reduce water withdrawals by reusing water multiple times instead of releasing it after a single use. Other solutions include the use of dry cooling systems, sewage cooling, and locating thermal cycle plants near the ocean to utilize seawater for cooling.

It is worth noting that the environmental effects of electricity generation on water usage and quality can vary depending on the specific technologies, fuel sources, and geographic locations involved.

Frequently asked questions