Air Pollution's Racial Bias: Why Black Neighborhoods Suffer

Decades of residential segregation have resulted in Black Americans living in areas with greater exposure to air pollution. Studies have found that Black Americans are exposed to more pollution from every type of source, including industry, agriculture, vehicles, and construction. This has resulted in Black communities experiencing a higher risk of health issues, such as asthma, lung and heart disease, and premature death. The issue of air pollution in Black neighborhoods is a pressing concern that requires attention and action to address the environmental injustices faced by these communities.

Black neighborhoods are more exposed to industrial pollution

Black neighbourhoods are more exposed to industrial pollution due to various factors, including historical and structural racism, residential segregation, and the disproportionate siting of polluting industries and highways in these areas. This has resulted in significant health disparities and a higher burden of disease for Black communities.

Racial segregation in the US is closely linked to air pollution exposure disparities. Non-Hispanic Black people living in highly segregated areas are exposed to higher levels of total air pollution and particulate matter (PM2.5) than their non-Hispanic White counterparts in less segregated neighbourhoods. This disparity is not driven by income differences, as higher-income Black individuals still face greater pollution exposure than lower-income White individuals. Instead, it is a result of structural imbalances and racist practices, such as redlining, land-use decisions, and housing policies that have pushed people of colour and pollution together.

Black communities are often located closer to major sources of pollution, including industrial plants, power plants, and highways. This proximity results in higher exposure to toxic and carcinogenic pollutants, such as lead, ground-level ozone, sulfur oxides, and nitrogen oxides. For example, Black individuals are 75% more likely than White individuals to live near polluting power plants. Additionally, Black neighbourhoods are more likely to experience the negative health impacts of industrial pollution, with majority-Black census tracts showing more than double the cancer risk from industrial air pollution compared to majority-White tracts.

The impact of industrial pollution on Black communities is further exacerbated by socioeconomic factors. Low-income Black neighbourhoods may have limited access to healthcare, healthy food options, and quality education, increasing their vulnerability to the health effects of pollution. Furthermore, racial discrimination and chronic stress may also play a role in the heightened health risks faced by Black individuals exposed to industrial pollution.

Addressing these disparities requires acknowledging the systemic racism that has contributed to the disproportionate exposure of Black neighbourhoods to industrial pollution. Efforts to tighten air pollution standards and enforce regulations more collaboratively can help reduce the health burden on these communities.

Black Americans are more likely to live near polluting power plants

One study found that 68% of African Americans live within 30 miles of a coal-fired power plant, compared to 56% of whites. Additionally, over one million African Americans live within half a mile of natural gas facilities, and more than 6.7 million live in counties with oil refineries. African Americans are 75% more likely than whites to live in "fence-line" communities, which are areas near industrial facilities that produce noise, emissions, and other pollutants.

The impact of air pollution on health is significant. Exposure to poor air quality can cause various health problems, including asthma, heart attacks, birth defects, and cancer. People of color are among the groups most at risk from air pollutants, and studies have shown that they are more likely to suffer premature death due to particle pollution.

The disparity in exposure to air pollution is not solely due to income or socioeconomic status. Higher-income Blacks still face greater health risks than lower-income whites. This suggests that other factors, such as chronic stress from discrimination and environmental racism, are at play. Environmental racism refers to the unequal access to a clean environment based on race, resulting in communities of color facing inequitable living conditions and a higher risk of environmental causes of death.

Addressing this issue requires effective policies and programs that tackle systemic racism and environmental injustice. Organizations like the NAACP's Environmental and Climate Justice Program and the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) are working to rectify past injustices and create a more sustainable and equitable future for communities of color.

Racial disparities exist regardless of income level

Several studies have found that racial disparities in exposure to air pollution exist regardless of income level. Research by the EPA, for instance, found that people of color experience greater-than-average exposures from source types causing 75% of overall exposure, while white people are exposed to lower-than-average concentrations from emission source types causing 60% of overall exposure. The study also found that these disparities generally hold across states, urban and rural areas, and occur for people at all income levels.

Another study by Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health found that certain groups in the U.S.—Blacks, Asians, Hispanics, Latinos, and low-income populations—are exposed to higher levels of dangerous fine particulate air pollution (PM2.5) than other groups. The study, which linked 17 years' worth of demographic data with data on fine particulate pollution, also found that disparities in exposure to PM2.5 in relation to safety standards set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the World Health Organization have been increasing over time among racial/ethnic groups.

Similarly, a study by the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign found that Black Americans are exposed to more pollution from every type of source, including industry, agriculture, vehicles, construction, residential sources, and even emissions from restaurants. The study also found that racial disparities in exposure to air pollution hold for all income levels, reinforcing the finding that race/ethnicity, independently of income, drives air pollution-exposure disparities.

Furthermore, a study by the American Lung Association found that non-Hispanic blacks were more likely to live in counties with worse ozone pollution, and that income groups differed little in these exposures. The study also found that higher-income blacks who had higher incomes than many whites still faced a greater risk of harm from air pollution, suggesting that factors other than income, such as chronic stress as a result of discrimination, may be playing a role.

These studies highlight the existence of racial disparities in exposure to air pollution that persist regardless of income level, indicating the need for strong, targeted air pollution-reduction strategies to address these disparities and protect the health of marginalized communities.

Black communities are sacrificed for economic good

Black communities in the United States are disproportionately affected by air pollution, sacrificing their health and well-being for economic gains in other sectors. This issue is not merely a coincidence or the result of a few isolated factors but is deeply rooted in systemic racism and historical housing policies.

Numerous studies have consistently found that Black Americans are exposed to higher levels of dangerous fine particulate air pollution, known as PM 2.5, than other racial groups. This pollution comes from various sources, including industry, vehicles, power plants, and highways, which are often concentrated in or near Black neighborhoods. For example, Black people are 75% more likely than white people to live near polluting power plants. Additionally, Black communities have higher concentrations of lead pollution, which is released into the air during demolitions of vacant properties resulting from disinvestment in these areas.

The impact of air pollution on Black communities goes beyond mere exposure. The health consequences are significant, with higher hospitalization rates for lead poisoning, increased asthma rates, and higher risks of premature death. The American Lung Association's review of particle pollution health effects concluded that non-white populations, especially Blacks, faced a higher risk of harm. Furthermore, the stress of discrimination may also play a role in the increased health risks faced by Black communities.

Despite the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1970, which aimed to protect human health and the environment, and the EPA's goal of providing equal protection from environmental hazards, Black communities continue to bear the brunt of air pollution. This disparity persists across income levels, with higher-income Black individuals still facing greater health risks than lower-income individuals from other racial groups. The EPA's air quality standards have failed to adequately protect marginalized communities, and regulatory changes are needed to address this environmental injustice effectively.

The economic gains attributed to industrialization, transportation networks, and other development projects have come at the expense of the health and well-being of Black communities. It is crucial to recognize that the pursuit of economic growth should not be at the cost of sacrificing the health and lives of specific racial groups. Addressing this issue requires a commitment to strong and targeted air pollution reduction strategies, equitable environmental policies, and a recognition of the systemic racism that has perpetuated these disparities.

Black Americans are more exposed to vehicle pollution

Black Americans are exposed to greater-than-average concentrations of dangerous forms of pollution, including vehicle pollution. This exposure is due to various factors, including the concentration of highways in Black communities and the legacy of discriminatory housing policies.

A study by the EPA found that people of color experience greater-than-average exposures from source types causing 75% of overall exposure, while white people are exposed to lower-than-average concentrations from emission source types. This disparity holds across states, urban and rural areas, and income levels, indicating that race is an important factor in exposure to air pollution.

Black Americans are 75% more likely than white Americans to live near polluting power plants. They are also more likely to live in counties with higher levels of pollution, including particle pollution and ozone pollution. Particle pollution, or PM2.5, is a mixture of liquid droplets and solid particles, such as dust, dirt, and smoke, which can lodge deep in the lungs and enter the bloodstream. It has been linked to a number of diseases, including heart disease, lung cancer, and stroke, and is responsible for thousands of excess deaths each year in the United States.

The higher exposure to vehicle pollution among Black Americans is also due to the proximity of their neighborhoods to highways. Evidence suggests that people living near highways are exposed to high levels of nitrogen dioxide and fine particulate matter, which can irritate the lungs and trigger asthma attacks. Children exposed to traffic-related air pollution are at an increased risk of developing asthma, a lifelong and potentially life-threatening condition.

The disparities in exposure to vehicle pollution among Black Americans are a result of systemic racism and discriminatory policies. Redlining and residential segregation have resulted in Black communities being located near congested roadways and shipping routes with heavily polluted air. Additionally, the concentration of highways and industrial sites in Black neighborhoods has led to increased exposure to vehicle pollution and other harmful pollutants.

Frequently asked questions