Are Modern Diesel Cars Polluting? Exploring The Truth

Modern diesel cars have been at the centre of a pollution debate since the Volkswagen dieselgate scandal in 2015, which revealed that some diesel cars emitted up to ten times more toxic nitrogen oxide (NOx) pollution than a bus. While diesel cars were promoted as a more environmentally friendly fuel option in the late 1990s and 2000s due to their lower CO2 emissions, they emit larger quantities of other harmful pollutants, including NOx and particulate matter, which contribute to poor local air quality and adverse health effects. As a result, some governments are planning to discourage their use or even ban them from urban areas. However, it's important to note that newer diesel cars, particularly those manufactured after 2015, are much less polluting and not subject to the same restrictions as older diesel vehicles.

Modern diesel cars produce 10 times more NOx per litre of fuel than trucks and buses

Modern diesel cars produce significantly more NOx per litre of fuel than trucks and buses. This is due to the much stricter testing applied to large vehicles in the EU, according to researchers. The higher emissions from diesel cars are linked to tens of thousands of early deaths across Europe, with the UK suffering a particularly high toll.

The ICCT analysis revealed that heavy-duty vehicles tested in Germany and Finland emitted approximately 210mg of NOx per kilometre, which is less than half of the 500mg/km emitted by modern diesel cars that meet the highest "Euro 6" standard. However, the larger engines in buses and trucks cause them to burn more diesel per kilometre. This results in diesel cars producing 10 times more NOx per litre of fuel than trucks and buses.

The International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) found that manufacturers could keep heavy-duty vehicles below pollution limits when on the road. In contrast, emissions from diesel cars soared in real-world conditions. Official EU tests for cars are currently limited to laboratory measurements of prototype vehicles, while mobile testing devices have been mandatory for measuring NOx emissions from trucks and buses since 2013. This allows randomly selected vehicles to be tested under actual driving conditions.

The disparity in emissions standards between cars and larger vehicles has led to calls for stricter measures to be applied to cars. Catherine Bearder, a Liberal Democrat MEP and lead negotiator on the EU's air quality law, expressed disappointment in car manufacturers for failing to reduce harmful emissions despite having access to affordable and readily available technology. The ICCT researcher and author of the paper, Rachel Muncrief, emphasised the startling difference in NOx emissions per kilometre between light-duty and heavy-duty vehicles.

To address the issue of high NOx emissions from diesel cars, vehicle manufacturers have adopted Selective Catalytic Reduction. This process involves injecting Diesel Exhaust Fluid (DEF), commonly known as AdBlue, into existing gas circulatory systems to break down harmful NOx. AdBlue is a synthetic urea that converts nitrogen oxide into harmless steam and nitrogen. However, it requires regular monitoring and topping up, with long-distance drivers estimated to consume approximately 1.5 litres of AdBlue for every 620 miles.

Diesel cars are linked to respiratory problems and poor heart health

Diesel cars have been linked to a range of health issues, particularly respiratory problems and poor heart health. The particulate matter emitted from diesel engines is of particular concern, as it is associated with adverse cardiovascular effects. Research has shown that higher levels of particulate matter in the air lead to increased hospital admissions and deaths from heart attacks, especially among those already considered at-risk.

Additionally, diesel engines emit nitrogen oxides (NOx), which have been linked to a significant increase in respiratory issues such as asthma. The World Health Organization's International Agency for Research on Cancer has classified diesel exhaust emissions as carcinogenic to humans since 2012. This classification was made due to the presence of harmful pollutants in diesel exhaust, including nitrogen oxides and particulate matter.

The Volkswagen "Dieselgate" scandal of 2015 brought the issue of diesel emissions into the public eye. It was revealed that some diesel cars emitted up to four times more NOx pollution than a bus. This scandal exposed the shortcomings of current emissions testing procedures, particularly for cars, as stricter testing for heavy-duty vehicles was already in place.

While newer diesel cars that meet Euro 6 emissions standards emit lower levels of pollutants and are not subject to Clean Air Zone fines or city bans, older diesel vehicles continue to be a significant source of pollution. These older models emit high levels of harmful pollutants and are increasingly subject to charges or bans in cities across Europe and the UK.

The promotion of diesel vehicles as a more environmentally friendly alternative to petrol cars has been criticized, as it has contributed to a rise in harmful emissions affecting human health. While diesel engines produce lower CO2 emissions, they emit larger quantities of other pollutants, impacting local air quality and health.

Diesel cars are carcinogenic

Nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter are among the pollutants emitted by diesel engines, which contribute to poor local air quality and health issues. NOx emissions have been linked to a significant increase in respiratory problems such as asthma, while particulates from diesel exhausts are carcinogenic and can also impact respiratory health. The high levels of harmful pollutants emitted by older diesel cars have led to their restriction or ban in cities across Europe and the UK.

The Volkswagen "dieselgate" scandal of 2015 brought the issue of diesel emissions into the public eye, revealing that some diesel cars emitted up to four times more NOx pollution than a bus. Modern diesel cars produce 10 times more toxic air pollution than heavy trucks and buses, and emit about six times more NOx than is permitted in official lab-based tests. The disparity in emissions between cars and larger vehicles is due to the stricter testing standards applied to trucks and buses in the EU, which involve the use of mobile testing devices.

While diesel cars were once promoted as a more environmentally friendly alternative to petrol cars due to their lower CO2 emissions, the negative impact of their toxic emissions on human health has become increasingly apparent. The focus on reducing CO2 emissions in the past led governments to overlook other harmful compounds emitted by diesel engines. As a result, diesel vehicles have gained negative publicity, and some governments are now planning to discourage their use or ban them from urban areas.

Diesel cars produce higher levels of CO2 emissions

Diesel cars have been the subject of much scrutiny in recent years, with growing awareness of their negative impact on the environment and human health. While it is true that diesel cars typically produce lower carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions than their petrol counterparts, this advantage is offset by the higher levels of other harmful pollutants they release.

Diesel engines emit larger quantities of toxic pollutants, including nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter. These emissions have been linked to significant health issues such as respiratory problems, poor heart health, and even cancer. The World Health Organization has officially classified diesel exhaust emissions as carcinogenic to humans.

The higher levels of NOx emissions from diesel cars are particularly concerning. Modern diesel cars can emit up to ten times more NOx per litre of fuel than heavy trucks and buses, which is alarming given the strict emission standards for these larger vehicles. This disparity is due to the less stringent testing procedures for cars, which often involve laboratory measurements of prototype vehicles rather than on-road testing.

In addition to the direct health impacts, the focus on reducing CO2 emissions has also contributed to the promotion of diesel vehicles. In the late 1990s and early 2000s, diesel cars were incentivized as a more environmentally friendly alternative to petrol cars, in line with efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions outlined in the 1997 Kyoto Protocol. However, this shift towards diesel has had unintended consequences, as the higher levels of toxic emissions from diesel engines were not adequately addressed.

It is worth noting that not all diesel cars are equal in terms of emissions. Newer diesel cars, particularly those manufactured after 2015, are generally less polluting and comply with more stringent emission standards. However, older diesel vehicles continue to dominate many vehicle fleets, and their emissions contribute to the ongoing damage to human health and the environment.

Governments are discouraging the use of diesel cars

Diesel cars have been the subject of much scrutiny in recent years due to their contribution to air pollution and associated health risks. Governments are increasingly taking action to discourage the use of diesel cars and reduce their negative impact.

One significant reason for the shift away from diesel is the growing awareness of the harmful pollutants emitted by diesel engines, including nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter. These emissions have been linked to respiratory problems such as asthma and more frequent hospital admissions and deaths from heart attacks. The World Health Organization has even classified diesel exhaust emissions as carcinogenic to humans. As a result, governments are under pressure to reduce emissions and improve air quality for their citizens.

In response to these concerns, some governments are implementing measures to discourage the use of diesel cars. For example, the UK government has introduced Clean Air Zone fines and city bans for older diesel vehicles that do not meet emission standards. Similar restrictions are being considered or implemented in other countries, such as India, which is exploring stricter emissions standards and gradually phasing out diesel cars in high-pollution zones.

In addition to local actions, international agreements such as the Paris Agreement are also driving governments to discourage diesel car usage. The agreement focuses on reducing carbon emissions and transitioning to cleaner forms of energy. As diesel cars emit large amounts of NOx and particulate matter, they are seen as a barrier to meeting these climate goals. Electric vehicles, backed by government incentives, are gaining popularity as a cleaner and more sustainable alternative.

While some diesel car owners may feel aggrieved by these changes, it is important to recognize the potential health and environmental benefits of reducing diesel emissions. Governments are taking action to protect their citizens and address the global climate crisis. The shift away from diesel is part of a broader movement towards cleaner technologies and more sustainable transportation options.

Frequently asked questions