Halides, Phosphates, Sulfates, And Nitrates: Water Pollutants?

Nitrates, phosphates, sulfates, and halides are all substances that can be found in water. While some of these substances can occur naturally in water, they can also be introduced through human activity, and can have adverse effects on human health and the environment. For example, high levels of nitrates in water can be caused by runoff from fertilized soil, wastewater, and septic systems, and can cause methemoglobinemia, or blue baby syndrome. Similarly, high levels of phosphates in water bodies can be caused by fertilizers, runoff from urban areas, and leaking septic systems, leading to excess growth of algae and degraded habitat conditions for aquatic life. Sulfates and halides have also been identified as potential water contaminants, with studies investigating their effects on human health.

High levels of nitrate in water can be caused by runoff or leakage from fertilised soil, wastewater, landfills, animal feedlots, septic systems, or urban drainage

Nitrates are naturally occurring compounds found in some lakes, rivers, and groundwater. They are also present in certain foods, particularly green leafy and root vegetables. However, high nitrate levels in water bodies, especially drinking water, can be harmful to human health. The maximum contaminant level (MCL) for nitrate in public drinking water supplies in the United States is 10 mg/L as nitrate-nitrogen (NO3-N). This standard is set to protect against infant methemoglobinemia, or "blue baby syndrome," which can be fatal.

High nitrate levels in water can have various human-made sources, including runoff or leakage from fertilised soil, wastewater, landfills, animal feedlots, septic systems, or urban drainage. Natural processes can cause low levels of nitrate in drinking water, usually below 3 mg/L. However, when nitrate levels exceed this threshold, it suggests human influence and contamination.

In Minnesota, for example, the Pollution Control Agency found that 27% of surface water samples had nitrate levels above 10 mg/L, with the highest levels in Southern Minnesota. About 4% of private wells constructed in the state since 1991 have nitrate levels above 3 mg/L, indicating potential contamination from human activities.

The presence of high nitrate levels in water sources can have significant health implications. Consuming excessive amounts of nitrate can affect how blood carries oxygen, leading to methemoglobinemia, which is particularly dangerous for bottle-fed babies under six months old. Long-term exposure to nitrate in drinking water, even at levels below the current regulatory standard, has been associated with potential health risks, including thyroid problems, adverse pregnancy outcomes, and cancers, specifically colorectal and ovarian.

Additionally, nitrate in water can be converted to nitrite, which is more harmful. Higher nitrite levels in drinking water have been linked to an increased risk of astrocytomas, a type of brain tumour. The formation of N-nitroso compounds (NOC) from nitrate ingestion is also concerning, as most NOCs are carcinogens and teratogens, potentially leading to cancer, birth defects, and other adverse health effects.

Nitrate consumption can affect how blood carries oxygen and cause methemoglobinemia, also known as blue baby syndrome

Nitrogen and its compounds are found in lakes, rivers, and groundwater. Nitrate, a compound that occurs naturally in the environment, is one such compound. It is found in some foods, like spinach and carrots, and is also produced by natural processes such as plant decay and lightning. Nitrate is also used in many fertilizers for yards, gardens, golf courses, and crops. Other sources of nitrate include discharge from sewage systems and animal waste.

Nitrate has been detected in groundwater and surface water in many places, including Minnesota. Land use and hydrogeology influence the levels of nitrate in water. The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency found that 27% of surface water samples had nitrate levels above 10 mg/L, with Southern Minnesota having the highest levels. Natural processes can lead to low levels of nitrate in drinking water, usually less than 3 mg/L. However, high levels of nitrate, above 10 mg/L, can result from runoff or leakage from fertilized soil, wastewater, landfills, animal feedlots, septic systems, or urban drainage.

Consuming excessive amounts of nitrate can be harmful, particularly for infants. High nitrate consumption can affect how blood carries oxygen, leading to a condition known as methemoglobinemia or blue baby syndrome. Bottle-fed babies under six months old are at the highest risk. Methemoglobinemia occurs when the blood carries oxygen less effectively, causing the lips and skin to turn bluish. This condition can be serious and even life-threatening, especially in infants where it may be difficult to detect.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has set a standard of 10 milligrams of nitrate (measured as nitrogen) per liter of drinking water (mg/L) to protect infants against methemoglobinemia. Recent studies have also suggested possible health impacts of long-term exposure to nitrate in drinking water at concentrations below the current regulatory standard. These potential impacts include associations with thyroid problems, adverse pregnancy outcomes, and cancers, particularly colorectal cancer. However, further research is needed to confirm these findings.

Phosphates are a common ingredient in commercial fertilisers, and too much phosphorus can stimulate excess growth of algae, which leads to low dissolved oxygen levels and degraded habitat conditions

Phosphorus is a common ingredient in commercial fertilisers. It is particularly important as a contributor to freshwater, coastal, and estuarine algal blooms. Phosphorus is the most common form of phosphates used by biological organisms. It plays a major role in the formation of DNA, cellular energy, and cell membranes (and plant cell walls).

When phosphorus is in excess, it can lead to water quality problems such as eutrophication and harmful algal blooms. This occurs when there is an overabundance of nutrients, causing an increase in algae growth that can deplete the water's oxygen levels and create "dead zones" where aquatic life cannot survive. These algal blooms can contaminate drinking water supplies, creating a health risk for humans, especially babies, who are at risk of methemoglobinemia or "blue baby syndrome".

Phosphorus is often found in fertilisers, and when excess fertiliser runs off into water bodies, it can cause an increase in algae growth. This is a particular problem in agricultural areas, where the use of fertilisers is common. Runoff from fertilised soil can carry phosphorus into water bodies, leading to an increase in algae. This is a significant issue in Minnesota, where high levels of nitrate have been detected in surface water. The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency found that 27% of surface water samples had nitrate levels above 10 mg/L, indicating potential contamination from human-made sources.

To address this issue, it is important to manage phosphorus levels effectively. This includes optimising its use in agriculture and recovering phosphorus from waste. By reducing the amount of phosphorus that enters water bodies, we can help prevent the negative impacts of excess algae growth, such as low dissolved oxygen levels and degraded habitat conditions.

Halides can scavenge HO* during AOP treatment, converting it to radical reactive halogen species (RHS) that react more selectively with electron-rich organic compounds

Halides are ubiquitous in natural waters and wastewaters. They play a crucial role in environmental photochemical processes and in reactions that occur during photochemical water treatment. While halides are inert to solar wavelengths, they can be converted into radical and non-radical reactive halogen species (RHS) through sensitized photolysis and reactions with secondary reactive oxygen species (ROS) produced through sunlight-initiated reactions.

RHS are highly reactive towards organic compounds, and some reactions result in the incorporation of halogen into byproducts. The specific reactions of RHS with organic compounds are not yet fully understood, and rate constants for these reactions are sparse, particularly for iodine compounds. However, it is known that RHS can react by H-atom abstraction, one-electron oxidation, and addition to double bonds and aromatic rings.

Halides can scavenge HO* during advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) for water treatment, which generate non-selective hydroxyl radicals (HO*)*. This scavenging effect by halides converts HO* into RHS, which then participate in contaminant destruction. Importantly, these RHS react more selectively with electron-rich organic compounds. This selectivity is due to the conversion of non-selective HO* into selective radicals in the presence of anions, which enhances the efficiency of electron-rich contaminant removal by focusing the oxidizing power away from natural organic matter (NOM) towards the target contaminant.

The impact of halides on the efficiency of contaminant degradation varies significantly among different target organic compounds. For example, the destruction of contaminants containing electron-poor reaction centers in seawater was nearly halted due to HO* scavenging, while 17beta-estradiol removal only declined by 3%. Additionally, the formation of halogenated byproducts during this process is minimal.

Sulfate in drinking water is currently unregulated by the EPA, but it has been associated with diarrhoea, especially in infants and travellers

Sulfate in drinking water is currently unregulated by the EPA, but high levels of sulfate have been associated with diarrhoea, especially in infants and travellers. The link between sulfate and diarrhoea was first investigated in 1998, when the CDC studied the impact of high sulfate levels in drinking water on susceptible populations, specifically infants and transients. The findings suggested a connection between the consumption of tap water with elevated sulfate levels and cases of osmotic diarrhoea in these vulnerable groups.

The presence of sulfate in drinking water is not merely a concern for infants and travellers; it has the potential to affect individuals with specific metabolic conditions as well. For instance, those with glucose-6-phosphate-dehydrogenase deficiency may face heightened risks to their health when exposed to sulfate in drinking water. This is a critical consideration, given that the EPA's role encompasses safeguarding public health by ensuring safe drinking water.

While the EPA has not yet implemented regulations specifically targeting sulfate, it has acknowledged the contaminant's potential health risks. In 1998, the EPA included sulfate on the Drinking Water Contaminant Candidate List, and it is currently evaluating whether to regulate it as a National Primary Drinking Water Regulation (NPDWR). This evaluation process involves analysing public comments, reviewing previous research, and considering various risk management factors, such as occurrence data on sulfate concentrations in public water systems and applicable treatment technologies.

The decision to regulate sulfate in drinking water is a complex one, as the EPA must weigh the potential health benefits against other factors, including the availability and cost of analytical methods and the overall costs and benefits of implementing new rules. In the meantime, the onus is on individuals, particularly those with infants or specific metabolic conditions, to take proactive measures to ensure the safety of their drinking water. This may include regular testing and inspection of private wells, as nitrate contamination, which can lead to the presence of other contaminants, is a concern in certain areas.

Although the EPA's current stance on sulfate in drinking water is to leave it unregulated, ongoing research and public health concerns may prompt a reevaluation of this position in the future. The potential health risks associated with sulfate consumption, particularly for vulnerable populations, underscore the importance of continued monitoring and assessment of water quality to ensure the safety of drinking water for all.

Frequently asked questions