Cruise Ships Vs Planes: Who's The Bigger Polluter?

The cruise industry has long been under scrutiny for its environmental impact, with cruise ships often described as floating cities. While flying is also known to have a significant carbon footprint, the question arises: which mode of transportation is more polluting? This comparison between cruise ships and planes is complex and involves considering various factors beyond carbon emissions, such as sewage treatment, air pollution, waste disposal, and fuel type.

Cruise ships emit more carbon dioxide per passenger mile

The cruise industry has long been under pressure to reduce its environmental impact. While cruise ships are taking steps to reduce their carbon emissions, they still emit more carbon dioxide per passenger mile than planes.

According to the EPA, air travel costs between 0.17 and 0.25 kg of carbon per passenger mile. In contrast, the Queen Mary 2 cruise ship emits 0.43 kg of CO2 per passenger mile, while the Queen Elizabeth II emits 0.29 kg of CO2 per passenger mile. These emissions are even higher when considering the further damage of emissions being produced in the upper atmosphere by planes.

The high emissions from cruise ships are due to the large amount of fuel they burn. For example, the Queen Elizabeth II burns 433 tonnes of fuel per day, and a tonne of shipping fuel contains 0.85 tonnes of carbon, which produces 3.1 tonnes of carbon dioxide when burnt. In addition to carbon dioxide, cruise ships also emit other pollutants such as nitrogen oxides, sulfur oxides, and particulate matter.

The impact of cruise ships on the environment is further exacerbated by the waste they produce and discard. On a typical one-week voyage, a cruise ship generates over 50 tonnes of garbage, a million tonnes of grey water, 210,000 gallons of sewage, and 35,000 gallons of oil-contaminated water, which can be pumped into the ocean.

While planes have a lower carbon footprint per passenger mile than cruise ships, it is worth noting that the carbon efficiency of planes can depend on various factors such as the number of passengers, the route, and the type of plane. Additionally, planes have a higher warming effect due to non-CO2 emissions released at high altitudes.

Cruise ships generate more waste

Cruise ships generate significantly more waste than planes. On a typical one-week voyage, a cruise ship generates over 50 tonnes of garbage, a million tonnes of grey (waste) water, 210,000 gallons of sewage, and 35,000 gallons of oil-contaminated water. The environmental impact of cruise ships is further exacerbated by the illegal dumping of sewage and fuel spills, as well as the leaking of dirty bilge water.

Cruise ships often burn large amounts of diesel fuel or gas, emitting substantial carbon emissions and other pollutants such as nitrogen oxides, sulfur oxides, and particulate matter. The air pollution generated by cruise ships has been linked to serious health issues, including higher rates of cancer and respiratory diseases.

In comparison, air travel emits between 0.17 and 0.25 kg of carbon per passenger mile, according to the latest numbers from the EPA. While planes have a higher carbon footprint than trains and buses, they emit significantly less carbon per passenger mile than cruise ships.

The high carbon emissions from cruise ships are due in part to the fuel used. Cruise ships often rely on heavy fuel oil, which has been described as the "dirtiest of all fuels." The switch to cleaner-burning liquefied natural gas can reduce a ship's carbon emissions by up to 20%, but the higher cost of such fuel has led to limited adoption.

The waste generated by cruise ships has a significant impact on the port cities they visit. The influx of large numbers of tourists can overwhelm small destinations, and the locals bear the brunt of dealing with the waste left behind by cruise ships. Environmental groups and regional governments are implementing emissions tests and issuing fines to cruise lines that do not meet standards.

Cruise ships have been caught illegally dumping sewage

Cruise ships have been found to be more polluting than planes. They often run on diesel fuel or gas, emitting large amounts of carbon, nitrogen oxides, sulfur oxides, and particulate matter. In addition, cruise ships use a large amount of electricity, equivalent to the monthly consumption of 77,000 American households.

Cruise ships have also been caught illegally dumping sewage. While modern ships treat sewage before discharge, it is still released into the ocean, and older cruise ships may continue to dump untreated waste. U.S. law allows cruise ships to dump raw sewage into the ocean beyond three miles from the shore. However, this has led to the ocean becoming a dumping ground for harmful waste. Cruise ships produce an estimated 30,000 gallons of sewage and 255,000 gallons of dirty water daily, impacting marine life and coral reefs.

The cruise industry has faced scrutiny and fines for polluting waters, and passengers are increasingly concerned about the environmental impact of their vacations. Many cruise passengers want the industry to stop dumping human waste into the ocean, and some are willing to pay a premium for environmentally friendly practices.

While some cruise lines have installed advanced sewage treatment systems, others, such as Carnival and Costa, have been accused of having poor waste management practices. Carnival Cruise Lines was caught dumping food mixed with plastic waste, and Royal Caribbean was fined $20 million for illegal plastic disposal.

The environmental impact of cruise ships extends beyond sewage dumping. They generate significant amounts of garbage, wastewater, oil-contaminated water, and fuel spills. The waste left behind by cruise ships affects coastal communities and the marine environment, causing wildlife deaths and coral destruction.

Overall, the illegal dumping of sewage by cruise ships is a significant environmental concern, contributing to the degradation of our oceans and marine life.

Cruise ships use dirtier fuels

Cruise ships often run on diesel fuel or gas, emitting large amounts of carbon and other pollutants such as nitrogen oxides, sulfur oxides, and particulate matter. In 2019, German watchdog Nabu surveyed 77 cruise ships and found that all but one used toxic heavy fuel oil, described as the "dirtiest of all fuels". The air quality on the deck of a cruise ship is comparable to that of the world's most polluted cities, with health experts warning of the adverse effects of poor air quality.

The type of fuel used by cruise ships is a significant contributor to their carbon emissions and pollution levels. A passenger's carbon footprint nearly triples when taking a cruise due to the emissions produced, which can have serious health consequences. The fuel burned by cruise ships contains carbon, which, when combusted, produces carbon dioxide. For example, the Queen Mary 2 emits 0.43 kg of CO2 per passenger mile, compared to 0.257 kg for a long-haul flight.

Cruise ships have also been criticized for their waste management practices, including the dumping of sewage, trash, and contaminated water directly into the ocean. The environmental impact of cruise ships extends beyond carbon emissions, with issues such as sewage treatment, air pollution, and food waste also being of concern.

While there have been some moves towards reducing ship pollution, such as switching to cleaner-burning liquefied natural gas, the cruise industry has been criticized for not doing enough to address the issue. Older ships, in particular, take a long time to adapt to new environmental standards, and campaigners believe that cruise lines could do more in terms of cleaner fuel and better waste treatment systems.

In summary, cruise ships often use dirtier fuels than planes, contributing to higher carbon emissions and other forms of pollution, with significant environmental and health impacts.

Cruise ships have a higher carbon footprint

Cruise ships burn a large amount of fuel, with the Queen Elizabeth II, for example, burning 433 tonnes of fuel per day. A tonne of shipping fuel contains 0.85 tonnes of carbon, which produces 3.1 tonnes of carbon dioxide when burnt. This means that every passenger travelling on the Queen Elizabeth II from Southampton to New York and back is responsible for 9.1 tonnes of emissions, 7.6 times as much carbon as flying.

Cruise ships also use large amounts of electricity, enough to power 77,000 American households in one month. In addition, they produce a significant amount of waste, with a typical one-week voyage generating more than 50 tonnes of garbage, a million tonnes of grey water, 210,000 gallons of sewage, and 35,000 gallons of oil-contaminated water, some of which is pumped into the ocean.

The cruise industry has been under increasing scrutiny as nations strive to reduce their CO2 emissions and companies are pressured to decrease their carbon footprint. While there have been moves towards reducing ship pollution, such as switching to cleaner-burning liquefied natural gas, the implementation has been slow, and older ships take a long time to adapt.

Frequently asked questions