Bri's Impact: Air Pollution And Health Risks

China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is a trillion-dollar socioeconomic and geopolitical strategy involving investments in transportation, communication, and energy networks across more than 60 countries. While China has pledged to limit the negative environmental impacts of BRI, there are concerns that it will cause more air pollution. BRI projects are expected to lead to a significant increase in global warming, threatening the lives and livelihoods of billions. The initiative's impact on air pollution is a complex issue, with a web of competing interests and a diverse range of local environmental standards across participating countries.

China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) will increase air pollution in South Asia

China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is a series of interlinked economic deals that are expected to follow the laws of the land where they take place. The BRI covers investments in transportation, communication, and energy networks across more than 60 countries in Eurasia, Oceania, and Africa. The initiative has raised concerns over its potential environmental effects, particularly in South Asia.

South Asian countries, such as Pakistan, are in dire need of infrastructure and economic development, which the BRI promises to provide. However, due to the higher immediate costs of sustainable infrastructure, many developing countries opt for pollution-heavy projects. Pakistan, for example, has the second worst air quality in Asia and is one of the largest consumers of non-renewable energy in the region. As a result, the country is vulnerable to accepting Chinese economic coercion, which could lock it into decades of coal pollution.

The construction of new coal-burning power plants along the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), a centerpiece of the BRI, will likely contribute to increased coal consumption and air pollution in the region. In addition, CPEC projects are predicted to cause periods of extreme heat in some Pakistani cities, lasting 60+ days, and lowering the average life expectancy in the country by 2.7 years.

Furthermore, the BRI's network of roads, railways, and pipelines can introduce more than 800 alien invasive species into several countries along its routes, threatening their ecosystems and causing environmental damage. The initiative's projects also pass through ecologically sensitive areas, disrupting natural environments and threatening the plants, animals, and livelihoods of local communities.

While China has assured the world that the BRI will be green, there is a lack of evidence of project guidance or implementation of environmental strategies. Critics suggest that the debt incurred by large BRI projects may damage host countries' economies, creating a cycle of financial inability to invest in more sustainable initiatives. Therefore, it is clear that China's Belt and Road Initiative will likely increase air pollution in South Asia, causing significant long-term harm to the region's environment and public health.

BRI projects are expected to lead to a 3°C increase in global temperatures

China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is one of the most ambitious infrastructure projects ever, promising to invest US$12 trillion in roads, railways, ports, power stations, and telecommunications links in 126 countries, from South America to Southeast Asia, over the next 30 years. The BRI has been touted as a green initiative, with China pledging to limit its negative environmental impacts. However, there are concerns that the BRI could lead to a 3°C increase in global temperatures, which would have devastating consequences.

The initiative's focus on carbon-intensive infrastructure, such as coal-fired power stations, steel and cement production, and traditional transport, is a major contributor to this potential temperature rise. More than a quarter of BRI energy projects in the pipeline are slated to be coal-powered, and China is the world's biggest investor in coal power beyond its borders. This "carbon lock-in" could set the world on a path towards a 3°C increase in global temperatures, according to a report co-authored by prominent Chinese environmentalist Dr Ma Jun.

The construction and operation of these carbon-intensive projects will result in increased air pollution, with poisonous gases such as chlorofluorocarbon, nitrogen oxide, and carbon monoxide emitted into the atmosphere. This will have a significant impact on the already vulnerable environmental geographies of South Asian countries, which have a poor history of road construction and are already experiencing high levels of air pollution. The increase in economic activities and urbanization due to the BRI will further exacerbate air pollution in these regions.

In addition to the direct emissions from BRI projects, there are also indirect effects on the environment. The initiative will increase interconnectivity in Eurasia, dissecting natural environments with roads and rails and threatening the plants, animals, and livelihoods of people in these ecosystems. The World Wildlife Fund (WWF) has noted that there will be considerable overlap between BRI projects and sensitive environments, putting over 265 threatened species at risk, including endangered tiger species and the critically endangered saiga antelope.

To address these concerns, there have been recommendations to boost green finance in BRI countries and mandate environmentally friendly standards for Chinese firms and banks across all projects. China has also introduced BRI "`reforms` to reduce emissions and pollution and protect biodiversity in BRI nations. However, it remains to be seen whether these efforts will be sufficient to prevent the potential 3°C increase in global temperatures and its devastating human toll.

BRI's infrastructure projects will disrupt natural environments and ecosystems

China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is a series of interlinked economic deals that are expected to follow the laws of the land where they take place. The BRI is an ambitious plan to boost connectivity in over 70 countries, including transportation, communication, and energy networks across more than 60 countries in Eurasia, Oceania, and Africa. The initiative includes the financing and building of roads, airports, and coal-burning power plants.

Many of the BRI's major corridors pass through ecologically sensitive areas. Increasing interconnectivity through the initiative could mean dissecting natural environments with roads and rails, threatening the plants and animals of the surrounding ecosystems and the livelihoods of the people who live there. A report by the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) identified over 1,700 critical biodiversity spots and 265 threatened species that will be adversely affected by the BRI, including endangered tiger species and the critically endangered saiga antelope and Sumatran orangutan.

In addition, the introduction of alien invasive species through the BRI's network of roads, railways, and pipelines could threaten ecosystems in several countries along its routes. A study in Current Biology found that the BRI could introduce more than 800 alien invasive species, including amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals, with potential costs of billions of dollars to agricultural exports.

The BRI's infrastructure projects can also have indirect impacts on the environment, such as downstream impacts from hydropower projects, air pollution, and disruptions to nutrient and flora/fauna flows. These indirect risks are challenging to capture through project-based environmental assessments, especially given the diverse range of local environmental standards across the countries involved.

To mitigate these risks, it is recommended that China and host countries integrate early-stage environmental assessments into the planning process for transportation corridors to identify the full range of mitigation options and place new infrastructure in locations that will cause the least environmental and social harm while maintaining economic and connectivity benefits.

BRI will increase economic activities and urbanisation, contributing to more emissions

China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is a series of interlinked economic deals that will boost connectivity in over 70 countries. The initiative involves a combination of investments in transportation, communication, and energy networks across more than 60 countries in Eurasia, Oceania, and Africa. This includes the construction of roads, railways, and pipelines, as well as the development of renewable and non-renewable energy sources.

While the BRI is expected to bring economic growth and improved connectivity, it will also likely increase economic activities and urbanization, contributing to more emissions. The construction and operation of roads, railways, and other infrastructure can directly cause air pollution, particularly in countries that opt for pollution-heavy projects due to the higher immediate costs of sustainable infrastructure. For instance, Pakistan, which has the second worst air quality in Asia and is one of the largest consumers of non-renewable energy in the region, is vulnerable to accepting Chinese economic coercion that may prioritize short-term economic gains over environmental sustainability.

In addition to the direct effects of construction and operations, there are also indirect risks associated with the BRI. The expansion of transportation infrastructure can disrupt nutrient and flora and fauna flows, leading to unforeseen consequences. The WWF has identified over 1,700 critical biodiversity spots and 265 threatened species that are at risk due to the BRI, including endangered tiger species and the critically endangered saiga antelope and Tapanuli orangutan.

Furthermore, the BRI could potentially introduce more than 800 alien invasive species into various countries, threatening their ecosystems and agricultural exports. The increase in economic activities and urbanization along the BRI routes may also lead to a rise in greenhouse gas emissions, contributing to climate change. As a result, some Pakistani cities are predicted to experience periods of extreme heat lasting 60+ days, and rising temperatures will result in resource depletion, particularly water supplies.

While China has assured the world that the BRI will be green, there is a lack of evidence of project guidance or implementation of environmental strategies. China has the opportunity to promote more concrete principles, such as caps on coal development and nuanced site selection processes that consider ecosystem services. By integrating environmental assessments into the early planning stages of transportation corridors, China and host countries can work together to minimize environmental and social harm while maintaining economic and connectivity benefits.

China is taking steps to make BRI more sustainable by reducing emissions and pollution

China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is a massive infrastructure plan that could transform the economies of over 70 countries. However, with its focus on coal-fired power plants, the initiative has raised concerns about its potential environmental impact, including increased air pollution and emissions.

Despite these concerns, China is taking steps to make BRI more sustainable by reducing emissions and pollution. Here are some key actions:

Firstly, China has pledged to cut emissions under the Paris Agreement, reduce coal use, and invest in renewable energy. While China continues to finance coal-fired power plants abroad through BRI, it has also imposed a cap on domestic coal consumption. China is also promoting the use of renewable energy in host nations, leveraging BRI to secure new markets for its renewable energy products. For example, BRI has helped China export $8 billion worth of solar goods, making it the world's leading exporter of environmental goods and services.

Secondly, China is working to launch a national emissions trading scheme, which would force polluters to pay for environmental harm and incentivize emissions reductions. This scheme, initially focusing on coal- and gas-fired power plants, is expected to reduce emissions and improve air quality.

Thirdly, China has expressed a commitment to "greening" the BRI, which involves reducing climate emissions, pollution, and protecting biodiversity. China has reaffirmed that no new coal power plants will be built under BRI and has encouraged retrofitting existing coal plants to make them more efficient and less polluting. China has also emphasized the importance of following host country laws on environmental protection and encouraged enterprises to adhere to international or Chinese environmental standards when local standards are insufficient.

Additionally, China has set time-bound targets for 2025 and 2030 to achieve green development goals, although measuring progress toward these goals remains challenging. China has also mandated environmentally friendly standards for its firms and banks, ensuring consistent sustainability across all BRI projects.

Finally, China is addressing the indirect risks associated with BRI projects, such as the disruption of natural environments and ecosystems due to roads and rails. While environmental impact assessments are required for each project, China recognizes the need for more comprehensive assessments that capture the cascading risks of its infrastructure projects.

In conclusion, while China's Belt and Road Initiative has faced criticism for its potential environmental impact, the country is taking steps to make BRI more sustainable by reducing emissions and pollution. These efforts include promoting renewable energy, implementing emissions reduction schemes, "greening" the BRI, adhering to environmental standards, and addressing indirect risks. However, the success and effectiveness of these measures will depend on consistent implementation and enforcement.

Frequently asked questions