Central Valley's Air Pollution: What's The Reason?

California's Central Valley, home to large productions of oil, agriculture, and warehouse distribution, has some of the worst air quality in the country. The region has been out of compliance with Environmental Protection Agency standards for 25 years, earning the distinction of being among the most polluted regions in the country. The Central Valley's specific topography, surrounded by mountains on three sides, traps polluted air in the Valley. Climate change is also worsening air quality in the region by increasing energy production that generates pollutants, accelerating chemical reactions that create pollutants like ozone, and causing more frequent and severe wildfires.

Climate change

California's Central Valley is known for its agricultural productivity, contributing about 25% of the nation's food while occupying just 1% of its farmland. However, the region consistently experiences the country's worst air quality, and climate change is exacerbating this issue.

Extreme heat caused by climate change also worsens air quality in the Central Valley. As temperatures rise, energy production that generates pollutants increases, and chemical reactions that create pollutants like ozone accelerate. For example, Fresno, a city in the Central Valley, historically experienced an average of 3 days per year with temperatures above 105°F. Due to climate change, these extreme temperatures are projected to occur 59 days per year by the end of the century. This pattern is consistent across other cities in the Central Valley, including Bakersfield, Modesto, Stockton, and Sacramento.

In addition, climate change is increasing the risk and severity of wildfires in California, which directly impacts the Central Valley. During the record-breaking 2020 wildfire season, the Central Valley experienced some of the highest levels of air pollution ever measured, with hazardous concentrations of PM 2.5. The smoke from these wildfires contains fine particles that can trigger asthma attacks, cause permanent lung damage, and even lead to respiratory failure.

While efforts have been made to improve air quality in the Central Valley, such as phasing out agricultural burning and implementing regulations to reduce vehicle pollution, climate change is complicating these efforts. The combination of extreme heat, droughts, and wildfires fueled by climate change is creating a perfect storm that is worsening air quality in the Central Valley and threatening the health and well-being of its residents.

Industrial and agricultural pollution

California's Central Valley is known for its agricultural productivity, contributing about 25% of the nation's food while occupying just 1% of its farmland. However, the region has consistently experienced the country's worst air quality due to industrial and agricultural pollution, which has severe health impacts on residents.

Agricultural burning, a practice involving burning fields no longer in production, has been a significant contributor to air pollution in the Central Valley. While efforts to phase out this practice led to a reduction in particulate pollution between 2003 and 2011, California's drought has tripled the amount of waste burned, exacerbating the problem. The Central Valley's topography also plays a role, trapping polluted air between the Coast Range and Sierra Nevada mountains.

Industrial pollution from facilities and polluting industries in the region has further worsened air quality. The EPA has taken action against facilities that fail to comply with the Clean Air Act, resulting in the reduction of volatile organic compound (VOC) emissions and the improvement of landfill gas collection systems. However, residents and activists argue that more needs to be done, as the slow pace of progress has resulted in few significant solutions over the years.

The San Joaquin Valley, a large producer of oil, agriculture, and warehouse distribution, has been out of compliance with EPA standards for 25 years, earning the distinction of being among the most polluted regions in the country. The concentration of polluting industries in the region has influenced policy-making, hindering efforts to improve air quality.

In addition to burning and industrial emissions, agricultural emissions, vehicle exhaust, and dust from agricultural fields contribute to the poor air quality in the Central Valley. The unique geography of the valley, surrounded by mountains on three sides, traps pollution on the valley floor, further exacerbating the issue.

Wildfires

In 2020, California experienced its worst wildfire season on record, with blazes burning across the state and blanketing the Central Valley in smoke. The valley's air quality reached hazardous levels, with high concentrations of PM 2.5, a type of fine particulate matter that can enter the bloodstream and impact heart health. The smoke from these fires not only affected local communities but also travelled thousands of miles, reaching as far as Europe.

The impact of wildfires on air quality in the Central Valley is exacerbated by the region's climate. Extreme heat, made worse by climate change, increases energy production and accelerates the formation of pollutants like ozone. The combination of wildfires and extreme heat creates a dangerous mix of pollutants that pose a serious risk to public health.

Communities in the Central Valley are particularly vulnerable to the effects of wildfire smoke due to the high number of outdoor workers and structural inequities that limit resources and enforcement of regulations to reduce air pollution. Lower-income communities are often unable to stay indoors or access air filtration equipment during periods of high smoke concentration. As a result, they face increased health risks, including respiratory issues, cardiovascular problems, and potential impacts on pregnancy and birth outcomes.

The Central Valley is a critical agricultural region, producing a significant portion of the nation's food. However, it also faces challenges such as poverty, housing insecurity, and a large number of at-risk workers. The poor air quality caused by wildfires adds to these existing issues, creating a complex set of public health and socioeconomic concerns.

Ineffective regulation

California's Central Valley is known for its poor air quality, and climate change is exacerbating this issue. The region is a major contributor to the country's food supply, producing about 25% of the nation's food despite occupying just 1% of farmland. However, it also has some of the highest rates of poverty and housing insecurity. The unique topography of the Valley, surrounded by mountains on three sides, traps pollution, leading to stagnant air and hazardous levels of particulate matter (PM2.5) and ozone.

The Central Valley Air Quality Coalition and environmental groups have been advocating for stronger regulations and working to phase out agricultural burning, a significant source of pollution. While there has been some success in reducing agricultural burning between 2003 and 2011, leading to a significant decrease in particulate pollution, other factors, such as drought, have led to an increase in burning practices, undoing some of the progress made.

The EPA has taken some action, providing funds for research, technology advancements, and medical studies on the health impacts of pollution. They have also enforced penalties for non-compliance and worked with local air districts to implement plans to reduce pollution. However, these efforts have not been sufficient to address the scale of the problem, and the Central Valley continues to experience the negative health impacts of poor air quality, with increased hospitalizations and respiratory issues among residents.

To effectively tackle air pollution in the Central Valley, centralized state-level regulation and a reduction of the influence of polluting industries on policy-making are necessary. Strengthening the regulatory powers of air districts and ensuring compliance with air quality standards are crucial steps towards improving the health and well-being of residents in the region.

Poverty and housing insecurity

California's Central Valley is known for its agricultural productivity, contributing about 25% of the nation's food while occupying just 1% of the country's farmland. However, despite this abundance, the region also experiences some of the highest rates of poverty and housing insecurity in the state.

The Central Valley is evolving into a patchwork of poverty and prosperity, with communities experiencing a mix of low and high economic indicators. For example, while cities like Bakersfield and Hanford exhibit strong economic indicators, Fresno and Stockton, the largest and third-largest cities in the Central Valley, have relatively low median household incomes and high proportions of households below the poverty level. This disparity is further exacerbated by racial dynamics, as Latino and Hispanic communities in the Central Valley face a persistent gap in incomes relative to all household median incomes.

Housing insecurity is a significant issue in the Central Valley, with rising rents, stagnant median household incomes, and a shortage of affordable housing contributing to the challenges faced by residents. According to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, households should not spend more than 30% of their incomes on rent and utilities. However, in the Central Valley, an estimated 25% of Fresno-area households are considered "moderately burdened," paying between 30% and 50% of their incomes on rent. Additionally, 35% are considered "severely burdened," paying more than half of their income for rent. This crisis is not limited to Fresno, as other Valley counties like Modesto/Stanislaus, Merced/Merced, Hanford/Corcoran/Kings, and Visalia/Tulare also have a significant proportion of rent-burdened households.

The high rates of poverty and housing insecurity in the Central Valley are closely linked to the region's agricultural economy. Labor-intensive agriculture contributes to poverty by attracting large numbers of unskilled foreign workers and offering most of them poverty-level wages. This dynamic results in a significant portion of residents living in households with below-poverty incomes and struggling to secure stable housing. Additionally, agricultural practices, such as burning fields no longer in production, have historically contributed to the region's poor air quality, further exacerbating the challenges faced by residents.

Addressing poverty and housing insecurity in the Central Valley is crucial not only for the well-being of its residents but also for the region's economic vitality. Efforts to ameliorate the situation include modifying immigration and labor laws that affect farming to help farmworkers earn higher wages and advocating for stronger air quality regulations to curb pollution from agricultural burning and other sources. By tackling these interconnected issues, the Central Valley can move towards a more prosperous and sustainable future for all its residents.

Frequently asked questions