Salt Lake City's Air Pollution: What's The Deal?

Salt Lake City has been dubbed Smog Lake City due to its poor air quality, which is caused by a combination of geographical factors and human activities. The city's location in a valley surrounded by mountain ranges results in pollutants and smog becoming trapped, particularly during temperature inversions in the winter months. While the air quality has shown some improvement, it still falls short of federal attainment levels for ozone and PM2.5 pollution, with motor vehicles being the largest source of pollution emissions. Other factors contributing to Salt Lake City's air pollution include interstate highways, industries, jet engines, warehouses, and the historical practice of redlining, which has disproportionately impacted minority communities.

Vehicle emissions

The geography and climate of Salt Lake City also play a role in the city's air pollution. The city is surrounded by mountain ranges on both sides, with narrow passages to the north and south, which cause particulate matter and smog to get trapped. The winter months tend to be the most polluted, with December, January, and November having the highest Air Quality Index (AQI) ratings in recent years. During these months, cold ground-level air becomes trapped under warmer air above, causing pollutants to linger until the weather changes.

In addition to vehicle emissions, other factors contributing to Salt Lake City's air pollution include interstate highways, industries, rail lines, jet engines at the international airport, and warehouses with heavy-duty diesel vehicles. The city's geographical location in the Great Salt Lake Basin also influences its air quality. The basin experiences some of the most severe winter particulate matter air pollution in the nation, with emissions from a magnesium refinery contributing significantly to the dense winter brown clouds that hang over the city.

The air pollution in Salt Lake City has been linked to adverse health effects. A study by Brigham Young University researchers found that Utah's air pollution reduces the average resident's life by 1.1 to 3.5 years. Additionally, a Salt Lake County, Utah study found a 42% higher rate of emergency room visits for asthma during the latter stages of air pollution events from 2003 to 2008.

While Salt Lake City has implemented measures to improve air quality, such as adding trees to the west-side canopy and planning to build a regional park, the city continues to face challenges in reducing vehicle emissions and improving overall air quality.

Interstate highways

Salt Lake City's air pollution is caused by a variety of factors, including interstate highways, industry, rail lines, airports, and warehouses that use diesel vehicles. The city's unique geography and climate also play a role in trapping pollutants and preventing their dispersal.

The impact of interstate highways on the air quality in Salt Lake City is particularly noticeable during stagnant events, such as inversions. Inversions occur when cold ground-level air becomes trapped under warmer air above due to temperature differences. This trap prevents pollutants from rising and dispersing into the atmosphere, causing them to linger and build up until weather conditions change. During these stagnant events, the emissions from interstate highways and diesel vehicles become more prominent and concentrated.

The issue of air pollution in Salt Lake City is not new. Even in the 1880s, communities were organizing to tackle the "smoke nuisance" caused by businesses burning large amounts of coal. While air quality has improved since then, the decisions and infrastructure developed over a century ago continue to impact the city today. The placement of minority populations near polluting sources through redlining has also contributed to the disproportionate impact of air pollution on certain areas and communities.

Addressing the air pollution caused by interstate highways and other emission sources requires a comprehensive approach. While adding trees and green spaces can help mitigate the concentration of pollutants, long-term infrastructure planning must also consider the environmental impacts over the next 100 to 150 years. This includes evaluating the potential consequences of projects like the Utah Inland Port and the widening of Interstate 15 on air quality and exploring alternatives to reduce emissions and mitigate pollution.

Industrial emissions

Salt Lake City has been ranked 105th out of 202 metropolitan areas for the worst year-round particle pollution, and its air quality has never met federal attainment levels for ozone or 24-hour PM2.5 pollution. The city's air quality is largely influenced by its unique geography and climate. During the winter, the Wasatch Front's geography leads to temperature inversions, where cold air is trapped underneath a layer of warm air, acting like a "lid" on the Salt Lake Valley. This causes particulate pollution to double daily and results in the city's highest AQI months.

While motor vehicles are the largest source of pollution emissions, comprising 55% of the city's emissions, industrial emissions also play a significant role in Salt Lake City's air pollution. Industry comprises 8% of the city's emissions, with industrial sites emitting over 100 tons per year of regulated pollutants. These emissions include halogenated compounds such as chlorine and bromine, which are known to deplete ozone levels rapidly. In fact, one study found that emissions from a single refinery contributed to 10-25% of Salt Lake City's winter inversion PM2.5 pollution.

The impact of industrial emissions on the city's air quality is further exacerbated by the presence of interstate highways, rail lines, jet engines at the international airport, and warehouses with heavy-duty diesel vehicles. These factors contribute to the concentration of pollutants in specific areas, particularly the west side of Salt Lake County, which has been historically impacted by redlining. The interplay between industrial emissions and other pollution sources underscores the complexity of Salt Lake City's air pollution challenges.

To address these issues, Salt Lake City is taking action through internal operations and the creation of external policies and programs to support air quality improvement and pollution reduction. The city's efforts include initiatives to increase the tree canopy and develop green spaces, which can help mitigate the effects of industrial emissions and improve air quality for all residents.

Jet engines

Salt Lake City's air pollution has been attributed to various factors, including the interstate highways, industries, rail lines, and the concentration of warehouses in the area. Another significant contributor to the city's air pollution is the Salt Lake City International Airport, specifically the jet engines revving on the planes that take off and land there.

The performance of jet engines is dependent on several factors. One critical aspect is the efficiency of the compressor, which affects the overall pressure ratio and temperature of the compressed air. Additionally, the design of the combustion chamber and the fuel injection system play a role in ensuring complete and efficient combustion. The materials used in the engine's construction must also withstand extremely high temperatures and pressures.

To enhance the performance of jet engines, engineers have employed various techniques. One approach is to utilize advanced materials that can tolerate higher temperatures, allowing for increased engine operating temperatures and, consequently, improved engine efficiency. Another strategy is to incorporate complex aerodynamic designs and advanced cooling methods to manage the extreme temperatures within the engine. Furthermore, the development of sophisticated fuel injection systems and the use of alternative fuels, such as synthetic or biofuels, have contributed to improved engine performance and reduced emissions.

While jet engines have revolutionized air travel, they also contribute to air pollution. The combustion process in jet engines releases various pollutants into the atmosphere. These emissions include nitrogen oxides (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), unburned hydrocarbons (UHC), particulate matter (PM), and, in some cases, sulfur oxides (SOx). Nitrogen oxides are formed at high temperatures when nitrogen and oxygen in the air react during combustion. Carbon monoxide is produced due to incomplete combustion, while unburned hydrocarbons result from fuel that doesn't fully burn. Particulate matter consists of tiny solid or liquid particles, such as soot, that are emitted along with the exhaust gases.

Lack of trees

Salt Lake City's air pollution is influenced by a multitude of factors, one of which is the lack of trees in certain areas. The disparity in the number of trees between the east and west sides of the city is notable, with the east boasting a more extensive urban forest canopy. This difference has its roots in a discriminatory housing practice known as "redlining," which historically relegated minority homeowners to less desirable areas.

The consequences of this historical injustice are still felt today, with the west side suffering from poorer air quality. The lack of trees on the west side means that residents are more exposed to pollutants, acting as "human filters," according to some. Trees are natural air filters, capturing particulate matter and helping to clean the air. Their absence contributes to the higher concentration of pollutants in the air that west-side residents breathe.

Recognizing this issue, Salt Lake City has committed to adding 1,000 trees to the west side's canopy annually and developing a regional park in Glendale. However, the west side continues to lag, facing challenges such as tree die-off due to insufficient watering and drought conditions. The harshening local climate underscores the urgency of investing in urban forest growth.

The benefits of trees extend beyond air quality improvement. Urban forests offer multiple advantages, including stormwater control, energy conservation, habitat creation for wildlife, and social cohesion. They enhance the aesthetic appeal of urban spaces and provide recreational opportunities for residents. Additionally, studies indicate lower childhood asthma rates in areas with more trees, which may help address the higher rates of childhood asthma on Salt Lake City's west side.

Addressing the lack of trees in Salt Lake City's west side is not just about improving air quality but also about creating a healthier, more equitable, and vibrant community for all residents. The Urban Forest Action Plan, introduced in 2020, reflects the city's commitment to increasing tree cover across the city and addressing historical inequalities.

Frequently asked questions