Co2: Friend Or Foe In The Air We Breathe?

Carbon dioxide (CO2) is a gas that is naturally present in the Earth's atmosphere. While it is true that animals, including humans, exhale CO2 as part of the natural respiration process, the debate surrounding CO2 as an air pollutant arises from its presence in the atmosphere at levels that can no longer be explained by natural processes alone. The increase in CO2 concentrations is primarily attributed to the burning of fossil fuels, which releases large amounts of this gas into the atmosphere, contributing to the greenhouse effect and climate change. Despite some studies and individuals disputing the classification of CO2 as a pollutant, legislative actions, such as the 2022 climate bill in the United States, have provided a legal foundation for regulating CO2 emissions and addressing their impact on climate change.

CO2 is a natural byproduct of human respiration

Carbon dioxide (CO2) is a natural byproduct of human respiration. It is formed intracellularly in the human body as a byproduct of metabolism. During cellular respiration, nutrients such as glucose and oxygen are converted into energy, adenosine triphosphate (ATP), and carbon dioxide is produced as a byproduct of this reaction. The oxygen needed for this process is obtained through inhalation, and the carbon dioxide generated is removed from the body via exhalation.

The respiratory and circulatory systems play a crucial role in regulating CO2 levels in the human body. The respiratory system is responsible for gas exchange, while the circulatory system transports blood and its components to and from the tissues. Gas exchange occurs in the lungs and tissues. In the lungs, oxygen diffuses into the blood, and carbon dioxide diffuses from the blood into the alveolar spaces. In the tissues, carbon dioxide produced by respiration diffuses from the tissues into the blood.

CO2 plays several important roles in the human body, including regulating blood pH, respiratory drive, and hemoglobin's affinity for oxygen. Fluctuations in CO2 levels can cause disturbances, and elevated levels can lead to respiratory acidosis. The body has mechanisms to compensate for respiratory acidosis, such as bicarbonate retention in the kidneys, which helps normalize pH levels.

While CO2 is a natural byproduct of human respiration, it is important to distinguish between natural levels and the increased levels caused by human activities, such as the burning of fossil fuels. The excessive release of CO2 into the atmosphere through these activities contributes to the greenhouse effect and climate change.

CO2 is a natural compound and building block of life

Carbon is a crucial element for all life on Earth and is considered a building block of life. Carbon compounds form solids, liquids, and gases. The majority of inorganic carbon exists as carbon dioxide, carbonate, and hydrogen carbonate. Carbon may be either organic or inorganic, and there is a continuous two-way flow between the two forms. Inorganic carbon is found in what is known as an oxidised state, which is reduced to organic carbon during photosynthesis. Organic carbon can be oxidised by atmospheric oxygen, usually through respiration. The energy released during respiration is used by plants and animals to maintain their bodily functions.

Carbon dioxide is a gas that contains carbon and oxygen. It is often written as CO2 and is a natural compound exhaled by animals, including human beings, as a product of respiration. CO2 levels in the atmosphere depend on a balance between sources and sinks. Sources give out CO2, and sinks absorb and store it. For example, the erosion of silicate rocks is a process that removes carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Rainwater, which contains carbon dioxide, reacts with silicate rocks to form bicarbonates, which are eventually incorporated into the mantle.

Volcanoes can also increase CO2 in the atmosphere. Volcanism was much greater during the Cretaceous Period, resulting in higher CO2 levels and a warmer climate. While carbon is a natural element, it can become a pollutant when introduced to the environment at a large scale. The burning of fossil fuels, for example, releases carbon that has been sequestered underground for millions of years, leading to harmful effects on the environment. The extra carbon dioxide in the atmosphere contributes to the greenhouse gas effect, preventing some of the sun's radiation from exiting and increasing the Earth's surface temperature.

Although CO2 is a natural compound and building block of life, the unnatural release of CO2 through human activities can have detrimental consequences. The distinction between CO2 as a natural compound and a pollutant lies in the scale and impact of its presence in the atmosphere.

CO2 is not directly harmful to human health

Carbon dioxide (CO2) is a colourless, odourless gas that is vital for life on Earth. The human breathing mechanism revolves around CO2—without it, humans would not be able to breathe. However, CO2 is also a significant greenhouse gas, contributing to climate change, which is an existential threat to humanity.

CO2 is not considered an air pollutant because it is not directly harmful to human health in small quantities. It is not poisonous, and in fact, humans naturally release it when they breathe. While the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is much larger than what humans naturally emit, it is only when CO2 gets concentrated that it becomes a concern for human health. CO2 acts as a simple asphyxiant, meaning that as levels of the gas rise in a closed room, it replaces the oxygen that our bodies need. When our bodies cannot get enough oxygen, they slow down and do not function properly.

CO2 primarily affects the brain. At moderate levels of around 1000 parts per million (ppm), there are observable effects on thinking, concentration, and focus. These levels of CO2 are common in office meeting rooms, schools, and homes, and while they are not optimal for human health, they are also not directly harmful. At much higher concentrations of 20,000 ppm, CO2 causes deepened breathing, and at 100,000 ppm, it leads to visual disturbances, tremors, and loss of consciousness. A concentration of 250,000 ppm (25%) can cause death.

The maximum recommended occupational exposure limit for an 8-hour workday is 5,000 ppm as a time-weighted average. Epidemiological and intervention research has shown that higher levels of CO2 within the range found in normal indoor settings are associated with perceptions of poor air quality, increased prevalence of acute health symptoms (e.g. headaches, mucosal irritation), slower work performance, and increased absences. However, these effects are attributed to the correlation of indoor CO2 with concentrations of other indoor air pollutants that are influenced by outdoor ventilation rates.

While CO2 is not directly harmful to human health in small quantities, it has become a pollutant because its introduction into the environment on a large scale has harmful effects on the planet, which in turn impacts human health and survival.

CO2 is not a pollutant according to a 2017 study

The researchers state that there is very little doubt that the EPA's claim of a Tropical Hot Spot caused by rising atmospheric CO2 levels does not exist. They argue that after naturally occurring events, such as solar, volcanic, and oceanic activity, are accounted for, there is no record-setting warming to be concerned about.

CO2, or carbon dioxide, is a natural byproduct of human respiration and is essential for life on Earth. However, the burning of fossil fuels has significantly increased the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere, leading to concerns about its impact on the environment. While CO2 is a greenhouse gas that helps regulate the Earth's temperature, excess CO2 can contribute to global warming and climate change.

According to the 2017 study, the EPA's regulations on fossil fuels based on the endangerment finding may not be justified. The study suggests that the impact of rising CO2 levels on global warming may be overstated. However, other studies and organizations, such as the IPCC, continue to assert that CO2 emissions contribute to climate change and have harmful effects on the environment.

While the 2017 study provides a different perspective on the role of CO2, the consensus among the scientific community is that human activities, particularly the burning of fossil fuels, have led to increased CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere. Efforts to reduce emissions and transition to cleaner energy sources remain a priority for mitigating climate change and its associated impacts.

The EPA has faced legal challenges to its attempts to regulate CO2

While carbon dioxide (CO2) is a natural byproduct of human respiration, it becomes a pollutant when it is introduced to the environment at a scale far beyond natural emissions. The burning of fossil fuels, for example, releases vast amounts of CO2, creating a harmful greenhouse gas effect. This effect contributes to climate change and poses risks to human health.

Recognizing the dangers of CO2, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has made efforts to regulate CO2 emissions, particularly from power plants, which are significant contributors to greenhouse gases. However, these attempts have faced considerable legal challenges. One notable challenge relates to the EPA's use of the Clean Air Act to regulate greenhouse gas emissions. In a previous case, Justice Scalia issued a warning against the agency overstepping its authority, suggesting that the EPA should not unilaterally regulate a significant portion of the American economy.

The EPA's proposed regulations have also faced resistance from states and industries. Fifteen states and the nation's largest privately-owned coal producer sought to block the EPA from issuing certain rules, arguing that the agency lacked the statutory authority to regulate existing power plants under the Clean Air Act. Additionally, 32 states raised concerns about the legality of the proposed rules. The EPA's regulations have also been criticized for potentially disrupting the traditional Federal-State division in the power sector and favoring costly renewable energy sources over other forms of energy.

The EPA has defended its position, citing the need to address climate change and protect public health. The agency has published legal defenses of its rules and continues to implement CO2 emission standards for various industries, including aviation and oil and natural gas. However, the EPA faces an uphill battle, with predictions that its rules will face stiff resistance in court, potentially reaching the Supreme Court.

Frequently asked questions