Salt Lake's Air Pollution: What's The Source?

Salt Lake City has some of the worst air quality in the United States. Interstate highways, industries, rail lines, jet engines, warehouses, and heavy-duty diesel vehicles all contribute to the city's air pollution. Fossil fuels are responsible for much of Salt Lake City's air pollution, with an estimated 85% of harmful emissions resulting from fossil fuel combustion for heating, traffic, and other uses. Seasonal fluctuations also play a role, with temperature inversions in the winter trapping polluted air and preventing its dispersal. While air quality improvements have been made, Salt Lake City still experiences high levels of PM2.5 and ozone pollution, which can have adverse health effects on sensitive groups such as children, the elderly, and those with respiratory conditions.

Fossil fuels, including home heating and traffic

Fossil fuels are a major contributor to air pollution in Salt Lake City, with an estimated 85% of harmful emissions stemming from fossil fuel combustion. This is largely due to home and building heating, as well as traffic. The city's geographic location, nestled between mountain ranges with narrow passages to the north and south, traps pollutants, including those from fossil fuels.

Home heating, a significant source of fossil fuel emissions, is particularly problematic during the winter months. Temperature inversions trap polluted air, preventing its dispersal, and leading to significantly higher concentrations of PM2.5—a measure of fine particulate matter in the air. This results in a severe degradation of air quality, with winter months experiencing more than five times the PM2.5 concentration compared to summer.

Traffic, including cars, motorbikes, trucks, lorries, and heavy-duty diesel vehicles, also plays a significant role in Salt Lake City's air pollution. Interstate highways, such as Interstate 80, contribute to the problem, as do the jet engines at Salt Lake City International Airport and the concentration of warehouses with their associated diesel vehicles. Improvements in vehicle emissions standards and the introduction of more efficient, lower-emission vehicles have helped reduce pollution levels, even as the population and number of registered vehicles have increased.

To further mitigate the impact of fossil fuels on air quality, Salt Lake City can implement legislative measures to promote the use of electric or low-emission vehicles, improve building energy efficiency, eliminate subsidies for oil and gas companies, expand alternative transportation options, and transition to cleaner energy sources. These steps will be crucial in reducing the health risks associated with air pollution, which include increased emergency room visits for asthma and a higher risk of miscarriage.

Seasonal fluctuations, particularly winter inversions

Winter inversions in Salt Lake City can result in more than five times the concentration of PM2.5 compared to summer months. PM2.5 refers to particulate matter with a size of 2.5 micrometers or less, which is small enough to infiltrate the lungs deeply and cause respiratory irritation. The health impacts of winter inversions are significant, with a 42% higher rate of emergency room visits for asthma observed during the latter stages of air pollution events from 2003 to 2008. High-risk groups, including young children, senior citizens, pregnant women, and those with heart or lung disease, are advised to stay indoors and limit outdoor activities during periods of poor air quality.

The unique geography of the Wasatch Front contributes to the severity of winter inversions in Salt Lake City. The strong, multi-day inversions, known as persistent cold air pools, develop during December, January, and early February. These months consistently exhibit the highest Air Quality Index (AQI) ratings in the city. The basin-like shape of the surrounding mountains shields the city from winds that could otherwise help disperse the trapped pollutants. Additionally, snowstorms can contribute to cold ground-level air, further exacerbating the inversion effect.

While annual averages may suggest that Salt Lake City has "good" air quality, these averages can obscure pollution events and unhealthy air pollution days. The city's air quality has consistently failed to meet federal attainment levels for ozone and 24-hour PM2.5 pollution, resulting in "F" ratings for these measures. The American Lung Association ranked Salt Lake City 105th out of 202 metropolitan areas for year-round particle pollution. The city's geographical characteristics and winter inversions play a crucial role in these poor air quality ratings.

Fossil fuel combustion, primarily from home and building heating and traffic, is a significant contributor to Salt Lake City's air pollution. However, legislative measures and technological advancements have led to improvements in air quality. The adoption of more efficient, lower-emission vehicles and tightening vehicle emission standards have helped reduce pollution levels, even with a growing population and an increase in vehicle registrations. Additionally, a 2017 study by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) identified emissions from a magnesium refinery as responsible for a significant fraction of the fine particles contributing to the dense winter brown clouds over the city.

Industrial emissions, including from refineries

Salt Lake City, Utah, is known for its poor air quality, which is largely due to industrial emissions, including those from refineries. The city's air quality has never met federal attainment levels for ozone or 24-hour PM2.5 pollution, and it consistently receives "F" ratings for both measures. The area, which includes Provo and Orem, ranked 7th out of 217 metropolitan areas for the worst 24-hour particle pollution and 11th out of 228 for worst ozone pollution.

One significant contributor to Salt Lake City's air pollution is the US Magnesium refinery located on the Great Salt Lake's southwest corner. This refinery is the only one of its kind in the country and is the nation's biggest emitter of chlorine. While federal and state regulators require the reporting of chlorine emissions, they do not track bromine, another reactive chemical emitted by the refinery. Modeling has shown that emissions from this refinery are responsible for 10-25% of regional PM2.5 during winter "inversions," when pollution is trapped in the basin around the lake by cold air.

The Utah Division of Air Quality requires the reporting of particulate precursors, such as chlorine and nitrogen oxide emissions, which are then shared with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. However, the lack of mandatory reporting for bromine emissions may contribute to an underestimation of the industrial sector's role in Salt Lake City's air pollution.

In addition to the US Magnesium refinery, Salt Lake City is also home to five oil refineries, which process about 207,000 barrels of crude oil per calendar day. These refineries produce motor gasoline, diesel fuel, and jet fuel, contributing to the city's air pollution.

The energy industry is an important component of Utah's economy, and the state has a variety of energy resources, including crude oil, natural oil, coal, and renewable energy sources. While there have been efforts to improve air quality, such as the creation of an electric vehicle charging network, Salt Lake City continues to struggle with poor air quality, particularly during the winter months when temperature inversions trap polluted air.

Interstate highways, rail lines, and airports

Salt Lake City's air quality is impacted by several factors, including interstate highways, rail lines, and airports. The city's unique geographical location, with mountain ranges on both sides and narrow passages to the north and south, traps pollutants in the valley.

Interstate highways, such as Interstate 80, contribute significantly to the air pollution in Salt Lake. The heavy-duty diesel vehicles, trucks, and construction trucks that operate on and around these highways emit exhaust fumes, which contain harmful pollutants. Additionally, the interstate highways themselves can act as physical barriers, hindering the dispersal of pollutants and contributing to the concentration of smog and particulate matter in the area.

Rail lines and rail yards are another source of air pollution in Salt Lake. The diesel locomotives and idling trains can emit significant amounts of nitrogen oxide and particulate matter. The constant movement of trains and the proximity of rail lines to residential areas can expose nearby communities to air pollutants, particularly those living on the west side of Salt Lake County.

Salt Lake City International Airport also plays a role in the city's air pollution. Jet engines revving on the runways emit pollutants, including nitrogen oxide and particulate matter. The impact of the airport is particularly noticeable during inversion conditions when the pollution from the jet engines becomes trapped in the valley, affecting the air quality for those living nearby.

The combination of interstate highways, rail lines, and airport activities contributes to the overall air pollution levels in Salt Lake. The pollutants emitted by these sources can have significant health impacts on sensitive groups, including children, the elderly, and individuals with respiratory conditions. The unique geography of the region further exacerbates the issue by trapping the pollutants and creating a concentrated area of smog and particulate matter.

To mitigate the impact of these pollution sources, various measures can be implemented. This includes adopting cleaner technologies, improving fuel efficiency, and transitioning to electric or low-emission vehicles. Additionally, the development and enforcement of pollution control regulations can help reduce emissions from these sources, improving the air quality for the residents of Salt Lake City and the surrounding areas.

Construction, dust, and poorly paved roads

Construction sites generate dust and release fine particles into the air, contributing to the city's air pollution. The movement of construction trucks and heavy machinery stirs up dust, leading to increased particulate matter in the atmosphere. Poorly paved roads, particularly those outside the city centre, also contribute to dust and particle pollution. The unpaved or uneven surfaces can cause vehicles to kick up dust, adding to the overall pollution levels.

Seasonal fluctuations further exacerbate the impact of construction and poorly paved roads on air quality. During the winter months, temperature inversions trap polluted air, preventing its dispersal. As a result, the concentration of PM2.5 (particulate matter with a diameter of 2.5 micrometres or less) can be more than five times higher in winter than in summer. This trapped pollution, combined with the dust and particles from construction and roads, creates a significant health hazard for residents.

The effects of construction and road-related pollution are particularly pronounced in certain areas of Salt Lake City. The west side of the city experiences worse air quality due to the interstate highways, industries, rail lines, and the proximity of the airport. The lack of trees and green spaces on the west side further exacerbates the problem, as there are fewer buffers to capture and filter out the particulate matter.

To mitigate the impact of construction and poorly paved roads on air quality, several measures can be implemented. These include improved paving and maintenance of roads, especially in areas outside the city centre. Additionally, implementing stricter regulations on construction sites, such as requiring water spraying to suppress dust and enforcing the use of covered trucks for transporting materials, can help reduce the release of particulate matter. Increasing the number of trees and green spaces in affected areas can also help capture and filter dust and fine particles, improving the overall air quality for residents.

Frequently asked questions