Polluting Water: When Is It Ever Okay?

Water pollution is a pressing issue that jeopardizes the health of millions of people and aquatic ecosystems worldwide. It occurs when harmful substances contaminate bodies of water, degrading water quality and rendering it toxic or unusable. With finite sources of drinkable water and increasing global demand, it is essential to address the question: Are there ever circumstances in which it is acceptable to pollute a body of water? This complex question requires a nuanced exploration of various factors, including the type of pollution, its sources, and the potential impact on human health and the environment.

Point source pollution

Point-source pollution refers to contamination that originates from a single source. It is easier to identify and control than non-point-source pollution. Examples of point-source pollution include wastewater (also called effluent) discharged by a manufacturer, oil refinery, or wastewater treatment facility, as well as contamination from leaking septic systems, chemical and oil spills, and illegal dumping.

The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) defines point-source pollution as "any single identifiable source of pollution from which pollutants are discharged, such as a pipe, ditch, ship or factory smokestack." This includes factories, sewage treatment plants, and farms, which typically discharge pollutants into bodies of water. For instance, oil refineries, paper mills, and auto plants that use water in their manufacturing processes may discharge wastewater containing harmful chemical pollutants into rivers, lakes, or the ocean. Similarly, municipal wastewater treatment plants can introduce nutrients and harmful microbes into waterways, leading to rampant algae growth.

The Clean Water Act established the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES), which requires factories, sewage treatment plants, and other point sources to obtain a permit before discharging waste or effluents into any body of water. The EPA regulates point-source pollution by setting limits on what can be discharged directly into a body of water. However, it is important to note that some chemicals discharged by point sources are toxic to people and wildlife, while others are harmless.

Point-source pollution can have severe impacts on human health and the environment. For example, combined sewer systems in older cities may overflow during heavy rainfall, discharging untreated sewage and stormwater directly into nearby water bodies, causing water pollution and unsafe drinking water. This can also restrict activities like fishing and swimming.

Nonpoint source pollution

The term "nonpoint source" refers to any source of water pollution that does not meet the legal definition of "point source" in the Clean Water Act. Point sources are confined and discrete conveyances, such as pipes or ditches, from which pollutants are discharged. In contrast, nonpoint sources are very broad unconfined areas from which a variety of pollutants enter the water body, such as agricultural or urban stormwater runoff.

Agricultural land, such as cropland, pastureland, and rangeland, is a major source of NPS pollution. Contaminants from agricultural land can include oil, pet waste, pesticides, herbicides, fertilizers, road salt, bacteria, and sediment. Urban land, including forests, wetlands, minelands, and developed areas for housing, roads, and businesses, is another significant source of NPS pollution. Urban runoff flows through storm drains and pipes, carrying pollutants such as sediment, nutrients from fertilizers and animal waste, and other contaminants directly into lakes and streams.

The effects of NPS pollutants on specific waters can vary and may not always be fully assessed. However, NPS pollution can damage aquatic habitats, harm aquatic life, and reduce the capacity of water resources to be used for drinking water and recreation. Sediment, for example, can cause water to become cloudy, making it difficult for aquatic organisms to see and feed properly, damaging fish gills, and reducing sunlight penetration, which affects plant growth. Sediment can also carry other pollutants such as metals and toxic chemicals.

While it is important to address and mitigate the impacts of NPS pollution, it is challenging to regulate due to the lack of a single, identifiable culprit. However, there are federal programs and public initiatives in place to help control and reduce the impact of NPS pollution on water quality.

Radioactive waste

There are several methods for disposing of radioactive waste, including deep geological repositories, ocean floor disposal, and burial. International scientific consensus supports deep geological repositories as a safe and environmentally sound disposal method for high-level radioactive waste. Such projects are well advanced in some countries, such as Finland and Sweden. In the USA, a deep geological waste repository (the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant) is already in operation for the disposal of transuranic waste.

Ocean floor disposal of radioactive waste has been suggested, as deep waters in the North Atlantic Ocean do not present an exchange with shallow waters for about 140 years based on oxygen content data recorded over 25 years. This method would require an amendment to the Law of the Sea. Radioactive waste is typically isolated and encased in glass and concrete to prevent leakage on the ocean floor. However, it is essential to keep it on land for some time while radioactivity levels decrease.

While there are no instances of radioactive release causing harm during transport, the nuclear industry's "waste problem" remains a concern for many. The transport and disposal of radioactive waste pose an unacceptable risk to people and the environment. Radioactive waste can enter the food chain through plankton and kelp, contaminating fish and other marine life. Radioactive caesium and plutonium have been found in seals and porpoises in the Irish Sea.

Eutrophication

The most visible effect of eutrophication is the creation of dense blooms of noxious, foul-smelling phytoplankton, which reduce water clarity and harm water quality. These algal blooms limit light penetration, reducing plant growth and causing die-offs in littoral zones. They also impair the success of predators that rely on light and chemosensory abilities to catch prey. When these blooms eventually die, microbial decomposition severely depletes dissolved oxygen, creating "dead zones" that lack sufficient oxygen to support most organisms.

To prevent and reverse eutrophication, it is crucial to minimise point source pollution from sewage and agriculture, as well as non-point pollution sources. Additionally, introducing bacteria and algae-inhibiting organisms, such as shellfish and seaweed, can help reduce nitrogen pollution and control the growth of cyanobacteria.

Solid waste pollution

Plastics are a significant contributor to solid waste pollution, with items such as microplastics ending up in rivers, lakes, and oceans. The breakdown of plastic pollution in ocean waters is a growing concern. Sunlight and seawater cause larger plastic objects to break down into microplastics, which are then consumed by small marine animals, potentially working their way up the food chain.

Another source of solid waste pollution is the improper disposal of wastewater from industrial plants and chemical process facilities. This type of pollution, known as point source pollution, includes the discharge of contaminated water from a single source, such as a pipe or a channel. The EPA regulates point source pollution by setting limits on the amount and type of discharge allowed directly into bodies of water. However, even with these regulations in place, accidental releases or improper disposal of contaminants can still occur, threatening groundwater, surface water, and marine resources.

Nonpoint source pollution, on the other hand, is more challenging to regulate as it originates from diffuse sources. This type of pollution includes agricultural runoff, stormwater runoff, and debris blown into waterways from the land. While it may be more challenging to address, nonpoint source pollution is the leading cause of water pollution in U.S. waters.

To address solid waste pollution, proper waste management is essential. The Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA), passed in 1976, provides a framework for hazardous and non-hazardous waste management in the United States. EPA regulations define solid wastes and hazardous wastes, providing guidelines for generators of hazardous waste to determine if their waste is subject to regulation. Additionally, reducing the use of single-use plastics and safely treating wastewater can help prevent solid waste pollution and protect our valuable water resources.

Frequently asked questions