Air Pollution: The Silent Indoor And Outdoor Killer

Air pollution is a pressing global issue, and it is generally understood that outdoor air pollution is a significant contributor. However, the quality of the air we breathe indoors is also a critical concern. People spend a significant amount of time indoors, and the indoor air quality can have a more substantial impact on our health. Various factors, including indoor activities, ventilation, and external pollution sources, influence indoor air quality. This complex interplay between outdoor and indoor air pollution raises the question: which is worse for our health, and how can we mitigate the negative consequences?

Indoor air pollution can be 2-5 times worse than outdoors, and up to 100 times in some cases

While outdoor air pollution is a well-known issue, with smog, acid rain, smoke, and exhaust being visible and noticeable, indoor air pollution can be an even more pressing concern. According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), indoor air pollution levels in homes, workplaces, and school classrooms are typically 2-5 times higher than outdoor pollution levels. In some cases, indoor pollution can become 100 times worse than outdoor air pollution.

This discrepancy is partly due to the time spent indoors, with studies showing that people spend about 87% of their day in homes or buildings and another 6% in enclosed vehicles. The design of modern homes and the materials used in construction can also contribute to poor indoor air quality. For instance, building materials can release pollutants like asbestos fibres or chemical off-gassing from pressed wood products. Additionally, indoor activities such as cooking with solid fuels or burning wood, gas, and fossil fuels can generate significant indoor air pollutants like SO2, NOx, CO, and PM. These pollutants may accumulate if the indoor air is not well ventilated, which can have serious health consequences for occupants.

Furthermore, outdoor air pollutants can enter buildings through open doors, windows, ventilation systems, and cracks in structures. People can also inadvertently bring in outdoor pollutants on their shoes and clothing. The air exchange rate with the outdoors, influenced by building design and ventilation systems, plays a crucial role in determining indoor air pollutant concentrations. When outdoor pollutant levels are high, opening windows and doors to ventilate indoor spaces can sometimes worsen indoor air quality.

The impact of indoor air pollution on health can be significant. Studies have linked particle pollution to premature death in people with heart or lung disease. The concentration of certain pollutants indoors can lead to lasting health effects, even if exposure outdoors is brief. Therefore, addressing indoor air pollution through behavioural changes, improving ventilation, and modifying home environments is crucial to minimising the impact of outdoor air pollution on indoor air quality and reducing overall exposure to harmful pollutants.

Outdoor air pollution infiltrates indoor spaces, accounting for 10-100% of indoor air pollution

While outdoor air pollution is a well-known issue, with visible smog and exhaust fumes, indoor air pollution is often more harmful. People typically spend 87% of their day in homes or buildings, and another 6% in enclosed vehicles, so indoor air quality is a significant concern.

Outdoor air pollution infiltrates indoor spaces through open doors and windows, ventilation systems, and cracks in structures. This infiltration can significantly worsen indoor air quality, with indoor pollution levels becoming 2-5 times higher than outdoor levels and, in some cases, over 100 times worse. A 2016 report by the Board on Population Health and Public Health Practice found that anywhere from 10 to 100 percent of indoor air pollution consists of outdoor air pollution.

The air exchange rate, which is influenced by building design, construction, and operating parameters, plays a crucial role in indoor pollutant concentrations. Mechanical ventilation devices, such as fans or air handling systems, can help regulate this exchange rate. However, increasing ventilation may not always be the best solution, as it can also increase energy costs. Weather conditions and occupant behaviour also impact indoor air quality.

To reduce the impact of outdoor air pollution on indoor spaces, individuals can make changes to their habits and homes. For example, using air purifiers, sealing off sources of pollution like asbestos, and adjusting emission levels of certain appliances. Additionally, occupants can avoid bringing outdoor pollutants inside by removing shoes and changing clothes when entering buildings.

In summary, while outdoor air pollution is a significant issue, it is important to recognise that it can infiltrate indoor spaces, significantly impacting indoor air quality. Taking proactive measures to minimise this infiltration and improve indoor air quality is crucial for protecting the health and comfort of building occupants.

Outdoor ground-level ozone can enter homes, triggering asthma and respiratory issues

Outdoor air pollution can enter homes through open doors, windows, ventilation systems, and even tiny, often undetectable cracks and openings in walls and windows. Older homes are especially susceptible to outdoor pollutant infiltration due to their lack of airtightness.

Ground-level ozone is a significant component of outdoor air pollution. Ozone is a gas molecule composed of three oxygen atoms. While stratospheric ozone protects us from the sun's ultraviolet radiation, ground-level ozone is harmful to human health. It forms when gases from pollution sources such as tailpipes, smokestacks, and factories react with sunlight, creating ozone smog.

Ground-level ozone is a critical concern for people with asthma. It can trigger and exacerbate asthma symptoms, leading to increased medication use, doctor visits, and hospital admissions. Even healthy individuals can experience adverse effects, with studies showing that lifeguards in Galveston had greater airway obstruction at the end of the day when exposed to high ozone levels.

Research has also linked indoor ozone from outdoor sources to asthma and respiratory issues. A 2009 study in the Journal of Asthma found a correlation between elevated indoor ozone levels during hot summers and airway obstruction, heightened inflammation, and reduced quality of life in people with asthma and allergies. Furthermore, a 2019 study in Frontiers in Immunology suggested a connection between ground-level ozone and long-term respiratory issues, impaired lung function, and emergency respiratory disease symptoms.

Therefore, while indoor air pollution can be more deadly due to the concentration of pollutants, outdoor ground-level ozone that enters homes can have significant health impacts, particularly for those with asthma and respiratory conditions.

Socioeconomic disparities: low-income households are at risk of higher indoor air pollution concentrations

While outdoor air pollution is a serious issue, indoor air pollution poses a more significant threat to human health. People spend over 80% of their time indoors, where they are exposed to various indoor air pollutants, many of which also originate from outdoor sources.

Socioeconomic disparities contribute significantly to the risk of exposure to higher indoor air pollution concentrations, particularly for low-income households. This vulnerability is influenced by several factors:

• Housing conditions: Low-income households often reside in older, less energy-efficient homes with inadequate ventilation. These homes are more susceptible to leaks of outdoor pollutants due to their lack of airtightness. Additionally, building modifications, such as the use of wooden construction materials, oil-based paints, and indoor plants, can inadvertently worsen indoor air quality without proper ventilation.
• Energy consumption: Homes with higher energy consumption and poorer energy efficiency are more likely to belong to low-income, African American, and Hispanic individuals. The use of combustion-related activities for cooking and heating, such as wood-burning stoves, contributes to indoor air pollution.
• Access to resources: Low-income households may have limited financial capabilities to invest in energy-efficient upgrades, ventilation improvements, or modern appliances. They may also have restricted access to healthcare, healthy food options, and job opportunities, further exacerbating their vulnerability to indoor air pollution.
• Outdoor pollution infiltration: While outdoor air pollution can infiltrate all buildings, low-income neighbourhoods often experience higher concentrations of outdoor pollutants due to their proximity to industrial areas or heavy traffic. This increases the risk of indoor air pollution in these households, as outdoor pollutants can enter through openings, ventilation systems, or chemical reactions with building materials.
• Behavioural factors: Occupant behaviour, such as prolonged indoor time and extended usage of air conditioners due to climate change, can impact indoor air quality. Additionally, cultural practices, such as cooking habits and the use of fragrant decorations, can introduce indoor air pollutants.

Addressing these disparities requires interventions and policies that prioritize environmental justice. Federal and state programs offering financial support, such as the U.S. Department of Energy Weatherization Assistance Program, can assist low-income households in improving energy efficiency and reducing indoor air pollution sources.

Indoor air quality is harder to regulate than outdoor, as it depends on occupant behaviour

While outdoor air pollution is a well-known issue, indoor air quality is often overlooked. People spend a significant amount of time indoors, with studies indicating that individuals spend up to 90% of their time inside homes, buildings, or vehicles. This high proportion of time spent indoors underscores the critical importance of maintaining good indoor air quality.

Indoor air quality is influenced by various factors, including the type and operating conditions of indoor pollution sources, ventilation conditions, and indoor activities. Cooking, heating, and the use of open fireplaces or stoves with dirty solid fuels like waste wood, charcoal, or coal can generate significant indoor air pollutants such as SO2, NOx, CO, and particulate matter (PM). Additionally, indoor air quality can be affected by anthropogenic sources, such as wooden construction materials, oil-based paints, fragrant decorations, and indoor plants, which emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs) like formaldehyde and turpenes. These VOCs can have serious health implications, including potential carcinogenic effects.

The unique behaviours and activities of occupants play a significant role in determining indoor air quality. For example, cooking habits, preferences for ventilation, and the use of artificial products can all contribute to the presence of fine particles and pollutants in the indoor environment. Small concentrations of indoor pollutants can quickly accumulate and lead to greater health concerns compared to outdoor pollution, as they are not dispersed by natural airflow.

Regulating indoor air quality is challenging due to the dynamic nature of occupant behaviour and the diverse sources of indoor pollution. Unlike outdoor air, which is primarily influenced by industrial activities and vehicle emissions, indoor air quality depends on the specific actions and choices of individuals within the indoor space. This variability in human behaviour and activities makes it difficult to implement standardised regulations or controls.

To address indoor air quality issues, it is essential to focus on source control and filtration. This may include interventions such as switching to newer, more energy-efficient appliances, improving ventilation, and reducing the use of pollutants in indoor spaces. By targeting the sources of indoor air pollution and implementing effective filtration methods, it is possible to improve both indoor and outdoor air quality, as indoor sources significantly contribute to outdoor pollution levels.

Frequently asked questions