Strokes And Air Pollution: Which Engines Are Worse?

Two-stroke engines are a major source of air pollution, particularly in developing countries. Two-stroke engines burn a mixture of oil and gasoline, producing high levels of smoke, carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, and particulate matter in their exhaust emissions. In contrast, four-stroke engines burn only gasoline, resulting in significantly lower emissions. While two-stroke engines are simple, compact, and cheap to maintain, their pollution output has led to efforts to phase them out and develop cleaner technologies.

Two-stroke engines burn a mixture of oil and gasoline, emitting more smoke, carbon monoxide, and hydrocarbons

Two-stroke engines are simple, lightweight, and powerful, but they also produce more emissions than four-stroke engines. This is because two-stroke engines burn a mixture of oil and gasoline in every cycle, and some of the unburned fuel escapes through the exhaust port. The unburned fuel exits the combustion chamber as exhaust gases, resulting in the emission of smoke, carbon monoxide, and hydrocarbons.

The oil-gasoline mixture in two-stroke engines gets contaminated with the engine's lubricating oils. As a result, some of the fuel and oil mix with the exhaust, leading to higher emissions. The poor fuel economy and high emission rates of total hydrocarbons (THC) and carbon monoxide (CO) are predominantly due to scavenging losses. At wide-open throttle, 30-40% of the air-fuel mixture may escape burning in the cylinder and exit as exhaust.

The high levels of THC emissions are also due to the rich air-to-fuel overall calibration, unstable combustion, and misfiring, especially under low speed and load conditions. The high particulate matter (PM) emissions result from the oil-fuel mixture lubrication used in two-stroke engines, as the unburned or partially burned lubricating oil exits through the exhaust. The use of lubricating oil in two-stroke engines contributes to the emissions of hydrocarbons, particulate matter, and smoke.

To reduce emissions, some methods have been proposed, such as using a separate oil pump that delivers oil according to engine speed and load instead of a fixed oil-gasoline ratio. Synthetic or semi-synthetic oils with lower viscosity, better lubrication, and lower volatility can also help reduce emissions. Additionally, engine tuning can improve performance, efficiency, and reliability while reducing emissions of carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, and nitrogen oxides.

Another effective way to reduce emissions from two-stroke engines is to replace the carburetor with a fuel injection system, which can reduce emissions of hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide, and particulate matter by up to 90% compared to carbureted engines. The use of catalytic converters can also drastically reduce pollutant emissions from internal combustion engines.

Four-stroke engines burn pure petrol and are found in newer motorcycles

Two-stroke engines are a major source of air pollution, particularly in Asian countries. Two-stroke engines burn a mixture of oil and gasoline, releasing smoke, carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, and particulate matter into the atmosphere. In contrast, four-stroke engines, found in newer motorcycles, burn pure petrol, resulting in lower emissions.

Four-stroke engines are internal combustion engines in which the piston completes four separate strokes (intake, compression, power, and exhaust) while turning the crankshaft. This design allows for greater thermal efficiency than traditional piston engines, as the expansion ratio can be higher than the compression ratio. Additionally, the power stroke is longer than the compression stroke, contributing to improved fuel economy.

The first four-stroke engine was developed by Nikolaus August Otto in 1862, and it ran on illuminating gas. Over time, the four-stroke engine has become the most common internal combustion engine design for motorized land transport, including automobiles, trucks, diesel trains, light aircraft, and motorcycles.

Four-stroke engines are preferred over two-stroke engines due to their environmental advantages and fuel efficiency. Four-stroke engines reuse oil, losing only a small amount during the combustion process. In contrast, two-stroke engines use oil once, requiring a higher volume of oil to be mixed with the fuel. This results in higher fuel consumption and increased pollution.

While four-stroke engines produce less pollution than two-stroke engines, they still contribute to air pollution, which is a significant health concern worldwide. Outdoor air pollution is responsible for approximately 800,000 deaths annually and affects the health of many more. To mitigate the impact of engine emissions, cities like San Fernando in the Philippines have implemented policies to phase out two-stroke vehicles and encourage the adoption of four-stroke models through economic incentives.

Two-stroke engines are simpler mechanically and develop more power with the same displacement

Two-stroke engines are mechanically simpler than four-stroke engines. They have 25-50% fewer parts, which makes them lighter and gives them a higher power-to-weight ratio. This simplicity of design also makes them less efficient, and they are generally noisier. Two-stroke engines do not require additional lubricating oil pumps, piping, or filters, nor do they need cooling water pumps, push rods, or exhaust valves. This further reduces weight.

Two-stroke engines are used when mechanical simplicity, light weight, and high power-to-weight ratios are design priorities. They are found in small propulsion applications, such as outboard motors, motorcycles, mopeds, and scooters. They are also used in industrial and marine applications, as well as some trucks and heavy machinery.

Two-stroke engines are also more powerful than four-stroke engines of the same displacement. This is because they complete several stages per stroke, whereas four-stroke engines require one full stroke per stage. Two-stroke engines require only two strokes per combustion cycle, while four-stroke engines require four strokes.

However, two-stroke engines produce more air pollution than four-stroke engines. This is because the fuel-air mixture in two-stroke engines gets contaminated with the engine's lubricating oils. As a result, they emit more smoke, carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, and particulate matter. A single two-stroke engine produces pollution equivalent to that of 30 to 50 four-stroke engines.

The high levels of pollution from two-stroke engines have led to efforts to phase them out and replace them with four-stroke engines. For example, the city council of San Fernando in the Philippines offered interest-free loans for down payments on four-stroke tricycles, resulting in the replacement of 400 two-stroke engines within three years. Similarly, when two-stroke "baby taxis" were phased out in Dhaka, Bangladesh, particulate concentrations dropped by up to 40%, and carbon monoxide and hydrocarbons fell significantly.

Four-stroke engines are water-cooled, while two-stroke engines are air-cooled

Two-stroke engines have been identified as major contributors to air pollution, particularly in developing nations. They burn a mixture of oil and gasoline, releasing smoke, carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, and particulate matter into the atmosphere. The combustion chamber draws in this contaminated mixture, resulting in unburned fuel and oil mixing with the exhaust. A single two-stroke engine can produce pollution equivalent to 30-50 four-stroke engines.

Four-stroke engines, on the other hand, burn pure petrol, making them significantly cleaner. They are also water-cooled, which is a fundamental difference from two-stroke engines. The water-cooling system in four-stroke engines helps transfer heat away from the engine, reducing the temperature and prolonging its lifespan. This cooling system also contributes to the overall efficiency of the engine by maintaining optimal operating temperatures.

In contrast, two-stroke engines are typically air-cooled. While this design contributes to their lightweight and mechanical simplicity, it also has some drawbacks. Air-cooled engines rely on the flow of air to dissipate heat, which can be less efficient than water-cooling in maintaining optimal temperatures. Additionally, the high combustion temperatures of small, air-cooled two-stroke engines can lead to the production of NOx emissions, further contributing to air pollution.

The preference for air-cooled two-stroke engines stems from their lightweight, simplicity, and high power-to-weight ratio. They are well-suited for lightweight and portable applications such as chainsaws and motorcycles. However, the lack of water-cooling can result in higher operating temperatures, impacting performance and emissions over time.

While four-stroke engines are generally considered more environmentally friendly due to their lower emissions, they also have their own set of advantages and disadvantages. They are often larger and more complex than two-stroke engines, which can make them heavier and more challenging to maintain. However, their water-cooling system and pure petrol combustion contribute to their reduced environmental impact.

In summary, the water-cooled four-stroke engines offer improved temperature management and lower emissions compared to their air-cooled, two-stroke counterparts. This distinction is a critical factor in the ongoing efforts to reduce air pollution, particularly in highly populated urban areas.

Two-stroke engines are cheaper and easier to maintain, but they produce high levels of pollution

Two-stroke engines are a major source of air pollution. They burn a mixture of oil and gasoline, which results in the release of smoke, carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, and particulate matter. In fact, a single two-stroke engine can produce the same amount of pollution as 30 to 50 four-stroke engines. This has led to a push for cleaner technologies and the development of new, more efficient two-stroke engine designs.

Two-stroke engines are commonly found in smaller vehicles such as motorcycles, mopeds, motor scooters, and tuk-tuks, as well as handheld outdoor power tools like leaf blowers and chainsaws. Their high power-to-weight ratio and ability to be used in any orientation make them popular for these applications. They are also cheaper to manufacture and easier to maintain due to their mechanical simplicity and lightweight design.

The problem of two-stroke engine pollution is particularly acute in developing countries. In cities across Asia, two-stroke engines have been identified as a significant contributor to poor air quality and respiratory illnesses. For example, in Bangkok, two-wheelers were found to contribute up to 47% of particulates, and in Delhi, two- and three-wheelers were responsible for high levels of unburned hydrocarbon emissions and carbon monoxide.

To address this issue, some cities have implemented policies to phase out two-stroke vehicles. For instance, San Fernando City in the Philippines offered interest-free loans for down payments on four-stroke models, resulting in the replacement of 400 two-stroke tricycles within three years. However, the higher cost of four-stroke vehicles can be a barrier for many, and the sold two-stroke vehicles are often reused elsewhere, merely transferring the pollution.

A more affordable solution is to retrofit existing two-stroke engines with conversion kits that significantly reduce smoke and hydrocarbon emissions. Envirofit, a startup co-founded by Bryan Willson of Colorado State University, offers such a kit. By cutting fuel loss and reducing oil use, these modified engines can also provide financial savings for users, making them a more attractive option.

Frequently asked questions