Transportation Pollution: What's The Worst Offender?

Transport is a significant contributor to air pollution, with emissions from vehicles burning fossil fuels such as gasoline and diesel releasing carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. The transport sector is the fastest-growing contributor to climate emissions, and road transport is the largest contributor within this sector. Cars, trucks, ships, and airplanes are major polluters, emitting nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide, and particulate matter, which have harmful effects on both the environment and human health. While electric cars are becoming an increasingly popular solution, other modes of transport such as trains, bicycles, and walking are also being prioritized to reduce pollution and encourage active lifestyles.

Cruise ships

The large size of cruise ships also poses physical threats to coral reefs and other underwater ecosystems. Anchors can cause irreparable damage to coral reefs, and in some cases, cruise companies destroy coral to build docks and channels to access ports.

The economic benefits of the cruise industry are significant, with cruise tourism supporting jobs and generating revenue for local economies. However, the environmental and health impacts of cruise ships are severe and widespread. Port cities in Europe, such as Genoa, Italy, and Barcelona, Spain, are considering bans and restrictions on cruise ships due to growing concerns about their health and environmental consequences.

Domestic flights

The impact of aviation on global warming has been estimated through a measure called "radiative forcing", which calculates the difference between incoming energy and the energy radiated back into space. Aviation has accounted for approximately 3.5% of effective radiative forcing to date. This figure is expected to grow, with passenger numbers projected to double in the next 20 years.

Aircraft emit CO2 and other gases and pollutants that have a warming effect on the atmosphere. These include water vapour, soot, sulfur aerosols, and water contrails, which trap additional heat at flight altitude. The use of jet fuels with high aromatics and naphthalene concentrations increases soot formation, leading to persistent contrail cirrus.

Reducing corporate travel is one way to cut aviation emissions. By halving corporate travel to pre-COVID levels, Europe could reduce CO2 emissions by up to 32.6 MtCO2 by 2030, which is the equivalent of taking 16 million polluting cars off the road.

From 2025, the EU will begin monitoring non-CO2 emissions on all flights departing the bloc. This is a step towards tackling aviation's climate impact, and solutions such as e-fuels and clean fuels have the potential to significantly reduce emissions in the sector.

Combustion-powered cars

Transportation is a significant contributor to air pollution, and combustion-powered cars are a major part of the problem. Cars, trucks, buses, and other vehicles with internal combustion engines burning fossil fuels emit various pollutants that have detrimental effects on both human health and the environment. These vehicles release primary pollutants directly into the atmosphere and create secondary pollution through chemical reactions with atmospheric elements.

One of the most common combustion-powered car pollutants is carbon monoxide (CO), a colorless and odorless gas. It prevents oxygen uptake in the body, leading to dizziness, headaches, fatigue, and reduced cognitive and physical abilities. Another harmful pollutant is nitrogen oxide (NOx), which contributes to smog formation, increases respiratory infections, and has been linked to asthma and heart attacks. Nitrogen dioxide (NO2), a specific type of NOx, causes over 50,000 premature deaths annually in Europe alone.

Additionally, combustion engines emit particulate matter (PM), tiny solid particles, and liquid droplets that infiltrate the airways and lungs. These particles have been associated with increased respiratory issues, decreased lung function, alterations in defense systems, and premature mortality. They also contribute to cardiovascular diseases, including heart attacks and strokes, by entering the bloodstream and causing inflammation and arterial damage.

The combustion process in vehicles also releases hydrocarbons, which can form larger particles in the atmosphere when they come into contact with airborne dust. While diesel engines produce lower emissions of carbon monoxide, they still emit measurable amounts. Furthermore, the presence of nitrogen in the air during the combustion process can lead to the formation of reddish-brown nitrogen oxide gases that irritate the lungs and eyes.

To address the pollution caused by combustion-powered cars, several solutions are being explored. These include transitioning to electric vehicles (EVs), which produce significantly less carbon dioxide and other pollutant emissions. In fact, switching from internal combustion engines to battery-powered vehicles instantly eliminates toxic tailpipe pollution, including NOx, CO, and hydrocarbons. Additionally, electric cars utilize regenerative braking, reducing particle emissions by restoring braking energy back to the car's battery. However, it is important to note that the benefits of electric vehicles depend on the energy sources used to recharge them, which may still be fossil-fuel-based in certain countries.

Electric cars

Transport is a significant contributor to air pollution, with road transport responsible for a large share of particulate matter emissions, particularly from diesel traffic. The transport sector is the fastest-growing contributor to climate emissions due to rapid motorization and energy use. Cars, trucks, ships, and airplanes are major polluters, emitting nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, and carbon monoxide, which can lead to respiratory issues and cardiovascular diseases.

Electric vehicles (EVs) have been proposed as a solution to reduce transport-related pollution. EVs have zero tailpipe emissions, which means they do not emit pollutants directly from their exhaust pipes. However, EVs are typically heavier than gasoline cars, which can cause increased wear on brakes and tire treads, releasing toxic particles into the atmosphere.

The environmental impact of EVs depends on the energy sources used to generate the electricity they consume. In areas with low-polluting energy sources, such as wind or solar power, EVs have a significant life cycle emissions advantage over conventional gasoline or diesel vehicles. However, in regions relying heavily on fossil fuels for electricity generation, the benefits of EVs may be diminished, as the power generation process for charging EVs can also create carbon pollution.

Overall, research suggests that EVs typically have lower greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline cars over their lifetime. This is because, despite the higher emissions associated with manufacturing EV batteries, the absence of tailpipe emissions during operation results in lower total GHG emissions for EVs. Additionally, as the world transitions to more renewable energy sources, the total GHG emissions associated with EVs are expected to decrease further.

Trains

Transport is a significant contributor to air pollution, with road transport responsible for a large share of particulate matter emissions, particularly from diesel traffic. The transport sector is the fastest-growing contributor to climate emissions, with land transport, including cars, being the main driver of this growth.

Despite this, there are still concerns about the air quality inside train stations, especially those that are enclosed and host diesel trains. A study found that peak-time emissions from diesel trains at London's Paddington Station exceeded European recommendations, with levels of nitrogen dioxide higher than those on a nearby busy road. This poses a risk to passengers and workers as exhaust emissions reduce air quality.

While electrification of train tracks and networks is ongoing in some regions, such as Europe and the UK, it is a slow process, and approximately half of the train lines in Europe remain non-electrified. This highlights the need for continued efforts to reduce emissions from diesel trains and improve air quality, especially in enclosed train stations.

Overall, while trains, especially those powered by diesel, contribute to air pollution, they are still a more environmentally friendly mode of transport compared to cars, trucks, and planes when considering emissions per passenger and distance travelled.

Frequently asked questions