Air Pollution: Indoor Vs Outdoor

Indoor and outdoor air pollution are closely linked, and both can have negative health effects. While outdoor air pollution is often more visible, research suggests that levels of indoor air pollutants are often 2 to 5 times higher than outdoor levels. This is due to a variety of factors, including the type and running conditions of indoor pollution sources, ventilation, and human activities. Older, less energy-efficient homes are more susceptible to outdoor pollutant infiltration, while newer, airtight homes can have quicker pollutant buildup. Climate change and meteorological conditions also play a role in indoor air quality, with temperature, humidity, and solar irradiation increasing pollutant concentrations. Therefore, understanding the relationship between indoor and outdoor air quality is crucial for mitigating the effects of pollutants on human health.

Indoor air pollution is often 2-5 times higher than outdoor levels

While it is easy to assume that outdoor air quality is worse than that of indoor air, the opposite is true. According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), indoor air pollution levels are often 2 to 5 times higher than outdoor levels, and in some cases, these levels can exceed 100 times that of outdoor levels. This is a pressing issue, considering that people in the US spend approximately 90% of their time indoors.

The difference in air quality between indoor and outdoor spaces is influenced by several factors, including the air exchange rate, outdoor climate, weather conditions, and occupant behaviour. For instance, during hot summer months, indoor ozone levels tend to be higher, which can trigger asthma symptoms and lead to respiratory problems. Similarly, weather conditions influence whether occupants of a building open windows or use air conditioners, which can affect indoor air quality.

The quality of indoor air is also impacted by outdoor air pollution, which can enter buildings through open doors, windows, ventilation systems, and even tiny cracks in structures. Outdoor ground-level ozone and other gases can enter homes through ventilation processes and react with chemicals in building materials, creating harmful byproducts. Older, less energy-efficient homes are more susceptible to outdoor pollutant infiltration due to their lack of airtightness.

However, newer, airtight homes can also have issues with indoor air quality. Because of the low exchange rate between indoor and outdoor air in these homes, pollutants that enter can build up more quickly. Additionally, indoor pollutants such as ozone and nitrogen dioxide from vehicle exhaust can react with off-gassing from building materials and household chemicals, creating even more toxic compounds like formaldehyde.

To improve indoor air quality, it is recommended to monitor indoor air quality using live data to identify when the air is becoming too polluted. Adequate ventilation is also crucial, especially when using chemicals for crafts, decorating, or cleaning. Regularly changing air filters, installing and checking radon detectors, and avoiding smoking indoors are other effective ways to enhance indoor air quality.

Outdoor air pollution infiltrates indoor spaces

Outdoor air pollution can infiltrate indoor spaces, affecting indoor air quality. Research suggests that outdoor air pollution contributes anywhere from 10 to 100 per cent of indoor air pollution. Outdoor ground-level ozone and other gases can enter buildings through ventilation processes and even react with chemicals in building materials, creating harmful byproducts.

The rate of exchange between indoor and outdoor air varies depending on the building. Older, less energy-efficient homes are more susceptible to leaks of outdoor pollutants due to damaged seals and weather stripping around doors and windows. However, newer, airtight homes can also have issues as pollutants that enter can build up more quickly due to the low exchange rate.

Meteorological conditions such as temperature, humidity, and solar irradiation also influence the concentration of indoor pollutants. For example, a study found that during hot summer months, high levels of indoor ozone from outdoor sources were linked to airway obstruction and heightened inflammation.

Additionally, human behaviour and activities can introduce outdoor pollutants indoors. For instance, gas cooking, even with stove venting, can result in high levels of indoor NO2. Furthermore, the use of chemicals for crafts, decorating, or cleaning can impact indoor air quality.

The infiltration of outdoor air pollution into indoor spaces is a critical concern as people spend a significant amount of time indoors. The COVID-19 pandemic has likely increased this behaviour, making it even more important to address the issue of outdoor air pollution infiltrating indoor spaces.

Older homes are more susceptible to outdoor pollution leaks

While outdoor air pollution poses a significant risk to human health worldwide, indoor air pollution is often more harmful. Research indicates that people spend approximately 90% of their time indoors, increasing the health risks associated with indoor air pollution.

Furthermore, cracks, openings, and gaps in walls, doors, and window sealants provide entry points for outdoor pollutants in older homes. A study in 2015 highlighted that leaky homes, often characteristic of older residences, resulted in the highest human exposure levels to harmful particulate matter and ultra-fine particles. Even the use of air filtration systems in these older homes may not be sufficient to mitigate the indoor air pollution.

Additionally, the interaction between indoor and outdoor pollutants is influenced by both individual behaviour and the surrounding environment. Certain habits and activities within the home can contribute to indoor air pollution, exacerbating the impact of outdoor pollution leaks in older homes. For example, using chemicals for crafts, decorating, or cleaning without proper ventilation can deteriorate indoor air quality.

Moreover, outdoor ground-level ozone and other gases can infiltrate older homes through ventilation processes and react with chemicals in building materials, furnishings, and household items, creating harmful byproducts. This can lead to respiratory issues, especially for individuals with asthma and allergies. Therefore, older homes, due to their structural characteristics and reduced airtightness, are more susceptible to outdoor pollution leaks, posing potential health risks to their occupants.

Behaviour and environment influence indoor-outdoor pollution interaction

Secondly, environmental factors, such as temperature, humidity, and solar irradiation, have a significant influence on the variation in pollutant concentrations between indoor and outdoor spaces. Higher levels of these environmental factors contribute to a more concentrated I/O ratio, indicating a stronger correlation between indoor and outdoor pollution levels. Additionally, the physical characteristics of the building, such as airtightness and ventilation capability, play a role in mitigating the exchange of indoor and outdoor air.

Furthermore, human behaviour in response to climate change can also impact indoor air quality. For example, as people spend more time indoors due to extreme outdoor temperatures or weather conditions, the concentration of indoor pollutants can increase, especially in older, less energy-efficient homes that are more susceptible to leaks of outdoor pollutants. In contrast, newer, airtight homes can have the downside of lower indoor-outdoor air exchange rates, leading to a quicker buildup of pollutants.

Outdoor physical activity also influences environmental behaviours. Children who engage in physical activity in outdoor parks are more likely to be influenced by subjective norms, while those who primarily participate in indoor activities are influenced by descriptive norms. Encouraging outdoor physical activity can foster a connection with nature and promote environmentally friendly behaviours, as children develop a consciousness to minimise their negative impact on the environment.

Lastly, the type and running conditions of indoor pollution sources, as well as indoor activities, contribute to the interaction between indoor and outdoor pollution. For example, indoor activities that involve the use of chemicals or smoking can significantly impact indoor air quality, which, in turn, affects the exchange of indoor and outdoor pollutants. Understanding these behavioural and environmental factors is crucial for developing strategies to minimise the impact of outdoor air pollution on indoor spaces and improve overall air quality.

Cooking methods affect indoor air quality

The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that 2.1 billion people worldwide use cooking methods that may be detrimental to their health. Indoor air pollution is linked to a range of illnesses, including asthma, pneumonia, lung cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, cardiovascular disease, and stroke.

Cooking methods can significantly impact indoor air quality. Frying, deep-frying, grilling, and browning meat release high amounts of particulate matter (PM) and other harmful pollutants. This is due to the high temperatures involved and the use of oil or fat, which can create polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, causing eye and lung irritation. Meat dishes, especially those with high-fat content, emit more particles than vegetables.

Ovens and stoves are significant sources of airborne pollutants. Gas-powered appliances can produce carbon monoxide, formaldehyde, and nitrogen dioxide, while electric appliances release fine particles. Self-cleaning ovens, whether electric or gas-powered, can generate high levels of pollutants when burning away food waste. Baking or roasting at low heat for extended periods may not seem to require ventilation, but these methods create large amounts of pollutants over time and need proper ventilation to minimize health risks.

The type of cooking appliance and fuel used also affect indoor air quality. Stovetops powered by natural gas or propane can emit carbon monoxide, formaldehyde, and nitrogen dioxide, a respiratory irritant. Nitrogen oxide (NOx) is prevalent in homes using gas, and exposure to high levels can lead to bronchitis, asthma symptoms, and respiratory illnesses.

To maintain good indoor air quality while cooking, proper ventilation is crucial. Kitchen exhaust fans or opening windows can help remove pollutants. Installing a whole-house ventilation system can further improve indoor air quality. Additionally, specific cooking methods, such as boiling or steaming, are safer options that release fewer particles into the air.

Frequently asked questions