Air Pollution Rule: Cross-State Impact

The Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR) is a rule by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that requires member states to reduce power plant emissions that contribute to air pollution in other states. Cross-state air pollution, also known as interstate or transported air pollution, occurs when emissions from one location are blown by the wind to another area. The CSAPR provides a 4-step process to address this issue and help states attain clean air standards. The EPA sets emission budgets and allows sources to determine their own compliance paths, with the goal of reducing sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxide emissions that significantly affect air quality in downwind states.

Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR)

The rule requires 28 states to reduce power plant emissions

The Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR) is a rule by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that requires member states to reduce power plant emissions that contribute to ozone and/or fine particle pollution in other states. The rule aims to protect the health of Americans by helping states attain clean air standards.

CSAPR provides a 4-step process to address cross-state air pollution:

• Identify downwind areas that are expected to have problems attaining or maintaining clean air standards.
• Determine which upwind states contribute to these problems in amounts sufficient to link them to the downwind air quality issues.
• Identify upwind emissions that significantly contribute to the problem and quantify appropriate emission reductions, assigning responsibility to the linked upwind states.
• Reduce the identified upwind emissions via permanent and enforceable requirements, such as regional allowance trading programs.

The rule sets a pollution limit (emission budget) for each state covered by CSAPR, and authorizations to emit pollution, known as allowances, are allocated to affected sources based on these state emissions budgets. The CSAPR requires 23 states to reduce their annual emissions of sulfur dioxide (SO2) and nitrogen oxides (NOx) to help downwind states attain the 24-hour National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS). Additionally, 25 states are required to reduce ozone season nitrogen oxide emissions to help downwind states reach the 8-hour NAAQS. These states are divided into two groups, with Group 1 needing to make additional emissions reductions by 2014.

The EPA has also announced new rules covering mercury, wastewater, and coal ash disposal at power plants. These rules aim to reduce pollutants discharged through wastewater from coal-fired power plants and ensure the safe management of toxic coal ash. The EPA estimates that the rule under Clean Air Act Section 111 will significantly reduce carbon emissions, with positive health and climate benefits.

It helps states meet federal Clean Air Act obligations

The Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR) is a rule by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that requires member states to reduce power plant emissions that contribute to ozone and/or fine particle pollution in other states. The rule is intended to help states meet federal Clean Air Act (FCAA) obligations regarding the interstate transport of air pollution.

CSAPR provides a 4-step process to address cross-state air pollution of certain pollutants. Firstly, it involves identifying downwind locations that are expected to have problems attaining or maintaining clean air standards (i.e., NAAQS). This is followed by determining which upwind states significantly contribute to these identified problems. The third step is to identify upwind emissions that interfere with the maintenance of a standard by quantifying appropriate upwind emission reductions and assigning responsibility among linked states. Finally, the identified upwind emissions are reduced via permanent and enforceable requirements, such as regional allowance trading programs.

The EPA sets a pollution limit (emission budget) for each state covered by CSAPR. Authorizations to emit pollution, known as allowances, are allocated to affected sources based on these state emissions budgets. The rule provides flexibility to these sources, allowing them to determine their own compliance path, which may include adding or operating control technologies, upgrading or improving controls, switching fuels, and using allowances. Sources can buy, sell, and bank (save) allowances, as long as they hold enough to account for their emissions by the end of the compliance period.

CSAPR includes provisions to ensure that each state will meet its pollution control obligations and eliminate SO2 and NOX emissions that impact downwind air quality. The EPA has also issued memos and updates, such as the 2015 ozone NAAQS memo, to address interstate transport obligations and ensure timely progress using the CSAPR framework.

A cap and trade system is used to reduce pollutants

The Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR) is a rule by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that requires member states to reduce power plant emissions that contribute to air pollution in other states. The EPA sets a pollution limit (emission budget) for each of the states covered by CSAPR.

A cap-and-trade system is a market-based approach that puts a limit on pollution and creates a market for allowances. The government sets a cap on emissions and issues emission allowances that emitters must hold for every ton of greenhouse gas they emit. These allowances can be bought and sold, creating an exchange value for emissions. Companies that reduce their emissions faster can sell their allowances to other companies, providing a financial incentive to cut emissions. This system has been shown to effectively reduce emissions and pollution, as seen in California, which met its goal of reducing greenhouse gas emissions to 1990 levels by 2016 through its cap-and-trade program.

The CSAPR addresses cross-state air pollution by identifying downwind areas that struggle to maintain clean air standards due to upwind emissions. It then determines which upwind states significantly contribute to these issues and assigns responsibility for reducing emissions. The flexibility of the CSAPR allows states to choose their own compliance path, including adding control technologies or switching fuels. Sources can also buy, sell, or bank allowances as long as they hold enough to account for their emissions by the end of the compliance period.

The cap-and-trade system has benefits for taxpayers as well. The sale of emission credits to businesses generates income for the government, supplementing taxpayer resources. Additionally, consumers have more choices as they can choose to support companies that comply with emission reduction efforts. However, critics argue that cap and trade could lead to an overproduction of pollutants up to the maximum levels set by the government, slowing the transition to cleaner energy. The system can also increase the cost of energy, impacting the economy negatively.

Overall, the cap-and-trade system is a powerful tool for reducing pollutants, as demonstrated by its successful implementation in various regions, including California and several countries in Europe and Asia. By creating a market for emissions and providing incentives for companies to invest in cleaner technologies, the system drives innovation and accelerates progress towards ambitious climate goals.

The EPA sets a pollution limit for each state

The Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR) is a rule by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that requires member states to reduce power plant emissions that contribute to ozone and fine particle pollution in other states. The EPA sets a pollution limit (emission budget) for each of the states covered by CSAPR.

The CSAPR provides a 4-step process to address cross-state air pollution of certain pollutants. The first step is to identify downwind receptors that are expected to have problems attaining or maintaining clean air standards (i.e. NAAQS). This involves determining which locations will be unable to attain or maintain the National Ambient Air Quality Standards due to the transport of pollutants from upwind sources.

The second step is to determine which upwind states are contributing to these identified problems in amounts sufficient to "link" them to the downwind air quality issues. This involves quantifying the upwind state contributions to downwind air quality problems and identifying the specific upwind emissions that are responsible.

The third step is to identify the necessary upwind emissions reductions and assign responsibility among the linked states. This step includes determining the appropriate emission reduction targets for each upwind state and ensuring that the reductions will address the downwind air quality issues.

The fourth and final step is to implement permanent and enforceable requirements to reduce the identified upwind emissions. This may include regional allowance trading programs, federal implementation plans, and other measures to ensure that the upwind states meet their emission reduction obligations.

The EPA's modeling analyses project that by implementing the CSAPR, there will be significant improvements in downwind air quality and a positive impact on the health of millions of Americans. The EPA is committed to working with the states to address cross-state air pollution and help them achieve clean air standards.

The EPA's modelling analysis projects that by 2023, there will be no remaining nonattainment or maintenance areas

The Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR) is a rule by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that requires member states to reduce power plant emissions that contribute to ozone and/or fine particle pollution in other states. The EPA has set pollution limits (emission budgets) for each state covered by the CSAPR, and sources of pollution can buy, sell, and bank (save) their allowances as long as they hold enough allowances to account for their emissions by the end of the compliance period.

The CSAPR provides a 4-step process to address cross-state air pollution:

• Identify downwind areas that are expected to have problems attaining or maintaining clean air standards (NAAQS).
• Determine which upwind states significantly contribute to these problems.
• Identify upwind emissions that significantly contribute to nonattainment or interfere with the maintenance of a standard.
• Reduce the identified upwind emissions via permanent and enforceable requirements.

The EPA has also released a Good Neighbor Federal Implementation Plan for 2023, which addresses 23 states' compliance with the 2015 Ozone NAAQS of 70 ppb for the primary and secondary 8-hour standards. This plan ensures that states eliminate significant contributions to or interference with the maintenance of the NAAQS in other states.

Frequently asked questions