Fishy Dangers: Toxic Meals And Health Risks

Fish is a nutritious food, packed with protein, vitamins, minerals, and omega-3 fatty acids, which are great for your heart, brain, and overall health. However, eating contaminated fish can lead to several diseases and health issues. Fish can be contaminated by toxins, such as ciguatera, scombroid, and tetrodotoxin, or by pollutants, such as mercury, PCBs, and dioxins, which can be passed on to humans through consumption. These contaminants can cause a range of health issues, from food poisoning to nervous system damage, birth defects, and an increased risk of cancer. While cooking does not always destroy toxins, there are ways to reduce the risk of exposure, such as choosing fish that are low in mercury and other contaminants and following safe eating guidelines.

Ciguatera fish poisoning

The symptoms of ciguatera poisoning typically appear between a few minutes and 6 hours after consuming the toxic fish, but in some cases, they may not manifest for up to 30 hours. These symptoms include a range of gastrointestinal, neurological, and cardiovascular abnormalities, such as nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea, muscle pains, dizziness, and sensations of temperature reversal. In more severe cases, individuals may experience irregular heart rhythms and low blood pressure. While the symptoms usually resolve within a few days, they can persist for several weeks or even months, and in rare cases, they may last for several years.

Treatment for ciguatera poisoning focuses on relieving symptoms and managing any complications. Cold ice baths have been recommended for pain and itching, which are often the longest-lasting symptoms. Mannitol has also been used to treat acute cases of ciguatera poisoning, but its effectiveness is debated. There is currently no cure for ciguatera poisoning, and prevention relies primarily on avoiding the consumption of tropical reef fish. Local knowledge about safe fishing areas and species is essential for minimizing the risk of ciguatera poisoning.

To reduce the risk of ciguatera fish poisoning, it is important to be cautious when consuming reef fish, especially in tropical and subtropical regions. The CDC recommends avoiding moray eel and barracuda altogether and exercising caution with sea bass and other tropical reef and warm-water fish, as they may contain toxins unpredictably. Additionally, it is advised to refrain from consuming the liver, intestines, eggs, and head of fish, as these parts tend to have higher toxin concentrations.

Scombroid poisoning

Symptoms of scombroid poisoning typically develop within minutes to an hour of consuming the contaminated fish and often resemble an allergic reaction. These symptoms include a rash, particularly on the torso or body, reddening or flushing of the face, neck, arms, and upper body, sweating, headache, vomiting, and diarrhoea. More severe symptoms include a burning sensation or swelling of the mouth, difficulty swallowing, stomach pain, and heart palpitations. Symptoms usually disappear within 3 to 36 hours, and people typically recover within 12 to 48 hours, even without treatment. However, in rare cases, scombroid poisoning can be fatal.

To prevent scombroid poisoning, it is crucial to ensure that fish is properly stored and refrigerated. If symptoms of poisoning occur, rapid-acting antihistamines are commonly used for treatment, along with supportive care tailored to the specific symptoms.

Mercury poisoning

Fish is generally considered a healthy food choice. However, some fish contain high levels of mercury, which can be toxic to humans, particularly developing foetuses. Elemental mercury is present in rocks and soil and is found naturally in lakes and streams. Human activity, such as emissions from industrial processes and the burning of garbage, fossil fuels, and pulp and paper, can increase mercury levels in the environment. Microorganisms in lake and stream sediments convert elemental mercury to organic methylmercury, which is absorbed and retained by the fish. Larger predatory fish that are higher up the food chain tend to accumulate higher levels of mercury.

Methylmercury is a potent neurotoxin, and when ingested by humans, it can cause a range of abnormal central nervous system-related symptoms. These symptoms can include paresthesia (a tingling or prickling sensation), ataxia (lack of muscle control), hearing impairment, and progressive constriction of the visual fields. The effects of methylmercury poisoning can be severe and long-lasting, even leading to constriction in the visual fields. In some cases, symptoms may not appear for months after exposure.

The risk of mercury poisoning from fish consumption is well-documented, particularly in certain species. For example, a case study reported a 48-year-old male deep-sea fisherman who developed chronic mercury poisoning due to excessive consumption of tuna while working on a pelagic fishing vessel. The patient consumed tuna for at least two meals per day, every day, resulting in elevated blood mercury levels. After discontinuing tuna consumption, his symptoms improved, and his blood mercury levels decreased.

It is important to note that cooking, smoking, or freezing fish does not eliminate mercury or prevent mercury poisoning. Therefore, it is recommended to limit the consumption of fish known to contain high levels of mercury, such as tuna, and be aware of the potential risks associated with consuming contaminated fish.

In addition to mercury poisoning, there are other types of fish poisoning that can occur, such as ciguatera poisoning, which is caused by eating fish contaminated with toxins produced by tiny algae found around coral reefs. Scombroid poisoning, caused by improper fish storage and handling, is also common. These types of poisoning can lead to a range of symptoms, including allergic reactions, and it is important to seek medical care if any negative health effects are experienced after consuming fish.

PCBs poisoning

Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) are long-lasting contaminants that can build up in the body over time. PCBs have good insulating and flame retardant properties and were widely used as coolants and lubricators in electrical equipment. The level of PCBs in fish varies with region and type of fish, with bottom-feeding fish (such as striped bass and bluefish) and larger predator fish (such as bass and walleye) caught in contaminated waters containing higher levels of PCBs. Farmed salmon that are fed ground-up fish have also been found to have higher levels of PCBs compared to wild-caught salmon.

PCBs are one of the contaminants responsible for health advisories within West Virginia, along with methyl mercury, selenium, and dioxin. It can take up to six years or more for the body to eliminate PCBs, which is significantly longer than the one year it takes to get rid of mercury.

The accumulation of PCBs in the body over time can lead to health problems, including small, hard-to-detect changes, birth defects, and mental and physical retardation in newborns. Women who eat highly contaminated fish for many years before becoming pregnant may have children who are slower to develop and learn. Therefore, it is recommended that women who plan to become pregnant follow the fish consumption advice given to pregnant and nursing women for several years before conception.

To reduce exposure to PCBs, it is suggested to limit the intake of fish containing high levels of PCBs, such as salmon and bluefish. When consuming fatty fish, it is recommended to trim away fatty areas (including the belly, top back, and dark meat along the sides), remove the skin before cooking, and allow the fat to drain off by grilling, baking, or broiling the fish.

It is important to note that cooking, smoking, or freezing fish does not eliminate PCBs or prevent scombroid poisoning, which is caused by eating fish that has not been properly refrigerated after being caught.

Dioxins poisoning

Dioxins are chemical compounds that are hazardous to human health. They are found throughout the world in the environment and accumulate in the food chain, mainly in the fatty tissue of animals. More than 90% of human exposure to dioxins is through the food supply, with contaminated meat, dairy products, fish, and shellfish being the primary sources.

Dioxins are formed through human and natural processes, including manufacturing, volcanic activity, and backyard burning. While manufacturers in the United States no longer produce them, they are still present in the environment and can contaminate the food chain. Dioxins are highly toxic and can have serious health consequences, including an increased risk of cancer and developmental and reproductive problems. They can also damage the immune system and interfere with hormones.

In the context of fish, dioxins can accumulate in their fatty tissue, with higher concentrations found in certain species. Freshwater fish, for example, have been found to contain higher levels of dioxins compared to other types of fish. Additionally, fish that occupy contaminated environments, such as polluted lakes or rivers, are more likely to have higher levels of dioxin exposure.

To prevent or reduce human exposure to dioxins, strict control of industrial processes is necessary to reduce the formation and release of these toxic compounds into the environment. Proper incineration of contaminated material, including PCB-based waste oils, is one method to achieve this. The incineration process requires extremely high temperatures, typically exceeding 850 °C, to ensure the complete destruction of hazardous substances.

It is important to note that dioxin poisoning from fish consumption is a serious health concern, and efforts should be made to minimize exposure. While trimming fat from meat and consuming a varied diet may help reduce the risk, the primary responsibility lies with feed and food producers to ensure safe raw materials and processes during production. Additionally, national governments play a crucial role in monitoring the safety of the food supply and taking necessary actions to protect public health.

Frequently asked questions