Utah's Air Pollution: Causes And Concerns

Utah's air quality is often considered some of the worst in the United States. The state's air pollution is caused by a combination of natural phenomena and human activity. The mountainous topography, cold winters, and inversions—where temperatures increase with altitude—cause pollutants to build up near the surface. This, combined with emissions from vehicles, wood-burning, industry, and agriculture, leads to poor air quality. Additionally, Utah is one of the most fire-prone states, and wildfire smoke can adversely affect air quality and health.

Vehicle emissions

Utah's mountainous terrain and cold winters also contribute to inversions, where pollutants build up near the surface. When coupled with emissions from gasoline and diesel vehicles, particularly older models, this leads to unnatural accumulations of hazardous pollutants. Heavy-duty diesel vehicles, for example, make up only 7.5% of vehicle miles traveled but produce over 30% of mobile source pollution. This includes harmful pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM2.5 and PM10).

PM2.5, microscopic particles with diameters of less than 2.5 micrometers, is the main component of Utah's wintertime air pollution. It is smaller than pollen and most bacteria and can cause or worsen respiratory issues, decrease lung function, and lead to cardiovascular issues. PM10, larger particles such as dust and coal particles, can also be stirred up by vehicles on roads and contribute to air pollution. Exposure to PM10 can cause coughing, wheezing, and even asthma attacks.

To address this issue, Utah has implemented various measures, such as offering incentives for clean fuel vehicles and advocating for sustainable and equitable transportation alternatives. However, there have also been conflicting policies, such as imposing additional registration fees on clean fuel vehicles. Overall, improving transportation systems and reducing vehicle emissions are crucial for curbing climate change and improving air quality in Utah.

Industrial emissions

The increase in oil and gas production in the Uinta Basin has led to higher precursor gas emissions, causing wintertime ozone concentrations to exceed EPA standards. Additionally, Utah's unique geography, particularly in the Wasatch Front, contributes to temperature inversions where warm air traps cold air, leading to the build-up of particulate pollution. This phenomenon is more common during winter and significantly impacts Salt Lake City, where pollution levels have reached the "unhealthy category."

Furthermore, industrial sources are responsible for the emission of larger particles such as PM10, which includes dust and coal particles. PM10 is generated through processes like crushing or grinding operations, wind-blown dust, and combustion in industrial sources. Exposure to PM10 can have severe health consequences, including coughing, wheezing, asthma attacks, and the aggravation of lung and heart conditions.

To address these issues, Utah's Division of Air Quality actively monitors air pollution and works to strengthen air quality standards. Additionally, organizations like HEAL Utah advocate for cleaner air, encouraging sustainable transportation options and policies that prioritize public health. Despite these efforts, air quality in Utah remains a challenge, with Salt Lake City experiencing more unhealthy air pollution days in recent years.

Wood fires

The emissions from wood-burning stoves and fireplaces are a significant source of air pollution. A single fireplace can emit as much particle pollution as 90 sport-utility vehicles, and the pollution from a traditional wood-burning stove is equivalent to the emissions of 3,000 natural gas furnaces. Even EPA-certified stoves can emit as much pollution as 60 gas furnaces. Therefore, it is essential for residents to use these appliances correctly and follow regulations to reduce their impact on air quality.

Wood smoke contains a complex mixture of compounds, including carbon dioxide, water vapour, carbon monoxide, particulate matter (PM10 and PM2.5), hydrocarbons, and nitrogen oxides. Carbon monoxide, formed when wood is not completely burned, can build up to dangerous levels in homes with poorly vented or maintained wood-burning appliances. Exposure to high levels of carbon monoxide can be fatal, and even lower levels can have adverse effects on pregnant women and children.

While some studies have shown limited associations between wood smoke and health problems, the majority of evidence indicates that wood smoke can be hazardous to human health. The particles from wood smoke cause similar health issues to other types of particulate matter, and there is no reason to treat it separately from other sources of pollution. Overall, wood fires significantly contribute to air pollution in Utah, and residents must take steps to reduce their impact on air quality and protect their health.

Inversions

Utah's mountainous terrain and cold winters make inversions a frequent occurrence. When inversions are coupled with community emissions from gasoline and diesel vehicles, wood fires, industry, and agriculture, they can lead to an unnatural accumulation of hazardous pollutants, especially PM2.5. PM2.5 refers to microscopic particles or particulate matter with a diameter of less than 2.5 micrometers, smaller than pollen and most bacteria. These fine particles can penetrate deep into the lungs, causing or worsening respiratory issues, and can even enter the bloodstream, leading to cardiovascular issues and potentially crossing the blood-brain barrier, causing degenerative brain diseases.

During a typical winter, Salt Lake City experiences about six multi-day inversions, resulting in approximately 18 days of pollution above the National Ambient Air Quality Standards. The build-up of pollution during inversions can occur even when the air is clear, and it affects the health of Utah's residents. For instance, about 200 Utahns are hospitalised with severe pneumonia due to particulate pollution each year, and emergency room respiratory-related visits in Salt Lake City increased by 40% during pollution episodes in 2014.

Sources of PM2.5 during inversions can be broken down into three categories: point sources, mobile sources, and area sources. Point sources, such as large stationary industrial or commercial facilities, contribute 13% of a typical inversion. Mobile sources, including vehicles, trains, and aircraft, are non-stationary sources and account for 48% of a typical inversion. Area sources, which are smaller stationary sources like home heating systems, wood-burning fires, and emissions from small businesses, contribute 39% of a typical inversion.

To address the issue of inversions and air pollution in Utah, various measures have been implemented. The Division of Air Quality (DAQ) in Utah actively monitors air pollution, and HEAL Utah collaborates with DAQ to strengthen monitoring efforts and develop solutions. The state has also offered incentives, such as a $1500 credit for clean fuel vehicles in 2015-2016, and advocated for improved transportation systems to reduce emissions and improve air quality.

Wildfires

The smoke produced by wildfires is a complex mixture of gases, fine particles, and water vapour. These fine particles, also known as particulate matter (PM), are the primary health concern from short-term smoke exposure. The particles produced by wildfires are generally smaller than 2.5 micrometres in diameter, which is approximately 1/70th the size of a human hair. These fine particles can lodge deeply in the lungs, leading to respiratory and cardiovascular issues. The health impacts of wildfire smoke exposure can range from burning eyes and a runny nose to more severe respiratory and cardiovascular problems.

The impact of wildfires on air quality can be sudden and last for extended periods, affecting both indoor and outdoor environments. The smoke can travel great distances and become trapped in areas far from the source of the wildfire due to weather patterns. During the summer wildfire season, Utah residents are often advised to take precautions to minimise their exposure to wildfire smoke. This includes staying indoors, keeping windows and doors closed, and using air conditioning to prevent outdoor smoke from entering their homes.

In 2007, Utah experienced its largest wildfire to date, the Milford Flat fire, which destroyed over 363,052 acres in Millard and Beaver Counties. This fire, along with other wildfires that year, led to an increase in unhealthy air quality days, with the Division of Air Quality reporting 40 days of unhealthy air. More recently, in 2017, Utah recorded 1,166 wildfires, burning a total of 249,829 acres. The Brian Head Fire, caused by human activity, destroyed 71,673 acres, while the lightning-caused Onaqui Mountain Complex fire consumed 37,942 acres.

The increase in wildfires across the western United States, including Utah, has had a significant impact on air quality and public health. The complex mixture of pollutants produced by wildfires, including carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, and nitrogen oxides, poses risks to individuals, especially those with pre-existing heart or lung conditions, older adults, pregnant women, and children. It is crucial for residents in areas affected by wildfires to stay informed about air quality conditions and take necessary precautions to protect their health.

Frequently asked questions