Christchurch's Air Pollution: Causes And Concerns

Christchurch, the largest urban area in Canterbury, has had a wintertime air pollution problem for much of the last century. The main sources of air pollution in Christchurch are home heating, industrial and commercial processes, motor vehicles, and natural sources. The burning of wood and coal for home heating, especially during the winter, has been identified as a major contributor to air pollution in the city. Temperature inversions during the cooler months, along with the surrounding hills and valleys, trap pollutants and allow them to build up, exacerbating air quality issues. Other factors include industrial activities, vehicle emissions, and natural sources such as sea salt near the coast.

Temperature inversions

During temperature inversion events, the concentration of particulate matter (PM), specifically PM10 and PM2.5, can reach harmful levels. These fine particles are produced by the combustion of fuels, such as wood or coal burning in residential heating systems, and vehicle emissions. While the former is a more significant contributor to Christchurch's winter air pollution, the latter also plays a role, along with industrial sources.

The impact of temperature inversions on air quality is exacerbated by human activities, particularly the use of wood or coal burners and open fires for heating during the cooler months. The older and less efficient the heating system, the more significant the emission of dangerous fine particles. On cold, still winter nights, these particles can accumulate to form a choking, brown smog.

The health consequences of temperature inversions and the resulting air pollution are significant. Research suggests that ambient air pollution in New Zealand contributes to approximately 970 premature deaths annually among individuals over 30 years of age. Of these, about 400 deaths are attributed to vehicle emissions, highlighting the role of human activities in exacerbating the effects of temperature inversions on air quality.

To address the issues caused by temperature inversions, it is crucial to implement measures such as improving heating systems' efficiency and providing targeted heating and insulation subsidies. Additionally, promoting the use of alternative, cleaner energy sources for residential heating during the cooler months can help mitigate the impact of temperature inversions on air quality in Christchurch.

Vehicle emissions

Traffic sites near busy roads or intersections are monitored for air quality, and data shows that PM concentrations are typically highest during winter evenings when temperatures are coldest and there is little wind to disperse the pollutants. The interaction of certain factors exacerbates the air pollution caused by vehicle emissions and other sources. These factors include the use of solid fuel for domestic home heating, settled anticyclonic conditions in winter resulting in temperature inversions, and local topographical influences causing the convergence of cold air drainage over the central city.

Temperature inversions, where a layer of warm air traps cold air and pollutants near the ground, are more common during the cooler months. This phenomenon, along with the surrounding hills and valleys acting as barriers, contributes to the build-up of pollutants. The Clean Air Act of 1972 was the first substantial legislation to address emissions, and more recent proposals aim to phase out solid fuel burning gradually.

Industrial processes

Christchurch, the largest urban area in Canterbury, has a number of commercial and industrial areas. While the land area is predominantly residential, industrial processes have been a significant contributor to the city's air pollution problem.

The main industrial sources of air pollution in Christchurch are heavy commercial and processing factories. These factories emit harmful pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx) and suspended particulate matter, which includes PM10 and PM2.5. These fine particles are produced during the combustion of fuel and pose significant health risks, especially to vulnerable groups.

One of the key issues with industrial air pollution in Christchurch is the lack of wind during the winter to disperse these pollutants. The still conditions, combined with temperature inversions, trap the pollutants and allow them to build up in the atmosphere. The surrounding hills and valleys act as additional barriers, further trapping the pollutants and preventing their dispersal. As a result, PM concentrations are typically highest during the winter evenings when temperatures are coldest and wind speeds are lowest.

To address the issue of industrial air pollution in Christchurch, local authorities have proposed plans to phase out the use of solid fuel for home heating, as well as implementing the Clean Air Act and the more recent Resource Management Act (1991). However, these efforts have met with public opposition, and the management of air quality continues to be a challenge.

Home heating

In an effort to address this problem, local authorities have attempted to ban the use of solid fuel for home heating. However, these attempts have faced significant public opposition. The Resource Management Act (1991) places the responsibility for overseeing air quality on regional authorities. A proposed Air Plan, which includes a slow phase-out of domestic solid fuel burning, is currently under public debate.

The interaction of several factors contributes to the high pollutant concentrations in Christchurch during winter. The use of solid fuel for domestic home heating, combined with settled anticyclonic conditions and local topographical influences, leads to temperature inversions and increased pollution. The surrounding hills and valleys act as barriers, trapping pollutants and preventing their dispersal.

To mitigate the impact of home heating on air pollution, the Health Impact Assessment (HIA) of the Canterbury Regional Air Plan recommends a carefully phased introduction of home heating changes. This includes targeted heating and insulation subsidies to support residents in transitioning to cleaner energy sources.

It is important to note that while home heating is a significant contributor to air pollution in Christchurch, other sources such as motor vehicles, industrial and commercial processes, and natural sources also play a role. However, addressing the impact of home heating on air quality is a crucial step towards improving the respiratory health of Christchurch residents.

Outdoor burning

One key factor is the use of solid fuel, such as wood, for domestic home heating. The combustion of wood releases fine particles, known as PM10 and PM2.5, which pose significant health risks. These particles can accumulate in the air, especially during the winter evenings when temperatures are coldest and there is little to no wind to disperse them. The surrounding hills and valleys of Christchurch act as natural barriers, trapping the pollutants and allowing them to build up in the atmosphere.

Temperature inversions during the cooler months exacerbate the air quality issues in Christchurch. Clear nights lead to a layer of warm air trapping cold air near the ground, preventing the dispersal of pollutants. This phenomenon is more common in Christchurch due to local topographical influences, which cause the convergence of cold air drainage over the central city.

It is important to note that outdoor burning is just one aspect of Christchurch's air pollution problem. Other sources, such as vehicle emissions, industrial processes, and home heating, also play a significant role in degrading air quality. Addressing these issues requires a comprehensive approach that takes into account various factors and implements effective policies and strategies to reduce air pollution and improve the health and well-being of Christchurch's residents.

Frequently asked questions