Air Pollution's Impact On The Great Lakes

The Great Lakes, a set of five lakes in Canada and the United States, are the largest system of freshwater in the world. They are a critical source of drinking water and contribute to manufacturing and trade in the region. However, over the years, the Great Lakes have faced significant pollution problems, with Lake Erie being declared dead in 1970 due to severe pollution. Air pollution is a critical factor contributing to the degradation of the Great Lakes ecosystem. Air toxics or hazardous air pollutants (HAPs) related to heavy industry, dense urban development, and roadways release toxic chemicals that can bioaccumulate in the food web, endangering both human and wildlife health.

Industrial waste and chemical pollutants

Lake Erie, in particular, has suffered from heavy industrial pollution since the 1960s due to the dense industrial presence along its shores. Factories have historically dumped chemical pollutants into the lake and its tributaries, such as the Cuyahoga and Detroit Rivers. With a population of 11.6 million people in its basin and large cities and farmland in its watershed, Lake Erie is highly vulnerable to human-induced pollution. The lack of substantial government oversight in the past has allowed waste, pesticides, fertilizers, and other pollutants from surrounding urban and agricultural areas to contaminate the lake.

The Great Lakes basin, with its high population density and diverse landscape, has a significant amount of industrial activity. This industrial presence contributes to air pollution, as hazardous air pollutants (HAPs) are released into the atmosphere during heavy industrial processes. These HAPs, such as benzene, perchloroethylene, and methylene chloride, are known to have severe health impacts, including suspected links to cancer and other serious ailments.

Additionally, the burning of coal, oil, and wood, as well as the incineration of mercury-containing waste, releases mercury into the atmosphere. Mercury is a significant concern in the Great Lakes region, as it accumulates in the environment and can lead to health advisories regarding fish and water consumption. Other heavy metals, such as lead and cadmium, also pose threats to the ecosystem and human health. These pollutants can have detrimental effects on both wildlife and humans, as they interfere with municipal water supplies, recreation, and the propagation of fish and wildlife.

While legislation and cleanup efforts have been implemented to address industrial waste and chemical pollution in the Great Lakes, it remains a challenging issue. The unique characteristics of each lake within the Great Lakes system further complicate the process of managing and mitigating the impact of these pollutants.

Sewage and agricultural runoff

Sewage has been a significant contributor to the pollution of the Great Lakes, particularly Lake Erie. By the 1960s, Lake Erie had become predominantly polluted, largely due to the heavy industrial presence along its shores and the waste flowing into the lake from various industrial cities. Detroit's factories, for instance, dumped acids, iron, and oil wastes into the Detroit River, which flows into Lake Erie.

The issue of sewage was further exacerbated by the fact that the Great Lakes Basin lacked substantial government oversight, allowing waste from surrounding cities' sewers and industrial plants to make its way into the lake. This resulted in toxic chemicals, pollutants, pesticides, and heavy metals entering the lake, causing severe ecological damage. Even in small concentrations, these toxins can cause cancer, birth defects, and damage to the nervous and immune systems.

Additionally, during heavy rainstorms, the combined storm water and sanitary sewer systems in some areas, such as Lake Michigan, can exceed the capacity of treatment plants, resulting in raw sewage bypassing the plant and ending up in the lake. This sewage poses a danger to fish and other wildlife, as well as contaminating the water supply.

Agricultural runoff is another critical factor in the pollution of the Great Lakes. Farms are the main source of nutrient pollution, with excess fertilizer and manure from farm fields flowing into waterways during rainfall. This runoff contains high levels of nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorus, which, while vital for plant growth, can have detrimental effects on aquatic ecosystems when present in excess.

The nutrient-rich runoff fuels harmful algal blooms, which can make water toxic to fish, wildlife, and people. When the algae die and decompose, they consume oxygen in the water, creating "dead zones" where fish and other aquatic life cannot survive due to insufficient oxygen levels. This pollution has had significant impacts on the region's drinking water quality, quality of life, and economic well-being.

In conclusion, sewage and agricultural runoff have historically played a significant role in the pollution of the Great Lakes, particularly Lake Erie. While efforts have been made to mitigate the impact, such as the construction of sewage plants and the installation of water filters, the long-term ecological consequences of these pollutants persist, underscoring the importance of continued environmental preservation and pollution prevention measures.

Radioactivity and nuclear power plants

The presence of nuclear power plants in the Great Lakes region has resulted in the accumulation of radioactive waste on the shores of the lakes. This waste, known as spent nuclear fuel, is highly toxic and radioactive and requires careful management and disposal. The challenge arises from the lack of a central repository for this waste, with more than 60,000 tons stored on the shores of four of the five Great Lakes. The US government had promised to provide a central underground repository by 1998 but failed to do so, leading to growing stockpiles of radioactive waste near the lakes.

The International Joint Commission (IJC) has played a crucial role in addressing the issues related to nuclear power plants and radioactivity in the Great Lakes region. The IJC has recommended special precautions and improvements to the regulatory approach to decommissioning nuclear power facilities in the area. The board's report focuses on four key areas: transparency and community engagement, radioactive waste storage, transportation of spent nuclear fuel, and site clean-up and long-term monitoring. The IJC also emphasizes the need for ongoing monitoring to ensure comprehensive clean-up and reduce threats to the Great Lakes environment.

While there have been strict regulations and monitoring of nuclear plants in both Canada and the United States, the presence of radionuclides in the Great Lakes is a concern. Radionuclides, or radioactive forms of elements, can enter the lakes through natural background radiation, fallout from global atmospheric nuclear bomb tests, and operating nuclear power plants. Tritium, a radioactive form of hydrogen, is of particular interest as it tends to bond with oxygen to form water, which can then find its way into the lakes. However, representatives from the nuclear industry assert that reactors release only a small fraction of the allowed limit for radioactive materials and that no reactor has approached the drinking water limit for tritium.

The management and disposal of radioactive waste from nuclear power plants in the Great Lakes region remain a complex and contentious issue. While there are protocols in place to contain and manage radioactive waste during the decommissioning of nuclear plants, the long-term implications of this process are significant. The lack of a central repository for spent nuclear fuel has led to growing stockpiles near the lakes, raising concerns among residents and environmental groups. The potential impact of radioactivity and nuclear power plants on the Great Lakes environment and public health underscores the need for ongoing vigilance and effective regulatory measures.

Air toxics and hazardous air pollutants

Air toxics, or hazardous air pollutants (HAPs), are local, near-source pollutants associated with heavy industry, dense urban development, and roadways. These pollutants are known or suspected to cause cancer and other serious health issues, such as developmental effects or birth defects. Examples of HAPs include benzene (found in gasoline), perchloroethylene (emitted by some dry cleaning facilities), and methylene chloride (a solvent).

HAPs are a major contributor to the pollution of the Great Lakes, as they can contaminate the water through atmospheric deposition. These toxic chemicals can bioaccumulate in the food web, increasing in concentration as they are slowly metabolized or excreted by living organisms. This process can endanger the environment and harm the health of both humans and wildlife.

The Great Lakes Basin, including Lake Erie and Lake Michigan, has historically lacked substantial government oversight, allowing various pollutants to contaminate the water sources. Industrial waste, sewage, pesticides, fertilizers, and chemical pollutants from factories have all contributed to the degradation of water quality in the Great Lakes region.

To address these issues, the Environmental Council, composed of state and federal government representatives, has discussed federal environmental programs to assist states in pollution prevention. Additionally, legislation has been passed, and clean-up orders are now enforceable in state and federal courts. The EPA is actively working to mitigate the adverse effects of HAPs on public health and the environment through initiatives like the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement and the IADN protocol.

Acid deposition and acid rain

The Great Lakes, comprising Lake Superior, Lake Michigan, Lake Huron, Lake Erie, and Lake Ontario, have faced significant air pollution over the years, threatening the health of humans and wildlife in the region. Acid deposition and acid rain, caused by the emission of harmful gases, have been major contributors to this issue.

The adverse effects of acid deposition and acid rain on the Great Lakes ecosystem are evident. Acid rain falls directly onto aquatic habitats, and as it flows through the soil, it can leach aluminum from soil clay particles, further contaminating streams and lakes. This process is particularly detrimental in areas with low "buffering capacity," or the ability of the water and soil to neutralize acidic compounds. As a result, the pH levels of the lakes decrease, making the water more acidic. This increased acidity can be harmful, and even fatal, to fish and other wildlife. For example, at pH 5, most fish eggs cannot hatch, and at lower pH levels, some adult fish die.

Additionally, acid rain can have indirect effects on the ecosystem. It can reduce biodiversity, making the ecosystem more vulnerable to other stressors such as pollution. Furthermore, acid rain can damage man-made structures, corroding metal and causing deterioration of paint and stone. Monuments, buildings, and statues may suffer aesthetic damage, and the air quality may be affected, impacting visibility and enjoyment of scenic areas.

To address the issue of acid deposition and acid rain, legislative action has been taken. The 1990 Clean Air Act Amendments, for example, aimed to regulate emissions of sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxide compounds. While these efforts have led to reduced emissions, acid rain remains a threat to lake ecosystems and water quality. Continuous monitoring and mitigation efforts are necessary to protect the Great Lakes and their surrounding environments from the detrimental effects of acid deposition and acid rain.

Frequently asked questions