Air Pollution's Worst Offenders: States Ranked

Air pollution is a serious health threat, affecting millions of people worldwide. It can trigger asthma attacks, harm lung development in children, and even lead to early death. While the Clean Air Act has improved air quality in some countries, certain states continue to struggle with poor air quality, posing significant risks to their residents' health and well-being. This paragraph introduces the topic of air pollution, highlighting its detrimental effects and the need to identify the most polluted states to address this pressing issue.

California: Los Angeles, Visalia, Bakersfield, and Fresno are the most polluted cities

California is home to some of the most polluted cities in the United States. Los Angeles, Visalia, Bakersfield, and Fresno are the most polluted cities in California. Each city has unique factors contributing to its poor air quality, posing significant health risks to residents and visitors alike.

Los Angeles, California's most populous city, is notorious for its smog, a result of high levels of particle and ozone pollution. Vehicle emissions and traffic congestion from its large population of about 4 million people, with another 6 million in the surrounding county, significantly contribute to Los Angeles' poor air quality. The city's geographic location and frequent wildfires also play a role in its air pollution levels. Despite improvements over the last three decades, Los Angeles still fails to meet national air quality standards for PM2.5 and ozone, with health implications including increased asthma rates and higher overall risk for cancer.

Bakersfield, California, has consistently struggled with unhealthy air quality, particularly regarding PM2.5 and ozone levels. Until 2019, the city had failed to meet federal guidelines for these pollutants, and while it has since made some progress, it still exceeds standards for short-term pollution measures. Bakersfield's air pollution disproportionately affects sensitive individuals, including children, the elderly, and those with pre-existing heart and lung conditions.

Visalia, California, while not as frequently mentioned as other cities in the state, also experiences air quality issues. The city's proximity to agricultural hubs and highways contributes to spikes in air pollution, particularly from vehicle emissions and agricultural activities.

Fresno, California, is another major hub for the state's agricultural industry and a confluence of several major highways, leading to consistently high levels of air pollution. The city's geographic features also trap pollutants in low elevations, exacerbating the problem. Nearly 1.5 million fuel-inefficient trucks pass through Fresno County annually, contributing to diesel and particle pollution. Additionally, the tourism industry, with millions of visitors each year, further adds to the city's poor air quality.

Georgia: Atlanta ranks second for air pollution from vehicles

Air pollution is a critical issue in the United States, adversely affecting the environment and the health of millions of Americans. The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) plays a vital role in monitoring and regulating air pollution, but it faces challenges due to significant staffing and funding cuts.

Georgia, particularly Atlanta, is a notable example of a state struggling with air pollution. Atlanta, known for its heavy traffic, ranks second in the nation for air pollution from vehicles. The primary source of nitrogen oxides, the pollutant in question, is tailpipe emissions from cars and trucks. This has had a significant impact on the health of Georgia's residents, with approximately 11% of children in the state suffering from asthma, almost double the national average.

The high levels of air pollution in Atlanta are largely due to vehicle emissions, which are a significant source of nitrogen oxides. These emissions are released into the air during long periods of high traffic, contributing to Atlanta's poor air quality. The state of Georgia as a whole shares this issue, with an air quality index of 48.2, tying with Ohio for the second-worst air quality in the United States.

The consequences of air pollution in Georgia are severe. In addition to the high asthma rates, air pollution can cause various health issues such as accelerated ageing of the lungs, decreased lung function, bronchitis, and cardiovascular and respiratory illnesses. Climate change further exacerbates the problem, creating conditions that increase the formation of ozone pollution and making it harder to improve air quality.

To protect themselves from the harmful effects of air pollution, Georgians can take proactive measures such as checking air quality forecasts and avoiding outdoor activities when unhealthy air quality is expected. However, the responsibility for improving air quality lies with policymakers and government officials, who must address the root causes of air pollution and implement effective solutions. Policies and regulations such as the Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act are crucial in this effort.

Ohio: Cleveland and Cincinnati are highly polluted

Ohio's Cleveland and Cincinnati are highly polluted, with Cincinnati ranking 22nd most polluted city in the US, according to the American Lung Association's 2024 Annual 'State of the Air' report. The report grades exposure to unhealthy levels of ground-level ozone air pollution, annual particle pollution, and short-term spikes in particle pollution over a three-year period. The Cincinnati metro area was named one of the worst cities in the nation for particle pollution.

Ground-level ozone pollution, commonly known as smog, is a significant issue in Cincinnati. It is formed by the accumulation of various oxides of nitrogen (NOx) and other gases and chemical compounds from vehicles or combustion sources. Ozone pollution is typically higher during the sunnier months and in areas with high traffic. The Cincinnati metro area ranked 42nd worst in the nation for ozone pollution, with Hamilton County, Ohio, experiencing an average of 4.5 unhealthy days per year due to ozone.

Particle pollution is another concern in Cincinnati. PM2.5, particulate matter that is 2.5 micrometres or less in diameter, is considered the most hazardous pollutant in the city and the state of Ohio. In 2020, Cincinnati had a yearly PM2.5 average of 10.1 μg/m³, placing it in the 'good' rating bracket for air quality. However, this relatively good rating still placed the city 2507th out of all cities ranked globally, indicating that pollution levels are high compared to other cities in the United States.

Cleveland, situated on the southern side of Lake Erie, has a history as a prominent manufacturing hub. While the city has diversified its industries, Ohio's oil and gas industry remains a concern for air pollution. Cleveland experiences periods of elevated PM2.5 air pollution in both summer and winter. The city has failed to meet EPA attainment standards for PM2.5 and ozone pollution. Ground-level ozone is a noxious gas formed by the reaction of nitrogen dioxide and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in the presence of sunlight and heat. Cleveland experiences an average of 66 days a year above 80°F, indicating a higher likelihood of unhealthy ozone levels during the summer months.

The effects of air pollution in both Cincinnati and Cleveland can be detrimental to human health. Particle pollution can increase the risk of lung cancer and trigger asthma attacks, while ozone pollution irritates the lungs. Vulnerable groups, including children, older adults, and people with pre-existing health conditions, are more likely to experience adverse effects.

West Virginia: Power plants, car emissions, and the coal industry are sources of pollution

West Virginia has long struggled with air pollution from power plants, car emissions, and the coal industry. The state has 49 coal ash dumpsites, ranking fifth in the nation for ash production in 2020. Coal ash contains toxic pollutants, including heavy metals such as arsenic, lead, and mercury, which have been linked to serious health issues such as cancer and heart disease. Despite this, West Virginia utilities operate 14 regulated coal ash ponds and landfills, with six of these sites containing over 10 million cubic yards of toxic ash. This has resulted in significant groundwater contamination, yet no effective cleanups have been initiated.

The Biden-Harris administration has recognized the severity of the issue, allocating over $140 million to address legacy pollution and revitalize coal communities in West Virginia. This funding aims to create jobs, improve water quality, and reclaim hazardous land. Additionally, the EPA has issued new rules to force power plants to clean up their toxic coal ash, extending federal monitoring and cleanup requirements to older coal ash landfills.

While there has been progress in reducing year-round particle pollution levels in West Virginia, the 2018 State of the Air Report highlights that ozone smog remains a persistent issue. The report also emphasizes the dangers of particle pollution, which can trigger asthma attacks and contribute to heart attacks and strokes. To address these concerns, the American Lung Association in West Virginia has called for the defense of the Clean Air Act and urged the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to enforce regulations such as the Clean Power Plan and promote cleaner cars to reduce air pollution.

The state's air pollution problems are not limited to coal ash and particle pollution. West Virginia also faces challenges with car emissions, which contribute to the state's air quality issues. The retirement of old diesel engines has helped reduce particle pollution levels, but more efforts are needed to address the problem comprehensively. Overall, West Virginia's air pollution issues are complex and multifaceted, requiring continued attention and action from policymakers and stakeholders to improve the state's air quality and protect public health.

Alaska: Anchorage and Mat-Su have particle pollution problems due to wood-burning

While Alaska has good air quality, with an air quality index of 29.1, the second-best in the US, there are areas where particle pollution is a problem. Anchorage and Mat-Su are two such areas, where air pollution is caused by wood-burning home heating. However, these areas have seen improvements in air quality in recent years, and most of Alaska can be found in the "good" AQI range for the majority of the year.

Particle pollution can cause a range of serious health issues, including an increased risk of lung cancer, heart attacks, strokes, and early death. It can also trigger asthma attacks and harm lung development in children. Climate change increases the risk of wildfires, which spread dangerous particle pollution, and makes it harder to clean up communities where ozone levels are high.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) plays a critical role in cleaning up air pollution. EPA staff monitor air pollution, write rules to clean it up, and enforce those rules. However, the EPA is currently facing significant staffing and funding cuts, which endanger their work.

Despite Alaska's overall good air quality, the particle pollution in Anchorage and Mat-Su highlights the need for continued efforts to improve air quality and protect the health of vulnerable populations.

Frequently asked questions