Tampa's Water Quality: Is It Safe?

Water pollution in Tampa, Florida, is a pressing issue. Tampa Bay's water quality has declined after decades of improvement, with the region facing challenges such as industrial pollution, sewage problems, and the environmental repercussions of phosphate mining. The Clean Water Act of 1972, which marked its 50th anniversary in 2022, was a significant milestone in the history of Tampa Bay's water quality improvement efforts. However, despite past successes, Tampa Bay and other waterways in Florida are facing increasing pollution levels. This has resulted in adverse effects on aquatic life and the ecosystem. The water quality in Tampa is a concern for both the local community and environmental advocates, with ongoing efforts to address the issue and raise awareness about the importance of clean water.

Tampa Bay's water quality is declining due to industrial pollution and sewage

The region is home to several phosphate mines, and their byproducts and gypsum stacks have significantly impacted water quality and public health. In 2021, a leak at the Piney Point phosphogypsum stack in Manatee County resulted in the release of millions of gallons of polluted water into Tampa Bay. This highly contaminated water contained high levels of ammonia, nitrates, and slightly radioactive substances. The incident had devastating consequences for the local sea life, with one source noting that "any sea life around here will probably be pretty wiped out".

Stormwater runoff is another significant source of pollution in Tampa Bay, contributing to approximately 59% of the total nitrogen loading in the bay. This excess nitrogen has been linked to red tide, which causes diminished oxygen levels, fish deaths, and the degradation of vital fish habitats. Stormwater runoff also introduces marine debris, microplastics, and PCBs (Polychlorinated biphenyls), known carcinogens, into the water system.

The effects of these environmental challenges are evident, with areas that once thrived with life now reduced to sand flats. Healthy populations of redfish, trout, and snook have declined, and the tradition of dyeing the Hillsborough River green for St. Patrick's Day has come under scrutiny due to its potential impact on wildlife behaviour and the ecosystem.

While Tampa Bay has historically been a model for successful water restoration, the current decline in water quality underscores the limitations of the Clean Water Act amid weak state pollution control, intense population growth, and climate change.

Phosphate plants and phosphate mines are major contributors to water pollution

Tampa Bay's water quality has been declining after a half-century of gains. Phosphate plants and phosphate mines are major contributors to this water pollution. In the mid-20th century, phosphate plants were permitted to discharge their wastewater into the Alafia River, which flows into Tampa Bay. This wastewater contains small amounts of naturally occurring radium and uranium, and the stacks can also release large concentrations of radon gas.

In April 2021, the Piney Point phosphate mine, which had shut down 20 years ago, released 215 million gallons of wastewater into Tampa Bay to reduce pressure and avoid a potential disaster. This incident was caused by a leak in the wall holding back polluted water, which led to fears of an "environmental catastrophe". The Florida agriculture commissioner, Nikki Fried, warned that more pollutants in Tampa Bay would increase the risk to wildlife from toxic red tide algae blooms.

Phosphate mining and its long-term environmental repercussions have been a concern for decades. The region's phosphate mines produce byproducts and gypsum stacks that significantly impact water quality and public health. These stacks, called "gypstacks," are mounds of radioactive phosphate waste that stand as reminders of the industry's indefinite pollution potential.

In October 2024, polluted water from the Mosaic phosphate plant, the world's largest phosphate miner, likely spilled into Tampa Bay during Hurricane Milton. The company attributed the breach to the relentless rainfall, which overwhelmed the water collection system. Mosaic's facility in Riverview, which has been producing fertilizer since 1928, stores a stack of phosphate waste called phosphogypsum, which contains radium. While the company expects water quality issues to be "modest", the exact volume of polluted water leaked remains unknown.

Stormwater runoff is a significant source of pollution, leading to red tide and the degradation of fish habitats

Tampa Bay's water quality has been declining, with the region facing issues of pollution and the degradation of fish habitats. Stormwater runoff is a significant contributor to this problem, and it has led to red tide occurrences and the deterioration of vital fish habitats, such as seagrass beds.

Tampa Bay's history with water pollution is well-known, and in the mid-20th century, the region witnessed phosphate plants dumping their wastewater into the Alafia River, which flows into Tampa Bay. While there have been efforts to improve water quality, such as the opening of the Howard F. Curren Advanced Wastewater Treatment Plant in 1979, which reduced nitrogen loads, the bay continues to face challenges.

Stormwater runoff is a major source of pollution in Tampa Bay, accounting for a significant portion of the total nitrogen loading. This excess nitrogen has been linked to red tide events, which result in decreased oxygen levels and the death of fish. The runoff also introduces marine debris, microplastics, and PCBs (polychlorinated biphenyls) into the water system, further degrading the habitat and posing risks to public health.

The impact of stormwater runoff on red tide and fish habitats is evident in the observations of anglers and environmental incidents. Areas that were once thriving with life have been reduced to sand flats, and populations of fish species such as redfish, trout, and snook have declined. The Piney Point leak in 2021, which released millions of gallons of polluted water into Tampa Bay, is a notable example of how runoff can exacerbate red tide and harm the ecosystem.

The urbanization of Tampa has disrupted the natural balance of stormwater runoff, leading to an increase in impervious surfaces like rooftops and streets. This shift has resulted in a greater concentration of human-derived pollutants, which directly impact the water quality of surface waters, including the Hillsborough River and Tampa Bay. The City of Tampa's Water Quality Report provides valuable information on the source and quality of drinking water, but more efforts are needed to address the ongoing issues of stormwater runoff and its impact on the bay's delicate ecosystem.

The Clean Water Act of 1972 was a significant step in improving water quality, but challenges remain

The Clean Water Act of 1972 was a significant step in improving water quality in Tampa Bay, which had seen its worst period of water quality in the 1970s. The Act established a nationwide approach to enhancing the quality of lakes, rivers, streams, and other water bodies. It required the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to monitor and regulate pollutant discharges into US waters, setting standards for wastewater and surface water quality.

Tampa Bay became a national model for restoration and the success of the Clean Water Act. In 1979, the opening of the Howard F. Curren Advanced Wastewater Treatment Plant reduced nitrogen loads into the Bay by 90%. However, despite these improvements, challenges to water quality remain. Intense population growth, industrialization, and climate change have placed unprecedented pressure on Tampa Bay's waters.

Stormwater runoff, the leading cause of water pollution, has increased due to urbanization, with more pollutants from rooftops and streets flowing into the Hillsborough River and Tampa Bay. This has contributed to the occurrence of red tide, which leads to diminished oxygen levels, fish kills, and the degradation of seagrass beds. The region's phosphate mines have also affected water quality, with radioactive wastewater and leaks of polluted water causing ongoing issues.

While the Clean Water Act provided a framework for regulating pollution, ensuring compliance and enforcement remains a challenge. The EPA has been criticized for lacking reliable information to ensure polluters are complying with their permits, and illegal discharges continue to threaten water bodies. As a result, Tampa Bay's water quality is once again declining, with fecal and industrial pollution, harmful algae blooms, and the decline of seagrass and marine life.

Addressing these challenges requires continued cooperation between governments, industries, and citizens, as well as a commitment to enforcing regulations and adapting to new threats posed by population growth and climate change.

The tradition of dyeing the Hillsborough River green for St. Patrick's Day has raised environmental concerns

The city of Tampa has been dyeing the Hillsborough River green for St. Patrick's Day since 2012. The tradition was started by former Mayor Bob Buckhorn. The city uses a powder chemical called Bright Dyes, supplied by the Ohio-based company Kingscote Chemicals.

The tradition has raised environmental concerns, with critics arguing that even non-toxic additives may have unforeseen impacts on an already stressed ecosystem. The river is home to hundreds of animal species, including dolphins, manatees, wood storks, and snowy egrets. The Florida Department of Environmental Protection considers the river "impaired," meaning it is a waterbody in need of restoration.

There are also concerns about the message that dyeing the river green sends about environmental stewardship. Boat Captain Dustin Pack, who started a petition to end the tradition, said, "You can party and also not dye our river green. It just doesn't look good that we say we care about an estuary that we live on or live near, but we're just throwing this crap in it." Pack also noted that the dye lingered for at least 48 hours in Tampa's waterways, contrary to claims by city officials that it dissipates in a few hours.

However, Tampa Water Production Manager John Ring has assured the public that the powder mixture used is safe for the environment and wildlife. He said that the precaution in the safety data sheet is geared more toward a bulk spill of the concentrated dye, while the city mixes water with the dye to lower the concentration. The city's water experts, the county's environmental regulators, and Kingscote Chemicals all maintain that the dye is food-grade and poses no risk to human or environmental health. They also claim that the river flushes out soon after the event finishes and that the concentration of the dye is so small that it hardly makes a difference.

Despite these assurances, public sentiment, as reflected in a petition with over 5,000 signatures, calls for a reevaluation of the tradition. Tampa Bay has a history of water pollution, with industrial and municipal sewage contributing to poor water quality in the past. While there have been efforts to improve water quality, such as the opening of the Howard F. Curren Advanced Wastewater Treatment Plant in 1979, Tampa Bay continues to face challenges such as stormwater runoff, nutrient pollution, and algae blooms.

Frequently asked questions