Estimating Traffic Pollution: Methods And Applications

Traffic-related air pollution (TRAP) is a major source of air pollution, especially in urban areas, and has been linked to adverse health effects. TRAP is caused by emissions from motorized vehicles, which release pollutants such as carbon monoxide, NO2, and particulate matter into the atmosphere. As a result, people living in close proximity to high-traffic roadways are likely to be exposed to higher levels of air pollution, leading to an increased risk of health problems such as asthma, allergies, lung function issues, and cardiovascular and respiratory diseases. To estimate TRAP, various methods and tools can be employed, including simulation modeling, risk assessment techniques, and the use of dedicated roadside air monitoring sites. By understanding and evaluating the impact of TRAP, researchers and policymakers can work towards mitigating its effects and improving public health outcomes.

Health risks and impacts of traffic-related air pollution

Motor vehicles are a significant source of urban air pollution, and the health effects of traffic-related air pollution (TRAP) are a major public health concern. TRAP has been linked to a wide range of adverse health outcomes, including respiratory, cardiovascular, immunological, reproductive/developmental, neurological, and acute lower respiratory infections in children.

Several studies have investigated the health risks associated with TRAP. For instance, Tonne et al. (2008) predicted that a congestion charging zone in London could result in a significant gain in years-of-life for the population. Similarly, Eliasson et al. (2009) estimated that a similar zone in Stockholm would avoid multiple deaths annually due to reduced traffic-related air pollution. These studies highlight the potential benefits of congestion pricing in mitigating the health impacts of TRAP.

Additionally, recurring congestion can lead to increased long-term health risks due to repeated and chronic exposures. "Incident congestion," such as that caused by accidents or disabled vehicles, can also have acute health impacts, such as exacerbating asthma. The health risks from congestion can vary depending on the type of road and other factors, including travel time and the duration of rush hour.

The specific pollutants associated with TRAP include ultrafine particles, carbon monoxide, NO2, black carbon, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and certain metals. These pollutants have been linked to increased mortality, with stronger effects observed for black carbon and NO2 in some studies. The Health Effects Institute (HEI) has conducted extensive reviews of the epidemiological evidence, concluding that TRAP is associated with adverse health outcomes such as circulatory issues, ischemic heart disease, lung cancer, and asthma onset.

Overall, the health risks and impacts of traffic-related air pollution are significant and warrant further attention from the public and policymakers. Evaluating the health risks associated with TRAP is challenging due to the difficulty in isolating the contributions of individual pollution sources. However, various studies have employed simulation modeling and predictive risk assessment techniques to estimate the health impacts of TRAP, providing valuable insights into this important public health issue.

Modelling and simulating traffic-related air pollution

One key aspect of modelling traffic-related air pollution is the collection and integration of diverse data sets. This includes traffic data, meteorological information, 3D city building data, and pollutant emission details from various sources such as urban traffic, domestic heating, and industrial processes. By feeding these data into simulation tools, potential traffic flows and their associated air pollution levels can be predicted.

Traffic flow models are essential for estimating traffic patterns and their impact on air quality. These models consider factors such as traffic volume, speed, and road infrastructure. For example, the SIMulation of Traffic-induced Air Pollution (SIMTRAP) project integrates traffic flow information with air pollution modelling to simulate the dynamic behaviour of traffic flow and its pollution consequences.

Additionally, emission factors play a crucial role in understanding traffic-related air pollution. Different models, such as the Comprehensive Modal Emissions Model and the Motor Vehicle Emissions Factor Model, help quantify emissions from combustion engines, including pollutants like NO2, nitric oxide, carbon monoxide, and black smoke. These emission factors are influenced by traffic volume, road type, and congestion levels.

The health risks associated with traffic-related air pollution are also incorporated into the modelling process. Studies have shown that exposure to ambient air pollution is linked to morbidity and mortality, particularly in populations living in close proximity to busy roads. By combining emission factors with health data, researchers can assess the potential health impacts of specific pollutants and develop strategies to mitigate these risks.

Furthermore, modelling and simulating traffic-related air pollution should consider the interactions between traffic, emissions, air quality, and water quality. For instance, stormwater runoff can be contaminated by pollutants from road traffic, leading to water quality issues. Integrated modelling approaches, such as the Storm Water Management Model (SWMM), help evaluate the impact of traffic emissions on both air and water quality in urban environments.

Traffic congestion and its effects

Traffic congestion is a significant problem that has wide-ranging effects on cities and their populations. The most obvious impact is the delay caused to commuters, which can be extremely frustrating and inconvenient for those affected. This can also have a knock-on effect on productivity and the economy, as people may be late for work, and goods may spoil or arrive too late. In 2019, New York City was found to have the highest economic losses out of any US city due to congestion. The American Transportation Research Institute has estimated that congestion in the freight sector costs $74.1 billion, with $66.1 billion attributed to urban areas.

Congestion also impacts the predictability of travel, as commuters can no longer rely on consistent travel times. This is particularly concerning for emergency vehicles, which may be delayed in reaching their destinations. Furthermore, the environmental impact of congestion is significant. In 2021, 15% of London's total CO2 emissions were attributed to traffic congestion, amounting to 2.2 megatons of CO2. This contributes to global warming and its associated consequences.

The health risks associated with traffic congestion are also notable. Exposure to air pollution from vehicle emissions has been linked to increased morbidity and mortality, with potential impacts on lung function, and an increased risk of lung cancer, cardiovascular disease, and respiratory disease. Studies have found higher levels of pollutants such as NO2, nitric oxide, carbon monoxide, and black smoke at traffic-influenced sites compared to background sites. Furthermore, congestion charging zones in London and Stockholm are predicted to result in gains of 183 and 20-25 years-of-life per 100,000 population, respectively, further emphasising the health impacts of congestion.

To address these issues, cities can implement strategies such as congestion charging zones, which have been shown to reduce traffic-related health impacts. Additionally, improving traffic monitoring and control systems can help manage congestion and make travel safer and more efficient. By considering the various effects of traffic congestion, cities can work towards finding effective solutions to mitigate these impacts.

Air pollutants and their sources

Motor vehicles are a significant source of air pollution in urban areas. The adverse health effects of living near roads have been observed, even after adjusting for socioeconomic status and noise levels. While PM2.5 levels are only slightly elevated near roads, pollutants such as ultrafine particles, carbon monoxide, NO2, black carbon, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and some metals are more prevalent in these areas. These pollutants, individually or in combination, are likely responsible for the negative health impacts observed.

Exhaust emissions are a significant contributor to traffic-related pollution, and epidemiological and toxicological studies have linked them to adverse health effects. Non-exhaust emissions, such as road abrasion, tyre wear, and brake wear, become relatively more important as exhaust emissions decrease. Toxicological research suggests that these non-exhaust pollutants may also contribute to the observed adverse health effects. Motor vehicles emit substantial amounts of carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons, nitrogen oxides, particulate matter (PM), and substances known as mobile source air toxics, such as benzene, formaldehyde, acetaldehyde, 1,3-butadiene, and lead.

The type and age of vehicles, operating and maintenance conditions, exhaust treatment, fuel type and quality, and engine lubricants all influence pollutant emissions. Non-combustion particulate matter emissions from motor vehicles include wear particles from roads, tyres, and brakes, as well as resuspended road dust. These non-combustion emissions contain trace metals and organic compounds. Traffic emissions are the primary source of intra-urban variations in pollutant concentrations, but these can vary by time and location.

Traffic congestion can exacerbate the problem by reducing the dispersion of pollutants and altering driving patterns, leading to increased emissions. Lower vehicle speeds, frequent speed changes, and higher power acceleration during congestion contribute to higher emissions of CO, HC, and NOx. Therefore, it is crucial to differentiate between congestion-free and congestion-related impacts when assessing pollution and health risks.

Various methods and models have been developed to estimate and address traffic-related air pollution. These include simulation modelling, emission factors from models like the Comprehensive Modal Emissions Model and Motor Vehicle Emissions Factor Model, the California Line Source Dispersion Model, and frameworks to identify studies of traffic-related air pollution. Additionally, national programs and standards, such as those implemented by the EPA, aim to reduce emissions from transportation sources, improve air quality, and protect public health.

Policy and regulatory solutions

Pricing Strategies

Implementing pricing strategies such as congestion charges, emissions-based tolls, or vehicle ownership taxes can discourage private car usage and generate funds for public transportation improvements.

Land Use Planning

Urban planning policies should promote mixed-use development, where residential, commercial, and recreational areas are in close proximity, reducing the need for long-distance travel. This can also encourage active transportation options like walking and cycling, reducing traffic congestion and associated pollution.

Infrastructure Development

Investments in public transportation infrastructure, such as subways, light rail, and bus rapid transit systems, provide efficient and environmentally friendly alternatives to private cars. Additionally, the establishment of dedicated bike lanes and pedestrian walkways can further encourage active transportation.

Technology Advancements

Encourage the adoption of alternative fuel technologies, such as hybrid and electric vehicles, by offering incentives like subsidies or tax breaks. This can significantly reduce emissions and improve air quality, as demonstrated by successful initiatives in cities like Beijing.

Emission Standards and Regulations

Strict enforcement of emission standards for vehicles, engines, and fuels is crucial. Regulatory bodies like the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) play a vital role in setting limits on air pollutants and ensuring compliance through inspections and evaluations. The Clean Air Act, for instance, empowers the EPA to regulate emissions from various sources.

Health Impact Assessments

Policy interventions should be informed by health impact assessments that evaluate the exposure and risks associated with traffic-related air pollutants. This includes understanding the spatial distribution of pollutants and their impacts on nearby residences, schools, and vulnerable communities. Such assessments guide interventions to protect public health and reduce societal costs.

Frequently asked questions