Caribbean Crisis: Pollution's Impact On Paradise

The Caribbean is facing a growing threat from pollution, development, and overuse, with marine pollution and coastal degradation becoming serious issues for the region. The Caribbean is particularly vulnerable to the impacts of pollution due to its dependence on natural resources and its vast exposed coastlines. Marine pollution in the region includes plastics, sewage, agricultural runoff, gas, oil, and chemicals, which impact the value of the goods and services provided by the oceans, including fisheries and tourism. The region's capacity to treat sewage has not kept up with the large numbers of tourists, and cruise ships, a major component of the Caribbean's tourism market, are singled out as major polluters. The Caribbean is also affected by land-based sources of marine pollution, with hot spots identified in mainland countries and larger industrialized islands. Organic and nutrient pollution, particularly from sewage, is the most widespread and serious marine pollution problem in the region.

Cruise ship pollution

The large volume of sewage and wastewater generated by cruise ships poses a significant threat to the Caribbean's marine environment. A large cruise ship with over 7,000 passengers and crew is estimated to produce 210,000 gallons of human sewage and 1 million gallons of greywater (water from sinks, baths, showers, laundry, and galleys) in just one week. In addition to sewage and greywater, cruise ships also generate large volumes of oily bilge water, sewage sludge, garbage, and hazardous wastes.

The discharge of sewage and wastewater from cruise ships has contaminated the Caribbean's pristine marine environments, including its mangrove and coral reef areas. These fragile ecosystems are also facing degradation from human contact, destructive fishing practices, and fertiliser runoff from farms. The impact of this pollution on the region's marine life is significant, with scientists noting that nearly every corner of the world's oceans has been damaged in some way by human activity.

The Caribbean's tourism industry, which relies heavily on its coastal areas and marine environments, is vulnerable to the effects of cruise ship pollution. A decline in tourism revenues is possible as tourists may be deterred by the degradation of these once-pristine areas.

To address the issue of cruise ship pollution, there have been calls for stricter regulations and the implementation of advanced sewage and wastewater treatment systems. Environmental groups have also advocated for the use of shore power, cleaner fuels, and the reduction of single-use plastics to mitigate the impact of cruise ships on the Caribbean's environment.

Agricultural runoff

The health of coral reefs is vital to the Caribbean for several reasons. Firstly, coral reefs support marine biodiversity and provide habitats for many species. They also protect the coast from erosion and the impacts of storms, acting as a natural barrier. In addition, coral reefs are a significant draw for tourists, who are attracted by the opportunity to explore pristine marine environments. Tourism is a major contributor to the economies of Caribbean countries, and the revenue it generates is crucial for the region's development and the quality of life of its residents.

To address the issue of agricultural runoff, it is essential to implement sustainable farming practices that minimise the use of chemicals and reduce the risk of pollution. This includes applying fertilisers and pesticides sparingly and adopting integrated pest management approaches. Additionally, investing in waste management infrastructure and treatment systems can help prevent the discharge of untreated sewage and agricultural runoff into the ocean. By prioritising these measures, Caribbean countries can protect their vital marine ecosystems and promote long-term economic growth and environmental sustainability.

Plastic pollution

The sources of plastic pollution in the Caribbean are multifaceted. One significant contributor is the improper disposal of plastic waste on land. Between 70% and 85% of marine litter in the Caribbean Sea originates from land-based sources, with plastic constituting a substantial portion of this waste. This land-based litter finds its way into waterways and oceans, where it accumulates and persists.

The impact of plastic pollution in the Caribbean is extensive. Visually, plastic pollution mars the beauty of the region, detracting from its allure as a tourist destination. The economic implications are significant, as tourism accounts for a substantial portion of the region's GDP. The presence of plastic waste also poses a direct threat to marine life. Marine animals, such as seabirds, fish, whales, and even plankton, mistake plastic for food, leading to choking, indigestion, and poisoning. Additionally, plastic acts as a magnet for toxins, absorbing agricultural pesticides, chemicals from industrial plants, and greenhouse gas emissions, which are then ingested by marine organisms.

The problem of plastic pollution in the Caribbean has spurred governments into action. Antigua and Barbuda led the way in 2016 with a comprehensive five-phased approach to eliminating plastics, incorporating the ban into existing legislation. This initiative resulted in a significant reduction in plastic waste, with the proportion of plastic dumped in landfills decreasing from 19.5% in 2006 to 4.4% in 2017. Building on this momentum, over 18 territories in the region have imposed bans on single-use plastics or Styrofoam products, with more countries considering similar measures.

The United Nations Environment Programme's Clean Seas campaign further underscores the global commitment to addressing marine plastic litter. By targeting the production and consumption of non-recoverable and single-use plastics, the campaign aims to tackle the root causes of the issue. As of April 2019, 60 governments, including nine in the Caribbean, have signed up for the initiative, collectively representing over 60% of the world's coastline.

While progress has been made, the battle against plastic pollution in the Caribbean is ongoing. It requires continued efforts from governments, industries, and individuals to reduce, reuse, and recycle plastic responsibly. The future of the Caribbean's delicate marine ecosystems and the well-being of its residents depend on our collective ability to address this pressing environmental challenge.

Sewage

Untreated sewage can contain a range of harmful substances, including water, nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus), solids (organic matter), pathogens (bacteria, viruses, and protozoa), helminthes (intestinal worms), heavy metals (mercury, cadmium, lead), and toxic chemicals. These contaminants pose significant risks to human health, causing various illnesses and infections. According to GESAMP (2001), sewage contamination of coastal areas leads to a significant increase in infectious diseases linked to swimming and seafood consumption.

The Caribbean is particularly vulnerable to the health-related impacts of sewage pollution. For example, litter from sewage provides breeding grounds for mosquitoes carrying viruses such as dengue, chikungunya, and Zika. Sewage also contributes to the growth of algae blooms, which can be toxic and harm or kill marine mammals, causing hundreds of millions of dollars in damage to commercial fisheries.

The impact of sewage pollution on the Caribbean's ecosystems is evident. Excess nutrients from sewage discharge lead to eutrophication, causing an excessive growth of marine plants and decay. This, in turn, limits sunlight availability and reduces oxygen levels in the water, endangering marine animals, coral reefs, seagrass beds, and other vital habitats in the region.

The economic implications of sewage pollution are also significant. Tourism is a vital industry in the Caribbean, and the degradation of marine ecosystems poses a direct threat to the region's economic well-being. Additionally, the health risks associated with sewage pollution can deter tourists, further impacting the local economies.

Addressing the sewage problem in the Caribbean is crucial for protecting human health, the environment, and the region's economic stability. It requires collective action, improved wastewater management systems, and a stronger commitment to treating wastewater before disposal.

Climate change

The Caribbean is one of the most vulnerable regions in the world when it comes to the impacts of climate change. The region is bearing the brunt of climate disruptions, despite contributing very little to global greenhouse gas emissions. The unique challenges faced by small island developing states (SIDS) make them especially susceptible to the effects of climate change. Here is a detailed overview of the ways in which climate change is affecting the Caribbean:

Rising Sea Levels and Coastal Erosion:

• The Caribbean's low-lying coastal areas are extremely vulnerable to rising sea levels. This threat is exacerbated by the region's high coastline-to-land ratio, meaning that even a slight rise in sea level can have a significant impact on agricultural lands, infrastructure, and populations along the coast.
• Sea-level rise, combined with stronger wave action and higher storm surges, will result in more frequent and severe coastal flooding, as well as increased coastal erosion.
• Critical infrastructure, such as power plants, schools, housing communities, and transportation hubs, are at risk of damage or destruction due to rising sea levels and associated impacts.

More Frequent and Intense Storms:

• The Caribbean is particularly exposed to the effects of hurricanes, tropical storms, and other extreme weather events, which are becoming more frequent and intense due to climate change.
• These storms can cause widespread damage to infrastructure, natural ecosystems, and local economies, with the potential to wipe out entire communities, as seen with Hurricane Beryl in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines in 2024.
• The combination of rising sea levels and more frequent intense storms poses a significant threat to the region's critical cargo ports, ferries, and cruise ship terminals, further disrupting local economies and livelihoods.

Drought and Water Scarcity:

• The Caribbean region is projected to experience reduced rainfall and increased drought conditions in the coming decades due to climate change.
• This will result in decreased water availability for both human communities and natural ecosystems, impacting agriculture, fisheries, and overall food security.
• Saltwater intrusion into freshwater aquifers, due to sea-level rise, further exacerbates the issue of water scarcity and affects the quality of available freshwater sources.

Biodiversity Loss:

• The Caribbean's unique biodiversity, including its rich marine life and endemic plant species, is at risk due to climate change.
• Coral reefs, which make up about 10% of the world's total and are vital for coastal protection, are already undergoing bleaching due to increasing water temperatures.
• The loss of coral reefs and other ecosystems, such as mangrove wetlands, threatens the region's biodiversity and the livelihoods of those dependent on fisheries and marine resources.

Economic Impacts:

• Climate change poses significant economic threats to the Caribbean, particularly in the tourism and agriculture sectors.
• Tourism, a mainstay of the region's economy, is vulnerable to the loss or deterioration of natural attractions, such as beaches and coral reefs, due to climate change. A 2022 study estimated that sea-level rise alone could result in a 38-47% reduction in tourism revenue by 2100.
• Agriculture, which employs a significant portion of the region's population, is vulnerable to reduced water availability, soil erosion, and damage to crop yields and livestock caused by higher temperatures, droughts, and more frequent storms.

Migration and Social Disruption:

• Climate-induced migration is already a significant issue in the Caribbean, with close to ten million people internally displaced by natural disasters between 2008 and 2023, and cross-border migration is also expected to increase.
• The social fabric of the region is being strained by climate-related disasters, with entire communities being displaced and livelihoods disrupted, leading to increased economic and social inequality.

In summary, climate change poses an existential threat to the Caribbean, and urgent action is needed to mitigate and adapt to its impacts. The region's small island nations are particularly vulnerable, and global efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and provide climate financing are crucial for their survival.

Frequently asked questions