San Francisco's Air Quality: A Pollution Concern?

San Francisco's air quality has improved since 2012, but the city still experiences unhealthy levels of air pollution. The Bay Area's air basin consists of nine counties, and exceedance of air quality standards in any one of them would result in a violation of air quality standards in the entire basin. While the city has not violated air quality standards in recent years, its westerly winds carry pollutants generated in the city to the eastern and southern areas of the region. The primary sources of air pollution in San Francisco are transportation emissions, industrial facilities, and wildfires, which are becoming increasingly common in the Bay Area.

Wildfires and air quality

Wildfires can have a significant impact on air quality, and San Francisco is no exception to this. The city has seen an increase in the size and frequency of wildfires over the last two decades, which has resulted in drastic spikes of air pollution. The main component of wildfire smoke is particle pollution, which can have negative health effects on those who breathe it in. These particles are characterized by their aerodynamic diameter and can be grouped into two main categories: coarse particles (PM10-2.5) and fine particles (PM2.5). Fine particles are of the greatest health concern as they can travel deep into the lungs and may even enter the bloodstream. Certain groups are more vulnerable to the health effects of wildfire smoke, including individuals with respiratory or cardiovascular diseases, children, older adults, pregnant women, outdoor workers, and people of lower socioeconomic status.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the U.S. Forest Service have developed resources to help people protect their health from wildfire smoke. They have created the AirNow Fire and Smoke Map, which provides information on fire locations, smoke plumes, near real-time air quality, and protective actions to take. The map uses data from various sources, including monitors that regularly report to AirNow, temporary monitors deployed near fires, and crowd-sourced data from low-cost sensors that measure fine particle pollution. The map also provides access to Smoke Outlooks, which offer a forecast of smoke impacts to help people plan their activities and reduce their exposure to smoke.

In addition to the AirNow Fire and Smoke Map, the EPA has developed the Air Quality Index (AQI), a color-coded index that indicates whether air quality is healthy or unhealthy. By knowing the AQI in their area, individuals can take steps to protect their health. The EPA has also created educational resources for children, such as the picture book "Why is Coco Red?", which teaches children about the effects of wildfires on air quality and health.

To improve air quality in the San Francisco Bay Area, the city has implemented measures such as reducing pollution from automobiles and trucks and promoting clean air through its transportation system. The city's leadership in this area is recognized by the Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD). However, San Francisco still experiences unacceptable levels of air pollutants, such as carbon monoxide, ozone, and particulate matter, particularly during the winter months when heating and wood burning are more common. Overall, while San Francisco has relatively good air quality compared to other cities, wildfires continue to be a significant challenge for the region.

Transportation emissions

San Francisco's air quality is impacted by various factors, and transportation emissions play a significant role in this context. The city's coastal location, natural topography, and sparse industrial presence contribute to relatively better air quality compared to other cities. However, transportation emissions, particularly from vehicles like cars, trucks, motorbikes, planes, and ships, are primary sources of air pollution in San Francisco.

Emissions from cars and trucks account for a substantial portion of the city's carbon footprint, with a contribution of 46% as of 2018. The San Francisco County Transportation Authority (SFCTA) is actively working to reduce transportation-related greenhouse gas emissions. They are leveraging funding sources, such as San Francisco's half-cent sales tax, to expand and green the city's transit fleet, supporting projects like Transit-First and improving street safety for pedestrians and cyclists. The SFCTA's Transportation Fund for Clean Air also finances electric vehicle chargers and bike racks, encouraging a shift towards more sustainable transportation options.

The SFCTA has set ambitious goals for the future of mobility in San Francisco. By 2030, the city aims to achieve 80% of trips made by transit, biking, walking, and carpooling. This target is crucial for meeting California's climate goals, as vehicle emissions have been a significant challenge in the state. To support this transition, the SFCTA is working with employers and developers through the Transportation Sustainability Program to promote cleaner and more sustainable travel choices.

While San Francisco has not violated air quality standards in recent years, the city's pollutants are carried by westerly winds to the eastern and southern areas of the region. This highlights the importance of regional cooperation in improving air quality. The Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD) recognizes San Francisco's leadership in promoting clean air, considering the city's population density and transportation system. Nevertheless, the increasing number of commuters driving into the city remains a concern, and addressing this challenge is essential for maintaining and improving air quality in the region.

Industrial facilities

The city's objectives include enhancing the energy efficiency of housing, promoting the use of renewable energy sources, and improving transportation efficiency. These initiatives aim to reduce the environmental impact of industrial facilities and other sources of pollution.

Transportation is a significant factor in particle pollution, especially heavy-duty trucks, which make up only 5% of vehicles but emit the most pollutants. Electrifying big trucks and promoting public transit, walking, and biking can help reduce emissions and improve air quality.

Additionally, the energy sector plays a role in San Francisco's air pollution. The city has recognized the need to increase energy efficiency and promote the use of renewable energy sources. By reducing energy consumption and transitioning to cleaner energy alternatives, the city can mitigate the pollution caused by the energy sector.

Furthermore, industrial facilities outside the local region can also impact San Francisco's air quality. According to a study, about 29% of the pollution in the San Francisco Bay Area originates from East Asia, particularly China. Dust storms pick up particulate pollution from coal-fired power plants and metal ores in China and carry them across the Pacific to the United States.

Household products

San Francisco has seen substantial improvements in air quality over the past 30 years. This is due to cleaner-burning automobile engines and fuels, as well as tighter regulatory controls on industrial sources of air pollution. Despite this, the city still experiences unacceptable levels of certain air pollutants, such as carbon monoxide, ozone, and particulate matter.

• Aerosol sprays, such as hair sprays, deodorants, and air fresheners, can deplete the stratospheric ozone layer and contribute to outdoor air pollution.
• Paints and solvents: These can release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and particulate matter into the air, contributing to both indoor and outdoor air pollution. Low-VOC paints are available as a less-polluting alternative.
• Cleaning products: These often contain harmful VOCs, which can be inhaled directly or react with other chemicals in the air, impacting air quality and human health.
• Candles and incense: Burning wood or incense can increase carbon monoxide and particulate pollution levels, especially in smaller, poorly ventilated spaces.
• Cooking: Cooking on a gas stove can emit a significant number of nanoparticles into the air, which can be inhaled.
• Personal care products: Items such as perfumes, soaps, and shampoos can emit VOCs, which contribute to indoor and outdoor air pollution.

To reduce the impact of household products on air pollution in San Francisco, residents can opt for natural alternatives, improve ventilation, and choose low-emission products. Public education and awareness about the environmental impacts of household products can also help diminish their use and promote cleaner alternatives. Additionally, recycling and energy conservation can indirectly reduce emissions from the manufacturing of new materials, further improving the city's air quality.

Climate Action Plan

San Francisco has relatively good air quality compared to other cities such as Los Angeles, London, and Paris. However, the city still experiences unacceptable levels of air pollutants like carbon monoxide, ozone, and particulate matter. The primary sources of air pollution in the Bay Area are automobile tailpipe emissions and transportation emissions, including vehicles, planes, and ships. Wildfires in the Bay Area, which have increased due to anthropogenic climate change, also contribute to poor air quality.

To address these issues, the San Francisco International Airport (SFO) has implemented a Climate Action Plan as part of its Strategic Plan. The plan aims to reduce greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) by 50% by 2021 from a 1990 baseline. SFO focuses on indoor air quality and takes a comprehensive approach, including source control, ventilation design, and building commissioning. They also work with the Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD) to monitor ozone and fine particulate matter levels and notify residents of unhealthy levels.

The City and County of San Francisco have also developed the Air Quality Element of the General Plan to improve air quality and comply with state and federal standards. This includes cooperating with regional agencies and implementing transportation and land-use policies that align with clean air goals.

To reduce pollution from automobiles, the Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG) projects that increasing employment in San Francisco will result in more commute trips, which could lead to greater air pollution if not managed properly. Encouraging alternative modes of transportation and reducing emissions from vehicles can help improve air quality in the region.

Overall, San Francisco has made great strides in improving its air quality, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic when fewer people were driving. However, as the city returns to normal activity, a continued focus on implementing the Climate Action Plan and promoting clean air initiatives will be essential to maintaining and further enhancing the air quality in the Bay Area.

Frequently asked questions