Lake Erie's Pollution Problem: A Troubled Waterway

Lake Erie is the smallest and shallowest of the Great Lakes, with shores in several states, including Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, New York, and the Canadian province of Ontario. It is the source of drinking water for about 11 million people. However, Lake Erie is also the most industrialized of the Great Lakes and is susceptible to pollution from various sources, including industrial waste, agricultural runoff, and sewage. By the 1960s, the lake had become extremely polluted, leading to the coining of the phrase Lake Erie is dead. While some efforts have been made to improve water quality, such as the Clean Water Act passed by Congress in 1972, Lake Erie continues to face pollution issues, particularly from excess phosphorus pollution, which contributes to harmful algal blooms and eutrophic conditions.

Industrial pollution

Lake Erie is the shallowest and most industrialized of the Great Lakes, making it the most susceptible to pollution. By the 1960s, the lake had become extremely polluted, largely due to the heavy industry that lined its shores. Factories dumped pollutants into the lake and the waterways that flowed into it, such as the Cuyahoga River, without much government oversight. This industrial pollution, along with agricultural and urban runoff, led to increased levels of phosphorus and nitrogen in the lake, contributing to eutrophication and harmful algal blooms.

The industrial pollution of Lake Erie during the 1950s and 1960s was well-documented, with the river's brown and polluted waters making headlines. In 1969, the Cuyahoga River caught fire, bringing negative publicity to Cleveland and its polluted waterways. This incident, along with the declining health of the lake, sparked a national movement against water pollution and led to the Federal government's intervention.

As a result of the pollution, Lake Erie became known as the "dead" lake, with dead fish littering the shoreline due to a lack of oxygen in the water. The phrase "Lake Erie is dead" started to appear in national publications in the late 1960s, reflecting the dire state of the lake. This perception of the lake as ""dying"" brought attention to the issue of water pollution and resulted in efforts to improve water quality.

To address the pollution, Congress passed the Clean Water Act in 1972, tightening regulations on industrial dumping. Additionally, the United States and Canada signed the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement to reduce the amount of pollutants entering the Great Lakes. Local governments also took steps to improve sewer systems and monitor water quality more effectively. These efforts led to a decline in open lake phosphorus concentrations and represented a successful collaboration between countries to produce environmental results.

However, despite these improvements, Lake Erie continues to face pollution challenges. Beginning in the late 1990s, harmful algal blooms returned and have plagued the lake every summer since, impacting the lake's ecosystem, tourism industry, and drinking water quality for the 12 million people it serves. While industrial pollution has been mitigated to some extent, the current wave of pollution is largely attributed to industrial-scale agricultural operations and manure runoff, which remain unregulated.

Agricultural pollution

Lake Erie is the smallest and shallowest of the Great Lakes, and it is also the most industrialized. It is largely agricultural, intensively industrialized, and highly urbanized, with about one-third of the total population of the Great Lakes basin residing within its watershed. Due to its shallow waters, it is also the most susceptible to pollution.

In the 1960s, Lake Erie was perceived to be "dying" due to extreme pollution, in part caused by heavy industry and agricultural runoff. Fertilizer and pesticides from agricultural runoff, as well as pollutants from factories, sewers, and waterways, increased the levels of phosphorus and nitrogen in the lake. This contributed to eutrophication, encouraging the development of harmful algal blooms that impaired the recreation economy and threatened drinking water sources.

Today, Lake Erie continues to face pollution challenges, particularly from agricultural sources. Excess phosphorus pollution, largely from the agricultural industry upstream in the Maumee River Watershed, is a significant contributor to the lake's algae problem. Liquified animal waste from concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs) leaches into the water, causing frequent algal blooms that can shut down drinking water supplies and harm local communities.

Efforts to curb agricultural pollution in Lake Erie have been met with challenges. While some states, like Michigan, have implemented programs to help farmers reduce runoff and connect them to federal funding, critics argue that voluntary programs are insufficient. Environmental groups have pushed for the creation of a pollution diet, known as a Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL), and stronger enforcement of farm pollution limits. However, the development and implementation of effective solutions are complex due to the basin's multi-state and international nature.

Climate change further complicates the issue, as wetter springs and heavier rainfall can increase nutrient-laden runoff into the lake, despite farmers' efforts to reduce fertilizer use. Warmer temperatures, on the other hand, may offset the impact of heavier rain by increasing evaporation and reducing runoff.

Sewage treatment plants

Lake Erie is the shallowest and most industrialized of the Great Lakes, making it the most susceptible to pollution. The lake is surrounded by urban and agricultural land, which contributes to immense sediment loads in the lake. The lake's watershed is home to about 12 million people, and it provides drinking water for about 11 million of them.

During the 1960s, water quality issues in the Great Lakes became a concern, and Lake Erie was perceived to be "dying". This was due to the heavy industry that lined its shores, with factories dumping pollutants into the lake and the waterways that flowed into it. Waste from city sewers, fertilizer, and pesticides from agricultural runoff also made their way into the lake, leading to increased levels of phosphorus and nitrogen, which contributed to eutrophication and encouraged the development of algal blooms.

In recent years, there have been record-setting algal blooms and associated "dead zones", which are oxygen-depleted areas created when algae die and decompose. These events negatively impact the lake's critical $12.9 billion tourism industry and world-class fishery. The algal blooms in Lake Erie are caused by excess phosphorus pollution, nearly 90% of which comes from the booming agricultural industry upstream in the Maumee River Watershed.

To address the issue of pollution in Lake Erie, regulatory agencies in Canada and the United States agreed in the late 1960s that limiting phosphorus loads was essential to controlling excessive algal growth. This joint effort led to a decline in open-lake phosphorus concentrations. In 1972, the two countries signed the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement to further reduce the amount of pollutants entering the Great Lakes.

Additionally, there have been efforts to improve sewage treatment facilities in the Lake Erie region. Small flow treatment facilities (SFTFs) are designed to treat 2,000 gallons of sewage or less per day. These facilities are permitted through the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and monitored by local health departments. While challenges remain, such as removing ammonia from the water, there have been innovative solutions, such as using cattails and oxygenation to improve water quality.

Algal blooms

Lake Erie is the shallowest and most industrialized of the Great Lakes, and as a result, it is the most susceptible to pollution. The lake's algae problem is caused by excess phosphorus pollution, which, in turn, is caused by the booming agricultural industry upstream in the Maumee River Watershed. Liquified animal waste from concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs) is leaching into the lake at growing rates.

Excess phosphorus and nitrogen in the lake contribute to eutrophication, a process that encourages the development of algal blooms. These harmful algal blooms are capable of producing toxins that can cause skin rashes, GI problems, and varying degrees of damage to a person's liver, kidneys, and nervous system. Some algae even produce microcystin bacteria, which is more poisonous than cyanide and can cause liver damage in humans and animals.

Each summer, communities and businesses around Lake Erie worry about and plan for toxic algae blooms, wondering if the algae will contaminate their drinking water. In 2014, a massive algal bloom shut down Toledo's drinking water supply to 400,000 people for three days, and the National Guard was deployed to bring in bottled water. The harmful algal blooms have also impacted the local economy, impairing the recreation industry and threatening drinking water. Communities along the lake are spending millions on water treatment.

Scientists report that reducing the amount of runoff pollution will significantly reduce Lake Erie's algal blooms and improve the lake's health. However, very few rules are in place to limit runoff pollution from big farms. In the absence of mandatory regulations to reduce runoff pollution, local governments and communities are bearing the brunt of the negative impacts of algal blooms, both in terms of health and the economy.

Eutrophication

Lake Erie is the smallest and shallowest of the Great Lakes, with a large population living in its basin and sprawling farmland and big cities dominating its watershed. The lake is largely agricultural, intensively industrialized, and highly urbanized. It is the most susceptible to pollution of all the Great Lakes.

By the 1960s, Lake Erie had become extremely polluted, largely due to heavy industry that lined its shores. The lake was perceived to be "dying", with national publications coining the phrase "Lake Erie is dead". The Cuyahoga River, which flows into the lake, was described as "brown and polluted" in 1966, and even caught fire in 1969.

Factories dumped pollutants, including chemical pollutants, into the lake and its waterways, with little government oversight. Waste from city sewers, industrial plants, and agricultural runoff also made their way into the lake. As a result, Lake Erie contained increased levels of phosphorus and nitrogen, which contributed to eutrophication. Eutrophication is an excessive nutrient enrichment process that encourages the development of algal blooms.

Eutrophic conditions promote plant and algae growth. Eutrophication in Lake Erie has resulted in severe algal fouling, creating aesthetic, taste, and odor problems, as well as reducing available oxygen and leading to fish die-offs. The western basin of Lake Erie is highly eutrophic, with high phosphorus and chlorophyll concentrations and harmful algal blooms.

The agricultural industry upstream in the Maumee River Watershed is a major contributor to the excess phosphorus pollution in Lake Erie. Liquified animal waste from concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs) is leaching into the water, and this will continue until adequate policies are in place.

Frequently asked questions