Nuclear Power's Watery Grave: Pollution's Lingering Legacy

Nuclear power plants have been a source of debate for decades, with proponents touting their ability to generate electricity without producing air pollution or carbon dioxide emissions, while opponents highlight the potential dangers of radioactive waste and thermal water pollution. The latter is a less obvious but significant form of pollution, where nuclear power plants discharge wastewater at higher temperatures, impacting the temperature of surrounding bodies of water and affecting both ecosystems and human populations. Additionally, the processes involved in uranium mining and refining, as well as the creation of radioactive wastes, pose risks of water contamination. The rare but catastrophic nuclear accidents, such as Fukushima Daiichi and Chernobyl, have also led to the release of radioactive material into nearby water sources. As the world embraces nuclear power as a solution to climate change, managing radioactive waste and mitigating water pollution become crucial aspects to safeguard the environment and human health.

Radioactive waste

The creation, handling, transportation, storage, and disposal of radioactive waste are subject to strict regulations to protect human health and the environment. However, accidents and natural disasters can lead to the uncontrolled release of radioactive material, as seen in the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster, where a tsunami caused a release of radioactive material into the surrounding water. The decision to release contaminated water into the ocean has divided opinions, with some arguing it is the most pragmatic long-term solution, while others are concerned about the potential effects on marine and human life.

The challenge of long-term waste disposal remains, and improving existing nuclear facilities to minimise waste generation is crucial. For instance, forcing radioactive byproducts to decay faster could be one approach. Additionally, there is a need for internationally accepted regulations for radiation exposure levels to safeguard human health and the environment effectively.

While serious accidents in nuclear power plants are rare, the potential impact of radioactive waste on the environment and human health is significant. The large amounts of data gathered from disaster sites have contributed to advancements in nuclear security, and the management of waste from nuclear reactors is generally considered safe. However, the long-term effects of radioactive waste releases, particularly into bodies of water, are still not fully understood, and ongoing research and transparency are essential to address these concerns.

Uranium mining

Firstly, uranium mining often involves extracting uranium from rock, which leaves behind radioactive waste. Uranium eventually decays to form radium, and subsequently, radon—a radioactive gas. While open-pit uranium mining and in-situ mining sites do not pose a significant radon risk to the public or miners as the gas disperses into the atmosphere, the waste rock produced by these processes has caused problems. For instance, on Navajo lands, abandoned uranium mines from the 20th century and their waste remain, and the wind can blow radioactive dust from the waste into populated areas, contaminating surface water sources.

Secondly, uranium mining can result in the generation of acid mine drainage (AMD), which contains high concentrations of fluoride, sulfate, manganese, zinc, aluminum, and uranium. AMD is often observed in mine sites with sulfide rocks, where the oxidation of metal sulfides produces sulfuric acid and discharge metals, leading to potential toxicity. This has been observed in Caldas, Brazil, where the treated uranium mine effluent is discharged into the Antas reservoir, contributing to high hardness values in water samples.

Moreover, uranium mining can increase dissolved radioactive materials in bodies of water. For example, a uranium mine located near Gallup, New Mexico, led to increased uranium and radium activities in the Puerco River from 1967 until 1986. The radionuclide activities declined once water treatment was initiated in the mid-1970s to comply with the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System's limitations.

Additionally, uranium mining and processing can result in physical and chemical impacts on water sources. Open-pit mines generate dust that enters the air and can eventually settle in water bodies, leading to increased sediment loads and habitat disturbance. Subsurface mines require ventilation systems, and while air pollution controls can be installed, vented dust can still enter the ambient air and potentially settle in water sources. Chemical impacts may include emissions from diesel equipment or contaminated water from mine pits.

The pollution caused by uranium mining can have lasting effects on deep water, impacting biogeochemical cycles. It is essential to implement proper monitoring, handling, storage, and disposal procedures to protect human health and the environment from the adverse effects of uranium mining on water sources.

Thermal water pollution

Nuclear power plants have been found to cause thermal water pollution, which is a less obvious but impactful consequence of power generation. This occurs when nuclear power plants use water from lakes, rivers, or oceans for cooling. The water absorbs heat from the plant, and when it is discharged back into the body of water, it raises the temperature of the surrounding water, causing thermal pollution. This can have far-reaching effects on both the ecosystem and human populations.

For example, the Danube River in Romania exhibits a thermal plume current due to discharge from two nuclear power plants. This current extends up to 6 km downstream, and temperature changes of up to 1.5°C between plume and non-plume areas have been measured. Similarly, a study of 128 power plants along the Mississippi River Watershed found that thermal pollution significantly impaired the energy efficiency of downstream plants, as they use warmed upstream water for cooling.

The near field of power plants, where there are strong shear velocities and rapid temperature changes, is particularly stressful for fish. To mitigate this, there may be stringent limitations on the timing and strength of discharges to reduce these stresses to non-damaging levels. Off-stream cooling systems can also be used to reduce the impact on water temperatures, although they may increase cloudiness, ground fog, precipitation, temperature, and local winds.

While nuclear power plants have lower thermal efficiencies than conventional thermal power plants, they release a higher percentage of their wastewater as liquid effluent streams instead of vapour. This is because coal and natural gas plants discharge wastewater at much higher temperatures, so the impact on water temperatures is more significant. The use of cooling towers can help to avoid excessive heating of rivers, but it is not always possible to utilize all the heat produced, especially in summer.

Safety and security

One critical aspect of safety is the management of radioactive waste. Nuclear power plants generate high-level and low-level radioactive waste. High-level waste includes spent nuclear fuel, which remains highly radioactive and must be stored in specially designed pools of water or dry storage containers. Low-level waste includes contaminated tools, protective clothing, and other disposable items, which are also subject to strict regulations for handling, storage, and disposal to prevent environmental contamination.

The cooling process in nuclear power plants relies on water, and this water becomes contaminated with radionuclides. To prevent the release of radioactive wastewater into the environment, it undergoes filtration to remove radionuclides, followed by storage in large steel tanks. However, in some cases, it may be released into nearby bodies of water, as seen in the aftermath of the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear accident, where the Japanese government decided to release over a million tonnes of radioactive water into the ocean.

To ensure the safe operation of nuclear power plants, stringent safety measures and redundant barriers are implemented. These include control rods that prevent uncontrolled chain reactions, as well as containment structures designed to withstand extreme weather events and contain accidental releases of radiation. Additionally, a large area surrounding a nuclear power plant is restricted and guarded by armed security teams, further enhancing security.

While serious accidents in nuclear power plants are rare, the potential impact on human health and the environment cannot be overlooked. The creation of exclusion zones and the resettlement of populations, as seen in the Chernobyl and Fukushima Daiichi incidents, underscore the importance of safety and security measures. The continuous advancement of nuclear security, informed by data gathered from disaster sites, plays a crucial role in mitigating risks and enhancing the overall safety of nuclear power generation.

Accidents and disasters

One of the most well-known nuclear disasters is the Chernobyl accident in 1986, where an uncontrolled nuclear reaction led to the release of large quantities of radioactive material into the environment. The area surrounding the plant became heavily contaminated, and an "exclusion zone" was established, displacing approximately 350,000 people. The accident also had significant impacts on nearby bodies of water, as the water used to cool the reactor became contaminated and was released into the surrounding environment.

Another notable nuclear accident that impacted bodies of water was the Fukushima Daiichi disaster in 2011. A tsunami caused by an earthquake disabled the power supply and cooling systems of three reactors and four spent nuclear fuel storage pools. This resulted in the release of radioactive material into the air and water, including the ocean nearby. Authorities used over a million tonnes of water to cool the disabled reactors, and the decision was made to release this radioactive water into the ocean, sparking concerns about potential unknown effects on marine and human life.

Nuclear power plants also contribute to thermal water pollution, where the water used for cooling is released into the environment, raising the temperature of nearby water bodies. This can have lasting effects on deep-water biogeochemical cycles and impair the energy efficiency of downstream plants. For instance, the Danube River in Romania exhibits a thermal plume current due to discharge from nuclear power plants, causing temperature changes of up to 1.5°C between plume and non-plume areas.

While nuclear reactors do not produce air pollution or carbon dioxide during operation, the processes of mining and refining uranium ore can impact bodies of water. Underground mining exposes workers to high levels of radon gas, increasing the risk of lung cancer. Additionally, surface or open-pit mining can result in increased erosion, landslides, and polluted soil and water due to the large amount of blasted earth and radioactive, toxic leftover material.

Frequently asked questions