Detroit's Air Pollution Crisis: Causes And Concerns

Detroit, Michigan's largest city, is a highly polluted city. In 2024, the Detroit metro area was ranked 13th worst in the nation for annual particle pollution, with Wayne County, Michigan, receiving a failing grade for pollution levels above the federal standard. Detroit's air pollution is caused by a variety of factors, including heavy industrial activity, transportation, and climate change, which have led to increased levels of nitrogen dioxide, volatile organic compounds, and ground-level ozone. Southwest Detroit, in particular, has been identified as a public health crisis due to its dense concentration of heavy industry, including an oil refinery, steel plants, and a coal-burning power plant, which emit high levels of harmful pollutants. The area's residential population, largely comprising racial minorities and low-income communities, faces challenges in accessing quality healthcare and lacks the resources to address the air pollution issue.

Detroit's climate is influenced by the Great Lakes, with cold winters and hot summers

Detroit's climate is significantly influenced by the Great Lakes, resulting in distinct cold winters and hot summers. The Great Lakes affect the surrounding region's climate and weather, particularly during the summer and winter seasons. In the summer, the lakes act as a heat sink, absorbing heat and keeping the surrounding air cooler. This phenomenon leads to a notable difference in temperature between areas closer to the lakes and those located a few hundred feet inland. Conversely, during the winter, the lakes can be warmer than the air, influencing the local climate.

Detroit's geographic location in the Great Lakes region contributes to its unique climate characteristics. The Great Lakes, as the name suggests, are a collection of large lakes, including Lake Superior, Lake Michigan, Lake Huron, Lake Erie, and Lake Ontario. These lakes play a crucial role in shaping the local climate and have a considerable impact on the surrounding states and provinces, including Michigan, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Pennsylvania, New York, and the Canadian province of Ontario.

The Great Lakes region, including Detroit, experiences cold winters due to the interaction of several atmospheric factors. Cold air from Canada often moves southward and combines with warm, humid air from the Gulf of Mexico, leading to the formation of significant winter storms. These storms can generate very high waves within the lakes, impacting the local weather conditions. Additionally, during the winter, the lakes themselves can experience freezing temperatures, with ice coverage varying from year to year. For example, in 2024, the lakes had record-low ice coverage at the beginning of the year, but a subsequent cold snap increased ice levels to a seasonal maximum of 16% on January 22.

In contrast, the summers in the Great Lakes region can be quite warm, with the lakes influencing the temperature patterns. The lakes act as a heat source, warming the surrounding air and protecting fruit crops from early frosts. This phenomenon is particularly beneficial for the region's agriculture, as it helps extend the growing season and supports the cultivation of various crops.

While the Great Lakes exert a notable influence on Detroit's climate, other factors also contribute to the city's weather patterns and seasonal variations. Local wind patterns, prevailing atmospheric conditions, and the region's topography all play a role in shaping the local climate. Additionally, the urban heat island effect, resulting from the concentration of buildings, infrastructure, and human activity in Detroit, can also impact the city's temperature, particularly during the warmer months.

Detroit, like many urban areas, faces challenges with air pollution, which has a significant impact on the health and well-being of its residents. Southwest Detroit has been identified as an area with some of the highest levels of air pollution in Michigan and the country. Industrial sources, including factories, refineries, and power plants, are major contributors to the poor air quality in this region. Community organizations, health providers, and researchers are collaborating to address these pollution challenges and improve the health outcomes for Detroit's communities.

The city's air pollution is caused by coal-fired power plants and heavy industry

Detroit, Michigan's largest city, is an industrial metropolis known as the Motor City. The city's air pollution is caused by a combination of factors, including coal-fired power plants and heavy industry.

Coal-fired power plants in Detroit have been major contributors to air pollution. For example, the River Rouge Power Plant, a coal-fired plant in Southwest Detroit, lacked modern pollution controls and was surrounded by low-income communities of colour. This plant emitted harmful pollutants like nitrogen oxide, sulfur dioxide, and particulate matter, contributing to respiratory issues and other health problems. In 2016, community members and leaders advocated for lowering sulfur dioxide levels, leading to the retirement of one of the plant's coal-fired boilers by 2021. Detroit Edison (DTE) is another operator that has come under legal scrutiny for its coal-burning power plants in Southern Michigan, which emitted thousands of tons of additional pollutants annually.

Detroit's heavy industry, including industrial facilities and transportation corridors, also plays a significant role in air pollution. Industrial and transportation activity increases harmful gas pollution levels, particularly nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). When these gases react with heat and sunlight, they create ozone, a highly irritating gas pollutant. Additionally, the burning of wood in fireplaces for heat during colder months contributes to particle pollution in Detroit.

Climate change is another factor driving air pollution in Detroit. Wildfires, such as those in Canada in 2023, can bring smoke and particulate matter pollution to the city. Climate change intensifies these events and makes air pollution more challenging to manage.

Community organisations, health providers, and researchers are collaborating to address Detroit's air pollution challenges. Initiatives like the Community Action to Promote Healthy Environments (CAPHE) aim to develop and implement community-led public health action plans to reduce air pollution and improve health outcomes in Detroit and surrounding communities.

Southwest Detroit is the most polluted region, with a dense concentration of industry

Southwest Detroit has the highest levels of air pollution in Michigan and is ranked among the top 5% in the country. This is due to the dense concentration of heavy industry in the area, which emits higher levels of harmful particulate matter than in other regions. Within two zip codes in the city of Detroit, there are more than 150 facilities that emit toxic fumes, gases, chemicals, and particulate matter.

Among these facilities are a sprawling oil refinery that processes dirty Canadian tar sands, two aging steel plants, a coke battery plant that converts coal into fuel for steel furnaces, and a coal-burning power plant. Industries like U.S. Steel and Marathon Petroleum Refinery have been producing heavy pollutants for generations. With such a high quantity and concentration of industrial factories contributing to air pollution, identifying a single culprit is impossible.

The residential population of Southwest Detroit is largely comprised of racial minorities and people with lower incomes. Specifically, 57% of the community identifies as Latino, and 23% identify as Black. Almost half of all adults lack a high school diploma. Systemic racism, limited financial resources, and low educational attainment make the community of Southwest Detroit vulnerable to exploitation.

Community organizations, health providers, and public health researchers are working together to address the area's pollution challenges and improve the health and well-being of the community. Michigan Public Health researchers are fostering collaborations with community stakeholders to promote health equity through community-academic partnerships. One example is the Community Action to Promote Healthy Environments (CAPHE), which aims to develop and implement a community-led public health action plan to reduce air pollution and improve health outcomes in Detroit and surrounding communities.

The city's particle pollution is above the federal standard, with high levels of PM2.5

Detroit's air quality has been a matter of concern, with the city ranking 13th worst in the nation for annual particle pollution, according to the American Lung Association's 2024 "State of the Air" report. The city's particle pollution is above the federal standard, with high levels of PM2.5, or particulate matter that is 2.5 micrometres or less in diameter. These fine particles can originate from various sources, including industrial emissions, vehicle traffic, and power plants.

Southwest Detroit has been identified as an area with some of the highest levels of air pollution in Michigan and the country. The area is home to more than 150 facilities that emit toxic fumes, gases, chemicals, and particulate matter. Major industrial sources in Southwest Detroit include an oil refinery, steel plants, a coke battery plant, and a coal-burning power plant. The concentration of these industrial factories has made it challenging to identify a single culprit for the area's poor air quality.

The University of Michigan School of Public Health has conducted studies to identify the major sources of PM2.5 in Southwest Detroit, using data collected over six years (2016-2021) and comparing it with previous data from 2001-2014. Their findings contribute to the understanding of Detroit's air pollution sources and inform efforts to improve air quality and public health in the affected communities.

The high levels of PM2.5 in Detroit's air have significant health implications. Particulate matter of this size can penetrate deep into the respiratory system, causing respiratory issues and other adverse health effects. The National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (NIEHS) estimates that 9 out of 10 urban area residents are impacted by air pollution, underscoring the urgency of addressing this issue. Community organizations, health providers, and public health researchers are collaborating to address Detroit's pollution challenges and improve the health and well-being of the community.

While Detroit's air quality has shown some improvement over the years, with a decrease in PM2.5 concentrations between 2006 and 2010, the city continues to face challenges in reducing air pollution to meet federal standards. Climate change, wildland fires, and industrial activity contribute to episodic spikes in pollution levels. Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic had a negligible long-term impact on PM2.5 levels, as traffic and industrial sources resumed near-normal levels after short-lived decreases during the initial lockdown phase.

Detroit's air quality has improved since the 2000s, but climate change is worsening pollution

Detroit's air quality has improved over the past few decades, particularly since the turn of the century. University of Michigan public health researchers state that air quality in southeast Michigan, where Detroit is located, has improved significantly since the passage of the Clean Air Act 50 years ago. Detroit's air quality improved steadily during the 2000s, and levels of ozone and particle pollution have improved along three key metrics since the year 2000. The Biden administration has made progress in addressing air pollution by updating particle pollution standards, addressing leaks from oil and gas production facilities, and improving pollution standards for cars, trucks, and buses.

Despite these improvements, Detroit continues to rank among the worst cities in the nation for annual particle pollution. The Detroit metro area was ranked 13th worst in the nation for annual particle pollution in the American Lung Association's 2024 "State of the Air" report. Detroit's year-round particle pollution levels have improved since the previous year's report, but the city is still ranked 16th most polluted in that category. The report also found that Detroit experienced more unhealthy days due to short-term spikes in particle pollution than the previous year.

Southwest Detroit, in particular, has the highest levels of air pollution in Michigan and ranks among the top 5% in the country. The residential population of Southwest Detroit is largely comprised of racial minorities and people with lower incomes, who lack the political connections and economic resources to lobby against the corporate titans responsible for the air pollution. There are more than 150 facilities that emit toxic fumes, gases, chemicals, and particulate matter within two zip codes that encompass Southwest Detroit, including an oil refinery, two steel plants, a coke battery plant, and a coal-burning power plant.

Climate change is worsening pollution in Detroit, making it more difficult to clean up. Wildfires and heat increase ozone and particulate matter pollution, erasing some of the progress made in reducing air pollution. The 2023 Canadian wildfires, for example, led to unprecedented levels of pollution in Midwestern cities like Detroit. As the climate crisis intensifies, the number of hot days and the likelihood of wildfires will continue to increase, further degrading air quality.

Frequently asked questions