Utah's Ecosystems: Pollution's Impact And Consequences

Utah's air quality is often ranked among the worst in the United States, with Salt Lake City, Provo-Orem, and Logan being the cities with the highest levels of ozone and particle pollution. The state's unique topography, with its steep mountain ranges, can cause pollutants to build up near the surface, especially during inversions. This, combined with emissions from vehicles, wood-burning for home heating, industry, and agriculture, leads to a range of negative health and environmental effects. The Great Salt Lake ecosystem, for example, is under threat due to increased dust, elevated salinity, habitat loss, and other factors linked to poor air quality.

The impact of PM2.5 and PM10 particulate matter

PM2.5 and PM10 are particulate matter, or a complex mixture of small solid particles and liquid droplets in the air. PM2.5 is the main component of Utah's wintertime air pollution. PM2.5 particulates are fine, inhalable particles or droplets with a diameter of 2.5 microns or smaller. These are about 30 times smaller than the width of a human hair and can travel deeply into the lungs, causing both short-term and long-term health effects. Sources of PM2.5 are broken down into three categories: point sources (large stationary industrial or commercial facilities), mobile sources (non-stationary sources such as vehicles, trains and aircraft), and area sources (smaller stationary sources such as emissions from home heating and small businesses).

PM10, on the other hand, refers to inhalable coarse particles that are less than 10 microns in diameter but greater than 2.5 microns. While PM10 can compromise respiratory and cardiac health, PM2.5 poses a greater risk because of its ability to penetrate deeply into the lungs, causing inflammation and damaging lung tissue. Exposure to PM10 has been linked to coughing and wheezing, asthma attacks, and aggravation of lung and heart conditions.

Both PM2.5 and PM10 can be inhaled, but their deposition in the lungs depends on particle size. PM2.5 is more likely to travel into and deposit on the surface of the deeper parts of the lung, while PM10 is more likely to deposit on the surfaces of the larger airways of the upper region of the lung. Deposition of particles on the lung surface can induce tissue damage and lung inflammation.

Short-term exposure to PM2.5 has been associated with premature mortality, increased hospital admissions for heart or lung causes, acute and chronic bronchitis, asthma attacks, emergency room visits, respiratory symptoms, and restricted activity days. These adverse health effects have been reported primarily in infants, children, and older adults with pre-existing heart or lung diseases. Long-term exposure to PM2.5 has been linked to premature death, particularly in people with chronic heart or lung diseases, and reduced lung function growth in children.

Short-term exposure to PM10 has been associated with the worsening of respiratory diseases, including asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), leading to hospitalisation and emergency department visits. The effects of long-term exposure to PM10 are less clear, although studies suggest a link between long-term PM10 exposure and respiratory mortality.

In summary, PM2.5 and PM10 particulate matter have significant impacts on the health of Utahns, particularly those with pre-existing respiratory and cardiac conditions. The small size of PM2.5 particles allows them to penetrate deeply into the lungs, causing inflammation and tissue damage, while PM10 particles impact the upper regions of the lung. Exposure to both types of particulate matter has been linked to a range of adverse health effects, including respiratory issues, heart problems, and premature mortality.

The role of vehicles in air pollution

Vehicles release oxides of nitrogen (NOx), which are poisonous and highly reactive gases formed by burning fuel at high temperatures. NOx emissions from automobiles and non-road vehicles, such as planes and boats, contribute to the formation of ground-level ozone. This ozone is harmful to both human health and vegetation, causing issues like chest pain, coughing, and throat irritation. It is a key component of summertime smog and haze in Utah.

Additionally, vehicles are a source of particulate matter (PM), which is a complex mixture of extremely small dust and soot particles. PM2.5, microscopic particles with a diameter of less than 2.5 micrometers, is the main component of Utah's wintertime air pollution. Vehicles contribute to PM2.5 levels through emissions and by stirring up dust on roads. Exposure to PM2.5 can lead to respiratory issues, decreased lung function, and potential cardiovascular and neurological problems.

Carbon monoxide (CO) emissions from automobiles are also a concern. High levels of CO can reduce the supply of oxygen in the bloodstream, causing acute health issues. Moreover, vehicles contribute to the formation of sulfur oxides (SO2) through the combustion of fossil fuels. While catalytic converters have helped reduce SO2 levels in Utah, these gases still contribute to the formation of acid rain, which damages lakes, aquatic life, and plant life.

To address vehicle-related air pollution, Utah has implemented measures such as encouraging carpooling, public transit, and electric vehicle adoption. However, there have been conflicting policies, with some laws imposing additional fees on clean fuel vehicles, potentially slowing the transition to cleaner transportation options. Overall, vehicles play a significant role in Utah's air pollution, impacting both human health and the environment.

The effect of wildfires on air quality

Wildfires have a significant impact on air quality in Utah, and their smoke can travel thousands of miles, affecting areas far from the fire source. The smoke from wildfires is a complex mixture of gases and fine particles, including carbon dioxide, water vapour, carbon monoxide, particulate matter (PM10 and PM2.5), hydrocarbons, and nitrogen oxides.

PM2.5, or fine particulate matter with diameters of 2.5 micrometres or less, is the primary health concern from wildfire smoke exposure. These tiny particles can lodge deep in the lungs, causing or exacerbating respiratory and cardiovascular issues. They can also enter the bloodstream, leading to irregular heartbeats, heart attacks, and strokes. The health effects of PM2.5 are particularly harmful to vulnerable groups, including young children, the elderly, pregnant women, and people with existing heart or lung conditions. During periods of high PM2.5 concentrations, these individuals are advised to reduce physical activity and minimise outdoor exposure.

In Utah, wildfires have led to elevated levels of PM2.5, with smoke drifting in from fires in neighbouring states such as California, Idaho, Nevada, and Arizona. For example, in August 2020, smoke from California fires caused PM2.5 levels in Cache County, Utah, to exceed the federal threshold by more than 2.5 times. Similarly, in August 2021, smoke from the Dixie Fire and other West Coast fires caused PM2.5 levels in Salt Lake City to spike to over three times the federal standard, temporarily giving the area the worst air quality in the world.

Wildfires are considered "exceptional events" in air quality modelling due to their unpredictable nature and the difficulty in controlling or preventing them. They can rapidly increase pollutant concentrations, particularly downwind of the events, and their impact on air quality can last for days or weeks. The effects of wildfire smoke on air quality are not limited to outdoor environments but can also penetrate indoor spaces, posing risks to those spending time indoors.

To mitigate the health risks associated with wildfire smoke exposure, it is essential for individuals to stay informed about current air quality conditions and take appropriate precautions. Various tools are available to help track air quality, including apps and websites that provide real-time data. During periods of high smoke concentrations, it is recommended to minimise outdoor activity, especially for vulnerable individuals, and to take steps to reduce exposure indoors, such as using air purifiers or wearing masks designed to filter out fine particles.

The impact of ozone pollution

Ozone pollution, formed by the presence of heat and sunshine interacting with "ozone precursors" like nitrogen oxides (NOx) and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), is a major concern in Utah, particularly during the summer months. This type of pollution is invisible but extremely harmful to human health.

Ozone is a gas made up of three oxygen molecules. While "good ozone" in the stratosphere protects us from the sun's harmful UV radiation, "bad ozone," or ground-level ozone, is detrimental to our health. Major sources of these precursor emissions in Utah include transportation, industrial facilities, and oil and gas production. Once formed, ozone can travel across regions and states, affecting people far from the original pollutant sources.

Exposure to ozone pollution has been likened to getting a sunburn on your lungs. It can damage lung tissue, the respiratory and cardiovascular systems, and other organ systems. Even low amounts can cause chest pain, coughing, shortness of breath, and throat irritation. Long-term exposure has been linked to chronic respiratory issues and an increased risk of respiratory infections. Vulnerable groups, such as children, the elderly, pregnant individuals, those with pre-existing lung conditions, and people who engage in outdoor physical activities, are at particularly high risk.

In Utah, areas like the northern valleys, including Salt Lake City, experience some of the worst air quality in the nation during the winter due to geography and human emissions. However, in the summer, ozone pollution becomes the primary concern. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has reclassified the Northern Wasatch Front area, which includes Salt Lake and Davis counties, as well as parts of Tooele and Weber counties, from "marginal" to "moderate" nonattainment, reflecting worsening eight-hour average ozone levels.

To address ozone pollution, the EPA introduced the Cross-State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR) in March 2023, aiming to reduce nitrogen oxide pollution from power plants and industrial facilities in 24 states, including Utah. This rule holds out-of-state pollution sources accountable and requires states to submit plans to reduce emissions from fossil fuel-fired plants and industrial facilities. Despite resistance from Rocky Mountain Power and the state of Utah, collective action is necessary to protect communities from the harmful effects of ozone pollution.

The influence of geography on pollution

The unique geography of Utah has a significant influence on the state's pollution levels and subsequent impact on ecosystems. The state's topography, including its mountainous terrain, plays a crucial role in trapping pollutants near the surface, particularly during inversions. Inversions are common in Utah due to its mountainous landscape and cold winters. During these events, temperature increases with altitude, creating a warm inversion layer that prevents atmospheric mixing. This results in particulate matter, specifically PM2.5, being held close to the ground, leading to smog formation in the valleys of Northern Utah.

The Great Salt Lake, a prominent geographic feature in Utah, also contributes to the state's pollution levels. As the lake dries up, the exposed lakebed increases the amount of airborne dust, which further exacerbates air pollution. Additionally, the shrinking of the lake has raised concerns about the potential release of toxins and arsenic, posing risks to both human health and the environment.

Utah's geographic location within the Intermountain West region also influences its pollution levels. Wildfires in neighbouring states, such as California, Idaho, Nevada, and Arizona, have been known to significantly impact Utah's air quality. The smoke from these fires can drift into Utah, causing PM2.5 levels to exceed federal threshold levels.

Furthermore, Utah is not immune to global pollution sources. Ozone transport, the movement of ozone from one area to another, contributes to the state's ozone pollution levels. Intercontinental transport of ozone and nitrogen oxides from Asia has been shown to impact the western United States, including Utah. Stratospheric intrusions, where ozone from the upper atmosphere descends closer to the Earth's surface, can also increase ground-level ozone concentrations in the state.

The combination of Utah's unique topography, the presence of the Great Salt Lake, regional wildfire smoke, and global pollution sources creates a complex interplay that affects the state's pollution levels. These factors have direct consequences for Utah's ecosystems, including the Great Salt Lake ecosystem, which is crucial for migratory birds and the diverse wetlands it supports.

Frequently asked questions