Water Pollution's Impact On Italy's Environment And Health

Water pollution is a significant environmental issue in Italy. The nation's rivers, coasts, and lakes have been contaminated by industrial and agricultural pollutants, and its groundwater is being depleted by excessive use in agriculture. In 2017, Italy experienced its driest summer in 60 years, causing a water shortage that was exacerbated by a heatwave with temperatures soaring above 104°F (40°C). This has been linked to climate change and is expected to become more frequent and severe.

Italy's water infrastructure is struggling to cope with the country's high water demand. Agriculture is the main draw on Italy's water supply, as large areas of the country are not naturally suited for crops and require extensive irrigation. Of the water used for irrigation, 15% comes from non-renewable groundwater, twice as much as in Spain and seven times that of Greece.

In addition to agriculture, industry is the second-largest sector in terms of water usage. Industrial and domestic contaminants, including fertilizers, have seeped into the water table. In 2014, the European Court of Justice took legal action against the Italian government for failing to adequately treat water sources contaminated with calcium, arsenic, and fluoride.

Italy's water problems are also due in part to its unique geography. The country receives a good amount of rainfall most years, but it is not distributed evenly, with precipitation largely concentrated in the north during spring and autumn, and little reaching the south. Italy's mountainous terrain also makes it difficult to transfer water between regions.

To address its water crisis, Italy is investing in urgent upgrades to its water infrastructure and exploring solutions such as additional water storage and transfer schemes, desalination, and wastewater reuse.

Industrial and agricultural contaminants in rivers and coasts

Italy's coasts and rivers have been subjected to a strong impact by the increasing presence of industrial, mining, and agricultural activities. Consequently, the Italian government adopted a national program to protect human health and the environment from hazardous substances. This program identified many contaminated areas, which required cleanup actions and were defined as Sites of National Interest (SINs).

The marine areas included in the SINs are representative of sandy and rocky coastlines, lagoons, harbors, and river mouths. They are all subjected to a combination of impacts derived from industrial activities, incinerators, uncontrolled landfills, intensive agricultural activities, military arsenals, shipyards, and high maritime traffic. The main contaminants are metals and trace elements, heavy hydrocarbons, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), polychlorobiphenyls (PCBs), organochlorine pesticides, dioxins and furans, chlorinated organic solvents, and organotin compounds (TBTs).

Case Studies

The following are some case studies of SINs with industrial and agricultural contaminants:

• Bussi sul Tirino: Located in central Italy, Bussi is the biggest illegal toxic waste disposal site in Europe, with more than two million tons of soil and water tables contaminated by toxic compounds. The contamination profile includes PCDD/Fs, PCBs, PAHs, chlorinated solvents, mercury, and lead.
• Orbetello: This SIN includes a lagoon located close to Monte Argentario in southern Tuscany. The area has been impacted by mining activities, a fertilizer factory, and sewage effluents. The main contaminants are arsenic, cadmium, chromium, copper, mercury, lead, and zinc.
• Bagnoli: Located on the western coast of the Pozzuoli Gulf, this SIN includes an important steel plant that operated from 1910 to 1990. The main contaminants are iron, lead, zinc, and mercury, with high concentrations found in the sea bottom closest to the plant.
• Priolo: This SIN includes a large marine coastal area from Augusta Bay to Siracusa. The Augusta harbor, located within a natural bay, has been impacted by industrial activities, including a chlor-alkali plant that discharged over 500 tons of mercury directly into the sea. The main contaminants are mercury, barium, hexachlorobenzene, and PCBs.
• Sulcis: This SIN includes a large sector of southwestern Sardinia, with mining activities strongly impacting the marine areas. The main contaminants are cadmium, lead, zinc, arsenic, and mercury.

The Italian government has recognized the need for remediation of these sites to avoid environmental and health damage. However, in some cases, the remediation operations have not yet started, causing concern among the population and local authorities.

Lakes contaminated by acid rain

Italy's water bodies are susceptible to contamination from various sources, including industrial and agricultural activities. One particular issue affecting its lakes is acid rain, which poses a significant threat to the country's aquatic ecosystems. Acid rain occurs when emissions of sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides from fossil fuel combustion react with water, oxygen, and other chemicals in the atmosphere, resulting in a mild solution of sulfuric and nitric acid. This phenomenon has detrimental effects on Italy's lakes, their surrounding ecosystems, and human populations.

The lakes in Italy are particularly vulnerable to the effects of acid rain due to the sensitive nature of their watersheds. Acid rain falls onto forests, fields, and built environments, eventually flowing into streams, lakes, and marshes. It also falls directly into aquatic habitats. When lakes and their surrounding soils cannot adequately neutralise the incoming acid rain, their pH levels decrease, resulting in acidification. This process releases toxic aluminium into the water, which is harmful to many aquatic organisms, including fish. As the pH levels drop further, the number of fish species declines, and some lakes end up with no fish at all.

The impact of acid rain on Italy's lakes extends beyond the aquatic life. Frogs, for example, may be affected if they feed on insects that are sensitive to higher acidity levels. As biodiversity decreases, the ecosystem becomes more susceptible to other stressors such as pollution. Acid rain also poses risks to human populations, including the consumption of contaminated fish and shellfish, reduced enjoyment of lake ecosystems, and economic impacts on industries such as fishing and tourism.

The effects of acid rain on Italy's lakes are long-lasting and challenging to mitigate. While the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990 have helped regulate sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxide emissions, the threat of acid rain remains. If left unchecked, acidification rates of lakes are projected to rise significantly over time.

Addressing the issue of acid rain in Italy's lakes requires a comprehensive approach. Reducing emissions of sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxide is crucial, and while some progress has been made, fully eliminating acid rain could take decades. In the meantime, protecting and restoring Italy's lakes and their surrounding ecosystems is essential for mitigating the impacts on aquatic life and human populations alike.

Sewage and waste management

Italy's waste management sector is dynamic, contributing over 27 billion euros to the national economy each year. The country produces around 30 million tons of urban waste annually, with approximately half of it being recycled. This makes Italy the seventh-highest recycler in the EU. The country's waste management network comprises 657 operational structures, including organic fraction treatment facilities, mechanical or mechanical-biological treatment plants, landfills, and incineration plants.

Italy has embraced the conversion of waste to energy (WTE) as a key strategy for handling non-recyclable waste. WTE facilities process more than 6 million tons of urban waste every year, generating enough energy to power around 2.8 million households. This approach has the potential to contribute up to 8% of the country's electricity production.

In 2021, Italy produced about 10.7 million tons of hazardous special waste, with the construction and demolition sector being the largest contributor, accounting for 47.7% of the total. Waste treatment and remediation activities contributed 24.2%, while manufacturing activities contributed 18.2%. Special waste production is mainly concentrated in northern Italy, which represents 58.4% of the national total.

Italy is committed to meeting European standards for urban waste treatment and is focused on the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (PNRR). This plan involves significant investments to enhance the efficiency and sustainability of waste management, reduce landfill usage, promote material recovery, and modernise existing facilities.

The country is also exploring innovative technologies to improve waste management and environmental sustainability. This includes the development of waste monitoring systems, more efficient recycling technologies, and sustainable waste treatment processes. Additionally, public-private partnerships play a crucial role in implementing policies and initiatives aimed at improving waste management efficiency and sustainability.

Italy's sewage treatment infrastructure is facing challenges. In 2018, there were 17,897 operating plants, with the majority located in the North, particularly in Piedmont, Emilia-Romagna, Lombardy, and Veneto. While advanced plants are not the majority, they handle more than half (66.7%) of the polluting loads. However, there is still a gap between the demand for sewage treatment and the capacity to serve, with a demand of about 98 million equivalent inhabitants compared to 75 million served.

The European Union has been calling on member states, including Italy, to adapt wastewater treatment plants and sewage systems since 1991. In recent years, Italy has been sanctioned for non-compliance in certain urban areas.

Water scarcity

Italy is facing a growing water crisis, with water scarcity becoming an increasingly prominent issue. The country experiences significant regional disparities in rainfall, with Northern Italy receiving nearly twice as much precipitation as the south. This uneven distribution of water is further exacerbated by higher temperatures in the south, which contribute to increased evaporation. As a result, Italy's water availability is highly dependent on seasonality and regional variation.

In 2017, Italy faced its driest summer in 60 years, with up to 80% less rainfall than the historical average. This water shortage was compounded by a heatwave, with temperatures soaring above 104°F (40°C). Such extreme weather events are expected to become more frequent and severe due to climate change. The impact of these events is already being felt, with Venice's canals running dry, wildfires ravaging Sicily, and agricultural sectors suffering significant losses.

The availability of usable water in Italy is projected to worsen, with the country's high water stress rating predicted to increase by 25% during this century. This is further aggravated by issues with water management and infrastructure. Italy's water infrastructure is struggling to keep up with the demand, and the country has one of the highest water footprints in Europe, at 3012 cubic yards (2,303 cubic meters) per person per year, 25% above the European average.

To address water scarcity, Italy needs to invest in upgrading its water infrastructure, reducing water losses, and improving water management practices. This includes repairing and replacing outdated and inefficient parts of the network, as well as exploring additional water storage and transfer schemes. Italy also needs to optimize its water usage, especially in the agricultural sector, which accounts for a significant portion of water consumption.

Additionally, public awareness and education play a crucial role in water conservation. Small changes in behaviour, such as taking shorter showers, installing water-efficient appliances, and reducing unnecessary water usage, can lead to substantial water savings. By combining improved infrastructure, efficient water management, and responsible water usage, Italy can take significant steps towards alleviating its water scarcity issues.

Water infrastructure

Italy's water infrastructure is struggling to keep up with the nation's water demands. In 2017, Rome and Southern Italy suffered a prolonged drought and mounting water restrictions. This highlighted the fragility of the nation's water supply and raised the question, "How can Italy do better?".

Italy's distribution network handles just over ten billion cubic yards of water every year, of which nearly four billion cubic yards are lost to leaks. This has prompted increased investment and urgent upgrades at local and national levels, with a view to keeping more of Italy's potable water in the system. While better repairs, maintenance, and improvements will save water, stopping the leaks entirely could involve replacing the nation's entire water network—a huge undertaking in terms of time, effort, and money.

Italy's water infrastructure faces several challenges. Firstly, the country's rainfall, while abundant overall, is unevenly distributed, with precipitation largely concentrated in the north during the spring and autumn months, and less rainfall in the south. This regional disparity, coupled with Italy's mountainous terrain, makes it difficult to transfer surplus water between regions. As a result, although Italy receives approximately 392 billion cubic yards of water annually through rainfall and other sources, only about 76 billion cubic yards can be utilised.

The seasonality and variability of Italy's water resources also pose challenges for water infrastructure. The springs, lakes, and rivers that supply most Italian cities, towns, and villages can quickly dry up during prolonged dry spells. Climate change is expected to exacerbate this issue, with projections indicating that southern Italy will experience even less annual rainfall and a substantial decrease in summer rainfall—a drop of up to 40% in some arid areas.

Agricultural practices further contribute to water stress and pollution in Italy. Large areas of the country require extensive irrigation, and a significant proportion of the water used for irrigation comes from non-renewable groundwater sources. Additionally, fertilisers, along with industrial and domestic contaminants, have seeped into the water table, leading to legal action from the European Court of Justice against the Italian government for failing to adequately treat water sources contaminated with calcium, arsenic, and fluoride.

To address these issues, Italy is investing in infrastructure upgrades and exploring alternative water sources. Additional water storage and transfer schemes could help balance water availability across regions. For example, southern Italy could expand the traditional practice of farmers digging small ponds to harvest rainwater. On a larger scale, the construction of reservoirs, particularly in the north, could be combined with water transfer schemes to move water surpluses between regions. While Italy's mountainous topography presents technical challenges for such pipelines, it is not insurmountable.

Desalination is another option that has become more viable as the process has become less energy-intensive. Sardinia, for instance, already has a desalination plant supplying water to local industry, and similar plants could help address seasonal domestic water shortages on the island.

In conclusion, Italy's water infrastructure faces significant challenges due to uneven distribution and variable availability of water resources, agricultural demands and pollution, and the impacts of climate change. The country is investing in upgrades and exploring alternative water sources to improve water security and address pollution issues.

Frequently asked questions