Cars Vs Cigarettes: Who's The Real Polluter?

Cars and cigarettes are both major contributors to air pollution, which has been labelled the 'new smoking'. While cars emit pollutants such as carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide, cigarettes produce fine particulate matter, which is the most dangerous element of air pollution for health. According to a controlled experiment, cigarette smoke produces about 10 times more air pollution than diesel car exhaust. However, the impact of air pollution from cars and cigarettes on human health is complex and depends on various factors such as exposure time, location, and individual susceptibility.

Air pollution from cars and cigarettes is linked to lung damage

Cigarette smoke also produces air pollution and is particularly harmful indoors, where levels can far exceed those outdoors. A controlled experiment reported in Tobacco Control found that cigarette smoke produces ten times more air pollution than diesel car exhaust. Environmental tobacco smoke produces fine particulate matter, which is the most dangerous element of air pollution for health. These fine particles can reach the breathing sacs in the lungs and carry toxic chemicals linked to cancer.

Long-term exposure to elevated levels of air pollution, including ground-level ozone or smog, has been linked to accelerated lung damage, even in people who have never smoked. A study published in JAMA found that participants exposed to higher-than-average concentrations of ground-level ozone over several years developed changes in their lungs similar to those seen in smokers. The effects of ozone exposure were comparable to smoking a pack of cigarettes a day for 29 years.

While air pollution and smoking are both harmful to health, they differ in key ways. Air pollution is not addictive, nor is it aggressively marketed by an industry. Additionally, measures to improve air quality tend to receive tremendous public support, as people are not addicted to toxic air. However, the tobacco industry may welcome the comparison between air pollution and smoking, as it could create the perception that their products are "only as bad" as breathing polluted air.

Cigarette smoke produces more air pollution than diesel car exhaust

While cars are a major contributor to air pollution, cigarette smoke produces more air pollution than diesel car exhaust. A controlled experiment reported in Tobacco Control found that the air pollution emitted by cigarettes is 10 times greater than diesel car exhaust. The experiment was carried out in a private garage in a small mountain town in northern Italy. A turbo diesel 2-litre engine was left idling for 30 minutes in the garage with the doors closed, after which the doors were left open for four hours. Three filter cigarettes were then lit up and left smouldering for another 30 minutes. The combined particulate levels in the first hour after the engine was started measured 88 ug/m3, while the levels in the first hour after the cigarettes were lit measured 830 ug/m3.

The high levels of air pollution caused by cigarettes are due to the fine particulate matter produced by environmental tobacco smoke. This particulate matter is the most dangerous element of air pollution for health, and levels indoors can far exceed those outdoors. While new engine models and lead-free fuels have helped to reduce particulate matter emissions from car exhausts, the same cannot be said for cigarettes.

The comparison between air pollution and smoking has been labelled the "new smoking" by some, including the WHO Director-General, Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus. This comparison highlights the need to address toxic air pollution, just as the world has turned the corner on tobacco control. However, it is important to note that breathing polluted air is not addictive, nor is it heavily marketed like tobacco products.

Furthermore, while air pollution from cars can be mitigated through the use of better fuels, new technologies, and stricter emissions standards, the pollution caused by cigarettes remains a concern. Many countries with a high disease burden from tobacco, such as China, Indonesia, and Germany, have made limited progress in controlling smoking and tobacco consumption. Sales of cigarettes continue to soar in these countries, contributing to the overall pollution levels.

In conclusion, while cars play a significant role in air pollution, the evidence suggests that cigarette smoke is an even greater contributor. The toxic nature of cigarette smoke and the lack of progress in reducing tobacco consumption in certain countries underscore the urgency of addressing this issue.

Air pollution is labelled the 'new smoking'

Air pollution has been labelled the "new smoking", with news articles drawing comparisons between the two. For instance, articles with titles such as "If You Live in a Big City You Already Smoke Every Day" and "The Air Is So Bad in These Cities, You May As Well Be Smoking" highlight the dangers of air pollution. This comparison was also emphasised by Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, WHO Director-General, who stated that:

> The world has turned the corner on tobacco. Now it must do the same for the ‘new tobacco’ – the toxic air that billions breathe every day. Globally, with smoking on the decline, air pollution now causes more deaths annually than tobacco.

Indeed, air pollution poses significant health risks, especially to those living near busy roads. Vehicles are a major contributor to air pollution, emitting pollutants such as carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, and nitrogen dioxide when burning gasoline. These emissions increase the levels of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, contributing to global climate change. The percentage of air pollution caused by cars is higher in urban areas and near major highways. However, improvements in fuel technology and new car models have helped reduce emissions.

The impact of air pollution on health has been compared to that of smoking. Studies have found that long-term exposure to air pollution can be as harmful to the lungs as smoking, leading to lung diseases such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and emphysema. Additionally, air pollution has been linked to other health issues such as heart and lung disease, asthma, and child development problems. According to the World Health Organization, around 7 million premature deaths worldwide each year are attributed to air pollution.

While the comparison between air pollution and smoking is attention-grabbing, there are concerns about its implications. Smoking remains a leading preventable cause of death and disability, and the tobacco industry's aggressive marketing of addictive cigarettes continues to be a significant issue. Unlike smoking, measures to improve air quality tend to receive widespread public support, as people are not addicted to toxic air in the same way they are to nicotine. Furthermore, while air pollution levels can be mitigated through individual actions like driving less, the impact of an individual's smoking habits does not extend to those around them in the same way.

In conclusion, while the label of air pollution as the "new smoking" effectively underscores the seriousness of the issue, it is important to recognise the distinct characteristics and challenges associated with each. Addressing air pollution requires collective efforts and policy interventions, whereas smoking cessation relies more heavily on individual behaviour change and resisting addiction.

Cars are a major contributor to air pollution

When cars burn gasoline, they emit pollutants such as carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), and nitrogen dioxide (NO2). CO2 is the most prevalent, with a typical passenger vehicle emitting about 4.6 metric tons of CO2 per year, depending on fuel, fuel economy, and mileage. CH4 and N2O are also emitted, with a higher global warming potential than CO2. NO2 is formed from emissions from cars, trucks, and buses, and can affect the respiratory system, contributing to smog and respiratory issues when combined with hydrocarbons in sunlight.

The impact of car emissions is more severe in urban areas and near highways. While electric vehicles (EVs) are an improvement, they still emit small amounts of greenhouse gases due to air conditioner leakage. The EPA estimates that today's cars emit 98-99% less of certain tailpipe pollutants than cars from the 1960s, but the sheer number of cars offsets these advancements. Hybrid and electric cars can help reduce pollution, but behavioural changes are also necessary, such as driving less, carpooling, and using public transportation.

According to a study by Airlabs, the air pollution experienced by drivers stuck in traffic jams is 140% worse than for pedestrians and equivalent to passively smoking a few cigarettes. Another study found that an increase of three parts per billion of ground-level ozone was comparable to smoking a pack of cigarettes daily for 29 years. While cigarette smoke produces higher levels of air pollution than car exhaust in controlled experiments, the cumulative effects of car emissions and air pollution are detrimental to health, causing lung disease, heart disease, asthma, and other issues.

Air pollution from cars increases the levels of carbon dioxide

Air pollution from cars is a pressing issue that significantly impacts the environment and human health. Among the various pollutants emitted by vehicles, carbon dioxide (CO2) stands out as a primary contributor to global climate change. The combustion of gasoline in car engines plays a pivotal role in increasing carbon dioxide levels in the Earth's atmosphere.

When cars burn gasoline, carbon combines with oxygen to form carbon dioxide. This process releases a substantial amount of CO2 into the air, contributing to the greenhouse effect and global warming. The average passenger vehicle emits about 4.6 metric tons of carbon dioxide annually, and this estimate can vary depending on factors such as fuel type, fuel economy, and mileage.

The impact of carbon dioxide emissions from cars is not limited to a single country or region. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, highway vehicles in the United States alone release approximately 1.7 billion tons of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere each year, with carbon dioxide being the predominant component. This figure underscores the substantial contribution of vehicular emissions to the global carbon dioxide burden.

While the comparison between air pollution from cars and cigarette smoke may be attention-grabbing, it is essential to recognize their distinct impacts. Cigarette smoke produces significantly higher levels of particulate matter pollution compared to diesel car exhaust, as indicated by a controlled experiment. However, the focus of this discussion is on carbon dioxide emissions, which are predominantly linked to vehicle emissions rather than cigarette smoke.

To address the issue of rising carbon dioxide levels from cars, several strategies can be implemented. These include the adoption of low-carbon fuels, improvements in vehicle technology, reducing the number of vehicle miles travelled, and enhancing the efficiency of vehicle operations. Additionally, consumers can play a role by opting for more fuel-efficient vehicles, carpooling, or utilizing public transportation whenever possible. By combining these efforts, we can collectively work towards mitigating the environmental and health consequences of air pollution caused by vehicular carbon dioxide emissions.

Frequently asked questions