Hydraulic Fracturing: Water Pollution's Unseen Threat

Hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, is a multi-step fossil fuel extraction process that has expanded oil and gas development and increased water resource risks. The process involves drilling wells vertically and horizontally into the ground and injecting a mixture of water, chemicals, and proppants (like sand) into underground rock layers at high pressure. This mixture, known as fracking fluid, can contain toxic substances, and when injected, it can cause fractures in the rock that can potentially contaminate groundwater. While the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has claimed that fracking does not lead to widespread, systemic drinking water pollution, there is evidence that groundwater has been polluted at certain points along the fracking water cycle. The contamination of water resources by fracking is a complex issue that requires further investigation and regulation to ensure the protection of public health and the environment.

Groundwater contamination

There are several ways in which hydraulic fracturing can contaminate groundwater. Firstly, after the well is fracked, a significant amount of fracking fluid remains underground, and if fractures connect to aquifer systems, this fluid can contaminate groundwater. There is evidence that shallow aquifers have been polluted by methane due to poorly constructed production wells or "communication" between production and drinking water wells.

Secondly, during the fracturing process, wastewater, also known as "flowback", returns to the surface and must be collected and stored. This wastewater, called "produced water", can contain naturally occurring contaminants like radium, heavy metals, and salts, and must be treated or reinjected into deep disposal wells. If this wastewater is not adequately treated or stored in unlined pits, it can contaminate groundwater resources.

Additionally, the large volume of water used in each well, averaging 2.4 million gallons, poses a risk of groundwater pollution. Typically, only 15-35% of the water used for hydraulic fracturing is retrieved, and the remaining water can become severely contaminated, impacting local water availability and increasing the risk of groundwater pollution.

While federal and state regulators have emphasised the safety of hydraulic fracturing, acknowledging the role of construction methods, regulations, and industry standards in protecting groundwater, there is still a need for stringent regulations, sustained research, and effective management practices to address the potential risks of groundwater contamination.

Wastewater

Hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, is a multi-step fossil fuel extraction process that uses a water-based fluid to create fractures in underground rock layers and extract natural gas and oil. This process generates significant amounts of wastewater, which can have negative environmental impacts and contribute to water pollution.

The fracking process involves injecting a mixture of water, chemicals, and proppants (such as sand) into underground rock layers at high pressure. Once the production well is fully open, some of the wastewater, known as "produced water," flows back to the surface, along with the extracted oil and gas. This wastewater can contain various chemicals and contaminants, including heavy metals, radioactivity, and toxic substances like volatile organic compounds.

The large volume of wastewater generated during fracking operations poses a significant challenge. The amount of wastewater produced during a well's first year of production can increase significantly, straining water resources and risking pollution. In some cases, the wastewater is sprayed on forested land, which has been shown to have negative consequences for the environment, as observed in a study in West Virginia where more than half of the trees in the area died within two years.

The improper management and disposal of fracking wastewater can lead to water pollution. If not properly contained and treated, the wastewater can contaminate surface water and groundwater sources. There is evidence that shallow aquifers have been polluted by methane due to poorly constructed production wells or connections between production and drinking water wells. Additionally, the chemical composition of contaminated groundwater suggests that fracking fluids may have migrated directly into aquifers through fractures.

The detection and analysis of fracking-related compounds in groundwater can be challenging. Many commercial labs are not equipped to analyze the exotic compounds used in fracking, such as methanol, which can pose significant health risks to humans if consumed. Therefore, the potential impact of fracking on water pollution may be underestimated due to the difficulty in detecting and studying these compounds.

Toxic chemicals

Hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, is a process that involves injecting a mix of water, chemicals, and proppants (like sand) into underground rock layers at high pressure to extract oil and natural gas. This process has raised concerns about its potential impact on water resources, with studies indicating that fracking can lead to water pollution in several ways.

One of the primary concerns regarding hydraulic fracturing is the potential contamination of groundwater with toxic chemicals. Former EPA scientist Dominic DiGiulio's research in Pavillion, Wyoming, revealed that the deep groundwater in the region contained high levels of salt and anomalous ions typically found in fracking fluid. This suggests that the fracking fluids may have migrated directly into the aquifer through fractures. Shallow hydraulic fracturing, in particular, poses a risk as chemicals can more easily migrate into drinking water sources.

The composition of fracking fluid is often a closely guarded secret by companies, but it is known to include various toxic substances. Out of the recognized chemicals, methanol, a simple alcohol that can cause permanent nerve damage and blindness when consumed in sufficient quantities, has been identified. The presence of these toxic chemicals in fracking fluid underscores the risk of groundwater contamination.

Moreover, the wastewater generated during hydraulic fracturing can also contribute to water pollution. After the well is fracked and begins producing oil and gas, a significant amount of fracking fluid remains underground. If fractures connect to aquifer systems, this fluid can contaminate groundwater. The increase in wastewater generated during fracking operations further exacerbates the risk of water pollution, as improper disposal or inadequate containment can lead to the release of contaminants into water sources.

Additionally, there is a concern that the infrastructure associated with hydraulic fracturing, including well pads, access roads, and pipelines, can contribute to water pollution. The intense activity and traffic around these sites can result in accidental spills or leaks, leading to the contamination of local water resources. The vast web of infrastructure can also fragment ecosystems and degrade wildlife habitats, further impacting water systems and the natural environment.

Water-soluble compounds

One of the main concerns with hydraulic fracturing is the potential contamination of groundwater and drinking water sources. During the fracturing process, a significant amount of water is used, and only a small percentage of it is typically recovered. The water that returns to the surface, known as "flowback" or "produced water," contains high concentrations of salts, heavy metals, and toxic organic compounds. Inappropriate storage or spills of this wastewater can lead to the contamination of water sources, posing risks to human health and the environment.

The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has identified cases of water contamination near hydraulically fractured oil and gas production wells, ranging from temporary changes in water quality to severe contamination that renders private drinking water wells unusable. However, the full extent of water contamination from hydraulic fracturing activities is still unknown due to data gaps and uncertainties. The EPA's study also identified conditions under which impacts from hydraulic fracturing can be more frequent or severe, highlighting the need for better protection of drinking water resources in areas where hydraulic fracturing is occurring.

The chemical additives used in hydraulic fracturing fluids are of particular concern. While the specific chemicals used by companies are often kept confidential, studies have detected the presence of toxic organic compounds and carcinogens in wastewater and storage tanks. These compounds can leach into the surrounding environment, including water sources, and pose risks to human health. Additionally, the disposal of hydraulic fracturing wastewater in unlined pits has been identified as a direct source of groundwater contamination.

To mitigate the environmental and health risks associated with water-soluble compounds in hydraulic fracturing, stricter regulations on chemical usage and wastewater disposal are necessary. Efforts are being made to develop new materials and technologies that optimize production while minimizing the use of environmentally hazardous chemicals. Ongoing research focuses on characterizing hydraulic fracturing wastewater and establishing strategies to reduce its environmental impact, including the development of advanced monitoring and treatment technologies.

Increased water use

Hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, is a water-intensive process. Each fracking job requires millions of gallons of water, with the average in the United States ranging from 1.5 million to 9.7 million gallons of water per well, according to the USGS. The water used for fracking is typically freshwater, drawn from groundwater and surface water resources, including those that also supply drinking water. This has led to concerns about the impact of fracking on water supplies, particularly in drought-prone regions.

The water intensity of fracking has increased over time, with a Duke University analysis finding a surge in water use by fracking operations between 2011 and 2016, even as the number of new wells installed decreased during this period. In the drought-ridden Permian Basin region of West Texas, water use for fracking increased by up to 770% during these years, while another study predicted that fracking's water footprint could increase by up to 50-fold in some regions by 2030.

The high water requirements of fracking strain local water resources and can lead to increased competition for water between different sectors, including agriculture and municipalities. This competition can result in higher water prices and reduced water availability for other users, impacting local communities and ecosystems.

The vast amounts of water used in fracking are mixed with chemicals and sand to create fracking fluid, which is injected into underground rock layers at high pressure to extract fossil fuels. This process results in the contamination of the water with chemicals and proppants, making it unsuitable for other uses and requiring proper disposal or treatment before release back into the environment.

The increased water use and subsequent wastewater generation from fracking operations highlight the need for improved water management practices and regulations to ensure the sustainable use of water resources and protect local communities and ecosystems from the potential impacts of water scarcity and pollution.

Frequently asked questions