Nuclear Power's Water Pollution: What's The Real Damage?

Nuclear power plants can pollute water in several ways. Firstly, they require large amounts of water for cooling the reactors, and this water, when released back into the environment, can have an impact on surrounding ecosystems due to its high temperature. This can affect the proliferation of algae, for example. Secondly, nuclear power plants produce radioactive waste, which, if not properly handled, stored, and disposed of, can contaminate water sources. This has been seen in incidents at nuclear power plants in Vermont Yankee, Chernobyl, and Fukushima, where leaks or accidents have resulted in the release of radioactive water and the contamination of drinking water sources. The mining and refining of uranium, a fuel used in nuclear power plants, can also contribute to water pollution as it requires large amounts of water and can result in radioactive waste.

Radioactive leaks and accidents

The Fukushima nuclear disaster in Japan highlighted the risks associated with nuclear power. In an attempt to cool the plant, large volumes of seawater were pumped in, but this contaminated water was subsequently released back into the ocean, discharging radioactivity into the marine environment. This incident also impacted drinking water sources near Tokyo, located 130 miles from the plant, causing anxiety among residents and prompting advisories for infants to avoid tap water due to elevated levels of radioactive iodine.

The Chernobyl accident in Ukraine serves as another stark example of the consequences of radioactive leaks. This accident resulted in significant radioactive pollution across several European countries, leading to an estimated 9,000 to 90,000 deaths and causing long-lasting damage to the environment, including the contamination of water reserves.

The potential for radioactive leaks and accidents at nuclear power plants underscores the importance of adhering to stringent safety protocols and regulations. While the risk of uncontrolled nuclear reactions in modern nuclear power plants is relatively low due to safety measures, the consequences of a radioactive release can be catastrophic. Radioactive waste, if not properly managed, can contaminate water sources, posing risks to human health and the environment for extended periods due to its long half-life.

Furthermore, it is important to note that the ageing of nuclear facilities increases the likelihood of leaks and accidents. As nuclear plants get older, the incidence of leaks becomes more frequent, and 75% of US nuclear plants have leaked tritium, a radioactive form of hydrogen that poses health risks, including cancer and genetic defects.

Radioactive waste

Solid waste can include tools, protective clothing, wiping cloths, and other disposable items that become contaminated with radioactive particles. This type of low-level waste is typically disposed of in designated sites, such as the low-level waste disposal sites in the United States located in South Carolina, Utah, and Washington. However, proper handling, storage, and disposal procedures must be followed to prevent contamination of the outside environment.

Liquid and gaseous waste is also generated during the purification of water through evaporation. Liquid waste is continuously reprocessed, while gas waste is filtered, compressed, stored, diluted, and then discharged at regulated rates to ensure it does not pose a risk to public health. Most commercial nuclear power plants release gaseous and liquid radiological effluents as by-products of the Chemical Volume Control System (CVCS). The total amount of radioactivity released through the CVCS depends on the power plant, regulatory requirements, and the plant's performance.

High-level radioactive waste, on the other hand, consists of spent nuclear reactor fuel. This waste is highly radioactive and must be stored in specially designed pools of water, which act as a radiation shield and help cool the fuel. The water used for cooling can become contaminated and, if leaked or accidentally released, can pose a significant threat to the environment and human health, as seen in the Fukushima and Chernobyl incidents.

The mining and refining of uranium, a common fuel for nuclear power plants, also contribute to radioactive waste. Uranium mining can use large amounts of water, reducing its availability for other uses and potentially impacting ecosystems. The process of mining and milling uranium presents significant environmental dangers, and the waste generated can contaminate water sources if not properly managed.

Overall, the production, handling, transportation, storage, and disposal of radioactive waste are subject to strict regulations to protect human health and the environment. While most nuclear waste has low radioactive activity and becomes inert quickly, a small portion has high radioactivity and long lifetimes, remaining dangerous for hundreds or even thousands of years.

Tritium leaks

Tritium is radioactive hydrogen, which is generated in nature by the interaction between cosmic rays and the atmosphere. Although it occurs naturally, human activity, including the operation of nuclear power plants, significantly increases the amount of tritium in the environment. Nuclear power plants routinely and accidentally release tritium into the air and water as a gas (HT) or as water (HTO or 3HOH).

No economically feasible technology exists to filter tritium from a nuclear power plant’s gaseous and liquid emissions. Therefore, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) does not require that it be filtered. The NRC allows licensees to release tritium that could result in a radiation dose to a member of the public of up to 100 millirem (one millisievert) per year in planned air and water effluents. The current U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) standard for permissible levels of tritium in drinking water is 20,000 picocuries per liter. However, it is important to note that "permissible" does not mean "safe."

An investigation by the Associated Press revealed that radioactive tritium has leaked from three-quarters of U.S. commercial nuclear power sites, often into groundwater from corroded, buried piping. Over the history of the U.S. industry, more than 400 known radioactive leaks of all kinds of substances have occurred. Several notable leaks above the EPA drinking-water limit for tritium have happened in recent years, including at the Vermont Yankee reactor in southern Vermont, where levels reached 2.5 million picocuries per liter (125 times the EPA drinking-water standard).

The issue of tritium leaks has raised concerns about the reliability, durability, and maintenance of aging nuclear power plants. The U.S. Government Accountability Office noted that while the industry has a voluntary initiative to monitor leaks into underground water sources, the NRC has not evaluated the effectiveness of this system in detecting leaks promptly. Critics argue that weakened safety standards are inching reactors closer to an accident, and any exposure to radioactivity, no matter how slight, boosts cancer risk.

Water temperature

Nuclear power plants use water from lakes, rivers, or the ocean for cooling. About 40% of nuclear reactors in the US use recirculating cooling systems, and 46% use once-through cooling. The water used for cooling nuclear power plants is returned to the ecosystem at higher temperatures, causing thermal water pollution. This thermal pollution can have lasting effects on deep-water biogeochemical cycles, not just surface water or water directly near power plants.

Nuclear power plants operate at lower temperatures and lower turbine efficiencies than fossil fuel plants, and they do not lose heat via smokestacks. As a result, nuclear plants withdraw and consume more water per unit of electricity produced than coal plants using similar cooling technologies. The thermal energy efficiency of a typical nuclear power plant is around 30%, while conventional thermal power plants operate in the range of 30% to 48%.

The water discharged from nuclear power plants can increase the temperature of the receiving water body by several degrees Celsius. For example, a study of the Danube River in Romania found that due to discharge from two nuclear power plants, the river exhibited a thermal plume current that extended up to 6 km downstream, with temperature changes of up to 1.5°C between plume and non-plume areas. Similarly, a meta-analysis of coastal nuclear power plants found an average increase of 4.38°C in water temperature near the outfall.

The increase in water temperature caused by nuclear power plants can have significant effects on aquatic ecosystems. Warmer water has a lower dissolved oxygen concentration, which can impact the survival of aquatic organisms. Additionally, organic matter decomposes faster at higher temperatures, further altering the ecological balance. The effects of thermal pollution on marine biodiversity are not fully understood, and more studies are needed to assess the potential negative impacts on mariculture, especially in field environments.

Uranium mining

Uranium is a naturally occurring radioactive element that has been mined and used for its chemical properties for over a thousand years. It is now primarily used as fuel for nuclear reactors that generate electricity. Uranium mining and processing operations have significant impacts on air quality, soil, surface water, groundwater, and biota.

Uranium can be recovered through conventional mining of rock ore or through in situ leaching (ISL), also known as in-situ recovery (ISR). In the latter method, strong chemicals are used to dissolve uranium from the rock while it is still in the ground, and it is then pumped to the surface. Conventional mining can be further classified into surface or open-pit mining and underground mining. Open-pit mining strips away the topsoil and rock above the uranium ore, while underground mining involves digging tunnels to reach the ore. Underground mining exposes workers to high levels of radon gas, which has been linked to an increased risk of lung cancer. Miners also face the risk of cave-ins and pneumoconiosis, a lung disease caused by inhaling dust. On the other hand, open-pit mining is safer for miners but involves blasting a far greater amount of earth, and the leftover material is radioactive and toxic. This method also increases erosion and the risk of landslides, and it pollutes the soil and water.

The milling process, which takes place after uranium ore is removed from the Earth, involves crushing and grinding the ore before adding chemicals to dissolve the uranium. The liquid then undergoes further processing to recover the uranium. Regardless of the extraction method, these processes generate radioactive waste. Uranium mill tailings, which are often placed near the processing facility, contain the radioactive element radium, which decays into radon gas. To prevent the escape of radon, tailings are covered with a sealing barrier of clay and then a layer of soil, rocks, or other materials to prevent the erosion of the sealing barrier.

Frequently asked questions