Air Pollution's Impact On Moth Populations

The Industrial Revolution brought about a notable shift in moth populations, with the peppered moth becoming a key example of the impact of air pollution on these insects. The once-rare dark-coloured moths became increasingly prevalent in industrial areas, leading to speculation about the reasons behind this change. The pollution from factories darkened the trees, making light-coloured moths more visible to predators. This resulted in the survival and reproduction advantage for dark-coloured moths, which were better camouflaged in the polluted environment. As industrialisation progressed, the increase in dark-coloured moths became more pronounced, providing early evidence for Charles Darwin's theory of natural selection.

The impact of light pollution on moth behaviour

Light pollution is a growing problem that poses a significant threat to moth populations. Moths are nocturnal insects that rely on darkness to navigate, feed, and reproduce. As light pollution increases, it disrupts the natural behaviour of moths, leading to a decline in their numbers.

One of the main ways light pollution affects moths is by attracting them to artificial light sources. Moths are naturally drawn to light, but artificial lights can be disorienting. Moths may spend a lot of energy trying to reach these lights, taking them away from essential food sources or places of refuge. Once they reach the light source, they may become confused and exhausted from circling it, making them easier targets for predators.

Artificial lights also increase the vulnerability of moths to nocturnal predators. Predators take advantage of the high numbers of moths congregating around lights, making it easier for them to hunt. This can lead to an increase in the number of moths being eaten. Exhausted and disoriented moths are also less able to carry out essential activities such as feeding, breeding, and laying eggs, further impacting their survival and ability to reproduce.

Even low levels of artificial light can disrupt moth behaviour. Diapause induction is a process used by moth caterpillars to pause their development and wait for better conditions. Artificial light interferes with the visual cues that caterpillars use to determine the season, disrupting this process and leading to their development in less ideal conditions.

Light pollution may also impact the plants that moth species rely on for food and shelter. Adult moths may neglect their usual pollinating activities when drawn to artificial light, affecting the plants that caterpillars depend on. Some studies suggest that artificial light can alter the nutritional value of these plants, which may, in turn, affect the development of caterpillars that feed on them.

The effects of light pollution on moth behaviour are far-reaching and can have cascading impacts on entire ecosystems. Reducing light pollution is essential to mitigate these effects and preserve the delicate balance of nature.

Industrial melanism and the rise of dark-coloured moths

The evolution of the peppered moth is a classic example of directional colour change in moth populations as a consequence of air pollution during the Industrial Revolution. This phenomenon, known as industrial melanism, saw the rise of dark-coloured moths in polluted environments.

Before the Industrial Revolution, the black form of the peppered moth was rare. The first recorded sighting of a dark peppered moth was in 1848 by English naturalist R.S. Edleston, who noted in his journal:

> "Today I caught an almost totally black form of Biston betularia (peppered moth) near the centre of Manchester."

During the Industrial Revolution, new coal-burning factories blanketed the surrounding countryside in soot. The previously light-coloured trees and lichens darkened, affecting the camouflage of the resident peppered moths. As a result, light-coloured moths became easier prey for birds, leading to an increase in bird predation.

Bernard Kettlewell, a research fellow at the University of Oxford, was among the first to investigate this puzzling change in moth populations. He conducted experiments during the 1950s to test whether soot and pollution made it easier for black moths to blend into their newly darkened surroundings. His findings confirmed his predictions: black moths were becoming more abundant due to better camouflage, while their white counterparts were more vulnerable to predation by birds.

The impact of industrial melanism on peppered moth populations was significant. By the end of the 19th century, dark-coloured moths almost completely outnumbered the original light-coloured type. In 1895, records showed that 98% of the peppered moth population in Manchester were dark-coloured.

As pollution levels decreased in response to clean air legislation, the light-coloured form of the peppered moth once again predominated. This provided further evidence of natural selection at work, as predicted by Charles Darwin. The story of the peppered moth remains a classic example of evolutionary biology and a powerful illustration of the impact of environmental change on species.

The role of camouflage in moth survival

The peppered moth is found throughout Eurasia and North America and can be either white or black. The survival of these moths relies on their ability to camouflage themselves from predators. Juvenile caterpillars disguise themselves as twigs, while adult moths blend into their surroundings. However, as the world changes, these camouflage strategies can become ineffective, leaving the moths vulnerable.

During the Industrial Revolution, the increase in factories burning coal led to a dark smoke that covered the surrounding countryside. The trees that were once light and covered in lichens became darkened and bare. This change in the environment had a significant impact on the peppered moth population.

Before the Industrial Revolution, the light-bodied peppered moths were able to blend in effectively with the light-coloured lichens and tree bark, making it difficult for predators such as birds to spot them. However, as the pollution from factories blanketed the countryside, the light-bodied lichens died, and the trees became darkened. As a result, the light-coloured moths now stood out against their darkened surroundings, making them easier targets for bird predation.

On the other hand, the dark-coloured or melanic form of the peppered moth, which was once rare, began to thrive in this polluted environment. The dark moths were now better camouflaged against the soot-covered trees, making it harder for birds to spot them. This selective survival, where one type of moth had an advantage over the other due to its ability to camouflage, is known as industrial melanism.

As the pollution levels decreased in response to clean air legislation, the light-coloured form of the peppered moth once again became predominant. With the trees returning to their original lighter colour, the light-coloured moths could blend in effectively, reducing their chances of being predated by birds. This shift back to a lighter colour demonstrates the ongoing role of camouflage in the survival and evolution of the peppered moth population.

The effect of air pollution on moth genetics

The story of the peppered moth begins in 1848, when R. S. Edleston, an English naturalist, recorded the first sighting of a dark peppered moth in Manchester, England. Over the next 50 years, the population of dark-coloured moths rapidly increased, and by the end of the 19th century, they almost completely outnumbered the original light-coloured type. This change was a result of genetic variation, with the dark colour being caused by a mutation in the DNA of a single moth that was passed on to its offspring.

The survival of the peppered moth depended on its ability to camouflage against the tree bark and lichens, tricking predators like birds. Before the Industrial Revolution, the light-bodied moths were well-camouflaged against the light-coloured lichens and tree bark, making it difficult for birds to spot them. However, as pollution levels rose, the lichens died off, and the trees became darkened with soot. This made the light-coloured moths stand out, making them easier prey for the birds.

On the other hand, the dark-coloured moths, or melanic forms, benefited from the polluted environment. Their dark colouration provided excellent camouflage against the soot-covered trees, making them less vulnerable to predation. This selective survival, driven by the birds' preference for the more visible light-coloured moths, is known as "differential bird predation". It resulted in an increase in the frequency of the dark-coloured moths, as they had a higher chance of surviving to pass on their genes to the next generation.

The impact of air pollution on the genetics of peppered moths is a clear illustration of Charles Darwin's theory of natural selection. The colour variation in the moth population, driven by genetic changes, led to differential survival and reproductive success based on the polluted environment. As pollution levels decreased in response to clean air legislation, the light-coloured moths once again became the predominant form, demonstrating the dynamic nature of natural selection and the ability of species to adapt to changing conditions.

The impact of air pollution on moth populations over time

During the Industrial Revolution, people noticed a change in the population ratio of white and black moths. White moths, which had previously been the more common variety, became rarer, while black moths became more common. This was particularly noticeable in industrial cities like Manchester, England, where, by the end of the 19th century, black moths outnumbered the white variety by a significant margin.

The change in moth populations was attributed to the effects of industrial pollution. As factories burned coal, the surrounding countryside was blanketed in soot, darkening trees and other vegetation. This had a significant impact on the moths, which rely on camouflage to hide from predators. White moths became easier to spot against the darkened trees, leading to increased predation by birds. On the other hand, black moths benefited from better camouflage in the polluted environment, allowing them to avoid predation and pass on their dark-coloured genes to their offspring.

As a result of this selective survival, the frequency of dark-coloured moths increased dramatically. By 1895, the percentage of dark-coloured moths in Manchester had reached 98%, a stark contrast to the earlier population makeup. This phenomenon, known as industrial melanism, became an early test of Charles Darwin's theory of natural selection.

However, the story doesn't end there. As pollution levels decreased in response to clean air legislation, the light-coloured moths once again gained the upper hand. With cleaner air and reduced pollution, the trees returned to their original, lighter colour. This change in the environment now favoured the light-coloured moths, as they could blend in more effectively. As a result, the population of light-coloured moths began to increase, demonstrating the ongoing impact of air pollution on moth populations over time.

Frequently asked questions