Indicator Species: Pollution's Canary In The Coal Mine

Indicator species, also known as bioindicators, are organisms that can be used to monitor pollution and other environmental changes. They are highly sensitive to changes in their ecosystems, and their presence, absence, or abundance can indicate the quality of the environment. Indicator species are often monitored by scientists to gather data about climate change, pollution levels, and other factors that impact the health of an ecosystem. These species are typically among the first to be affected by any changes in their environment, making them effective early warning systems for potential ecological threats.

Indicator species can be used to monitor the presence of toxins and pollutants in the water

Indicator species are used to monitor the presence of toxins and pollutants in the water. They are a cost-effective way to monitor the health of an ecosystem and can be used to detect changes in the environment.

Lichens as Indicator Species

Lichens are one of the most common indicator species used to measure air pollution. They are similar to fungi and algae and absorb water and minerals from the air to grow on living and non-living surfaces. They absorb all the pollutants in the environment, and some varieties of lichen survive better in the presence of pollution than others. For example, green and bushy lichens survive only in clean air, so their presence indicates that the air is clean. On the other hand, hard and crusty lichens can survive quite well in the presence of pollution, so their abundance may indicate that the air in the environment is polluted.

Aquatic Invertebrates as Indicator Species

Different species of aquatic invertebrates can survive in polluted water, while others cannot. Scientists take a sample of the invertebrates living in a water source and use the species in the sample to assess the level of pollution in the water. A sample with invertebrates like freshwater shrimp and mayfly larvae indicates clean water, because these species have very low tolerance for any pollution. On the other hand, the presence of many rat-tailed maggots or sludge worms indicates that the water is highly polluted because these species survive well in polluted waters.

Fish as Indicator Species

Fish survival can also be used as a simple way to measure the health of a given water source. Fish rely heavily on the dissolved oxygen in water to survive, so if oxygen levels are low due to pollution, no varieties of fish will survive. Monitoring fish populations over time can provide important insights. For example, if a lake or pond once had a large fish population, but that population is in rapid decline, it can be inferred that pollution levels are growing in the lake or pond.

Bacterial Indicators

Bacteria can also be used as indicators of water quality. For example, the presence of Escherichia coli (E. coli) in freshwater and marine waters corresponds to the presence of bacterial pathogens. Total coliform, fecal coliform, E. coli, and Enterococcus are four assessors of fecal contamination that have been developed. Fecal streptococci species, which include Streptococcus faecalis and Streptococcus bovis, can also be used as an indicator organism because they do not grow and reproduce in water and other environmental systems, but they can survive for a long time.

Plankton as Indicator Species

Plankton are microorganisms that live in aquatic ecosystems and are unable to swim against currents. They are a crucial source of food for many small and large aquatic organisms. They are highly sensitive to natural changes in diverse ecosystems, so they are good indicators of aquatic consistency. They can monitor aquatic ecosystems under high phosphorus and nitrogen levels as both pollutants inspire other biotas living in the aquatic body.

Frogs as Indicator Species

Frogs are good biological indicators for the quality and changes in a given ecosystem. They are affected primarily by shifts in their freshwater and terrestrial ecosystems. They are also responsive to changes in their ecosystem and ingest toxic chemicals through their skin and larval gill membranes.

They can indicate the quality of the air

Indicator species are organisms that provide information on the condition of their environment. They are used to monitor changes in the environment and predict ecological shifts, helping conservationists to be proactive in protecting ecosystems from biodiversity loss and climate damage.

Lichens, for example, are complex organisms that are very important for filtering and trapping particulate matter from the air, playing a key role in creating cleaner, healthier air for us to breathe. They are sensitive to nitrogen pollution and sulfur dioxide, and when air quality is bad, they are among the first to suffer. Scientists can monitor the amount of chlorophyll in lichen, and if it decreases, then we know that air pollution is present.

Lichens are organisms consisting of a symbiotic relationship between a fungus and a chlorophyll-containing partner, either algae or cyanobacteria. They are found in both nature and human-made environments, including rocks, trees, barren earth, metal, and concrete. Lichens are sensitive to air pollution because they receive all their nutrients from the atmosphere, which makes them valuable as indicator species.

In the United States, the health of various lichen species is monitored and paired with atmospheric deposition data to identify critical sources and overall levels of air pollution. Lichens have also been used in Germany as a bioindicator for air pollution, as they are sensitive to a number of air pollutants.

Different lichen species have different sensitivities to air pollutants. For example, "nitrophyte" lichen species thrive in high-nitrogen environments and on tree bark with high pH, while "acidophyte" lichen species prefer the opposite. Bark pH has been found to be affected by sulfur dioxide concentrations. This method has been used to map and monitor nitrogen and ammonia pollution patterns across countries in Europe.

While lichens are a useful indicator species, the information they provide is limited. They can only be used to monitor nitrogen and sulfur dioxide levels, while there are many more pollutants that serve as ecological and health threats. Additionally, indicator species are unable to give immediate feedback on exact pollution levels, only averages over a longer period of time.

They can be used to monitor the effects of climate change

Indicator species are organisms that can provide information about the environmental conditions of an ecosystem. They are often used to monitor the effects of climate change.

The Impact of Climate Change on Indicator Species

Indicator species are highly sensitive to changes in their environment, including climate change. They can be used to detect subtle shifts in environmental health that may not be immediately apparent through direct measurement. For example, the presence or absence of certain indicator species can indicate the quality of the environment. Spotted owls, for instance, rely on old-growth forests for nesting and hunting. Their absence may indicate declining forest health due to excessive logging and urbanisation. Similarly, the presence of lichens, which are sensitive to nitrogen pollution, can indicate good air quality, while their absence or failing health can signal declining air quality.

The Impact of Climate Change on Other Species

The impact of climate change on indicator species can also reflect the effects on other species within the ecosystem. Healthy populations of indicator species often signify that other species are thriving, while their decline can signal broader ecological problems. For instance, the presence of river otters, which are resilient to climate change, can indicate the health of freshwater ecosystems. However, if their food sources, such as fish, crayfish, amphibians, and reptiles, are affected by climate change, the lack of food will eventually impact the otters as well.

The Role of Indicator Species in Climate Change Research

Researchers identify and monitor indicator species to gather data about climate change. Their presence, absence, or abundance can indicate different messages about the state of the environment. By studying their movements and behaviour, scientists can detect early warning signs of ecosystem change. Indicator species provide a cost-effective method for monitoring as focusing on a few key species can offer significant insights into the overall health of an ecosystem, reducing the need for extensive environmental testing.

Examples of Indicator Species for Climate Change Monitoring

Some specific examples of indicator species that can be used to monitor climate change include:

• Frogs: Frogs are sensitive to chemicals and absorb harmful substances from polluted water. They are also useful as they live in both land and water, providing insights into the environmental health of both habitats.
• Dragonflies: Dragonflies can be used to gather data on mercury levels in ponds and wetlands. As dragonflies eat contaminated insects, they accumulate toxic metals, which can then be analysed in a laboratory.
• Monarch butterflies: With a short lifespan, these butterflies are sensitive to environmental changes, making it easy to monitor changes between generations.
• Salmon: As salmon require uninterrupted river systems to migrate between freshwater breeding grounds and the ocean, their decline can indicate disruptions to habitats and water quality.
• Coral reefs: Coral reefs are sensitive to temperature changes, pollution, and ocean acidification. Coral bleaching is a clear sign that oceans are too warm or polluted for corals to survive.

By studying these and other indicator species, scientists can gain valuable insights into the effects of climate change on different ecosystems and take proactive measures to protect and conserve them.

They can be used to monitor the presence of pathogens and disease

Indicator species are organisms that are highly sensitive to environmental changes and can be used to monitor the presence of pathogens and diseases. They are crucial tools in monitoring habitats and managing ecosystems.

Bacteria

Certain bacteria can be used as indicator organisms to monitor the presence of pathogens and diseases. These bacteria are not dangerous to human health but are used to indicate the presence of a health risk. They are used to detect and estimate the level of faecal contamination in water. The presence of bacteria commonly found in human faeces, termed coliform bacteria (e.g. E. coli), in surface water is a common indicator of faecal contamination.

The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) lists the following criteria for an organism to be an ideal indicator of faecal contamination:

• The organism should be present whenever enteric pathogens are present.
• The organism should be useful for all types of water.
• The organism should have a longer survival time than the hardiest enteric pathogen.
• The organism should not grow in water.
• The organism should be found in warm-blooded animals' intestines.

The most common indicator bacteria are total coliforms, fecal coliforms, E. coli, and enterococci. Fecal coliforms are more useful as indicators in recreational waters than total coliforms, which include species that are naturally found in plants and soil.

Fungi

Fungi can also be used as indicator organisms. For example, in a study conducted by Cudowski et al., fungi in the water of the Augustow canal in eastern Poland were sampled and analysed. They found 38 fungal species, including 12 hyphomycetiae and 13 potential pathogens, belonging either to the dermatophytes or to relatives of Candida albicans. By analysing the presence of certain fungal species, they were able to determine whether a sample of water had been taken from the natural (lake-like) or artificial part of the canal.

Amphibians

Amphibians like salamanders and frogs are also indicator species as they are very sensitive to environmental changes. Their disappearance from an ecosystem or changes in their population can indicate a decline in water quality or habitat degradation caused by human-induced factors such as deforestation, cultivation, grazing, and mowing.

Owls

Certain species of owls, such as the northern spotted owl, are also indicator species. They rely on old-growth forests for nesting and hunting, and their population size can indicate the health of forest habitats. Their dependence on specific habitats makes them sensitive to changes caused by logging and urbanisation.

Fish

Salmon is another example of an indicator species. They are a unique type of fish as they can survive in both seawater and freshwater. However, with overfishing, damming, and habitat destruction, their populations are declining, indicating a decrease in water and habitat quality.

Coral

Coral reefs are good indicators of aquatic health. They are incredibly sensitive to temperature changes, pollution, and ocean acidification. When coral reefs are stressed, they expel the algae that live in their tissues, causing them to lose their colour and appear transparent. This is known as coral bleaching, and it signals to ocean conservationists that the reef is in trouble.

In summary, indicator species and organisms play a crucial role in monitoring the presence of pathogens and diseases by detecting subtle changes in the environment that may indicate the presence of a health risk.

They can be used to monitor the presence of pesticides

Indicator species, or bioindicators, are organisms that scientists use to monitor the health of an ecosystem. They are often used to detect early signs of environmental changes, such as pollution and climate change. They are cost-effective monitoring tools, as observing a few key species can provide significant insights into the overall health of an ecosystem.

Peregrine falcons are one such indicator species that can be used to monitor the presence of pesticides. Pesticides are chemicals used to kill or control pests, such as insects, weeds, and fungi, that can damage crops or harm humans and animals. They are commonly used in agriculture to improve crop yields and prevent the spread of diseases. However, they can also have negative impacts on the environment and human health if used excessively or improperly.

Peregrine falcons are highly sensitive to pesticides due to their place at the top of the food chain. As apex predators, they can accumulate high levels of pesticides in their bodies through a process called biomagnification. Biomagnification occurs when toxins are passed from prey to predator and become more concentrated at each trophic level. This means that the amount of pesticides in the falcon's body can provide valuable information about the level of pesticide contamination in the environment.

By regularly monitoring the falcon population and their behaviour, scientists can detect changes that may indicate the presence of harmful levels of pesticides. For example, a decrease in the number of falcons or a change in their reproductive patterns could signal that the pesticide levels in the area are too high. This information can then be used to implement measures to reduce pesticide use or switch to less harmful alternatives, protecting both the falcons and the wider ecosystem.

In addition to peregrine falcons, other bird species can also be used as indicator species for pesticides. Birds of prey, such as hawks and eagles, are often used for this purpose due to their high trophic level and sensitivity to environmental toxins. By studying the health and behaviour of these birds, scientists can gain valuable insights into the presence and impact of pesticides in the environment.

It is important to note that while indicator species are a valuable tool, they should not be relied upon as the sole method of monitoring. Their effectiveness can be limited by factors such as natural variability, disease, and predation. Therefore, it is crucial to combine the use of indicator species with other scientific methods to gain a comprehensive understanding of the ecosystem's health and the presence of pollutants like pesticides.

Frequently asked questions